Proof That God Does Not Exist Outside of Time

Yahweh

Philosopher
Joined
Apr 7, 2003
Messages
9,006
I have not seen this proof or anything like it before, so I feel special for having come up with something like this all on my own :) (I dont care if others have thought of it before me, I still feel special.)

I'm not exactly sure how to put this into "proof" form, so I am choosing to put it in the form of a dialogue.

Yahweh: Who created God?

Theist: He doesnt need a creator.

Yahweh: I suppose that was a poorly phrased question, I should have probably asked "where did God come from".

Theist: Then I would have answered "God has always existed".

Yahweh: It isnt obvious to me why that is.

Theist: Because God created time. Ergo, God exists outside of time. Ergo, God has always existed.

Yahweh: So God exists outside of time, I suppose that means God cant be omnipresent (existing across all space and time) can he?

Theist: This is a common lingual issue. It's more accurate to say God exists independent of time and space. He is neither constraint by nor necessarily seperated from time or space, and can thus be both preceding and outlasting time while being omnipresented within time-constrained space.

Yahweh: Alright, so you mean to say that omnipresence is not a necessary property of God, but rather a contingent property.

Theist: Can you expand on that?

Yahweh: Sure. All I have to ask is "was God omnipresent (existing across all space and time) before he created space and time", and hence omnipresence cannot be a necessary property of God.

Theist: Interesting thought.

Yahweh: Indeed, and an interesting non-traditional interpretation of God. I dont think its logically possible for God to exist outside of time.

Theist: How so?

Yahweh: Because it is impossible for actions which "follow" one another without reference to time. Hence, the logical impossibility of a creator who exists outside of time.

Theist: Hmmmm...
 
i'm not so sure god exists outside of time. anybody have the final word on that?

i think yesterday is forever lost. history.

and yahweh was a fact yesterday. sometime in the future, she will be legend, maybe. further out on the timeline, she will become myth, perhaps.

it seems that time is not kind to us, in several ways.
 
Riddick said:
and yahweh was a fact yesterday. sometime in the future, she will be legend, maybe. further out on the timeline, she will become myth, perhaps.
Welcome to my sig line :)

Note: Quote edited slightly for capitalization.
 
It always has struck me as odd when people say, "Before time began...". Any event which occurs would signify the start of time, period.

I think that's solid, Yahweh - good going.
 
Yahweh said:

Yahweh: Sure. All I have to ask is "was God omnipresent (existing across all space and time) before he created space and time", and hence omnipresence cannot be a necessary property of God.

If the Universe, including time and space, is a contingent property of God, then so also is omnipresence and ommipotence.

No contradiction
 
If time and space come together in the here and now, which is the moment, then the moment must be inclusive of time and space ... for the moment is here, there and everywhere, all at once. Therefore, if the moment is all-inclusive, shouldn't it also exist outside of time and space? ... as well as within?
 
Iacchus said:
If time and space come together in the here and now, which is the momet, then the moment must be inclusive of time and space ... for the moment is here, there and everywhere, all at once. Therefore, if the moment is all-inclusive, shouldn't it also exist outside of time and space? ... as well as within?

Bless you.

Oops, ya got a boogie on your chin, there, Iacchus.

BROKEN DOWN FOR LOGIC ANALYSIS:

If spacetime exists (CONCEPT: HERE AND NOW = THE MOMENT; BY MEANING - PRESENT SPACE-TIME COORDINATE? DEFINITION UNCLEAR - REMOVING UNDEFINED STATEMENT)... missing expression... followed by further undefined statement... followed by gibberish about relationship of undefined statement to spacetime...

Nope - nothing of content. Typical Iacchus post.
 
The moment is not contingent upon time and space, it is Eternity. This is what we had before time and space.
 
Iacchus said:
The moment is not contingent upon time and space, it is Eternity. This is what we had before time and space.

The concept of something being "before" time and space is logically bankrupt. It almost hurts my brain to think about it. It doesn't work, Iacchus - try harder.
 
Iacchus said:
The moment is not contingent upon time and space, it is Eternity. This is what we had before time and space.

Time and space are attributes of our universe. We cannot make attributions to before or after the universe since there can be no (absolutely NO) knowledge of them. Since Eternity implies time, how can it be before the universe?

Robert
 
kuroyume0161 said:

Time and space are attributes of our universe. We cannot make attributions to before or after the universe since there can be no (absolutely NO) knowledge of them. Since Eternity implies time, how can it be before the universe?

Robert
And if the Universe were in a state of non-physicalness and had no beginning? With respect to the God which created it and is Eternal?
 
Iacchus said:
And if the Universe were in a state of non-physicalness and had no beginning? With respect to the God which created it and is Eternal?

How could the universe have no beginning and yet have been created (an even that requires a beginning)?

Robert
 
Iacchus said:
The moment is not contingent upon time and space, it is Eternity. This is what we had before time and space.

Am I the only one who thinks this is just a pile of word stuck togheter to pose as having some sense?

Looks nice and wise for woos, but when one tries to find any real meaning...
 
Correa Neto said:
Am I the only one who thinks this is just a pile of word stuck togheter to pose as having some sense?

Looks nice and wise for woos, but when one tries to find any real meaning...

I'm beginning to think that Iacchus has the world's most complete collection of fortune cookie sayings, fortune-teller-machine outputs, and ouija board readings.

BTW

My ouija board responded to "What is Iacchus?" with the letters "I-D-O-I-T-D-O-R-Q-F-V-L-yes-no-?" Think there's anything to this? :D
 
That´s the type of sentence you also see coming out of many politician´s mouths...

Meaningless mumble-jumbo arranged to pass as something usefull.
 
Correa Neto said:
That´s the type of sentence you also see coming out of many politician´s mouths...

Meaningless mumble-jumbo arranged to pass as something usefull.
Compared to Iacchus, politicians are models of lucidity. There is no Rosetta Stone that can decipher the stream of gibberish that he emits.
 
Yahweh said:
Yahweh: Sure. All I have to ask is "was God omnipresent (existing across all space and time) before he created space and time", and hence omnipresence cannot be a necessary property of God.

Theist: Interesting thought.
If space and time didn't exist, how could God exist across it? I don't see how this question makes any sense. Is there asphalt covering the highway between Los Angeles and Honolulu?

Yahweh: Indeed, and an interesting non-traditional interpretation of God. I dont think its logically possible for God to exist outside of time.

Theist: How so?

Yahweh: Because it is impossible for actions which "follow" one another without reference to time. Hence, the logical impossibility of a creator who exists outside of time.

Theist: Hmmmm...
To paraphrase Rumsfeld, we use the words we have, not the words we want. A state of being unaffected by time is not something that we, as 3-dimensional time-bound entities, have any real way of describing. So we're going to use ill-fitting words like "before" to describe the state of God before He created the universe, simply because we don't have better words.

We're Flatlanders living on a finite plane, and we're trying to describe 3-dimensional space without having any knowledge of the word "up".
 
Excerpt from Joseph Campbell's, The Power of Myth ...


The vision of Black Elk ...

He says, "I saw myself on the central mountain of the world, the highest place, and I had a vision because I was seeing in the sacred manner of the world." And the sacred central mountain was Harney Peak in South Dakota. And then he says, "But the central mountain is everywhere."

That is a real mythological realization. It distinguishes between the local cult image, Harney Peak, and its connotation as the center of the world. The center of the world is the axis mundi, the central point, the pole around which all revolves. The central point of the world is the point where stillness and movement are together. Movement is time, but stillness is eternity. Realizing how this moment of your life is actually a moment of eternity, and experiencing the eternal aspect of what you're doing in the temporal experience -- this is the mythological experience.
 
Tricky said:

Compared to Iacchus, politicians are models of lucidity. There is no Rosetta Stone that can decipher the stream of gibberish that he emits.
Where have you been hanging out lately Tricky? Haven't heard too much from you lately? :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom