Orloff vs Blackmore

Iacchus

Unregistered
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
10,085
Hey, that would be something if both she and Orloff could get together wouldn't it?
That would be like watching matter and anti-matter come together.
Or, maybe they could reconcile their differences, seeing as how they're both women?
Well, I think this thread has pretty much been trashed, unless of course the mods would consider at least splitting it, beginning with post #162.
Oh, one thing I forgot to mention here, is that I view both women as professionals and, that if Dr. Blackmore was anywhere near as kind hearted and generous as Dr. Orloff, I don't see how there could be a problem. Of course the only problem I see (with you folks) is that Dr. Blackmore may stand in danger of being switched over to Dr. Orloff's line of thinking. Or, if not, I could hardly imagine it culminating into a catfight. At least, in my opinion, I know that Dr. Orloff is not that dumb. ;)
Actually, I think the trashing started with post 161, in which you made a baseless and patronising assertion which effectively caused the derailment.

I dunno, you take your eyes off a thread for a few hours and suddenly...
Well, here we go again ...

No, I think folks were just waiting to come unglued. And yes, I personally do think men tend to be less compromising when it comes to agreeing with each other. It was actually a compliment in favor of women, believe it or not ... albeit I suspected it might incite one or two male egos around here. Because, "No, we're not going to have anyone touching our beloved pet theories." I think men tend to have a hard time when it comes to admitting that they're wrong. In fact I have often heard women say this very same thing.
Well, half compliment, half astoundingly patronizing (and all without much supporting evidence).

But we both know your views on women are not the point of the thread, so I'm happy to drop the issue and ignore the bit about women agreeing if you are. Heck, we could even start another thread on that specific issue. Then this thread could go back to discussing if "I" exists. I believe the last relevant point was the difference of opinion between Drs. Blackmore and Orloff...
Sorry for bringing this up again, but I'd really hate to see this thing between Drs. Orloff and Blackmore get lost as a result of the derail in the other thread. Anyway, I'll go ahead and repost the excerpt from the converstion she had with Walter Jacobson, M.D., below. You can visit Dr. Orloff's home page by following the link.
 
And according to what I've read in her books, this is not untypical of the types of experiences Dr. Orloff is accustomed to having.

From her conversation with Walter Jacobson, M.D.

Re-printed from the Newsletter of the Southern California Psychiatric Society
Volume 49, Number 2, October 2000

Jacobson: Perhaps we could start by you describing what you do and how you apply it in a psychiatric practice setting.

Orloff: What I do is called intuitive healing. It’s bringing intuition into the practice of psychiatry and medicine. What that means is that I listen to every kind of linear, logical, rational, analytic piece of information that comes in, but I’m also aware of images, impressions, gut feelings, sights, smells, sounds, and senses of energy that I get in my body which help to add to the diagnosis. It’s not at all divorcing us from our analytic training. It’s about integrating new tools along with what we’ve learned traditionally.

Jacobson: A patient comes in and says he’s depressed. Is there a different way you’d do the initial assessment?


Orloff: It’s about intuitive listening. It’s more than going down the list of signs and symptoms. It’s about me listening to other forms of intuitive input that could come in at that time that could help lend more depth and richness to what they’re presenting. For instance, I had a patient, whom I knew very, very well. She came in and was talking about some stress symptoms at work. I was listening to her and suddenly had a premonition or a knowing that she had cancer, and it came to me very clearly and it had nothing to do with what she was saying. At that point, of course, I didn’t interrupt her and say, by the way, I think you have cancer; but what I did do was I suggested that she go for a physical exam. She did, and they found a mass in her breast. It was malignant and she had early diagnosis and treatment. Because I was listening to what came to me during her session, and, despite it having no clinical correlation at all, I trusted it, and it helped point her in a very positive direction in terms of something that she didn’t even know about herself that needed tending to.
 
Iacchus, if you are truly interested in this (that is, interested in finding out their real views, not in shoehorning what you think their views are into your own world view), Blackmore is widely published--she even has an autobiographical account of her journey from woo to science that you could read.

Or, start here: http://www.susanblackmore.co.uk/. But please, for once, read what she has to say before you continue. And watch the video. Right now, you are comparing the two women almost entirely on the basis of the fact that they are...women. You know little about Orloff, less about Blackmore. If you are truly interested, do your homework first.
 
What else do I need to know? It supports your views. Orloff's views support mine. And yes, I do know a little bit more about Orloff, than perhaps you think.
 
What else do I need to know? It supports your views. Orloff's views support mine. And yes, I do know a little bit more about Orloff, than perhaps you think.

This is absurd. You need to know the evidence, it's right in front of you. dismissing evidence because you disagree with the conclusions drawn from it...I have no word to describe such foolishness.
 
This is absurd. You need to know the evidence, it's right in front of you. dismissing evidence because you disagree with the conclusions drawn from it...I have no word to describe such foolishness.
"I" am the evidence.
 
What else do I need to know? It supports your views. Orloff's views support mine. And yes, I do know a little bit more about Orloff, than perhaps you think.
You don't know this without checking.

Recall, I also suggested that you should read Mary Calkins, specifically her "The Philosophical Credo of an Absolutistic Personalist". That agrees with you, although her expression is much much more logical and more supported than yours.

You cannot know until you see it. Even if it does support my view, so what? You have claimed to be interested in the topic--she explores a topic you are interested in, and does so at a very high level, with good evidence. Are you interested in the questions you ask, or are they merely rhetorical questions for you? Are you only interested in answers which agree with you? If so, I truly pity you. Fortunately, not everyone thinks that way.

As for knowing about Orloff...although my suspicion is that you know considerably less about her than you think you do, my question was not about her, but about Blackmore. You spoke about both--you spoke in utter ignorance about at least one.
 
What do you know about life, aside from the fact that you live it? What I speak of does not vary outside of these parameters.
 
What do you know about life, aside from the fact that you live it? What I speak of does not vary outside of these parameters.
How does this address anything? (oh, it doesn't. Ok.)

Watch the video. Read Blackmore's stuff. Quit hiding from life.

What are you afraid of, Iacchus? Do you really think that if you question your sky-daddy, he will take everything away?
 
How does this address anything? (oh, it doesn't. Ok.)

Watch the video. Read Blackmore's stuff. Quit hiding from life.

What are you afraid of, Iacchus? Do you really think that if you question your sky-daddy, he will take everything away?
So, what do you know about Orloff? Have you taken the time to look into it?
 
Last edited:
So, what do you know about Orloff? Have you taken the time to look into it?
I would wager that I know more about her than you do. I actually understand the jargon that she spews. I know that when Andrew Weil supports her, that is not a positive. I know that she has a total of 0 (zero) published articles available in the peer-reviewed literature on the subject she claims expertise in, according to an ebscohost search of the psychinfo and psychlit databases.

Why, what do you know about her?
 
Why, what do you know about her?
I have read a couple of her books and, have heard her on a talk radio program. And, based upon my own experience, meaning I know that such things are possible, she seems quite credible. Mind you, I am not prepared to vouch for anyone else on this matter.
 
I have read a couple of her books and, have heard her on a talk radio program. And, based upon my own experience, meaning I know that such things are possible, she seems quite credible. Mind you, I am not prepared to vouch for anyone else on this matter.
Iacchus, this is precisely the wrong way to evaluate something. Look into "subjective validation" and the "barnum effect", and you will quickly see that you cannot rely on your own gut feeling on such things. Evidence counts. Her books are not part of the peer-reviewed literature; it is entirely possible that she put her ideas out to the public as a way of bypassing peer-review entirely, because her ideas would not stand scrutiny.

Now...if you are truly as interested as you say you are, you will now read some of Blackmore's books, and watch that video.

You are interested, aren't you? You are not a hypocrite, are you?
 
Iacchus, this is precisely the wrong way to evaluate something. Look into "subjective validation" and the "barnum effect", and you will quickly see that you cannot rely on your own gut feeling on such things. Evidence counts.
As if to say it's not possible to know something for oneself?

Her books are not part of the peer-reviewed literature; it is entirely possible that she put her ideas out to the public as a way of bypassing peer-review entirely, because her ideas would not stand scrutiny.
Either that, or she's telling her story which, I am able to relate to by the way.

Now...if you are truly as interested as you say you are, you will now read some of Blackmore's books, and watch that video.

You are interested, aren't you? You are not a hypocrite, are you?
Yes, from the standpoint of not knowing, Blackmore's books might be a good place to start.
 
As if to say it's not possible to know something for oneself?
I am saying that it is quite possible, and has been demonstrated time and time again, to be certain of something you "know for yourself" and yet to be wrong.

You may be absolutely and utterly convinced you know something and yet be absolutely and utterly wrong.

...if only I could think of an example to point to...
 
I am saying that it is quite possible, and has been demonstrated time and time again, to be certain of something you "know for yourself" and yet to be wrong.

You may be absolutely and utterly convinced you know something and yet be absolutely and utterly wrong.

...if only I could think of an example to point to...
I spend a lot of time with the nymphs, and the nymphs and I revel. And in many ways Orloff is a nymph, from the story that she tells. In fact I have met her or, one two like her, on the "other side."
 
Last edited:
From this thread

Hey, that would be something if both she and Orloff could get together wouldn't it?
That would be like watching matter and anti-matter come together.
Or, maybe they could reconcile their differences, seeing as how they're both women?
Blackmore would wipe the floor with Orloff.

Actually, she would not have to. The evidence would do it for her.

Sorry, Iacchus, you may be proud to be seen as crazy, but you are simply a fool.
It's funny, I was just reading about this. From The Bacchae #476 ....

Pentheus

Again you diverted my question well, speaking mere nonsense.

Dionysus

[480] One will seem to be foolish if he speaks wisely to an ignorant man.

Pentheus

Did you come here first, bringing the god?

Dionysus

All the barbarians celebrate these rites.

Pentheus

Yes, for they are far more foolish than Hellenes.

Dionysus

In this at any rate they are wiser; but their laws are different.
Just a coincidence you think? ;)
Are you seriously suggesting that two people, whose views are irreconcilable, will happily find a middle ground, because they both have vulvas?
Women are known to get along much better than men. Besides, they both have similar stories to tell.
You obviously know nothing of women.
Women don't generally suffer from pride and arrogance the way that men do.
No. We don't. We really, really don't.

When it comes to bullying, girls are known to be more vicious than boys. I'm walking around with the scars still. I have been emotionally screwed with and physically hurt by more females than men. I myself tend towards mysogyny. I have less patience sometimes with women than with men (and this is slowly changing, thanks to a lot of folks I've met since my move.) Until recently, all of my friends had tube steaks and not roast beef sandwiches.

Women don't bond instantly because of Magical Vag Connection. It takes a combination of things, just like every other interpersonal relationship.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom