Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
And why should they become provoked by this? Dealing with such behavior comes with the territory of being a cop.
I never said they should become provoked. I think they should not become provoked. I think that is a minimum standard of the professionalism they should exhibit. My assertion was that it is immature and childish to attempt to provoke the cops for the sake of provoking the cops and/or to create a confrontation. It furthers the goals of the protest in no appreciable manner at all, regardless of the success of the tactic.

Nice straw man. Jane tried it earlier.

Also, I become unsettled when driving through a small town of no more than 10,000 people and the cars are equipped with steel reinforced roll-style bumpers and an L-RAD at the ready just in case a cow flips out or something.

Or gets set upon by an angry mob.

All the anti-pepper spray folks here will be happy to know Chicago police don;t use the stuff. They're using those good old-fashioned wholesome police methods RandFan was so much a fan of - smacking them with billy clubs when they get out of line.

Last night a group of occutards mobbed and attacked a police van occupied by a single officer, giving him a concussion and slashing several of the tires before the cop managed to speed away. Of course, this infuriated the occutards who can't understand why he sped through the mob after they attacked him, one claimed they were run over but that person was released this morning from the hospital without any apparent injury.

You can tell when the occutards are being violent by how often they use the word "peaceful" in their protests in a desperate attempt to manage the information flow, but the video speaks for itself.

http://www.chicagotribune.com/video...protesters-accuse-Chicago-police-of-brutality
 
Would you like a tissue?
No, but I could use some toilet paper. Do you have the OWS manifesto anywhere around?

I'm surprised that you have such a low opinion of the police.
Quite the opposite. I have a low opinion of the protesters. The police did exactly what they were legally and ethically supposed to do; they ignored them. But please, continue to dodge the question of what the protestors were doing, which was trying to provoke the cops for no reason. And, of course, the militant language used to call out the militant police is nakedly hypocritical.

Yes it's called civil disobedience.
Ah. So they only represent the wishes of the 99% when it's convenient.

For black people, especially, Obama's color is very important.
I would like to point out that you don't actually explain what race has to do with the ostensible concerns of OWS, which supposedly have to do with economics. I didn't ask you about how it relates to black people, I asked you about OWS.

And, of course, you don't contest my claim that those nice folks seem to think Obama is merely a lackey of the White european power structure. They all but use the words "race traitor".
 
I never said they should become provoked. I think they should not become provoked. I think that is a minimum standard of the professionalism they should exhibit. My assertion was that it is immature and childish to attempt to provoke the cops for the sake of provoking the cops and/or to create a confrontation. It furthers the goals of the protest in no appreciable manner at all, regardless of the success of the tactic.

Nice straw man. Jane tried it earlier.

I think they should not become provoked either. If you read the context of my statement, you would see that is what I meant.

Bringing up the incident of idiots dangling donuts in front of cops is a straw man. And I didn't bring it up. You did!

So really, Jane wasn't the one who "tried it earlier".

Or gets set upon by an angry mob.

Although there is a considerable crime index for the area I visited over the weekend, nothing proves why and for what reason the police should militarize their equipment.

Needless to say, there are times I have visited during a busy weekend like the 4th of July or Memorial Day weekend and the cops are nowhere to be found. I guess that must mean they're dealing with an angry mob elsewhere?
 
Last edited:
No, but I could use some toilet paper. Do you have the OWS manifesto anywhere around?

Sorry that you have been caught short. Good luck with your search.

Quite the opposite. I have a low opinion of the protesters.

Irrelevant.

The police did exactly what they were legally and ethically supposed to do; they ignored them. But please, continue to dodge the question of what the protestors were doing, which was trying to provoke the cops for no reason. And, of course, the militant language used to call out the militant police is nakedly hypocritical.


That you believe the police can be provoked into militarization by some dangling donuts proves that you have an extremely low opinion of the police.

Ah. So they only represent the wishes of the 99% when it's convenient.

Whatever. If you're happy with your level of democratic participation, good for you! You're welcome to stay off the streets.

I would like to point out that you don't actually explain what race has to do with the ostensible concerns of OWS, which supposedly have to do with economics. I didn't ask you about how it relates to black people, I asked you about OWS.

The article spells it out very clearly: Empire and slavery.

We black people are part of OWS. Do you have a problem with that?

Why don't you join OWS if you're so worried that it may be concerned with the wrong things?

And, of course, you don't contest my claim that those nice folks seem to think Obama is merely a lackey of the White european power structure.

I assume you disagree with their analysis, but, as you don't go into any details, it's hard to tell.

It's good to know that you think they're nice folks, anyway.

They all but use the words "race traitor".

Are you short of things to get upset about today?

It's funny and instructive that you're trying to get upset about a words they didn't use!



I see you’re still happy to quote childish, bigotted rubbish about “occutards”. What, to your mind, does the word “occutard” mean and why are still promoting its use despite claiming not to like it?



Do you think Obama is a race traitor Jane?

You did endorse the article.


Why do you hate the disabled, Virus?

Do you also hate black people?
 
Last edited:
I think they should not become provoked either. If you read the context of my statement, you would see that is what I meant.

And why should they become provoked by this? Dealing with such behavior comes with the territory of being a cop.​
The inference is that someone said the cops should be provoked by it.

Bringing up the incident of idiots dangling donuts in front of cops is a straw man.
How is it a straw man? It shows how OWS is spoiling for a fight, actively trying to provoke incidents, but keep claiming they're peaceful protestors and complaining about the militarized police. It's actually quite common for people these days to get in trouble with the cops and then only show the cops' responses and not the actions they were responding to.

And I didn't bring it up. You did!
And?

So really, Jane wasn't the one who "tried it earlier".
The "straw man!1!" portion of my post refers to diverting from claims about the protestors attempts to provoke the cops by talking about how the cops shouldn't be provoked, as if all responsibility in the incident lies on their shoulders. Jane made that straw man several times earlier, after she posted the photo of the protestors buskers fishing for cops. She was the one who initially introduced the matter to the thread.

Although there is a considerable crime index for the area I visited over the weekend, nothing proves why and for what reason the police should militarize their equipment.

Needless to say, there are times I have visited during a busy weekend like the 4th of July or Memorial Day weekend and the cops are nowhere to be found. I guess that must mean they're dealing with an angry mob elsewhere?
I don't think the cops are militarized. The term seems to have become popularized because it sounds oppressive. The police receiving training and support from the military isn't militarizing them. Riot cops are generally armed with less lethal weaponry and more less-lethal weaponry than they were ten or 20 years back, and receive better funding and training.

Hey! Did you just post a one sentence comment?
Yes.

And a correct one, it seems.
 
Last edited:
...
That you believe the police can be provoked into militarization by some dangling donuts proves that you have an extremely low opinion of the police....
I don't, and have never claimed as such. I have claimed the precise opposite. The protestors, apparently, did believe they could provoke the cops, and were disappointed. You seem incredibly loath to actually address that fact, to assign any sort of responsibility for negative actions to the buskers at all. Not the results of the actions, the actions themselves. If someone attempts to shoot someone with what they think is a loaded gun, and it loaded with blanks, they can still be charged with Attempted Murder.

...

We black people are part of OWS. Do you have a problem with that? ...

See image.

I have little problem with people of any color, creed, or sexual preference doing whatever fool thing they want, as long as it doesn't affect the rights of others.

However, once anyone starts deciding their desires take precedence over the rights of others, especially the very people they claim to represent, I have a big problem with that.
 

Attachments

  • Photo-on-21-05-2012-at-12.jpg
    Photo-on-21-05-2012-at-12.jpg
    27.5 KB · Views: 8
Last edited:
Be careful of special interest groups hijacking the message. That's what happened to the Tea Party leading them to be co-opted into the Fox News GOP. Even if people show up who you agree with on some political issue, ask yourselves if that issue is actually related to what the protest is about. There will be, and probably already are, many factions who want nothing more than to turn the entire movement into a DNC fundraiser. Suddenly it will be about collective bargaining for teachers or something else that doesn't involve a corporation at all, let alone Wall Street. The partisans on both sides will try and expand their trenches such that your movement falls into them. Keep an eye out, don't be the next Tea Party.

That is what we learn from History.

Ludwik Kowalski
.
 
The inference is that someone said the cops should be provoked by it.

Yes. And you just stated my point. Next.

How is it a straw man? It shows how OWS is spoiling for a fight, actively trying to provoke incidents, but keep claiming they're peaceful protestors and complaining about the militarized police.

It is definitely a straw man now that you have twisted my context.

Did I "claim they were peaceful protestors yet complaining about the militarized police"? I know I said I had a problem with how some branches of law enforcement are equipped but that does not infer that I DON'T have a problem with SOME OWS protestors.

In fact, if you scroll back you will see that I referred to the 'dangling donuts' protestors as 'idiots'.

It's actually quite common for people these days to get in trouble with the cops and then only show the cops' responses and not the actions they were responding to.

I see more of just the opposite. I see more of a glorification of law enforcement, especially by the news media and various television shows including, of all things, COPS, Disorderly Conduct, Rookies, The Academy, Smile! You're Under Arrest, Real Stories of the Highway Patrol, LAPD, SWAT, America's Most Wanted, Worlds Dumbest Criminals, Steven Segal, and the list goes on.


And... I didn't bring it up. You did!

The "straw man!1!" portion of my post refers to diverting from claims about the protestors attempts to provoke the cops by talking about how the cops shouldn't be provoked, as if all responsibility in the incident lies on their shoulders. Jane made that straw man several times earlier, after she posted the photo of the protestors buskers fishing for cops. She was the one who initially introduced the matter to the thread.

And here you are keeping the issue going. WOW!

I don't think the cops are militarized.

Which cops are you referring to?

The term seems to have become popularized because it sounds oppressive.

Something oppressive is popular? ...Okaaaay?

The police receiving training and support from the military isn't militarizing them. Riot cops are generally armed with less lethal weaponry and more less-lethal weaponry than they were ten or 20 years back, and receive better funding and training.

And so let's go back to my original observation about how does a town of 10,000 or less need a police force equipped with L-RADs, reinforced bumpers, and be trained by the military?

And a correct one, it seems.

If you say so. (***oops*** My bad for creating a one sentence response***) :boxedin:
 
...
000063 said:
The term seems to have become popularized because it sounds oppressive.
Something oppressive is popular? ...Okaaaay?
...
Asking someone to clarify their point, like I did is kind of the exact opposite of deliberately twisting their words. I'm not sure if you're deliberately misunderstanding me or not, and come to think of it, I'm not sure why I care.
 
Asking someone to clarify their point, like I did is kind of the exact opposite of deliberately twisting their words. I'm not sure if you're deliberately misunderstanding me or not, and come to think of it, I'm not sure why I care.

I don't know why you care either.
 
I don't, and have never claimed as such.

What, then, is the irony you are referring to here?:

And you haven't noticed the irony of complaining about militarized police when OWS supporters write things like this and dangle donuts at cops in attempts to provoke them. #winning!


I have claimed the precise opposite. The protestors, apparently, did believe they could provoke the cops, and were disappointed.


What evidence do you have for this assertion, besides your own imagination?


See image.

I have little problem with people of any color, creed, or sexual preference doing whatever fool thing they want, as long as it doesn't affect the rights of others.

However, once anyone starts deciding their desires take precedence over the rights of others, especially the very people they claim to represent, I have a big problem with that.

I agree. Democracy is a flawed system, especially when it mutates into corporatism. A system of informed consensus would be better. I notice, however, that you have failed to address why you are still promoting the use of disabled people as an insult, despite declaring your distaste for it.
 
Last edited:
I have to admit, Jane, the idea that I have to join OWS for my criticisms of it to be valid was amusing and original. I don't have to join OWS to criticize them any more than OWS has to join the government or the 1%, any more than you have to join the police to criticize them.
 
I have to admit, Jane, the idea that I have to join OWS for my criticisms of it to be valid was amusing and original. I don't have to join OWS to criticize them any more than OWS has to join the government or the 1%, any more than you have to join the police to criticize them.

Dodge.

I said nothing about you having to join OWS and you have avoided answering my questions.
 
Last edited:
However, once anyone starts deciding their desires take precedence over the rights of others, especially the very people they claim to represent I have a big problem with that.
What are you talking about? You mean like the sit-ins and civil disobedience of the 60s and 70s?

What about the right to pursue happiness? And I'm not talking about the protestors. I'm talking about the people whose investments and savings were wiped out because of greed and govt malfeasance? Many people have to delay retirement or simply cannot do what they wanted because their money vanished. For some reason people don't give a damn about that right.

What about the right to one's property? Retirement accounts lost $1.3 trillion as a result of that malfeasance and greed. Do you have a problem with that? I honestly do not understand some people's priorities. We gotta get all worked up at the inconvenience caused by protestors. OMG! Protestors never cost anyone their retirement or home.
 
Last edited:
What evidence do you have for this assertion, besides your own imagination?

.

Uh, I was there at the Thursday morning rally on Randolph, the Thursday afternoon rally on Lake and the friday rally at the Daley Center.

the Thursday morning was very low key.

The Thursday afternoon was initially low key but then filled with Black Bloc idiots who got in the police officers' faces. The comment I remember was a kid who asked a cop why only tenants were being let into their own building, and received a polite response, to which he replied: "thanks a lot ya ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊****** ******* pig."

Friday was fine until the rally ended, and then the barrage of abuse started.

So, yeah, some protesters were provoking the cops.

By the way, the anti-tar sands types on Lake were pissed when the face mask types showed up, and started grabbing all their orange slices.
 
Uh, I was there at the Thursday morning rally on Randolph, the Thursday afternoon rally on Lake and the friday rally at the Daley Center.

the Thursday morning was very low key.

The Thursday afternoon was initially low key but then filled with Black Bloc idiots who got in the police officers' faces. The comment I remember was a kid who asked a cop why only tenants were being let into their own building, and received a polite response, to which he replied: "thanks a lot ya ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊****** ******* pig."

Friday was fine until the rally ended, and then the barrage of abuse started.

So, yeah, some protesters were provoking the cops.

By the way, the anti-tar sands types on Lake were pissed when the face mask types showed up, and started grabbing all their orange slices.


000063 was referring to donut danglers in Montreal.

Hs claim was that they "did believe they could provoke the cops". He has offered no evidence for this assertion.



~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~



"""PRESS RELEASE
For Immediate Release: May 22, 2012

Occupy Chicago Releases Additional Photos of Both Suspected Police Informants Involved in NATO Terrorism-Related Cases

Chicago, IL -- Occupy Chicago has obtained photographs of suspected police informants, who according to witnesses and arrestees were part of a law enforcement operation, which has resulted in the prosecution of 5 NATO protesters on terrorism-related charges. The city has yet to admit to using infiltrators in the Wednesday night raid on a Bridgeport home of activists, but both suspected police informants who go by the names of "Mo" and "Gloves" (aka "Nadiya") were arrested with 9 others but then mysteriously disappeared. Mo and Gloves have not been seen since.

According to Occupy Chicago activists, Mo and Gloves took part in various organizing efforts over the past few weeks. Mo was arrested during an action on April 17th at 63rd & Woodlawn to protest the closure of a mental health clinic. The so-called NATO 3 (Jared Chase, Brent Betterly, and Brian Jacob Church), who came to Chicago from Florida, were befriended by Mo and Gloves and were likely sought out by the informants because of the out-of-town activists' unfamiliarity with local Occupy Chicago organizers.

Although the State's Attorney has not made any connections between the NATO 3 and two additional protesters with terrorism-related charges, the common thread between all of the cases is the involvement of Mo and Gloves.
"""

Source: Occupy Chicago Press Relations facebook page.
 
Last edited:
"""PRESS RELEASE
For Immediate Release: May 22, 2012

Occupy Chicago Releases Additional Photos of Both Suspected Police Informants Involved in NATO Terrorism-Related Cases

Chicago, IL -- Occupy Chicago has obtained photographs of suspected police informants, who according to witnesses and arrestees were part of a law enforcement operation, which has resulted in the prosecution of 5 NATO protesters on terrorism-related charges. The city has yet to admit to using infiltrators in the Wednesday night raid on a Bridgeport home of activists, but both suspected police informants who go by the names of "Mo" and "Gloves" (aka "Nadiya") were arrested with 9 others but then mysteriously disappeared. Mo and Gloves have not been seen since.

According to Occupy Chicago activists, Mo and Gloves took part in various organizing efforts over the past few weeks. Mo was arrested during an action on April 17th at 63rd & Woodlawn to protest the closure of a mental health clinic. The so-called NATO 3 (Jared Chase, Brent Betterly, and Brian Jacob Church), who came to Chicago from Florida, were befriended by Mo and Gloves and were likely sought out by the informants because of the out-of-town activists' unfamiliarity with local Occupy Chicago organizers.

Although the State's Attorney has not made any connections between the NATO 3 and two additional protesters with terrorism-related charges, the common thread between all of the cases is the involvement of Mo and Gloves.
"""

Source: Occupy Chicago Press Relations facebook page.

By the way, your comment that 00063's comment was limited to "to donut danglers in Montreal" appears to be bull ****. he was also referring to your article about Empire Blah blah in Chicago.

In any event, you have not contradicted a thing I have said about provoking the cops in Chicago, which is smart because I was there.

/Occupy Chicago Press Relations are carrying water for Black Bloc douchebags? I don't believe it. Sounds like they are trying to distance themselves from them. If not, their loss.

The Black Bloc gutter punks in Chicago were uniformly detested by the rank and file protesters.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom