• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

Cont: Possible Scientific Foundations of Homeopathy, Part 2

Maybe in the homeopathic world the dilution of knowledge to nothing at all makes ignorance wisdom, but elsewhere it does not.

How? Elsewhere, is it 100%? Í have very bad experiances with 98/99% when 1 become 100 and we cd nt even claim, blame or protest.
 
I've seen an apologist for homoeopathy claim that the 1835 Nuremberg Salt Test was a successful demonstration of homoeopathy because subjects in the group given the remedy exhibited proving symptoms, even if subjects in the control group did as well.

It is not matter of discussion here now. Some odds and cherry pickings supporting own perception or interests, do not make sense.
 
I shall be happy to learn from you, whatever I am indicating. Please teach.

Take classes - it is not our job to teach you things you can easily look up on the internet or find tutors for in pretty much any country on Earth!!!!!!. Including proper English speaking/writing/grammar.................
 
Physiological regulation[edit]
The immune system is involved in many aspects of physiological regulation in the body. The immune system interacts intimately with other systems, such as the endocrine [101][102] and the nervous [103][104][105] systems. The immune system also plays a crucial role in embryogenesis (development of the embryo), as well as in tissue repair and regeneration.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immune_system

I feel, members here are not able to discuss scope of above. Can anyone better explain it?
 
Well, if the members here can't explain it to your satisfaction, you can't understand Wiki (and follow and study the huge amount of links at the bottom), and you are some how hoping a random 'non member' will be able to post a nice simple treatise you can understand (hint, non members can't post), I think you're out of luck.
 
I feel, members here are not able to discuss scope of above. Can anyone better explain it?

Maybe you should cite the actual papers listed in the foot notes instead of just mentioning them.
Did you follow the footnotes? Which one do you wish to discuss and which parts of it?

https://academic.oup.com/edrv/artic...n-via-the-Hypothalamo?redirectedFrom=fulltext
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0167569988912893
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/334/6052/47
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4871617
http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v20/n2/full/nn.4496.html
 
Last edited:

Thanks. I shall study it. However what these link in brief suggest about immunesystem link with physiological regulation--either directly with different systems of body or vai endocrine and neurological systems?
 
Thanks. I shall study it. However what these link in brief suggest about immunesystem link with physiological regulation--either directly with different systems of body or vai endocrine and neurological systems?


Perhaps you can find out what they say by reading them.
 
Perhaps you can find out what they say by reading them.

That I shall do. But when those are quoted, I felt casually, probably that poster may be understanding these and so can help. Just casual.
 
Maybe you should cite the actual papers listed in the foot notes instead of just mentioning them.
Did you follow the footnotes? Which one do you wish to discuss and which parts of it?....
......2

Yes now I read links given by you. Thanks. These suggest that there is a link between Immune system and nNeuro-endocrine systems as mentioned in main article. I think it is both side regulation i.e Immune system can modulate these systems and also these systems can modulate Immune system. Since these are very important and basic systems, so may also modulate other body systems via these systems. Am I ok?
 
Now the other thought:

"The immune system also plays a crucial role in embryogenesis (development of the embryo), as well as in tissue repair and regeneration."

Can above in bold letters suggest that probably, Immune system can also revert cancer cells to normal cells by such tissue repair and regeneration property?
 
Kumar, I know you are ignoring me, probably with good reason as frankly all I really do is take the piss, which is too easy really with all the crap you post, but listen this time.

I have stage 4 cancer, started in the bowel, and has moved to my liver, lungs and probably a few other places by now. (I'm avoiding technical terms.) Your posts banging on about homeopathy (which is bollocks by the way) and things you just don't have a clue about, and probably never will, like spontaneous remission and the immune system, which to understand properly take years of medical training and a solid grasp of science, both of which you lack (understatement of the year?) are quite disrespectful, both to people who are dealing with cancer, and the professionals helping us, from oncologists, through dietitians and all the support staff like radiologists, nurses, and researchers trying to find cures and treatments for what is a very complex series of diseases.
Sitting on your little ivory tower mountaintop, banging on about odds, religion, your woeful interpretation of the laws of nature will help no one, least of all yourself.
Get a job, or a hobby within your capabilities - I suggest basket weaving or something.
Bottom line is I am going to die relatively soon. Might be a year, hopefully will be a bit longer. The chances of me making it through the next five are slim to remote. I'm doing my best, as are all the amazing people I deal with on an almost daily basis, to make it as long as possible. They are real, as am I. Your contribution to medicine is nil, nada, or even less if that's possible as your faith in garbage like homeopathy and all the other nonsense you bang on about can get people killed, or take time away from them that real medicine could give them.
So I respectfully ask you to stop it.
If not I'll continue to take the piss, and even that is probably more than your ideas are worth. You can ignore me (I stand by what I said about your daughter) but I am right, and you will be forever wrong.
 
Now the other thought:

"The immune system also plays a crucial role in embryogenesis (development of the embryo), as well as in tissue repair and regeneration."

Can above in bold letters suggest that probably, Immune system can also revert cancer cells to normal cells by such tissue repair and regeneration property?


No. As usual, you have it bass ackwards. Tissues are made of cells, not the other way round. Repairing tissues will not fix cells.
 
No. As usual, you have it bass ackwards. Tissues are made of cells, not the other way round. Repairing tissues will not fix cells.

Yes, how it can be repairing ànd regenératión of tissues without involvíng cells?
 
Yes, how it can be repairing ànd regenératión of tissues without involvíng cells?


Tissue repair and regeneration involves growth and multiplication of cells. It is not something that happens inside the cells so as to be able to make cancerous cells non-cancerous. Remember what the basic problem with cancer cells is?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom