Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
Amusing photo essay on the Portland Occugenuises.

Scroll down to see the gal wearing some sort of mink stole--and a gas mask! Not to be missed. Also love the one three down with the anarchists carrying a banner saying "A better world is possible" followed by the hammer and sickle. Nothing incompatible with anarchy and communism, apparently.
 
Last edited:
I've been hunting for this particular blog entry for a while, since it best encapsulates what I've been hearing, and remember, this was written by a supporter.

What do the Wall St occupiers want?

The Occupy Wall St movement is doing an admirable job of galvanizing people from around the world, but it's struggling. Unless it changes direction it's doomed and within a matter of weeks it will begin fizzing out towards an inglorious and anticlimactic end.


Why? One reason: It has no obvious set of demands. Despite being modelled on the Arab Spring, the Arab movement is a completely different ballgame because the protesters know exactly what they want and so does everyone else. Their demands are simple, clear and obvious – their leaders should stand down and hold democratic elections. Anyone can understand that and everyone knows what needs to happen.
http://blog.dave.co.nz/2011/10/what-do-wall-st-occupiers-want.html
 
I've been hunting for this particular blog entry for a while, since it best encapsulates what I've been hearing, and remember, this was written by a supporter.

http://blog.dave.co.nz/2011/10/what-do-wall-st-occupiers-want.html

That's a good blog entry. I'll add another quote:

I visited occupywallst.org, scrolled down the entire home page and couldn't see a single clear demand for anything. All I saw was advice on how to be a nuisance, and a bunch of complaints about the economy that are so vague it's just noise. This is worse than pointless, it makes the protesters look like a motley gathering of whiners who can't decide what they want.

I probably don't agree with him in a whole lot of questions, but it was an intelligently written piece by a critical thinker -- i.e. a guy who can take a critical look at people on his side of the fence. A good illustration of the difference between an OWS supporter and an Occutard.
 
Speaking of how the protesters look, it doesn't help when some people hijack the cause to promote their own agendas such as drug law reform. Although I'm inclined to agree with those of you asking for such reform, please take those issues elsewhere and don't taint the Occupy movement. Remember, not all the occupiers agree with you and it's not fair to make it seem that they do.
Hijacking a movement with no clear agenda, and being denounced as not really Occupiers?
 
How can you hijack something that isn't going anywhere in the first place?

It has been observed, throughout this thread, that what makes a real Occupier is whatever any given Occupier says it is. There is no objective criteria for what makes an Occupier, and they are oft all too willing to denounce their fellows the second they do something embarrassing.

http://www.portlandoccupier.org/2011/11/04/
http://dailycaller.com/2012/01/30/i...cupiers-really-are-kind-of-violent-and-stuff/
A friend of mine immediately and shrilly complained that the "real" OWS people didn't start out like this and that the OWS movement was "hijacked" by these others that are being violent.

Read more: http://dailycaller.com/2012/01/30/i...-are-kind-of-violent-and-stuff/#ixzz1oFzG6nns
http://minx.cc/?post=326763

Warning; some of those posts are very far-Right.
 
Three (not true) Occupy Oakland protesters charged with hate crimes. Apparently when a woman asked them to not riot in her neighborhood they just decided to rob and insult her instead.

Of course, the three (not true) Occupy Oakland protesters are not at fault - It's the eeeeeeeeeevil police framing them. Because they're occutards, apparently.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2012/03/05/BAAS1NGGI6.DTL&type=newsbayarea

It really doesn't get any better than this.
 
Those movements were popular. OWS is the lunatic fringe.
Those movements had an easily identified goal.
Occupy is more like the people who think they have a psychic power and want to apply for the million dollar challenge. They honestly think they have a point, but when you try to nail down what the point is, they squirm all over, complaining continuously.
 
Those movements had an easily identified goal.
Occupy is more like the people who think they have a psychic power and want to apply for the million dollar challenge. They honestly think they have a point, but when you try to nail down what the point is, they squirm all over, complaining continuously.

They want to overthrow capitalism and replace it with stupid stuff. They're open about it when they discuss it amongst themselves.
 
That may be so, but the women's and civil rights movement had some idea of what the result of the changes they wanted to make should look like. Occupy is all over the map.
It's as though children have broken into a workshop, and have found all these nice sharp tools for social change. So they're using the tools, just as a child might try out a saw on a table. Some of them are pretending they're building a boat, and some are pretending they're building furniture. And of course whatever they're pretending to build, it's going to be the bestest one ever!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom