Principal wants parents to ban Facebook.

And all they have to do is create a new account to start over. Yet again, the crime has to be done before you can have an account banned, which means the attack is already out there. The psychological effects of being bullied cannot all be attributed to fear of physical pain. It's being a target where ever you go, what ever you do. It can force a child to make their appearance as unnoticeable as possible in hopes of a day going by not being verbally tormented.
Facebook can go by IP address. Unless they start a new account AND use a different computer, they can still be blocked.
 
Facebook can go by IP address. Unless they start a new account AND use a different computer, they can still be blocked.

Most people I know use mobile uploads which means there is a good chance they are accessing through their home IP. Secondly, even if someone were to use their home address, they have to have multiple violations for them to turn to an IP block. In such cases, as I said earlier, the damage is already done.
 
Most people I know use mobile uploads which means there is a good chance they are accessing through their home IP. Secondly, even if someone were to use their home address, they have to have multiple violations for them to turn to an IP block. In such cases, as I said earlier, the damage is already done.
Yeah.
 
I have an idea.

Incorporate the educating bit into the Facebook networking bit.

The handheld window is the preferred medium of the kids already. Why not use it? 64% of newborns have *twittered at least once in their pre-lifetime. 19% have Facebook pics, posing west-SAH-ide with their umbilicals.

Morality plays and education programming already exist throughout television and film. Sesame Street. Saved by the Bell. Schindler's List.



*variations of wah wah
 
I think the Principal's proposal may be about excessive, but parents need to monitor the actions of their children reasonably speaking.
 
Actually it is very easy to get a new IP address. Or for most people anyway. I have been blocked at several sites, yet it is easy to get around.
If you have a little IT knowledge, that your average high school bully probably doesn't have.

Or maybe they do these days - I'm getting out of touch.
 
If you have a little IT knowledge, that your average high school bully probably doesn't have.

Or maybe they do these days - I'm getting out of touch.

Trust me, they are far more advanced than you give them credit for. I have no idea how the heck my 9 year old (at the time) son new how to do this but he apparently networked our computers (am I even using the right term?) to borrow files off my desktop to run on his. I only found out when he was trying to fix a program but somehow inadvertently deleted the .exe file on my desktop, from his.
 
A lot of people made solid points on this, so I'll just add a few thoughts:

First, just because it's "not as bad" to be bullied over the internet (a claim I disagree with), that doesn't mean it isn't a problem.

Second, the detached aspect of the internet that several folks brought up creates a new dynamic to bullying. I knew a family with a teenage daughter. She was bullied by former friends over the internet and what struck me about her situation was that these girls, who would never dream of being that cruel in person, were just vicious online.

The sort of bully that will punch you in the face is not going to be affected by the internet, but the behind-the-back style of gossip, the sort of thing that most people do and is relatively harmless, is directed in very harsh ways over the internet. The relative distance really unleashes the cruelty, which shouldn't be a surprise to anyone who has ever used the internet.

Finally, I would just caution against minimizing psychological bullying. I think I was relatively lucky in so far as I was never bothered much in school (being good at sports gives one a free pass, even if they prefer jazz to rap), but the people I knew who were bullied were almost never physically assaulted. It was all rumors and verbal harassment.
 
Many adults preach the fact that 4 people a year commit suicide over cyber bullying but the fact is that those people have some serious issues and are way to sensitive for such a simple matter. The bully says 'you're gay' so reply with a simple '**** off!'

You insensitive ****!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A lot of people made solid points on this, so I'll just add a few thoughts:

First, just because it's "not as bad" to be bullied over the internet (a claim I disagree with), that doesn't mean it isn't a problem [...] Second, the detached aspect of the internet that several folks brought up creates a new dynamic to bullying [...] The relative distance really unleashes the cruelty, which shouldn't be a surprise to anyone who has ever used the internet [...] I would just caution against minimizing psychological bullying [...]

Good points.

It's important to also note that these kids are getting it 24/7 nowadays. When I was about that age, if you got bullied at school, you still had half a day everyday and weekends to regroup. To heal. To take a step back and utilize that 'safe' time to think out a new scheme. Cause you need a damn scheme if you want to get through that 12 to 18 age range in one piece.

The TextGeneration have no escape.
 
If you do not know how to get a new IP address then you do not know much. It is covered in computers 101.
Indeed. My 11 year old has known how to get a new IP since he was 5. Most people can get a new one by accident, what with the prevalence of dynamic IP's for home and mobile use. And because of the prevalence of dynamic IP's, IP blocks are even less effective as they end up blocking many more than just the person intended -- including legitimate users/customers/clients.
 
I guess bullying can be a problem in all different kinds of neighborhoods.
Here Facebook is lame because that is what parents use...
Wow, I thought you were being sarcastic in your first post.

I didn't know anyone used myspace anymore. Every time I pull up a page it's been abandoned, graphics no longer working, last post in 2008, tumbleweeds blowing through.

Of course, in a year or 2 facebook will be out and something else will be in.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom