Proof of God's existence! 1 million dollar challenge at the end! Randi better pay-up!

muscleman said:
John Lockard, first and foremost I appreciate you gettin in the conversation, your not like the cowards here, who are NEVER GOOD IN DEBATES, but only knows how to type "YOUR A TROLL MUSCLEMAN, YOUR A STRAWMAN MUSCLEMAN, YOUR THIS, YOUR THAT, YOU NEED THIS, ETC.".. But have NO ARGUMENTS TO PRESENT...

Who called you a strawman? :confused:
 
Tricky said:

Then you are exhibiting a double-standard, wraith. When you say you control a car, are you talking about controlling the car's thoughts? Somehow I doubt that you would be that foolish.

haha!
Whats this? Assigning "thoughts" to a car now Tricky? Poets call this little number "personification". You should tell them about your little toast gag :rolleyes:

but nice strawman nevertheless ;)

No, you are talking about controlling actions. But now you insist for a virus to control you it has to control both your thoughts and actions? Keep it consistant, lad.

...well arnt your actions based on your thoughts?

Of course, the virus does control some of your thoughts. It forces you to think, "Damn, I feel like crap."

hmmm...
The virus may "force" me to think this, only because I hate being sick. However, are you saying that the virus is controlling me to say "Damn, I feel like crap"?
 
MRC_Hans said:
wraith: Are you more than youre thoughts/perceptions?

Hans: Well, try to go without food and drink for a few days and see what you think.

ahhh ok? What are you saying?

wraith: In your example of the boat, sure if Im out in the sea in a small row boat, the wind and currents would be controlling the movements of the boat, but in no way are they controlling me.

Hans: You could move around in the boat more or less as you pleased, but they would surely control where you were going. In other words, they would exert control over you, despite their being unconscious and unaware of you, which is my point.

So the wind and currents control my thoughts by controlling my movements?

wraith: Unless you look at the whole picture and see that the elements of nature are a product of TLOP, in this case, TLOP is controlling me in any case....

Hans: That is circular reasoning, or begging the question: You are using the conclusion to prove itself. That won't do; your claim was that to control something conscious, a higer consciousness is needed. Since the idea of that was to prove the tlop is conscious, you can't use that as a premise.
So the answer to that is: "Why, yes, tlop controls me, and tlop has not been proved conscious."

Look real close at what I said Hans....notice how I didnt use the word "consciousness"?

I said "TLOP is controlling me in any case."

So what are you saying? That you are indeed controlled by TLOP?
 
Wraith:
Mmm, this is getting silly. What are we discussing here? Lets start from scratch....

My claim is:
Tlop is a description of how reality behaves. So as a matter of definition everthing real behaves like described by tlop, me and atoms included.

To preclude the "map - landscape" discussion, I will point out that the tlop (description of how reality behaves) that we know and use is both incomplete and imperfect.

Whenever we observe parts of reality that do not follow our current version of tlop, we amend it, thus hopefully making it more complete and less imperfect.

Your claim is:?


Hans
 
I'm really starting to despise the term "tlop".

It's been what, a couple years since franko introduced that lovely term? Well, I'm sick of it.

THE LAWS OF PHYSICS.

Ok, better. Thanks.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Wraith:
Mmm, this is getting silly. What are we discussing here? Lets start from scratch....

My claim is:
Tlop is a description of how reality behaves. So as a matter of definition everthing real behaves like described by tlop, me and atoms included.

To preclude the "map - landscape" discussion, I will point out that the tlop (description of how reality behaves) that we know and use is both incomplete and imperfect.

Whenever we observe parts of reality that do not follow our current version of tlop, we amend it, thus hopefully making it more complete and less imperfect.

Your claim is:?

I agree with you on this.
Im saying that TLOP is the work of a consciousness. Youre saying that TLOP is non-conscious.
 
wraith said:


I agree with you on this.
Im saying that TLOP is the work of a consciousness. Youre saying that TLOP is non-conscious.

you are both wrong and damn it is pissing me off.

THE LAWS OF PHYSICS are descriptions made by man of how man sees the world. That's it. No more.

There will probably be more laws added, and maybe some removed. It all depends on what we find out as we go along.

The only consciousness is man's, insofar as the only description can be made by man. There is no other.

Now shut up and play nice, ok?
 
wraith said:


I agree with you on this.
Im saying that TLOP is the work of a consciousness. Youre saying that TLOP is non-conscious.
So far, there is no contradiction. Reality, and thus the laws of physics (to please Buki :p ), may be created by a consciousness.

That doesn't mean that "the laws of physics" is a conscious entity. My point is that the laws of physics do not have separate existence, they are the properties of reality.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
So far, there is no contradiction. Reality, and thus the laws of physics (to please Buki :p ), may be created by a consciousness.

That doesn't mean that "the laws of physics" is a conscious entity. My point is that the laws of physics do not have separate existence, they are the properties of reality.

Hans
Ok, a comment:

Do not, I repeat, NOT say anything just to "please" me. That smacks of favoritism and condescension, and I don't like it. Just say what you want to say, and that will be fine.

Now then. What consciousness do you think created the laws of physics? And what "reality" are you referring to?
 
buki said:
you are both wrong and damn it is pissing me off.

THE LAWS OF PHYSICS are descriptions made by man of how man sees the world. That's it. No more.

There will probably be more laws added, and maybe some removed. It all depends on what we find out as we go along.

Mmm, I could have sworn that was what I said ;)

The only consciousness is man's, insofar as the only description can be made by man. There is no other.

How can you know this?

Now shut up and play nice, ok?

Shut up I will not. I am playing nice (you don't want to see me play dirty :p )

:) Hans
 
buki said:
Ok, a comment:

Do not, I repeat, NOT say anything just to "please" me. That smacks of favoritism and condescension, and I don't like it. Just say what you want to say, and that will be fine.

Now then. What consciousness do you think created the laws of physics? And what "reality" are you referring to?

Well, dont worry, I'm sick of "TLOP" too, heheh.

I do not think a consciousness created reality, but lacking sufficient information, I reserve the possibility. That consciousness would be the one we term "God".

What reality? I was not aware there was more than one ;).

I am referring to the reality we live in; while our perceptions of it differ somewhat, only very few seriously suggest that it does not exist (and I really can't bother with those).

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
The only consciousness is man's, insofar as the only description can be made by man. There is no other.

How can you know this?:) Hans
How can you not?
 
Thanks goes to Muscleman for providing me with this link to a dictionary of logical fallacies. Although I didn't learn very much from it, the naming of specific fallacies makes them easier to reference and it makes you sound more authoritative because it's concise, and because nobody is safe!

This is a thread to end atheism and claims that God dont exist once and for all. I DARE anyone here refute my arguments
That's prejudicial language because "DARING" someone to refute you attaches the immense value to your arguments that only a fool or extremely brave person would stand against them. Note the emotional value he attaches to the capitalization of the word "DARE."

so far NONE have found any flaws of my argument...
Is that an appeal to popularity?

Below are questions and answers that I was confronted over the years debating with many atheists. I also have a 1 million dollar challenge at the end, this is no joke, Im serious.......


Here Ill post the proof of God's existence..........
It begins...

Ultimate Reality…
“God, the giver of life??”




The first life form to evolve from earth is "Cell", the building blocks of life. It would take about 40,000 of your red blood cells to fill this letter O. A cell is alive-as alive as you are. It "breathes," takes in food, & gets rid of wastes. It also grows & reproduces (creates its own kind). And in time, it dies. An optical microscope can magnify a cell up to 2,000 times. An electron microscope can magnify a cell by 1 million times. An ant magnified 200,000 times would be more than 21/2 miles (4 kilometers) long. But even with such tremendous magnification, the detailed structure of some cell parts still cannot be seen.

Is it possible that a detailed and complex form happens by chance w/out an intelligent cause?
Complex question right there. Musclman is asking two questions:
Can detailed and complex organisms happen by chance?
Do you believe that chance is independent of intelligent cause?
For if you believe that life did not happen by chance, you do not necessarily believe it was the result of intelligent cause.

Maybe there's a chance that computers could b formed by a series of hurricane/lightning/earthquake/ by Chance.
That's a better example of a STRAWMAN than Stephen provides, in my opinion. A stronger atheist argument might concentrate the lack of proof that God exists, as many on this forum do. This argument says that the evidence that God exists is not enough to say we know whether or not God exists, and therefore to argue that He really does exist, as you are arguing here is arguing from ignorance (see the first example, it's the most relevant).

Perhaps the lightning struck some rocks in place which caused it 2 melt & created wirings then the wind placed it in location where in Trillions of yrs earthquakes shook it & the design may possible turn into a laptop computer! But this won’t happen in a single step, but through random chance, the processor was made first, then the speakers, the keyboard, monitor, & so forth all by chance.
What a mighty strawman it is.

No one dares question the laws of physics (LOL).
Another appeal to popularity.

Is this possible? NO! This analogy is IMPOSSIBLE,
Prejudicial language.

there’s no "chance" natural resources contain the necessary tools to create a detailed and complex laptop computer (soldering iron, laser beams, mechanical precision, proper timing &position, etc.) this requires intelligent cause.
Refuting another strawman, this time refuting the argument that things known to be artificial as well are also assembled by chance.

Though impossible, that analogy can be mentally visualized, unlike the claim that series of earthquakes, hurricane, sunlight, and lightning can gather atoms and molecules together, and then form it into mitochondria, ribosome, cytoplasm, nucleus, and thousands of the cell’s parts all at once then bring it to life.
Refuting yet another strawman, this time he's refuting the argument that cellular life as it is now came together spontaneously by chance. Note that this particular strawman would contradict evolutionary theories that organelles evolved from primitive cells that got stuck reproducing inside other cells. A scientist's argument might be that it is absurd to think that a lump of clay transmogrified into differentiated cells with all their organelles inside, functioning as a whole, because an omniscient diety which has not been proven to exist, shaped it like a human being and blew on it. Occam's razor comes to mind.

For many years of observation & study, biochemists can only limitedly identify & label what’s contained in a cell, but never successful in creating one. Considering all the technologies modern science has to offer (electron microscope, etc.) they can even split an atom into half! Yet even then NOT ONE scientist are able to successfully create a single cell, NONE!
That's an inductive fallacy, since the past is not an accurate representation of the future.

If this was the case, why then do atheist claim that series of earthquake, wind, & lightning created life forms by accident "chance" when scientist with far better technology than wind & sunlight can't?
This is a hasty generalization] based on a previous strawman, in the form of a complex question, which ultimate assumes the outcome of a previous inductive fallacy. Ugh, it's no use. I'll never finsh at this rate. I'm going to bed.
 
buki said:
How can you not?
I think we are talking past each other here. Laws of physics as we know them are of course described by Man, I quite agree. But "the perfect description" exists, we may or may not find it, but, as we seem to agree, our laws of physics are not complete or fault-free, they are a map of the landscape with a less than 100% precision. The real landscape, however, must exist.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
So far, there is no contradiction. Reality, and thus the laws of physics (to please Buki :p ), may be created by a consciousness.

That doesn't mean that "the laws of physics" is a conscious entity. My point is that the laws of physics do not have separate existence, they are the properties of reality.

Hans

Only that property, as you see it, is non-conscious
:eek:
muhaha
 
buki said:


you are both wrong and damn it is pissing me off.

THE LAWS OF PHYSICS are descriptions made by man of how man sees the world. That's it. No more.

"We make the map...not the territory"

The only consciousness is man's, insofar as the only description can be made by man. There is no other..

Could you say that without the aid of TLOP?
 
MRC_Hans said:
I think we are talking past each other here. Laws of physics as we know them are of course described by Man, I quite agree. But "the perfect description" exists, we may or may not find it, but, as we seem to agree, our laws of physics are not complete or fault-free, they are a map of the landscape with a less than 100% precision. The real landscape, however, must exist.

Hans
Why must it exist?

And why must it be "perfect"?
 
buki said:
Why must it exist?

And why must it be "perfect"?

I am assuming reality exists. The behaviour of reality is not dependent on our understanding or description of it. Reality behaves the way it does; reality is the perfect description of itself.

"The laws of physics" is our attempt to describe reality. It is less than perfect.

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
"The laws of physics" is our attempt to describe reality. It is less than perfect.
Not quite true. Our understanding of the laws of physics is imperfect, but has the potential not to be. we can learn them all; everything there is to know. And before anyone jumps up and mistakenly declares that because our senses are flawed, our understanding inevitably will be, the laws of physics are not described in terms of our senses; they are described mathematically, and therefore can be known accurately and absolutely.
 
Yeah, well. I think that was more or less what I said. Since our understanding is imperfect, our description is too. Whether the complete laws of physics are knowable by us will no doubt be discussed forever. I think the universe might be fractal in nature, and if so, the amount of detail approaches infinity.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom