Paul would have had a 20-30% chance

Quote:
Where in the constitution are gold and silver monetized? The Coinage Act of 1792 created the dollar and monetized gold and silver, not the constitution.

http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_States_of_America#Section_10

I take it you're referring to:

No State shall enter into any Treaty, Alliance, or Confederation; grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal; coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts

Which clearly sets limits on what states (not the federal government) may do. Or are you also claiming that all the provisions of that paragraph apply to the federal government and that congress can not approve treaties or coin money (which in itself would render the gold standard useless since there would be no money for the gold to back)?
 
Last edited:
On the original topic...
Boeing Corp does not have a lot of love for John McCain, he came down on them hard over corruption. Boeing has a large presence in both Kansas and Washington St.
 
I take it you're referring to:



Which clearly sets limits on what states (not the federal government) may do. Or are you also claiming that all the provisions of that paragraph apply to the federal government and that congress can not approve treaties or coin money (which in itself would render the gold standard useless since there would be no money for the gold to back)?

No.
 
So we're clear then. The link you posted: http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Consti...ica#Section_10

in response to the question:



really has nothing to do with the question and you have no answer to that question.

No. What I'm saying is that your reduction ad absurdum is also a straw man. I never claimed that Congress was not allowed to make treaties or issue fiat money. I simply pointed out that States are by law to issue nothing but gold and silver in the repayment of debts.
 
Except that's clearly meant to mean that states must use federal currency to pay debts off. And in those times, paper money was worthless. Not anymore, though.

Clearly?

Maybe it was meant to mean that states ought to use gold and silver to pay debts off.
 
No. It means that the states can't demand payment in anything but gold and silver, but they can accept payment in any form they want.

taking the last three statements together:

coin Money; emit Bills of Credit; make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts

...seems to simply put the state out of the money business in language that would make sense at the time.

They can't coin money.
They can emit paper that says they owe the holder something, which would be more or less a form of paper currency.
They can't require the acceptence of anything but gold and silver coin as payment for a debt. For example a law requiring people to accept whiskey or beads or whatever in to create a medium of exchange within the state.

The status of our currency and coin as a legal tender is set by federal law.
 
@Richard Masters

Under the articles of confederation there were no provisions regulating money and currency. State governments printed their up their own fiat currencies and coined their own money which caused many problems in interstate trade. It's one of the reasons the confederation was a convoluted mess and a failed experiment. That's why in the constitution an enumerated power (article 1, section 8) of congress is:

To coin money, regulate the value thereof, and of foreign coin, and fix the standard of weights and measures

Article 1, section 10 on limiting the states is just what it says it is, limits not powers. The argument you're looking for here is that the constitution says that the congress shall coin money, coining money implies making money (gold and silver coin) not debt instruments (reserve notes).
 
@Richard Masters

Under the articles of confederation there were no provisions regulating money and currency. State governments printed their up their own fiat currencies and coined their own money which caused many problems in interstate trade. It's one of the reasons the confederation was a convoluted mess and a failed experiment. That's why in the constitution an enumerated power (article 1, section 8) of congress is:

To coin money, regulate the value thereof, and of foreign coin, and fix the standard of weights and measures

Article 1, section 10 on limiting the states is just what it says it is, limits not powers. The argument you're looking for here is that the constitution says that the congress shall coin money, coining money implies making money (gold and silver coin) not debt instruments (reserve notes).

Ideally, but I was well aware that it is a limit and not a power.
 
Now, this has me scratching my head. RP got 21% of the caucus in Washington State.

A state that tries to live up to the nickname that the FDR people gave us: "The Soviet of Washington." The state where the military voters keep liberals like Norm Dicks and Patty Murray in Congress. The home of William O. Douglas.

We're different out here.

I didn't realize we were that bloody different.

And we still haven't heard from most of the "fly-over" states, where the vote of a total moron outweigh those of three PhDs in Seattle, come the general elections.

And Huckabee didn't come out far behind McCain, either.

Don't rule anybody out, just yet. RP may actually turn out to be a power broker, if Huckabbee can hold on to the last vote.

IQ of 90 or IQ 210 a votes a vote and as an American citizen you have a right to express who you want to win, and everyones vote should be equal.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom