Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
The following is from an interview given by Peter Embarek, who led the WHO team in Wuhan in 2021. He reveals some of the political issues that the team had to face when preparing the final report.

https://nyheder.tv2.dk/udland/2021-...re-smittet-af-flagermus-som-den-foerste-siger

The text is in Danish, and I have translated it below.

You also have to move the viral collection, the sample collection, and other collections from one place to the other. This entire procedure is a disturbing element in the daily working of a laboratory, so that is why it at one point also will be interesting to look at this period, and this lab, says Peter Embarek.
I find that lab move to be an under-explored event.

Interesting in that the hypothesis of a worker getting infected directly from a bat almost seems like a convenient compromise about the origin. There are a number of news articles reporting on the TV documentary. They say much the same things as you posted.

Aljazeera: WHO scientist puts COVID lab leak theory back under spotlight - Head of WHO mission probing pandemic origins says virus may have started with a Wuhan lab staffer becoming infected.
The only people likely to have approached these types of bats are employees of the city laboratories, he said. ...

Long derided as a right-wing conspiracy theory and vehemently rejected by Beijing, the lab leak hypothesis has been gaining momentum....

Jamie Metzl, who sits on a WHO advisory board on human genome editing and who has been leading efforts calling for an independent investigation on how COVID-19 started, described Embarek’s comments as “a game-changer”, describing his earlier declaration that a lab leak was unlikely “shameful”.

“It’s even more significant that the international expert team who stated with such confidence in the February Wuhan press event that a lab origin was unlikely themselves believed this was not the case and were simply trying to assuage their Chinese government-affiliated hosts,” said Metzl.

All of the scientists on the WHO-led team were approved by China and the team’s agenda and final report were also vetted by the Chinese government.

And as much as a couple people in this thread are downplaying what the WHO chief said about the lab accident:
In recent weeks, WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has acknowledged it was “ premature ” to rule out a possible lab leak as the source of COVID-19, saying last month that he was asking China to be more transparent about the early days of the pandemic.

“I was a lab technician myself. I’m an immunologist and I have worked in the lab and lab accidents happen,” Tedros said. “It’s common.”



From the AP: WHO expert ‘had concerns’ about lab close to 1st COVID cases
The Danish documentary also featured Ben Embarek expressing his worries in January about the Wuhan branch of the Chinese CDC, concerns that have never been publicly disclosed by WHO. While numerous experts have questioned whether there might have been a lab accident at the Wuhan Institute of Virology — where scientists were studying coronaviruses — there has been less interest in another nearby facility.

“What is more concerning to me is the other lab,” Ben Embarek said. “The one that is next to the market,” he explained, referring to the Wuhan branch of the Chinese CDC, located just 500 meters (547 yards) away from the Huanan market.

I thought I saw a note in one of these articles about a recent trip to the Yunnan mine/caves but I can't find it now. Without an account of a recent trip to obtain more specimens or without a specimen that is a closer match than the one Shi claimed was the only one the WIV had, I can't see giving any more weight to this hypothesis than other accidental releases from one of the Chinese labs.

But it is clear the lab origin continues to gain more traction the further away people get from the blatantly tainted Daszak/Chinese WHO report.
 
The following is from an interview given by Peter Embarek, who led the WHO team in Wuhan in 2021. He reveals some of the political issues that the team had to face when preparing the final report.

https://nyheder.tv2.dk/udland/2021-...re-smittet-af-flagermus-som-den-foerste-siger

The text is in Danish, and I have translated it below.

Thanks for the translation. I was interested to see the full context of his remarks. Certainly he sees it as being more likely than it was characterized in the report.
 
But of course it is perfectly acceptable there has yet to be found a source animal of a natural spillover after almost 2 years now.

Yes that actually is perfectly acceptable, but lets set that aside for a moment.

Why is it "ok" that after 2 years the virus that was "manipulated" has yet to be found even though it was supposedly already sampled isolated and studied in the lab? It's understandable why a virus in the wild would be hard to find, it's much less understandable why a virus that that has already been identified can't be found.
 
No new news there. Anyone who was in contact with bats who are the most probable source of the virus could become infected. The argument against this is that no Wuhan lab staffer was found to be infected before the first known case. Staffers in and out of the lab would be monitored.
Then there is "In the Danish TV2 documentary, the WHO’s Ben Embarek is pictured arriving in China, inspecting the stalls at the Huanan seafood market in Wuhan and examining what he hypothesizes might have been living quarters for people who handled live animals there — raising the possibility that the virus may have jumped from animals to people at the market." when Skeptic Ginger has been telling us off for having the origin at the seafood market :eek:!

The most probable origin is from animals (probably bats) via an unknown route to the first known case whose family visited the Huanan seafood market. The 'extremely unlikely" (as in the WHO study which seems to overstate this) scenario of a lab link needs more investigation.
 
Last edited:
Why is it "ok" that after 2 years the virus that was "manipulated" has yet to be found even though it was supposedly already sampled isolated and studied in the lab? It's understandable why a virus in the wild would be hard to find, it's much less understandable why a virus that that has already been identified can't be found.
Do you really think that a lab in Wuhan would come out and declare “Oops, we found the virus in one of our bats!”

First of all, I think a reluctance would be human, and secondly, I think that the authorities would come down on them with a ton of bricks.

The virus may not come from a lab, but I am fairly sure that if it is found in a lab, we will never know.
 
Do you really think that a lab in Wuhan would come out and declare “Oops, we found the virus in one of our bats!”

First of all, I think a reluctance would be human, and secondly, I think that the authorities would come down on them with a ton of bricks.

The virus may not come from a lab, but I am fairly sure that if it is found in a lab, we will never know.

Yes. If it was in a bat then that would put an end to all the allegations about it being the result of gain of function research. It would identify the species and location of the bats the virus was circulating in and from which other out breaks might occur. Even if the virus was found in a bat collected by the laboratory it did not mean the laboratory was the source of the infection, as above it would be more likely to be acquired during collection and transport than once being handled in a virology lab. It could be acquired from another bat in the colony by someone unrelated to the laboratory.
 
No new news there. Anyone who was in contact with bats who are the most probable source of the virus could become infected. The argument against this is that no Wuhan lab staffer was found to be infected before the first known case. Staffers in and out of the lab would be monitored.
This is a disease where many infected people are asymptomatic. Are you suggesting that lab staffers would be regularly PCR tested for a disease that was not even known at the time? By the time that the first symptomatic case was identified, and the novelty of the disease was realised, the originally infected lab staffer might be virus free.
 
This is a disease where many infected people are asymptomatic. Are you suggesting that lab staffers would be regularly PCR tested for a disease that was not even known at the time? By the time that the first symptomatic case was identified, and the novelty of the disease was realised, the originally infected lab staffer might be virus free.

True, but some of the purported evidence for a lab leak is that the member of staff went to hospital. If it was asymptomatic it would not make sense for them to do that.

Similarly, some of the evidence is that the database was taken down (or rather, a public-facing portal was taken down) in September 2019 presumably because the WIV had something to hide. That would not make sense under the bat bites lab worker in the field argument.

The same goes for the GoF argument, etc... and the claims that the Wuhan Military Games were a superspreader event etc...

In fact, the whole, "The CCDC building moved in early December" argument seems even less related to the evidence if that is one theory of lab leak.
 
Yes. If it was in a bat then that would put an end to all the allegations about it being the result of gain of function research.
Correct, but I don’t think the lab management would feel much better that it was only a lab leak, and not by gain of function.

All the same arguments of course also count for gain of function, so I also don’t think that we would hear about it if the virus was found in a humanised mouse.

In fact, I find it perfectly understandable (though of course not acceptable) if such a virus sample would quietly be destroyed.
 
Do you really think that a lab in Wuhan would come out and declare “Oops, we found the virus in one of our bats!”

In spite of claims to the contrary, we don’t even know there were live bats or live coronaviruses in the lab. The vast majority of the WiV work involves genetic sampling. RaTG13, for example was never isolated in any lab. It is known from genetic samples taken from bat faeces where the virus itself could not survive. It would not be surprising if there were live corona viruses and their hosts present in the BSL-4 lab, that is why it was built in the first place after all, but due to the recent move to the facility it’s entirely possible that type of research simply hadn’t started yet.

Live virus or not, there is no particular reason why researchers wouldn’t record a new virus as soon as it was identified. It makes no sense to say “we found something new, instead of describing it and documenting it’s properties lets perform secret research on it to make it dangerous to humans”.
 
This is a disease where many infected people are asymptomatic. Are you suggesting that lab staffers would be regularly PCR tested for a disease that was not even known at the time? By the time that the first symptomatic case was identified, and the novelty of the disease was realised, the originally infected lab staffer might be virus free.

Which works against the idea that they covered it up after finding out there was a leak. Also, the staff were given serology tests in early 2020 that failed to show any evidence of covid antibodies suggesting no one had been infected.

Then there is also the matter of the lab being nowhere close to the earliest infections. Even “the other lab” is a significant distance away and on the wrong side of the Yangtze River. Conversely, even the case with no clear connection to the market is within walking distance to it
 
This is a disease where many infected people are asymptomatic. Are you suggesting that lab staffers would be regularly PCR tested for a disease that was not even known at the time?
No. I am suggesting that as lab workers working in the wild with bats known to carry coronavirus, their health would be monitored and they would report any incidents such a bite from a bat or protective gear failure. The monitoring would pick up symptomatic infection. The monitoring might include regular samples that would be tested after the outbreak was known.
 
Then there is also the matter of the lab being nowhere close to the earliest infections. Even “the other lab” is a significant distance away and on the wrong side of the Yangtze River. Conversely, even the case with no clear connection to the market is within walking distance to it
An unsubstantiated theory suggests the coronavirus accidentally leaked from a Chinese lab — here are the facts from April 2020 has a good description of the location of Wuhan labs.
A branch office of the Wuhan CDC is located about 600 meters – less than half a mile – from the Huanan market via main roads (though it’s not the Chinese CDC’s only site in Wuhan).

The agency, which includes labs that study AIDS and influenza, is responsible for disease surveillance.

The Wuhan Institute of Virology, meanwhile, actively researches infectious diseases – including coronaviruses – and did before the pandemic started. But that facility is more than 14 kilometers, or 8 1/2 miles, and across a river from the Huanan market.
 
No. I am suggesting that as lab workers working in the wild with bats known to carry coronavirus, their health would be monitored and they would report any incidents such a bite from a bat or protective gear failure. The monitoring would pick up symptomatic infection. The monitoring might include regular samples that would be tested after the outbreak was known.

Absolutely. Bats carry lyssavirus, and that is not something to be ignored!
 
I don't think the WiV building they show is the BSL-4 lab that drew suspicion for a potential lab leak. That is located another 15Km south of the WiV building.
That is correct. The lab close to the market is the Wuhan CDC lab which also collected bat samples. Its relocation was an argument for a laboratory incident in the March 2021 WHO study (the other was just that lab accidents happen). The argument against this is that the CDC lab reported no issue with the move and "reported no storage nor laboratory activities on CoVs or other bat viruses preceding the outbreak".
 
No. I am suggesting that as lab workers working in the wild with bats known to carry coronavirus, their health would be monitored and they would report any incidents such a bite from a bat or protective gear failure. The monitoring would pick up symptomatic infection. The monitoring might include regular samples that would be tested after the outbreak was known.
If only that actually was the standard operating procedure. :rolleyes:
 
If only that actually was the standard operating procedure. :rolleyes:
It is standard operating procedure to monitor the health of lab workers in labs and the field. That is part of the BSL standard for operating labs. That is basic commonsense for fieldwork. This might include taking spit and blood samples, possibly at the end of a field trip. Part of what made the transfer by WIV workers "extremely unlikely" was the lack of any SARS-CoV-2 antibodies found when they were tested after the pandemic started.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part
The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019, and no serological evidence of infection in workers through SARS-CoV-2-specific serology-screening.
 
I hear there is a bridge for sale in Brooklyn, you can get it for a steal.

Did you miss the whole section on the fact China told the WHO team this was so but refused and still refuses to let them see any actual evidence?
 
Nothing to do with my post about the WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part stating that the WIV had a staff health monitoring programme.
A "whole section" fantasy that the team were refused evidence (that the WIV had a staff health monitoring programme). Anyone looking at the table of contents, or searching the PDF for 'doc', 'refused', etc. can see that the section seems to not exist.

ETA: 74 instances of the word 'evidence' without it being refused by China.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom