It seems to me that the Occupy movement was, or perhaps still is, a genuine manifestation of some will toward change. It may have been confused, it may even have had people involved with bad intentions, but that's because it was open to all. That was the point. It's an expression of people's genuine, imo, frustration with, again imo, a hostile corrupt system. When we see unprecedented ideological attacks made into law against the poorest and weakest in society (certianly in the UK), it's not hard to understand a desire for change, however poorly implemented, and it's a little too easy to point and sneer at some people in their muddy tents occupying a public space.
Compare OWS with the Freedom Riders.
The Freedom Riders were absolutely
not open to all. The people that went on those rides were carefully screened, and carefully selected. They went on those rides with a specific mission, and a specific message. When they clashed with authorities, they did so on their own terms, over the issues that they had specifically chosen.
They had a clear, consistent message, that was not diluted or polluted by inclusion of diverging or opposing groups. They got respect, and they got results.
So much for the Freedom Riders.
But the Freedom Riders had a specific message, so they were able to be focused and exclusive.
The problem with OWS is that it was never conceived as a focused, exclusive movement. Instead, it was--as far as I can tell--conceived to give the impression that 99% of people are angry about the 1%. But since that's not actually true, it has to be all-inclusive. Anybody who's angry about anything is welcome to come down and join the crowd and swell the numbers and make it look like we're all in this together. Your anger is my anger. Your protest is my protest. Look how many of us there really are!
But of course that's not true. Even all the various angry activist factions together don't add up to anything like 99%. None of them individually appeal to more than a tiny fraction of the
real 99%. And all of them together are just a hopeless, hapless mish-mash of incoherent and opposing (and often ugly) ideas, that appeal to almost nobody at all.
As a show of unified anger against the 1%, OWS only managed to alienate the 99% they set out to attract and represent. As a force for change, OWS has failed miserably. Now it's down to a few muddy people in a few muddy tents, bickering amongst themselves and telling each other that they really do matter.
It's down to them, and it's down to you, telling us that they matter.