yellowbamboo
Student
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2003
- Messages
- 26
Open letter to James Randi
Please be advised that in your
latest weekly commentary 26 September 2003
there are quite a number of innaccuracies.
Since we believe you are sincere in your efforts
we would like to point just a few of the
many wrong points you raise.
1. You claim that your representative
Mr Joko Tri from Java did not follow
the protocol correctly.
"Just recall that my protocol required that
Mr. Joko Tri simply walk up and "tap" their "superman"
Nyoman Serengen on the leg with a small bamboo stick,
which was not the protocol followed, for some reason or other"
This again is incorrect.
We refer to our contract which has your
notarized signature of 15 August 2003.
a) No where does it specify how fast Mr Tri
was to approach Mr Serengen. Mr Tri
was walking towards Mr Serengen rapidly
but our contract does not specify a speed.
b) The contract states ".... and is not
required to actually contact Mr Serengen
except by attempting to gently tap him
with a piece of bamboo..."
i. No where does it specify the size of the
piece of bamboo.
ii. Since Mr Tri did not actually tap
Mr Serengen you have no way of knowing
if his intention was to tap Mr Serengen lightly
or not. As you have previously stated
there is no scientific way to know someones
intention.
2. You claim we have been trying to get you to
rush off to bali- in fact previous to this
email to you today we have only emailed you one
time since 14 September 2003. In that email we
simply asked you to give us an idea when you
might be coming as Dr Alvin has plans to travel
for business and would need plenty of notice
to be sure to be here to coincide with your
being here.
There is no rush or pressure to get you here
at any certain date.
3. The bottom line is this- Your representative
was knocked down by Mr Serengen and this was witnessed
by an independent journalist. There is
no dispute to this.
We realize that sicne we are the first to pass the
preliminary test and become claimants this must
be very distressing to you. Of course when we are to actually
win the prize this would ruin your gig but this is the
risk you took when you offered the prize.
There is no rush on our part to go forward but we would
ask you to proceed in a professional, accurate and fair manner
with no acrimony on either part.
We realized that your attitude towards us has been in part because
you probably get so many false claims daily it is very irritating.
But now the deal has changed. We are the first ever group to
pass your first step and as such we would respectfully request
you to accord us the same level of respect we give to you.
We would like to have a professional, harmonious and respectful
relationshipo with you and respectfully request you to endeavor
to do the same.
Sincerely,
Yellow Bamboo Society
Please be advised that in your
latest weekly commentary 26 September 2003
there are quite a number of innaccuracies.
Since we believe you are sincere in your efforts
we would like to point just a few of the
many wrong points you raise.
1. You claim that your representative
Mr Joko Tri from Java did not follow
the protocol correctly.
"Just recall that my protocol required that
Mr. Joko Tri simply walk up and "tap" their "superman"
Nyoman Serengen on the leg with a small bamboo stick,
which was not the protocol followed, for some reason or other"
This again is incorrect.
We refer to our contract which has your
notarized signature of 15 August 2003.
a) No where does it specify how fast Mr Tri
was to approach Mr Serengen. Mr Tri
was walking towards Mr Serengen rapidly
but our contract does not specify a speed.
b) The contract states ".... and is not
required to actually contact Mr Serengen
except by attempting to gently tap him
with a piece of bamboo..."
i. No where does it specify the size of the
piece of bamboo.
ii. Since Mr Tri did not actually tap
Mr Serengen you have no way of knowing
if his intention was to tap Mr Serengen lightly
or not. As you have previously stated
there is no scientific way to know someones
intention.
2. You claim we have been trying to get you to
rush off to bali- in fact previous to this
email to you today we have only emailed you one
time since 14 September 2003. In that email we
simply asked you to give us an idea when you
might be coming as Dr Alvin has plans to travel
for business and would need plenty of notice
to be sure to be here to coincide with your
being here.
There is no rush or pressure to get you here
at any certain date.
3. The bottom line is this- Your representative
was knocked down by Mr Serengen and this was witnessed
by an independent journalist. There is
no dispute to this.
We realize that sicne we are the first to pass the
preliminary test and become claimants this must
be very distressing to you. Of course when we are to actually
win the prize this would ruin your gig but this is the
risk you took when you offered the prize.
There is no rush on our part to go forward but we would
ask you to proceed in a professional, accurate and fair manner
with no acrimony on either part.
We realized that your attitude towards us has been in part because
you probably get so many false claims daily it is very irritating.
But now the deal has changed. We are the first ever group to
pass your first step and as such we would respectfully request
you to accord us the same level of respect we give to you.
We would like to have a professional, harmonious and respectful
relationshipo with you and respectfully request you to endeavor
to do the same.
Sincerely,
Yellow Bamboo Society