Princeton Nukes ESP Department

[Baron Samedi]

Ersby: Should we go back to actually talking about PEAR, or should I just open a new thread? I've been working on some numbers on the side that I would love to validate

 

[Ersby]

Ersby: Should we go back to actually talking about PEAR, or should I just open a new thread? I've been working on some numbers on the side that I would love to validate

New figures about PEAR? Sounds interesting. I'd start a new thread if I was you otherwise it'll just get lost.

 

[omegablue]

Omegablue, people here have explained patiently why the hit wasn't so amazing, and all you have said was that you choose not to take it seriously. No arguments in your favour, no details, just a constant demand for certainty. You can see why I'm so tired at your faux critical thinking.

No, you have explained your opinion, and if there is no proof, so there´s no room for saying you are right and I´m wrong. And in no way you can say I do not think critically and you do. If there was some proof and I refused to accept it, so yes ou could flame as an imbecil. Simple as that. I really want to end up this stupid discussion. If you cannot prove your points to me, then there´s no need to repeating your opinion on and on, otherwise you are just being plain silly.

 

[omegablue]

omegablue,

Why would Altea cheat, if she has real powers? To enhance a very weak effect?

Why not?

Why do you have a problem with exposing frauds?

No , I have not, in fact I think it´s very necessary. I was talking about you, pretending everyone who come here and do not agree with your points is a fraud. I think it is just..... I prefer not to write what I think about this strange attitude.

What would be a lucky guess?

The rosebush hit could be a lucky guess, ok, not impossible, this is not what I am suggesting. But the odds seems to me soooo small that I would go with the set-up kind of fraud, as we know she did it before. And if you object to this, show me some solid numbers, graphs, statistics, proofs in favor of you argument! Otherwise, you will just repeating you opinion, which I disagree, as you already know.

As a matter of fact I suggest we end up this discussion right here and if you want to discuss it further, create some thread and we can do it over there.

 

[CFLarsen]

Why not?

How will you determine what is the effect and what is cheating? You can't, because if you don't discover a situation where she does cheat, you will have to believe she is psychic.

No , I have not, in fact I think it´s very necessary. I was talking about you, pretending everyone who come here and do not agree with your points is a fraud. I think it is just..... I prefer not to write what I think about this strange attitude.

I don't do that. I point out that Altea is a fraud.

The rosebush hit could be a lucky guess, ok, not impossible, this is not what I am suggesting. But the odds seems to me soooo small that I would go with the set-up kind of fraud, as we know she did it before.

What "odds"? How do you calculate them?? Pull them out of your rectum?

And if you object to this, show me some solid numbers, graphs, statistics, proofs in favor of you argument! Otherwise, you will just repeating you opinion, which I disagree, as you already know.

As a matter of fact I suggest we end up this discussion right here and if you want to discuss it further, create some thread and we can do it over there.

Our opinions are not of equal value. You have consistently closed your ears to the natural explanations we have presented to you. Just saying "lalalala, I disagree" does not constitute a valid response to natural explanations.

 

[Baron Samedi]

New figures about PEAR? Sounds interesting. I'd start a new thread if I was you otherwise it'll just get lost.

There we go. I left my long post here
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=76043