Og det var Danmark ...

Since this thread seems to frequented mainly by Danes or other Scandinavians, I'd like to point out here that if anybody needs to get their facts straight about the Cartoon Controversy, this is a very good place to begin: http://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammed-tegningerne Many links to relevant newspaper articles.
For the rest of you: Unfortunately it is in Danish!
If you speak German, however, there's a meeting in Bremen next Thursday:
http://doku.argudiss.info/data/karika_streit_hb_0206_ank.pdf
 
Since this thread seems to frequented mainly by Danes or other Scandinavians, I'd like to point out here that if anybody needs to get their facts straight about the Cartoon Controversy, this is a very good place to begin: http://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammed-tegningerne Many links to relevant newspaper articles.
For the rest of you: Unfortunately it is in Danish!
If you speak German, however, there's a meeting in Bremen next Thursday:
http://doku.argudiss.info/data/karika_streit_hb_0206_ank.pdf

Tyvärr så är min danska lite rostig, men jag ska se om jag kan läsa det.

My danish is a bit rusty,but I'll give it a go.
 
It is interesting to look at the reason why Denmark wasn't swallowed completely by Sweden in the war that made Scania Swedish: The more powerful nations in Europe wouldn't let it happen! Until that war Denmark had controlled the seaward approach to the Baltic Sea which was a nuisance to nations doing business in that area: customs, a major source of income for the Crown! They did not want to let another country get this kind of monopoly! This is probably the only reason why Denmark still exists as an autonomous nation, surrounded by much more powerful countries!
Specifically, the Dutch Republic of the Seven United Provinces. From the late Middle Ages, trade from specifically Holland (one of those provinces) became more and more important and specifically the grain (wheat) imported from the Baltics was crucial to feeding the good people of Amsterdam and other Dutch cities. From 1497 on, more than half the ships that passed the Sound came from Holland. Dutch trade in the Indies now gets all the press, but the Baltic trade was back then called "moedernegotie" - the mother of all trades.

When in 1660, Denmark set out to reconquer Scania, the Dutch Republic disagreed:
Denmark insisted on the return of the Scanian lands, with the support of Brandenburg, Austria and Poland, but this time the Dutch did not agree with Denmark. On 8 March 1660, admiral Michiel de Ruyter and his Dutch fleet were ordered to leave the harbour of Landskrona, where he had bottled up the Swedish fleet. Frederick yielded, and the negotiations began in earnest on 24 March.
 
A few highlights from the history of Danish foreign policy and diplomacy

"All nations bigger than Denmark are crocks of doo-doo." Kurt Vonnegut
"And so is Denmark, just smaller ..." dann

Like the inhabitants of all other nations with a glorious past, Danes tend to think of themselves as part of a tradition, which is probably the reason why, over the years, illustrations from 'our' viking past have been printed on Danish banknotes alongside portraits of prominent dead Danes such as Ole Rømer, Hans Christian Andersen, H.C. Ørsted, Karen Blixen and Niels Bohr: http://www.nationalbanken.dk/DNUK/NotesAndCoins.nsf/side/Denmarks_banknote_series!OpenDocument

And it is true! (but nothing to be proud of, in my opinion.) A thousand years ago the vikings were able to conquer most of Scandinavia, major parts of England and plunder cities as far away as Paris and Constantinoble. And today Denmark has troops stationed in distant countries, Afghanistan and Iraq, but that is a story that we'll return to in due course.

If you look at maps of Denmark through the ages, the actual nation and its sphere of influence in the Baltic region, it soon becomes apparent that it has shrunk considerably: Maps of Denmark/Scandinavia and the Baltic region:
www.zum.de/whkmla/histatlas/scandinavia/haxdenmark.html
In 1658 it had almost shrunk to its present size when Sweden conquered Scania/Skåne on the other side of the Øresund, the sound separating Denmark from Sweden. It still had control of parts of Schleswig and Holstein (now Northwestern Germany) but lost (a little more than) these possessions in 1864 when Prussia and Austria liberated them as part of Prussia's unification project that created Germany.
Because Germany lost a war in 1919, a part of the territory lost in 1864 was returned to Denmark in a plebiscite forced upon Germany by the powers that won WWI. (Denmark had been neutral and profiteered from the war because it was able to do business with all the countries involved in the war.)

It is interesting to look at the reason why Denmark wasn't swallowed completely by Sweden in the war that made Scania Swedish: The more powerful nations in Europe wouldn't let it happen! Until that war Denmark had controlled the seaward approach to the Baltic Sea which was a nuisance to nations doing business in that area: customs, a major source of income for the Crown! They did not want to let another country get this kind of monopoly! This is probably the only reason why Denmark still exists as an autonomous nation, surrounded by much more powerful countries!

It also helps explains Denmark's position in the cold war:

"In an international crisis the Soviet Union - especially if the duration of the crisis is long - will be very interested in access to and from the Atlantic Ocean through the Baltic Sea." Well, actually the Soviet Union would be interested in this all the time, but in an international crisis certain powers might want to put a stop to it! "Here - in the Baltic - the USSR has more than half of its capacity in shipyards and supplies. If a crisis threatens to prolong itself, sooner or later the Soviet Union must be able to supply and repair its vessels in the Atlantic Ocean from its bases and shipyards on the coasts of the Baltic Sea. Therefore the Soviet Union needs to be free to sail through the Danish straits and sounds." (major Flemming Schroll Nielsen: AMF - NATO's krisestyrke, p.24-25, my translation)

"As we saw in the case of Murmansk in connection with Northern Norway, it is not very likely that the Soviet, Polish and East German forces in the Baltic area are deployed in order to be a threat to Denmark." !!! "They, too, should be seen in a larger - global - context. But the outcome will be the same! If a tense situation should arise anywhere in the world, and the USSR would want to secure its ability to sail unhindered in and out of the the Baltic," ... or if NATO would want to put a stop to this! "then the Soviet Union may feel tempted to seize control of the opening of the Baltic into the Atlantic." (p. 25-26)

So the logic actually was: By controlling Denmark, NATO would be able to put a stop to not only the Russian, but also the East German and Polish fleets as well, which would make the Warsaw Pact countries want to attack Denmark, a very small, impotent nation. Therefore it was of vital importance to NATO to make it obvious that they wouldn't then be at war with just Denmark, but with all of the Allied Mobile Force:

"If you attack now, you will be at war with troops from Seeland - i.e. Denmark. You will also be confronted with troops from eight other NATO countries." (Belgium, Canada, England, Holland, Italy, Luxemburg, the USA and West Germany) (...) "and that means that an attack on Denmark is an attack on all of the NATO alliance." (p. 36)

As a conseqence of its position Danish dipomacy and foreign policy has been based on trying not to piss off the major players in European affairs, since the existence of the country is based on the favours of the powerful nations in the region: Russia, Germany, Great Britain. 'We' have always relied on the kindness of strangers! That is not as easy to do as it may sound, since these nations were often at war with each other. During the Napoleonic wars Nelson almost completely destroyed the Danish fleet. It took the Germans about half an hour to occupy the country, April 9, 1940.

Like most other small, but fairly wealthy nations (Holland or the other Scandinavian countries) Denmark's speciality used to be on the field of virtuous ideals of international relations. If Denmark couldn't compete in international affairs with the major players, it could at least live up to the ideals of the UN and pay the required percentage of its GNP to aid countries in the so-called Third World. And since Denmark, due to its size, wasn't able to make a lot of enemies, the Danes cultivated an image of themselves as having the ideal relationship between political leaders and the populace - sometimes to the extent that the demonstration of this relationship pissed off leaders of other countries.

(In October 1972 when Denmark joined the EEC (now the EU), I was on a class trip to Paris. Sitting at a sidewalk café we watched as a policeman manually switched the traffic lights on and off to enable the big limos accompanied by motorcycles swish by, carrying the representative of the nine (?) member states away from some meeting. At one point the policeman looked confused, waited a while, and then he switched the traffic lights back to automatic and left. Ten minutes later another limo drove by as part of the ordinary traffic and without motorcycles - and (of course) with the (now so familiar!) Danish flag. Premier Anker Jørgensen enjoyed doing stunts like that, which naturally upset the security arrangements in general.
As part of the Danish national mythology an anecdote of Czar Peter the Great visiting Denmark is told: He and the Danish king were standing on top of Rundetårn, a round tower in central Copenhagen. Czar Peter bragged to the Danish king that he was so powerful that if he ordered one of his servants to jump off the tower, he would do so. The Danish king then told (off) Czar Peter that his own power rested on the loyalty of his subjects who knew that he would never order them to do a thing like that.
We do indeed live in the country of fairy-tale writer Hans Christian Andersen ...)

In recent years, however, Danish foreign ministers have enjoyed the power and significance it gives them to be part of a (super)powerful alliance. Before the Soviet Bloc collapsed completely they were able to go to Moscow and speak more or less on behalf of NATO, and in recent years they have had troops stationed in the Balkans, in Afghanistan and in Iraq. Until now, however, the Moslem and Arab world did not really notice the existence of Denmark whose role in these wars was mainly symbolic as one of the countries mentioned by Bush as part of the Coalition of the Willing!
At the very beginning of the current Iraqi war, Bush gave Anders Fogh Rasmussen the commission to go back to Europe and head the endeavours of making the Unwilling European nations join the war against Saddam Hussein and his alleged WMDs. When asked about his attitude to this by a Danish reporter, a French premier was heard saying: "What??! I never heard of such a thing!" By a reporter on Danish TV this was interpreted as an embarrassment, since this French statesman obviously hadn't done his homework properly.
In reality, however, the embarrassment, of course, was that the Danish premier was snubbed by the Frenchman who found the idea so utterly ridiculous that he pretended that he hadn't heard of this US affront to the old powers of Europe: Bush's suggestion that a Danish premier LEAD anything concerning them!

As recent developments (the "Cartoon Controversy", aptly named!) show, Danish diplomacy may have overrated its support from its powerful allies when it refused to meet with ambassadors from Moslem countries for talks about the cartoons published by the daily Jyllands Posten ....
There's a BIG difference between the USA and Denmark in this respect. Pointing at the high ideals of democracy and free speech isn't worth much when you are the leader of an impotent nation like Denmark. It may serve to convince the people that are subject to your power, but it doesn't help you much abroad. (And Jyllands Posten's campaign was probably never meant to be seen by an audience outside of Denmark!) If you represent a superpower like the USA, however, it is so much easier to pretend that these ideals are all you care about:
http://www.gegenstandpunkt.com/english/improving-the-world.html
Patriotism in a superpower never LOOKS as childish as patriotism in 'nations no bigger than Denmark' ...
http://www.gegenstandpunkt.com/english/patriotism.html
Edited to correct year: 1945 --> 1940!

Hold on a moment: the western Vikings went west from Norway, and the eastern ones east from Sweden to Novgorod via Russia.

Of course, Sweden didn't become a country until 1397, having up until then been part of the Danish empire. Thanks to the Stockholm bloodbath, instigated by King Christian of Denmark, that was the end of Danish influence there.

It is misleading to refer to modern day areas as we know them today by current names and political boundaries, because of course, before the Mediaeval Ages, there were the Dark Ages, with people living in tribes and walled cities.

So when you say 'Denmark has shrunk', I cannot see how, unless you are referring back to the Kalmar Union.
 
Islam has lost a lot. Fear is not respect. Acting like petulant, backward children will not gain respect.

Freedom of speech is just getting started, if print media cannot support it they will cease to be a source of information. I am already thinking of canceling a subscription - why bother with them?

Political cartoonists are pissed. Islam will be hearing from them again. Muslims have no sense of humor - they are a great target.

Interesting, necro thread is like a time capsule where we can read our futile hopes for the future.

Unfortunately, things did not go the way kopji hoped. Free speech did not take the fundementalist beast. Indeed, some countries such as the UK decided to enact additional laws in order to prohibit criticism of the fundamentalists. And in all countries, self censorship is the order of the day.

Fundementalist islam did not "lose a lot" back in 2006, it picked a winning strategy against the west.
 
Of course, Sweden didn't become a country until 1397, having up until then been part of the Danish empire. Thanks to the Stockholm bloodbath, instigated by King Christian of Denmark, that was the end of Danish influence there.

You have your years mixed up. The Kalmar Union BEGAN in 1397. The Bloodbath of Stockholm was in 1520, and the Vasa Uprising lasted until 1523, his reforms resulting in centralization and the creation of the modern nation of Sweden.

Anyway, Sweden existed before that! Eric of Pommerania was granted the crown, after all. Generally, the first commonly accepted king of Sweden is Erik Segersäll, in the 10th century. Other suggested starting points exist in the 11th-13th centuries (Sverker the Elder, Karl Sverkersson...), generally no later than Birger Jarl's reforms in the mid-13th.
 
Last edited:
You have your years mixed up. The Kalmar Union BEGAN in 1397. The Bloodbath of Stockholm was in 1520, and the Vasa Uprising lasted until 1523, his reforms resulting in centralization and the creation of the modern nation of Sweden.

Anyway, Sweden existed before that! Eric of Pommerania was granted the crown, after all. Generally, the first commonly accepted king of Sweden is Erik Segersäll, in the 10th century. Other suggested starting points exist in the 11th-13th centuries, generally no later than Birger Jarl's reforms in the mid-13th.


You'll find that what was then known as 'Svea' was just the small central part of the country, so no, it is not Sweden (Sverige) as we know the region today.

Stockholm was a walled city, with a law unto itself.

Yes, you are right, I got the dates wrong whoops - shows wikipedia can be careless about this, as I just took the first date that came up when I went to check when Sweden became a country.
 
You'll find that what was then known as 'Svea' was just the small central part of the country, so no, it is not Sweden (Sverige) as we know the region today.

Stockholm was a walled city, with a law unto itself.

Yes, you are right, I got the dates wrong whoops - shows wikipedia can be careless about this, as I just took the first date that came up when I went to check when Sweden became a country.

Thanks, I know the geography of my own country. Erig Segersäll is thought to possibly have ruled over Svealand, Västra Götaland and Östergötland. Thus he would have been king of both the Swedes and most of the Geats, which is usually taken to be the most important aspect. The southernmost parts of Sweden would be Danish and Bohuslän would be Norwegian. The Northernmost parts I'm not sure if anyone besides the Sami really claimed; to this day they're still quite sparsely populated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweden#/media/File:Scandinavia-12th_century.png This is Sweden in the 12th century. It gets a bit ridiculous to say that the Kingdom of the Swedes and Geats only came into existence with territorial acquisitions in the mid-16th century. There was a clear continuity at least 500 years back.

That there were often local laws that held great force was testament to the power of the Great Men (wealthy landowners). The Swedish king was indeed not very powerful prior to the mid-13th century, and would only really be an autocrat from Vasa and on.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, I know the geography of my own country. Erig Segersäll is thought to possibly have ruled over Svealand, Västra Götaland and Östergötland. Thus he would have been king of both the Swedes and most of the Geats, which is usually taken to be the most important aspect. The southernmost parts of Sweden would be Danish and Bohuslän would be Norwegian. The Northernmost parts I'm not sure if anyone besides the Sami really claimed; to this day they're still quite sparsely populated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweden#/media/File:Scandinavia-12th_century.png This is Sweden in the 12th century. It gets a bit ridiculous to say that the Kingdom of the Swedes and Geats only came into existence with territorial acquisitions in the mid-16th century. There was a clear continuity at least 500 years back.

That there were often local laws that held great force was testament to the power of the Great Men (wealthy landowners). The Swedish king was indeed not very powerful prior to the mid-13th century, and would only really be an autocrat from Vasa and on.

It was under the domain of Denmark until 1520 Stockholm Bloodbath, which led to its independence. Is that not so...?

That's the mythology I understand.
 
It was under the domain of Denmark until 1520 Stockholm Bloodbath, which led to its independence. Is that not so...?

That's the mythology I understand.

Sweden was part of a personal union under a Danish king for about 130 years before the Vasa Uprising ended it. But "Sweden" was recognizable to a degree before that union. Sweden didn't come to exist because of it, although it did get most of its current borders as a result.
 
Sweden was part of a personal union under a Danish king for about 130 years before the Vasa Uprising ended it. But "Sweden" was recognizable to a degree before that union. Sweden didn't come to exist because of it, although it did get most of its current borders as a result.

Ah. Well, of course, it was a Reformation versus Rome situation ultimately.
 
Ah. Well, of course, it was a Reformation versus Rome situation ultimately.
How so? The whole of Scandinavia turned Lutheran. Oh, and in 1520 there strictly wasn't yet a Reformation: Luther still had to appear at the Diet of Worms.

I thought it was more a question of "follow the money": the Vasa Uprising was financed by the good merchants of Lübeck.
 
How so? The whole of Scandinavia turned Lutheran. Oh, and in 1520 there strictly wasn't yet a Reformation: Luther still had to appear at the Diet of Worms.

I thought it was more a question of "follow the money": the Vasa Uprising was financed by the good merchants of Lübeck.

It was in that a key Archibishop (Catholic) was stripped of his title and his manor house razed. King Christian of Denmark was appraised of this. The archibishops of Stockholm and some Queen or other were desperate to appease him. When he arrived at Stockholm a banquet was laid on and the Archbishops had plans to pacify the guy. Instead, King Christian got his army to lock all the doors and something like 70 bishops and clergy were taken out one by one to the square outside and beheaded without further ado.

Thus there was a division between the bishops of the old Catholic order, versus those who supported the Stockholm rebels, which could not be healed.

Ultimately, it did lead to Sweden's independence and break with the Catholic church after Luther's reformation movement in Germany.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom