Question for truthers: what constitutes reliable FDNY testimony?

CHF

Illuminator
Joined
Oct 12, 2006
Messages
3,871
It's obvious from the Schroeder interview that a guy with bad memory who doesn't know what he was hearing but is willing to guess...that apparently constitutes reliable testimony in the eyes of truthers.

But I'm curious as to what truthers make of testimony from Fire Chief Daniel Nigro who said WTC7 was heavily damaged and in danger of collapse; or all those other FDNY who said WTC7 was going to come down due to its weakened state.

Can someone please explain to me how FDNY testimony is judged? What's reliable and what isn't?

Edited by chillzero: 
Members should not post anything other than their own responses. Please don't encourage members to post on behalf of non-members.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Oh, if I may add that someone saying "something was not right that day" doesn't cut it. Of course something was wrong that day.
 
Back door draft explosions = bombs

Over 150 quotes about how WTC7 was in danger of collapse = misguided

Chief Vincent Dunne mentioning CTers being 'ridiculed' by the FDNY = Bad for Dylan
 
Numerous firefighters who arent structural engineers predict an unprecedented collapse and thats reliable but numerous firefighters describe molten steel and thats unreliable because they aren't metallurgists lol
 
well I am sure they have seen alot more unsteady, near collapsed buildings in their past as FIREFIGHTERS, than they have MOLTEN STEEL...

TAM:)
 
Numerous firefighters who arent structural engineers predict an unprecedented collapse and thats reliable but numerous firefighters describe molten steel and thats unreliable because they aren't metallurgists lol


Well a firefighter must know the structure of a building before going inside them to fight a fire.

Molten steel? Where's the evidence of this claim? And don't be showing me a picture of the firemen around a glowing light from within the rubble. That picture just shows them looking for people who might have survived.
 
Numerous firefighters who arent structural engineers predict an unprecedented collapse and thats reliable but numerous firefighters describe molten steel and thats unreliable because they aren't metallurgists lol
firefighters are trained to assess the soundness of a burning building, its part of their job

firefighters are not trained to tell the difference between molten steel, molten copper, molten aluminum, or molten glass, thats not part of their job
 
Numerous firefighters who arent structural engineers predict an unprecedented collapse and thats reliable but numerous firefighters describe molten steel and thats unreliable because they aren't metallurgists lol

Have you ever personally spoken to a member of the FDNY who was on duty on 9/11/2001 or the months afterwards?

I HAVE.

Have you ever done any 9/11 research that didn't 100% rely on the Internet?

I HAVE.
 
well I am sure they have seen alot more unsteady, near collapsed buildings in their past as FIREFIGHTERS, than they have MOLTEN STEEL...

TAM:)

Really? Please list all the large buildings in New York that have completely collapsed before 911.
 
Really? Please list all the large buildings in New York that have completely collapsed before 911.
does the opposite not hold true though?

they said they saw molten steel, so it must have been molten steel because their firefighters and wouldnt lie

they said the building was fully involved with fire, with massive structural damage and was in danager of collapse, but no, it was barely on fire, no damage and wouldnt have collapsed without explosives
 
Numerous firefighters who arent structural engineers predict an unprecedented collapse and thats reliable

Yes.

Seeing a building such as WTC7 in the state was it in does not require an engineering degree to see that something is seriously wrong. Add to that that two other buildings had already collapsed, and it's not hard to see why they thought it might happen.

but numerous firefighters describe molten steel and thats unreliable because they aren't metallurgists lol

Molten metal - not molten steel. "Steel" in this case is likely being used as a synonym for "metal". I know of no-one who can take a quick glance at molten metal and determine what kind of metal it is.
 
Really? Please list all the large buildings in New York that have completely collapsed before 911.

Yes, and while your about it, show all buildings that collapsed in a similar fashion to the WTC7, and you'll see that they were all 'controlled demolitions'
 
Yes, and while your about it, show all buildings that collapsed in a similar fashion to the WTC7, and you'll see that they were all 'controlled demolitions'
and all planes that had crashed into buildings were just accidents, so apparently this whole terrorism vs inside job debate is all just one big misunderstanding
 
and all planes that had crashed into buildings were just accidents, so apparently this whole terrorism vs inside job debate is all just one big misunderstanding

Your logic is false.
There is, and was, before 911, good reason to believe that planes can be deliberately crashed into buildings...But there is no good reason at all to believe that buildings can collapse in the manner that WTC7 did, without a demolition.

Edit: Maybe that's why they are having difficulties in coming up with a credible report even after six years...
 
Last edited:
Really? Please list all the large buildings in New York that have completely collapsed before 911.

where did I say "Completely Collapsed" Rev...you can read right?

How about you Terry, you having trouble reading as well?

TAM:)
 
Please list all the ones that completely collapsed on 9/11....

BTW how do you visually determine the difference between molten lead, molten aluminium, and molten steel?
 
But there is no good reason at all to believe that buildings can collapse in the manner that WTC7 did, without a demolition.

But there IS good reason to believe that if there were 100 identical buildings, constructed exactly like WTC7, they would fail in similar ways if they were subjected to the same raining-down of tons of debris and hours of intense fire.
 
No one here doubts that the FDNY saw, felt, and heard explosions. But no one from the FDNY has claimed that they saw a bomb and then the bomb went off. Lots of things go boom. Only in the mind of a conspiracy theorist does explosion=bomb.

Have 9-11 Deniers ever considered all the possible explenations as to what could have caused explosions? This is what a true critical thinker does..and the answer is "NO".

This is the reason why 9-11 Deniers are not critical thinkers. They have a pre-determined outcome and theory already in their minds..and they will ignore ALL and ANY evidence which contradicts their pre-determined theory and outcome.

How do I know this is true? Ask any 9-11 Denier "what evidence would you need to see to believe that 9-11 was NOT an inside job?" and they will always answer "nothing...9-11 was an inside job".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom