Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mostly raising awareness via protests, etc.

If Occupy (whatever) is raising awareness of what you want to do, why am I (and others, I'm certainly not the only one) having to ask?

I was aware of Citizens United and the arguments on both sides of the issue before Occupy (whatever) existed. Occupy (whatever) has not, to my knowledge, spent much time arguing against Citizens United. Now, I understand the fact that I haven't seen it doesn't mean it hasn't happened. But it also means that Occupy (whatever)'s tactics have been largely ineffective in transmitting knowledge about any actual, concrete goals they may have.

Saying "I'm mad as hell and I'm not going to take it any more!" works well only if you have the script writer on your side. In the real world, not so much.
 
Money is not free speech.
The ability to publish is free speech, whether you like it or not.

It hasn't been seen as such since our country was founded until recently.
100% false. Would you have gone after Ben Franklin for publishing political commentary?

And you do realize that Citizens United did not declare money to be free speech? What exactly is your objection to that ruling? Have you ever read it?
 
Coordinating with Tea Partiers, for one:

http://news.yahoo.com/occupy-memphis-tea-party-members-meet-084306417.html

Honestly, we're still partly in the "diagnosis" phase of coming up with a plan to fix this mess. The people have to first agree on what's going on, what has gone wrong, etc before we can formulate a workable, effective remedy.

Honestly, this parses to me like "No, we don't have a plan, but we're going to protest anyway, because we're sure that whatever the plan is, it will involve us protesting."
 
Money is not free speech. It hasn't been seen as such since our country was founded until recently.

You have it exactly backwards. It's the idea that spending on political speech can be regulated which is recent. Nobody used to think it was a problem that pamphleteers could print as many pamphlets as they wanted.
 
You have it exactly backwards. It's the idea that spending on political speech can be regulated which is recent. Nobody used to think it was a problem that pamphleteers could print as many pamphlets as they wanted.

Are you a cop?
 
Honestly, this parses to me like "No, we don't have a plan, but we're going to protest anyway, because we're sure that whatever the plan is, it will involve us protesting."

As far as I can tell, the Occupy Memphis movement that kellyb co-founded doesn't even have any protests planned. In reply to my repeated requests for details about Occupy Memphis's plan of action, she's gone so far as to say there's a mellow campsite and a garbage-collection detail. There is also apparently some amount of "coordinating" with unions and Tea Partiers, I think, as well as some amount of keeping track of what Occupy Wall Street is up to. But no protesting at the moment, and apparently none planned for the future.
 
As far as I can tell, the Occupy Memphis movement that kellyb co-founded doesn't even have any protests planned. In reply to my repeated requests for details about Occupy Memphis's plan of action, she's gone so far as to say there's a mellow campsite and a garbage-collection detail. There is also apparently some amount of "coordinating" with unions and Tea Partiers, I think, as well as some amount of keeping track of what Occupy Wall Street is up to. But no protesting at the moment, and apparently none planned for the future.

Judging from their website their primary agendas are to not understand what they are talking about and to force other people to employ them.
 
No such idle protestors here in SF. A couple hundred occupiers are in the midst of a day of action, where they annoyed shoppers and tourists at Union Square (an upscale shopping district) and are now taking over an abandoned building in the Western Addition, a poor / working class neighborhood.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2012/04/01/BAP11NTE3K.DTL

This building must be better than the one the city offered to them last year, free of charge, for the exact same reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom