muscleman
Person A cannot do anything outside the laws of physics.
God controls the laws of physics.
Person A cannot do anything outside the control of god. (no freewill)
Using your definitions you cannot have it both ways; either humanity has freewill which would place us outside the laws of physics or humanity has to obey the laws of physics which would remove our freewill since god controls the laws of physics. Now, using your definitions, which one do you want to argue?
[your statement] Slippery Slope, From Ignorance, False Dilemma, Prejudicial Language, Post Hoc, Begging the Question, Affirming the Consequent, Untestability,
2. using your analogy,
a) a person(computer) is incapable of freewill
b) a person does something bad (computer runs a bad program)
c) controller of person punishes the person (person dismantles computer)
Want the baby to be blond, no problem.
Want to get rid of that pesky sickle cell anemia, no problem.
A bit in the future but that is what we are working toward.
MRC_Hans
A very intelligent and well thought out reply.
Ossai
edited for code
So close and yet so far. If god is driving and wrecks the car the car is destroyed. God then hops into another car and wrecks it, again, and again, and again, etc. Actually, according to your beliefs, god not only drives the car but also built it. He built it in such a manner that it would wreck no matter who was driving.BUT YOU IN THE OTHER HAND WANTS THE BOSS TO ROAST IN HELL. HE ALREADY SUFFERED, BUT YOU WANT HIM TO SUFFER ACCORDING TO YOUR WISH, AS IF YOUR THE GOD... OR YOU WANT THE DRIVER TO SUFFER, BUT NOT THE CAR, BECAUSE YOU WANT THE LAWS OF PHYSICS TO OBEY TO YOU AS IF YOUR THE MASTER, AND THE LAWS OF PHYSICS OBEY TO YOU AS IF YOUR GOD... YOU WANT TO BE THE BOSS, AND THE LAWS OF PHYSICS IS THE SERVANT.
From Merriam-WebsterA FREEWILL DEFINED BY WEBSTERS, WHICH MEANS "DONE IN ONE'S ACCORD"... YOU DEFINED THE WORD "FREEWILL" TO MEAN "NOT BEING CONTROLLED,
Main Entry: free will
Function: noun
Date: 13th century
1 : voluntary choice or decision < I do this of my own free will >
2 : freedom of humans to make choices that are not determined by prior causes or by divine intervention
I never claimed to be the alpha or the omega, that is just another straw man you have erected so you don’t actually have to examine the original argument.TO HAVE FREEWILL DOESNT MEAN TO BE THE ALPHA, GOD IS THE ALPHA AND THE OMEGA, NOT YOU
A big difference you continue to overlook. God is supposedly conscious. The laws of physics are not conscious. The laws of physics are the framework of existence.YOUR RIGHT, IT IS THE CHURCH THAT SAID GOD IS IN CONTROL OF EVERYTHING...
JUST AS SCIENCE IS SAYING WE ARE ALL UNDER THE LAWS OF PHYSICS AND THE LAWS OF NATURE,
Again you are claiming that we do not have freewill. You are equating god to the laws of physics.YOU DONOT DO OUTSIDE OF WHAT THE LAWS PERMIT, YOU ARE UNDER THE LAWS, THE LAWS ARE IN CONTROL OF YOU, IF NOT, THEN YOUR CLAIMING TO BE SUPERNATURAL...
ARE YOU SUPERNATURAL?
Person A cannot do anything outside the laws of physics.
God controls the laws of physics.
Person A cannot do anything outside the control of god. (no freewill)
Using your definitions you cannot have it both ways; either humanity has freewill which would place us outside the laws of physics or humanity has to obey the laws of physics which would remove our freewill since god controls the laws of physics. Now, using your definitions, which one do you want to argue?
Computers are not conscious. A computer cannot claim ownership have it’s own keyboard, mouse, etc. By using the above analogy, you have again relegated people to mere objects that are created, owned and controlled by god. The computer(people) may have ignorance but not freewill.Being our own simply means "FRUIT OF SELF'S WORK"... A computer have its "OWN" SCREEN...
IT HAS ITS "OWN" KEYBOARD...
IT HAS ITS OWN MOUSE...
IT HAS ITS OWN SPEAKERS...
Argumentum ad hominem. I never claimed to be smarter than theologians or scholars in their chosen fields but if you are their highest caliber then the claim doesn’t even have to be made since it’s apparent that you lack even basic grammatical skills.DO YOU THINK YOU ARE SMARTER THAN THEOLOGIANS?
DO YOU THINK YOU ARE SMARTER THAN THE SCHOLARS OF THE CHURCH?
So how does a person have the ability to go against god’s accord? Seems that you are saying that people have more power than god, at least in the physical world.WHY DO U THINK GOD SAID "WHAT YOU DO UNTO OTHERS YOU DID UNTO ME"...
WHY? ALTHOUGH THEY ARE THEIR OWN ACCORD, THEY ARE ALSO GOD'S OWN ACCORD..
WHY DO YOU THINK GOD SAID "LOVE YOUR NEIGHBORS?"
BECAUSE WHILE THEY ARE THEIR OWN ACCORD, THEY ARE ALSO GOD'S OWN ACCORD.
Go back and reread my posts. I have consistently stayed with the same definition. Franko is the one that uses worlds and makes up his own definitions.THATS WHY WHEN ARGUING, WE SHOULD STICK TO ONE DEFINITION..
I’m still standing. Waiting on the battlefield for more than an apologetic response. Evidence is lacking much less a formal logical proof of the existence of a supernatural entity. Although, straw men continue to be erected.THE REAL CHALLENGE FOR YOU GUYS IS TO DEBATE ME AND DEBUNK MY ARGUMENTS (IF YOU CAN)..
SO MANY FALLEN ATHEISTS SOLDIERS (OSSA, SCOTH, BELETH, ETC. ETC.) THAT HAVE CONFRONTED ME, WHOS NEXT?
[your statement] Slippery Slope, From Ignorance, False Dilemma, Prejudicial Language, Post Hoc, Begging the Question, Affirming the Consequent, Untestability,
So, I can make you evil by administering drugs that make you have bad feeling/emotions.FOR INSTANCE...EMOTIONS IS A FRUIT OF THE SPIRIT OF GOOD OR EVIL, AMD EMOITION IS "YOUR" SPIRIT (WHETHER YOUR EVIL OR NOT...)
A claim of the supernatural by you when it is only ignorance speaking.ANOTHER ENTITY CAN ALSO GIVE YOU EMOTION (ANOTHER HUMAN BRAIN), THEY CAN SEND INFO, THOUGH THE INFO BEING SENT IS UNDETECTABLE OR INVISIBLE (LIKE THE REMOTE CONTROLLED ANYTHING.).
Now, not only can I control someone but I can do it and be ‘present’ yet not there. Time Release Evil!IN SUMMARY, IF YOU FEEL AN "EMOTION" OTHER THAN WHAT YOUR BRAIN IS THINKING OF, THAT PROVES ANOTHER "EXISTING ENTITY" PRESENT AMONG YOU, IF NOT A HUMAN BEING, THEN SOMETHING ELSE.
1. computers aren’t consciousTHE LAWS OF PHYSICS ARE "ATTACHED" TO EVERY ATOMS IN OUR BRAIN, ATOMS MAKE UP BRAIN, ATOMS MAKE BRAIN CONSCIOUS...
IF CONSCIOUS, THEN THE CAUSE IS ALSO CONSCIOUS. EVEN A HIGHER CONSCIOUS THAN THE EFFECT...
A BRAIN SENDS INFORMATION, A BRAIN IS "A GIVEN, GUIDED" INFORMATION.
2. using your analogy,
a) a person(computer) is incapable of freewill
b) a person does something bad (computer runs a bad program)
c) controller of person punishes the person (person dismantles computer)
The laws of physics are very much detectable by direct and indirect observation.NOW, OF COURSE YOU WOULD SAY " THE LAWS OF PHYSICS IS UNDETECTABLE, THEREFORE IT DONT EXIST.."
Physics are very detectable. God is just a security blanket for those unable or unwilling to face reality.LAWS OF PHYSICS IS INVISIBLE..
GOD IS INVISIBLE..
The hear is a muscle and does not ‘feel’ in the manner you describe. The mind is the seat of emotions, although some chemicals(hormones) are produced elsewhere in the body the mind is what ‘feels’. The soul is an unnecessary addition.I CAN FEEL GOD IN MY HEART, MY SOUL, AND MY MIND...
What debate? You make baseless statements then ignore replies when your logic is refuted.Nope, its not. But good luck in winning a debate against me, by the way, unlike the cults here, I use facts, true definitions, and logic, so just make sure ur prepared
The other beliefs and theories you mention are backed by evidence. Something, which you apparently still do not comprehend.I agree. It is a BELIEF that our mind can work without us being aware how it works, an example of it is dream at night. But your also right, OTHER BELIEFS AND THEORIES ARE AVALIABLE AS WELL...
No it goes to supernatural, outside nature.God is physical, and God is non-physical...
So again, the topic goes back to what is physical and non-physical again?
Go take some basic high school level physics classes. While you are at it you might also like to look into a basic English class as well.Not attached? How do u define attach? If not attached (to interact, at some point they need to attach and release.), then how do they interact?
What is the law of physics anyway? How do u define it? Non material? Non-physical? Beyond subatomic level?
Virus. Crystallize it and it’s ‘dead’. Uncrystallize and it suddenly ‘lives’.YOU DISAGREED, WILL U MIND IF I ASK TO SET AN EXAMPLE OF A INTELLIGENT LIFE FORM EMERGING OUT OF ROCKS BY LUCK? WOULD U PLEASE GIVE "FACTUAL PROOF" OF NONLIFE+ NONLIFE= LIFE.
Yes they can be detected at that size, although it does require some specialized equipment.The DNA strands in a zygote that makes up our hair color, nose size, etc. CANNOT BE DETECTED AT THAT SIZE. THAT WAS MY POINT...
Have you even heard about he Human Genome Project? Not only is it detectable but DNA is currently being mapped out so that it can be changed.Again, contained in the DNA, BUT NOT DETECTED IN THE DNA, GOT IT??
Want the baby to be blond, no problem.
Want to get rid of that pesky sickle cell anemia, no problem.
A bit in the future but that is what we are working toward.
MRC_Hans
A very intelligent and well thought out reply.
Ossai
edited for code