Quaker Teacher Fired for Changing Loyalty Oath

I'm saying the original oath doesn't specify the form of defense she commits herself to, and so she is free to choose nonviolent defense.

Yes, I understand that you meant something like that. But that's only part of what you said. The other part is that the teacher shouldn't be allowed to insert the word "nonviolently" into the oath. I took that as an indication that you thought such an insertion would change the meaning of the oath, because I couldn't see any reason why you'd object to an insignificant change in wording. I still don't see any reason why you would, but apparently you do.

The harm is in setting a precedent that the oath is negotiable in any form.

It's setting a precedent that its wording can be changed in order to clarify that it means what (according to you) it always meant. That doesn't seem terribly problematic. Or, perhaps, you aren't really sure precisely what it did always mean. Me neither. In that case, I find ridiculous any requirement to "say these words, and never mind what they mean."

Surely, the significance of an oath lies in its meaning, not in the exact words used to express that meaning.

Such an allowance is fundamentally dishonest. Either the oath should not be negotiable, or it should not be in place at all.

I certainly do think that it shouldn't be in place at all.
 
Yes, I understand that you meant something like that. But that's only part of what you said. The other part is that the teacher shouldn't be allowed to insert the word "nonviolently" into the oath. I took that as an indication that you thought such an insertion would change the meaning of the oath, because I couldn't see any reason why you'd object to an insignificant change in wording. I still don't see any reason why you would, but apparently you do.

No. You fundamentally misunderstand my argument. The point is, there's no reason the state should have to figure out whether or not any changes alter the meaning or not. If the changes do not alter the meaning, then there's no reason to allow them because they're unnecessary, and if they do alter the meaning then it defeats the entire purpose. Which of those two it is in any particular case doesn't matter, there's no justification for allowing changes.

It's setting a precedent that its wording can be changed in order to clarify that it means what (according to you) it always meant.

No, it isn't. The precedent is only that it can be changed be the signer. Absent a court ruling, there can be no broader precedent set here.

I certainly do think that it shouldn't be in place at all.

That's fine. And the remedy, as I've said before, is quite obvious: remove the requirement completely. Allowing small changes doesn't actually satisfy the position you take.
 
Also where it says she will "swear or affirm", she crossed out "swear". The oath is unconcerned whether you swear, affirm, or both, but you must do one. Hence there is no need to cross out "swear" by even the strictest interpretation of oath takers. Any lawyer quizzing you on it on the witness stand would note you can indeed affirm but decline to swear. That's the whole purpose of the "or" in that phrase.

And technically she is correct. The Bible tells you not to "swear", which is to say, invoke damnation upon yourself should you be lying about whatever you're swearing is the truth.


The "nonviolent" thing is fascinating, though. Did the school district's lawyers actually suggest that a state employee would be required, if necessary, to use physical force to defend the Constitution? And that a person who refused to do this could be held accountable because of this oath?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom