Proof of no demolition

So long as we're going to speak in terms of hypotheticals I'd like to know what you think should have been done? Put yourself in the President's shoes. America was attacked, the guys that did it are inside Afghanistan calling for a holywar and the group that thinks it's the government won't give them up.

What would your course of action have been?

I see someone's derailed our derail, but since you asked, I'd have done something that I know Americans would have hated (hey even so I doubt my popularity would have dropped below 27%.) I'd have waited. I'd have sent in SF through Pakistan and had them blend into the population and surroundings in Southern Afghanistan and then waited. While waiting I'd have made sure that we got intelligence on where OBL was and then once he figured he was safe and that I wasn't planning to attack the country, so he could stick his head out of his cave, I'm have removed it for him.
 
A book on slums? I'm not with you.

Was a shot at the way the UN has (mis)handled Zimbabwe

Care to identify any nations that you consider were threats to peace and security, that had not been identified as such?

Depends on what you call threats to peace and security. Our peace and security, or the peace and security of the people living in the country? If the second, then yes.
 
When the three religions didn't have each other to fight with, they splintered and fought with themselves. They seem obsessed with fighting.

You know, I find it interesting looking at the listed Terrorists Groups that there are a total of 9 Christian or Jewish ones, 3 of the 5 so called Christian ones being in India, One in Thailand and one in the US (pretty much a Neo-Nazi group.) There are 42 listed Islamic ones. However, there are 62 Ethnically, or Politically based Terrorist organisations, and that doesn't include Northern Ireland or Cuba or the Ecological or other issue specific groups. Seems to me that there are more people that fight based on politics or ethnic background than there are that fight over religion (especially the Jewish and Christian religions)
 
A couple posts up you declared that you were "anti-Americanism", not "anti-American". It didn't take long for you to betray that lie.

Why? Because I think that most Americans don't know what's going on outside their own country? From most of what I have seen they don't. That's not really surprising either, America is so big that they don't have to be bothered with what is happening in the rest of the world, they have enough to keep themselves occupied inside their borders.

BTW I have never made a secret that I dislike the way many Americans act when in groups, nor have I hidden how I feel about the way the US Government treats non-Americans, yet I still stand up and defend them when they deserve defending. If I was really anti-American, would I do that? Would I be here defernding their actions on 9/11 or NASA over Apollo? One more thing I haven't made a secret of, my gf lives in Omaha. If I really was anti-America, would I have an American gf?

Americanism is different to Americans. It is the attitudes and way of doing things that get up my nose, not the people themselves. There are a lot of Americans I'd like to be able to call friends (I even like a few of the Aussies I know) but when it comes to America's apparent need to thrust its culture, politics and way of doing things onto the rest of the world I draw a line.
 
Just caught up with this thread and I only have two things to say:

1) Gumboot, Australia doesn't have any Nuclear power stations. We have one experimental reactor at Lucas Heights which isn't used for power generation. Medical isotopes mostly I believe.

2) You left Neil Finn off your list of famous Kiwis. He has written some of the best pop songs ever and you should be proud of him.
 
He left a few off, like William Pickering (head of JLP during the 60's), Temuera Morrison (Jango Fett) and Rena Owen (Actress) and made a boo-boo in refering to Jeff and Martin as Russel's brothers. They are actually his cousins.
 
Last edited:
Why? Because I think that most Americans don't know what's going on outside their own country? From most of what I have seen they don't. That's not really surprising either, America is so big that they don't have to be bothered with what is happening in the rest of the world, they have enough to keep themselves occupied inside their borders.

BTW I have never made a secret that I dislike the way many Americans act when in groups, nor have I hidden how I feel about the way the US Government treats non-Americans, yet I still stand up and defend them when they deserve defending. If I was really anti-American, would I do that? Would I be here defernding their actions on 9/11 or NASA over Apollo? One more thing I haven't made a secret of, my gf lives in Omaha. If I really was anti-America, would I have an American gf?

Americanism is different to Americans. It is the attitudes and way of doing things that get up my nose, not the people themselves. There are a lot of Americans I'd like to be able to call friends (I even like a few of the Aussies I know) but when it comes to America's apparent need to thrust its culture, politics and way of doing things onto the rest of the world I draw a line.
You still seem to be framing it as some sort of cultural flaw, though, not merely the fumbling missteps of a giant that grew up too fast and is trying to do the right thing but without an adequately analogous precedent to model itself after. In other words, it's not Americanism that's the problem--it's the unintended consequences of Super-Powerism.

edit: BTW, are Americans unique in their distasteful group behavior? I dislike the way many people of all stripes act when in groups in certain situations.
 
Last edited:
Just caught up with this thread and I only have two things to say:

1) Gumboot, Australia doesn't have any Nuclear power stations. We have one experimental reactor at Lucas Heights which isn't used for power generation. Medical isotopes mostly I believe.


I was referring to future Australian nuclear power generation which there seems to be a lot of talk about, and which I think is a likely prospect.

I figured if New Zealand jumped on board, provided resources to help develop and run it, and laid a cable across the Tasman, we could join in.


2) You left Neil Finn off your list of famous Kiwis. He has written some of the best pop songs ever and you should be proud of him.

Neil and Tim Finn. I know, but I was trying to list world famous people as much as possible. I'm not sure how well known Crowded House and Split Enz are outside Australasia. Hence why I also didn't mention people like Murray Ball.



He left a few off, like William Pickering (head of JLP during the 60's)

William Pickering is on my list.



Temuera Morrison (Jango Fett) and Rena Owen (Actress)


See above, neither of these two are especially famous outside New Zealand.

I also left off Nigel Brown, Rita Angus, Charles Goldie, Charles Heaphy, and Colin McCahon (all painters). I left off a lot of people.


and made a boo-boo in refering to Jeff and Martin as Russel's brothers. They are actually his cousins.

That's true. My bad.

-Gumboot
 
You still seem to be framing it as some sort of cultural flaw, though, not merely the fumbling missteps of a giant that grew up too fast and is trying to do the right thing but without an adequately analogous precedent to model itself after. In other words, it's not Americanism that's the problem--it's the unintended consequences of Super-Powerism.

Probably because I see it more as a cultural thing. Many Americans tend to have a culture of being loud, arrogant, and voicing their opinion that the US way is the only way, and the US is the only part of the world that really counts for anything. Most often when in groups. While amiddly it may not be intentional, the general impression it gives is that Americans believe that America is the greatest and everywhere else are little backward places of no importance and since America is so wonderful and great, and because everyone else is so pitiful and useless, everyone else should darn well shutup do what America tells them or else. That's the impression they give.

Americans often go on about how the US is a "young country still finding it's way." Well here's a newsbreak. New Zealand and Australia are way, way, way younger and yet we're out there leading the world in a number of things too.

In the end it's easy to get feed up with feeling that you are being condecended too, outright ignored and having your own culture run roughshod over because in the eyes of the 'super-power' you're nothing more than an upstart who doesn't know their place. Whether you like it or not impressions and perceptions matter a great deal in the real world, (something I wish our current Government would fast come to figure out,) and right now the US is giving the impression that since they are the most powerful and greatest nation on the planet, that anyone that dares to disagree with them and their way of doing things matters and if you do dare disagree or have an alien culture and concepts, well they can just rub you into the carpet like a piece of dirt. Not the way to win friends and influence people.
 
See above, neither of these two are especially famous outside New Zealand.

Ummmm, you realise that Star Wars has make them both household names worldwide among Sci-Fi fans. Hence why I listed Temuera Morrison as Jango Fett.
 
Probably because I see it more as a cultural thing. Many Americans tend to have a culture of being loud, arrogant, and voicing their opinion that the US way is the only way, and the US is the only part of the world that really counts for anything. Most often when in groups. While amiddly it may not be intentional, the general impression it gives is that Americans believe that America is the greatest and everywhere else are little backward places of no importance and since America is so wonderful and great, and because everyone else is so pitiful and useless, everyone else should darn well shutup do what America tells them or else. That's the impression they give.

Americans often go on about how the US is a "young country still finding it's way." Well here's a newsbreak. New Zealand and Australia are way, way, way younger and yet we're out there leading the world in a number of things too.

In the end it's easy to get feed up with feeling that you are being condecended too, outright ignored and having your own culture run roughshod over because in the eyes of the 'super-power' you're nothing more than an upstart who doesn't know their place. Whether you like it or not impressions and perceptions matter a great deal in the real world, (something I wish our current Government would fast come to figure out,) and right now the US is giving the impression that since they are the most powerful and greatest nation on the planet, that anyone that dares to disagree with them and their way of doing things matters and if you do dare disagree or have an alien culture and concepts, well they can just rub you into the carpet like a piece of dirt. Not the way to win friends and influence people.
There, there. NZ is nice, too. :rub:


I kid. Seriously, though, do you really believe in that broad-brush caricature you just painted? I mean, I agree that American foreign policy has often been a rude, obnoxious, and hegemonic embarrassment in recent years and in other recent decades. But honestly: "rub you into the carpet like a piece of dirt"???

You have a problem with unearned pride and undeserved disrespect. I don't blame you, I do too. Your frustration is completely out of focus, though. Try to find more accurate nouns and pronouns than "America" or even "Americanism" or even "many Americans"--there's a whole huge array of them to choose from.
 
I was referring to future Australian nuclear power generation which there seems to be a lot of talk about, and which I think is a likely prospect.

I think most, if not all, of our state governments have banned nuclear power stations. The Federal government is trying to get around the ban, but I think they're pushing ◊◊◊◊ up hill - the scare mongers have been working overtime.
 
Americans often go on about how the US is a "young country still finding it's way."
I've never seen that sentiment expressed, much less "often."

But really, let's reserve these discussions for the politics forum, okay?
 
Ummmm, you realise that Star Wars has make them both household names worldwide among Sci-Fi fans. Hence why I listed Temuera Morrison as Jango Fett.



I doubt that very much. Being in a Star Wars film doesn't automatically make you a household name.

Actually I suspect Cliff Curtis is more recognised outside New Zealand than Temuera Morrison. I probably should have mentioned him.

You may be right on Temuera Morrison however, he, like Cliff Curtis, is a bit borderline. They're certainly not of the same level of fame as people like Sam Neill Anna Paquin, and Russell Crowe, however.

I looked at it two ways. Some people are famous for their work - such as scientists, explorers, etc. Others are celebrities. While actors may be familiar to audiences via their roles, they don't really classify as a "famous" actor unless people recognise the actor them self.

This is why phenomenal actors like Gary Oldman are often overlooked.

-Gumboot
 
Probably because I see it more as a cultural thing. Many Americans tend to have a culture of being loud, arrogant, and voicing their opinion that the US way is the only way, and the US is the only part of the world that really counts for anything. Most often when in groups. While amiddly it may not be intentional, the general impression it gives is that Americans believe that America is the greatest and everywhere else are little backward places of no importance and since America is so wonderful and great, and because everyone else is so pitiful and useless, everyone else should darn well shutup do what America tells them or else. That's the impression they give.


Heh... you've been hanging out with the wrong Americans.




In the end it's easy to get feed up with feeling that you are being condecended too, outright ignored and having your own culture run roughshod over because in the eyes of the 'super-power' you're nothing more than an upstart who doesn't know their place.


Er... well politically I can understand the USA's attitude towards New Zealand. We're friends, not allies. Allies come first. We chose the foreign policy that has caused rifts between us and some of our former allies. It was our choice to do so. Any choice has consequences. We knew what those consequences would be when we made the choices.

Socially and culturally, I utterly disagree with you. New Zealand's culture is alive and well. It has huge local support, and is highly recognised internationally. The USA simply offers its culture to the world. If the world laps it up, that's the world's fault. We don't have to have American television programmes playing constantly. We chose that. Our Maori and pacific island RnB artists aren't being forced to mimic the LA Gangster image. They chose to. Consciously and eagerly.



Whether you like it or not impressions and perceptions matter a great deal in the real world, (something I wish our current Government would fast come to figure out,) and right now the US is giving the impression that since they are the most powerful and greatest nation on the planet, that anyone that dares to disagree with them and their way of doing things matters and if you do dare disagree or have an alien culture and concepts, well they can just rub you into the carpet like a piece of dirt. Not the way to win friends and influence people.


See, I don't get that impression from the USA at all. I get the impression that a heck of a lot of people desperately want to believe the above is true, but when I look at what is actually happening in the world, I don't see it.

-Gumboot
 
I've never seen that sentiment expressed, much less "often."

But really, let's reserve these discussions for the politics forum, okay?



We could phrase it that the USA has a conspiracy to take over the world using its culture. That would be a conspiracy theory.

-Gumboot
 
Seriously, though, do you really believe in that broad-brush caricature you just painted? I mean, I agree that American foreign policy has often been a rude, obnoxious, and hegemonic embarrassment in recent years and in other recent decades. But honestly: "rub you into the carpet like a piece of dirt"???

Well okay, so perhaps not quite, but I had a good rant going. :p

You have a problem with unearned pride and undeserved disrespect. I don't blame you, I do too. Your frustration is completely out of focus, though. Try to find more accurate nouns and pronouns than "America" or even "Americanism" or even "many Americans"--there's a whole huge array of them to choose from.

Hmm, but most of them are unprintable. :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom