President Bolsonaro against philosophy.

ETA: There's no reason to think that engineers, veterinarians and medical doctors can't be critical thinkers without help from philosophy and sociology. Critical thinking doesn't depend on the existence of the two faculties.

And that would be true. Except when one finds that one has none of those only graduate philosophers. Then what? Gaze at each others navels, I suppose. That will definitely feed people, right?
 
ETA: There's no reason to think that engineers, veterinarians and medical doctors can't be critical thinkers without help from philosophy and sociology. Critical thinking doesn't depend on the existence of the two faculties.

Of course, but they do not teach critical concepts about the past, society or morality. We are talking about the educational system.
 
We can discuss whether some issues are useful or not. But what Bolsonaro questions - and almost all ultraconservative politicians - is a model of society that was ideally founded in Greece and is still a model in our open societies. Culture is not just what we consume.

That's what you extrapolate from it. And you extrapolate much and far! I'm certain it's much more primitive than that.

(I'm sorry, this is the problem of the utility of philosophy. And this is a thread about philosophy. Do you think you can separate theory from practice?)

No, you have to make your extrapolations just for the thread to sway in the edge of this subforum. The subject is entirely political -and involves as much philosophy as any garden variety political problem harboured in the proper subforum-

"Bolsonaro against the Greeks. Let's keep this thread in the philosophy section!" What a stretch!

The fact is that Bolsonaro impersonates Trump without having support in the congress nor in the superior federal tribunal, and his office not having as many arbitrary attributes as the POTUS' has. He's a plain ignorant who seized the chance to get the power using a few platitudes in a society tired of the corruption, ineffectiveness and corporate doctrine of the Latin American pseudo-left.

The flavour of last May was Bolsonaro going one step up and one step down with his gun "discontrol" decrees. It sufficed that justice Rosa Weber called the executive power to do some explaining for Bolsonaro to paddle back a significant portion of his decree. The whole gun "discontrol" controversy remains to be solved by the Superior Federal Tribunal who most probably will end up declaring it illegal. And I'm waiting for it because what Bolsonaro has already done implies more illegal guns entering Argentina through the Triple Frontier.

That's the reality behind this so-called "dictator" who better resembles Dick Dastardly (Pierre Nodoyuna) than Stalin.
 
No, you have to make your extrapolations just for the thread to sway in the edge of this subforum. The subject is entirely political -and involves as much philosophy as any garden variety political problem harboured in the proper subforum-

"Bolsonaro against the Greeks. Let's keep this thread in the philosophy section!" What a stretch!
Don't caricature my words. It is not Bolsonaro against the Greeks. I said Bolsonaro was against a model of society that had its origins in Greece. This model involves political, ethical and philosophical concepts that have been discussed by the most important philosophers in Europe, from Plato to Arendt or Habermas. One of the discussions involved is the role of philosophy and science in education. This is the main theme in Plato and is a priority issue in Kant, Rousseau, Arendt or Habermas.

PhilPapers, a philosophical search tool, includes 579 articles in the item “Philosophy of Higher Education”.

My proposal was aimed to the concept of utility and knowledge and the place of humanities in higher education (there was a tense debate about this in my country between two of the most relevant philosophers at time). It seems it is not interesting for you, but extrapolation, in no way.
 
Interesting reference. Thank you.

See: https://www.brasildefato.com.br/201...onaro-censura-e-perseguicao-diz-especialista/ .

O alvo para se retirar investimento – e fazer um processo de focalização de investimentos – justamente está voltado para a faculdades das ciências humanas, e isso se dá por conta dessa perseguição ideológica que está sendo feita, que acredita que, para o desenvolvimento do país, precisa-se investir somente em exatas e biológicas, gerando inovações e tecnologias. Mas, se esquece que a filosofia é a base de todas essas ciências.

É impossível ter um processo de desenvolvimento tecnológico, stricto sensu, bem calcado, se não existisse uma filosofia por trás da matemática. Todas essas questões passam por trás de um pensamento crítico. O cientista, na hora de formular e desenvolver sua pesquisa, precisa pensar. E como se desenvolve o pensamento? Por meio do estudo de diversas disciplinas, inclusive e especialmente, das que derivam da filosofia.​

Very interesting.
 
Last edited:
And that would be true. Except when one finds that one has none of those only graduate philosophers. Then what? Gaze at each others navels, I suppose. That will definitely feed people, right?

Is that actually the case, though, or is it mostly or entirely fiction made up to serve as a pretext?
 
The subject of this thread has been overlooked.

The problem I wanted to raise has been overlooked by the participants of this thread. The problem is the kind of "sage men" a society needs to achieve a standard of both material and "spiritual" well-being. Few people deny that an advanced society needs experts in science and technology. Few people deny that along with these is also necessary another type of wisdom that integrates scientific knowledge with political and ethical skills. Bolsonaro seems the exception.
Letting Bolsonaro aside, the problem is summarized in two questions:

Is “wisdom” —in the above sense— innate or learned?

If this is learned, a new question arises:

What is the place to learn wisdom in a democratic society?

These are the issues that have been overlooked in this thread.
 
Isn't the first step then for you to provide the evidence for that claim?

Because in order to a wise ethical and political action it is necessary to know as deeply as possible the history and present of humanity, to understand what knowledge is, what is good and other related issues that only the so-called humanities study as a whole.

I don't know if this is what you call "evidence", but it seems to me that it is a compelling reason.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom