Our Greatest Fear Has Come to Pass: Coat-Hanger Abortions in Tennessee

What's odd about this story is that Tennessee does have at least three abortion clinics within its borders (and more in neighboring states).

It seems like abortion is actually legal in Tennessee, up to a point, just like it is everywhere else in the nation.

It does sounds like a horrible tragedy, but it also sounds like there's something missing from this story. I'm not sure the outrage is justified.
 
What's odd about this story is that Tennessee does have at least three abortion clinics within its borders (and more in neighboring states).

It seems like abortion is actually legal in Tennessee, up to a point, just like it is everywhere else in the nation.
It does sounds like a horrible tragedy, but it also sounds like there's something missing from this story. I'm not sure the outrage is justified.

When something is legal but inaccessible, what is the difference?
 
When something is legal but inaccessible, what is the difference?

It's legal. If accessibility is what you're worried about, feel free open up some legal clinics whenever you like. Or start an uber-type shuttle service. Or do some other damn thing to soothe your conscience and improve society.
 
Last edited:
It's legal. If accessibility is what you're worried about, feel free open up some legal clinics whenever you like. Or start an uber-type shuttle service. Or do some other damn thing to soothe your conscience and improve society.

So it would be fine if the only abortion clinic in Tennessee is in an abandoned building at the end of a dirt road, in the basement without light, behind a door marked "beware of the tigers" ? After all it would be legal.

Or is it that putting as many obstacle as possible to accessibility is actually akin to making it illegal.
 
It's legal. If accessibility is what you're worried about, feel free open up some legal clinics whenever you like. Or start an uber-type shuttle service. Or do some other damn thing to soothe your conscience and improve society.

You mean like raising awareness as I am trying to do here?
Or do you mean like donating money to Planned Parenthood as I have done and plan to continue?
 
I feel like throwing up after reading this article. . . .
http://rhrealitycheck.org/article/2...ar-come-pass-coat-hanger-abortions-tennessee/

Of course the #4%$# of Tennessee are going to charge her with murder

First, they can't charge her with murder, since the baby survived. It's attempted murder. Second, the story you linked is basically propaganda. It presents an essentially fictional tale of how this poor woman fits the stereotype of abortion rights advocate. Stuff like her not having enough money is purely speculation because it fits the narrative they want.

But here's the thing: people be crazy. Neither you nor the author know what motivated this woman. The actual source material simply isn't enough to go by. It's entirely possible she passed up opportunities to abort early in the pregnancy, and on a whim decided to end it at 6 months. Trying to turn her into the poster child for abortion rights isn't really a wise move in the absence of more information. Certainly the actual effects of her action are horrific: a child who is now permanently disabled. But you don't know that she isn't to blame here.
 
The Washington Post really is no kinder with regards to your argument
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...mpted-murder-for-failed-coat-hanger-abortion/

Tennessee has relatively tight restrictions on abortions. Women must make two trips to a clinic, 48 hours apart, before they can undergo the procedure. As of 2011, 63 percent of Tennessee women lived in a county without an abortion provider, according to the Guttmacher Institute. The state allows abortions up until the point of viability, around 24 weeks, with exceptions afterward for the life and health of the mother. But no clinics offer abortions after 16 weeks, according to the Tennessean.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
That's killing you're kids the hard way.

With all the maybe's with that article, maybe she shouldn't have gotten pregnant.

Maybe if conservatives did not try to block birth control for being easily available?
 
So it would be fine if the only abortion clinic in Tennessee is in an abandoned building at the end of a dirt road, in the basement without light, behind a door marked "beware of the tigers" ? After all it would be legal.

Or is it that putting as many obstacle as possible to accessibility is actually akin to making it illegal.

You make a good point. I apologize for being sharpish earlier.

Is that what you're saying happened here? The state put up so many obstacles that she couldn't get a legal abortion for six months?
 
First, they can't charge her with murder, since the baby survived. It's attempted murder. Second, the story you linked is basically propaganda. It presents an essentially fictional tale of how this poor woman fits the stereotype of abortion rights advocate. Stuff like her not having enough money is purely speculation because it fits the narrative they want.

But here's the thing: people be crazy. Neither you nor the author know what motivated this woman. The actual source material simply isn't enough to go by. It's entirely possible she passed up opportunities to abort early in the pregnancy, and on a whim decided to end it at 6 months. Trying to turn her into the poster child for abortion rights isn't really a wise move in the absence of more information. Certainly the actual effects of her action are horrific: a child who is now permanently disabled. But you don't know that she isn't to blame here.

Agreed. The article itself admits this: "While we don’t know what would have brought Yocca to self-induce, we can surmise what would bring a person to do so given the state of reproductive health care in Tennessee and the roles other factors, such as job security and health care, might play."

And that's followed by four paragraphs of speculation, each starting with "Maybe..."

People do crazy stuff. They make bad decisions. One incident doesn't tell you much about the impact of the availability of abortion services in Tennessee. No more than a guy who does his own trepanation with a drill tells you about the state of neurology there.
 
You make a good point. I apologize for being sharpish earlier.

Is that what you're saying happened here? The state put up so many obstacles that she couldn't get a legal abortion for six months?

Do not forget that many women do not realize that they are pregnant for a little while. Some give birth without even realizing they are pregnant. It is incredibly rare at that extreme but many more may take a couple of months before they realize that they are pregnant (8 weeks) and that narrows you window in Tennessee to eight weeks more (In Tennessee you are effectively limited to sixteen weeks.) In those eight weeks you need to get the money together and visit the doctor twice (two days apart.) This doctor may be a long drive away and likely only has certain hours. I would not be surprised if she had not tried some less extreme methods of aborting the child beforehand.
 
Last edited:
Do not forget that many women do not realize that they are pregnant for a little while. Some give birth without even realizing they are pregnant. It is incredibly rare at that extreme but many more may take a couple of months before they realize that they are pregnant (8 weeks) and that narrows you window in Tennessee to eight weeks more (In Tennessee you are effectively limited to sixteen weeks.) In those eight weeks you need to get the money together and visit the doctor twice (two days apart.) This doctor may be a long drive away and likely only has certain hours. I would not be surprised if she had not tried some less extreme methods of aborting the child beforehand.

Sure, everything could line up just like you say so that it fits your perfect narrative.

But you don't know that it did. And yet, you're basing your entire argument on the idea that it did. This is not prudent. As I said before, people be crazy.
 
It's legal. If accessibility is what you're worried about, feel free open up some legal clinics whenever you like. Or start an uber-type shuttle service. Or do some other damn thing to soothe your conscience and improve society.

Is that how you feel about gun acquisition in San Francisco?
 
Do not forget that many women do not realize that they are pregnant for a little while. Some give birth without even realizing they are pregnant. It is incredibly rare at that extreme but many more may take a couple of months before they realize that they are pregnant (8 weeks) and that narrows you window in Tennessee to eight weeks more (In Tennessee you are effectively limited to sixteen weeks.) In those eight weeks you need to get the money together and visit the doctor twice (two days apart.) This doctor may be a long drive away and likely only has certain hours. I would not be surprised if she had not tried some less extreme methods of aborting the child beforehand.

What the conservatives are saying is that this case may not be due to inaccessibility to abortion services, therefore it is okay for them to keep making abortion services inaccessible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom