Old Testament- Follow the rules?

Aren't there several versions of the 10 commandments and assorted translations as to what means what. How do you know what the sabbath day you are supposed to "keep holy" is? How can you kill someone if they have an immortal soul that lives forever and god knows when their time on earth is coming to an end anyhow (he premeditated his own son's murder-- but it was okay, because his son was really him and he got to live happily ever after after the blood atonement plot.)

It doesn't even say what you can't kill-- can you kill animals? plants? bacteria? Is it fair to kill things without immortal souls? What if you killed someone and thus ensured they'd go to heaven... whereas, had they lived they could have gone to hell...? Do you get a "get out of hell" free pass even though you killed?

Religion makes no sense. The smarter you are the crazier it all seems.
 
Last edited:
Whenever someone tell me the Bible (or 10 Commandments) is a moral guide, I ask them how they know what's moral from it.
If they have to pick and choose, then they are obviously using some other set of principles to guide their morals, and can no longer claim Bible as a moral guide.
If they stick to the letter of the Bible for moral guidance, well, as you say, let's hope they don't.
Exactly.

If you don't have some external source of morality, just "following the Bible" is much more likely to result in immoral behavior (just based on the proportion of horrible stuff to good stuff).

I think most people use it to bolster a moral position that they already have (independent of where reading the Bible would lead you). They have a position, then hunt through the Bible to find a passage that supports their position.

When there are passages that support the contrary position (and there often are), how could it be a moral guide? Which one should be followed?
 
Should Christians follow all some or none of the rules of the Old Testament ?
What's it to you?

44 " 'Your male and female slaves are to come from the nations around you; from them you may buy slaves.
I don't want Mexican slaves, slaves cost capital and money to maintain. 'Tis far cheaper to hire them for dirt cheap, eh? Ask the people who funnel money to Congress if you aren't sure about the cost benefit analysis.

DR
 
Last edited:
To answer the question, I don't think there is any support for Christians to maintain the laws of the Old Testament.

Just interested, but I see two obvious ways to interpret this: (1) nowhere does it say that Christians should maintain the laws of the Old Testament, so Christians needn't do so, and (2) passages do say that Christians are not required to follow the laws of the Old Testament. Of course, there could be others.

If the latter, do you have support for the position? If the former, why come to that conclusion since the absence of directions within a Jewish community doesn't seem to support that conclusion and Paul seemed fairly clear that the laws (sans dietary restriction and circumcision) should be followed (they simply don't justify you before God)?
 

I've only read about it, but it was fairly clear to me that he didn't live according the Bible. Not only couldn't he, but he plain didn't. (He did not stone the adulterer to death, e.g. Why? That the sinner failed to consent should hardly matter, and what are a few earthly consequences when it comes to following god's law?)
 
Well... you forgot the loophole... technically you can't actually kill people because they have immortal souls... plus god knows who is going to die and when and he can make people carry out his plot if he wants to (see Jesus for example)-- so just stoning the adulterer gets a pass... I mean the adulterer will eventually die and then ... well... whatever...

If you are clever enough you can get it all to sort of make enough sense to convince yourself that you are following all the laws in the right enough way to win the "happily ever after" game...

(If you are really good you can judge other earthlings while imagining yourself both humble AND "in on divine secrets" during the game-- heaven bonus points for dodging, asking insincere questions, being a hypocrite, playing semantic games, and illustrating amazing cognitive dissonance-- super extra credit for convincing others to be like you!)
 
I've only read about it, but it was fairly clear to me that he didn't live according the Bible. Not only couldn't he, but he plain didn't. (He did not stone the adulterer to death, e.g. Why? That the sinner failed to consent should hardly matter, and what are a few earthly consequences when it comes to following god's law?)
I think he explained in the introduction that he could only follow the bible inasmuch as it didn't ask him to do anything illegal. Much of what he did was dietary and grooming hints.
 
I'm still waiting to hear an explanation as to why god gave such absurd and wicked commandments in the first place.
 
I'm still waiting to hear an explanation as to why god gave such absurd and wicked commandments in the first place.


.
1) Because he could?
2) Because it's just the ramblings of diseased disabled minds in a group of nasty old men who have grown to hate everything, and by gee-willikers are gonna set those young uppity punks in their place?
Reading Samuel, it's 2).
 
I think he explained in the introduction that he could only follow the bible inasmuch as it didn't ask him to do anything illegal. Much of what he did was dietary and grooming hints.

Granted.
 
These days, you don't have to sort through all that tedious Old Testament language. You can just go to God's blog and find out directly all the stuff he hates.
 
These days, you don't have to sort through all that tedious Old Testament language. You can just go to God's blog and find out directly all the stuff he hates.

Finally, he's updated his communications. I guess he got sick of all that petty random interpreting people were doing (of course, he should have been able to foresee this issue given his purported omniscience.)
 
To answer the question, I don't think there is any support for Christians to maintain the laws of the Old Testament.

Could somebody explain: I thought that, for Christians, Jesus is God. Is that a different God from the one in the Old Testament?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom