Merged NYT: reaction to PDB reflected significantly more negligence than has been disclosed"

Lenbrazil

Muse
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Messages
974
NYT: reaction to PDB reflected significantly more negligence than has been disclosed"

September 10, 2012
The Deafness Before the Storm
By KURT EICHENWALD

IT was perhaps the most famous presidential briefing in history.

On Aug. 6, 2001, President George W. Bush received a classified review of the threats posed by Osama bin Laden and his terrorist network, Al Qaeda. That morning’s “presidential daily brief” — the top-secret document prepared by America’s intelligence agencies — featured the now-infamous heading: “Bin Laden Determined to Strike in U.S.” A few weeks later, on 9/11, Al Qaeda accomplished that goal.

On April 10, 2004, the Bush White House declassified that daily brief — and only that daily brief — in response to pressure from the 9/11 Commission, which was investigating the events leading to the attack. Administration officials dismissed the document’s significance, saying that, despite the jaw-dropping headline, it was only an assessment of Al Qaeda’s history, not a warning of the impending attack. While some critics considered that claim absurd, a close reading of the brief showed that the argument had some validity.

That is, unless it was read in conjunction with the daily briefs preceding Aug. 6, the ones the Bush administration would not release. While those documents are still not public, I have read excerpts from many of them, along with other recently declassified records, and come to an inescapable conclusion: the administration’s reaction to what Mr. Bush was told in the weeks before that infamous briefing reflected significantly more negligence than has been disclosed. In other words, the Aug. 6 document, for all of the controversy it provoked, is not nearly as shocking as the briefs that came before it.

[...]

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/11/opinion/the-bush-white-house-was-deaf-to-9-11-warnings.html

See also:

http://news.yahoo.com/bush-knew-more-bin-ladens-plans-realized-040141177.html

NOTE TO MODS: There should be a quotation mark between 'PDB' and 'reflected'
 
Last edited:
Seems to reinforce the notion of gross incompetence, negligence, arrogance, and sense of invulnerability which existed in the minds of the people charged to protect the US against foreign threats like OSB and Al Qaeda.
 
Hindsight may be 20 / 20, but single - minded focus on one perceived threat instead of a real one is blindness.

I've seen Bush administration defenders respond to this article saying that there was insufficient actionable intelligence, or that the Clinton administration didn't do enough. It all strikes me as whitewashing. Monday morning quarterbacking has earned its bad reputation, and yet I wonder still what a non - dismissive attitude, elevation of the threat level and doubled efforts of data fusion would have done. The stonewalling and evidence dismissal at lower levels prior to 9 / 11 may just be a reflection of the lack of concern higher up.

I guess we will never know what would have happened, but I would think a different attitude would have changed the probabilities.
 
Last edited:
Seems to reinforce the notion of gross incompetence, negligence, arrogance, and sense of invulnerability which existed in the minds of the people charged to protect the US against foreign threats like OSB and Al Qaeda.

Fine, then let's call it what it is, a conspiracy. Because if members of the Bush admin neglected to act on specific intel and then worked to cover it up, this is at the minimum a massive conspiracy.

Of course, you'd have to ignore a whole set of obvious questions that begin with, why? Why would the Bush admin so actively protect the Saudis? Why didn't Bush take any of the intel seriously?

It's bad for the jreffers because what was once the realm of goofy twoofies is becoming accepted journalistic reporting. Perhaps, enough time has passed that the emotional sensitivity is wearing off and actual journalism can take place.
 
Fine, then let's call it what it is, a conspiracy. Because if members of the Bush admin neglected to act on specific intel and then worked to cover it up, this is at the minimum a massive conspiracy.

Of course, you'd have to ignore a whole set of obvious questions that begin with, why? Why would the Bush admin so actively protect the Saudis? Why didn't Bush take any of the intel seriously?

It's bad for the jreffers because what was once the realm of goofy twoofies is becoming accepted journalistic reporting. Perhaps, enough time has passed that the emotional sensitivity is wearing off and actual journalism can take place.

Wrong truthers try to equate any question of the narrative told by the 9/11 Commission or even the one originally pushed by the Bush assministration with there views, this is absurd.

CYA is not LIHOP and Eichewald never suggested the neocons were behind the attacks or that they intentionally allowed the attacks to happen. What he did not address is what exactly Bush et. al. could have done. As LSSBB noted this is essentially unknowable.
 
Fine, then let's call it what it is, a conspiracy. Because if members of the Bush admin neglected to act on specific intel and then worked to cover it up, this is at the minimum a massive conspiracy.

Of course, you'd have to ignore a whole set of obvious questions that begin with, why? Why would the Bush admin so actively protect the Saudis? Why didn't Bush take any of the intel seriously?

It's bad for the jreffers because what was once the realm of goofy twoofies is becoming accepted journalistic reporting. Perhaps, enough time has passed that the emotional sensitivity is wearing off and actual journalism can take place.

The only conspiracy we have evidence of wasn't even a true conspiracy, since it wasn't very hidden. It was the drive to take down Saddam. 9/11 was planned and executed while the Bush administration had it's eyes on that Saddam prize. Why do you think after 9/11 they wondered how they could take advantage of the opportunity in order to push the case for Iraq.

9/11 Truth: obscuring the real issues and chasing ghosts for 11 years. Congratulations!
 
Fine, then let's call it what it is, a conspiracy. Because if members of the Bush admin neglected to act on specific intel and then worked to cover it up, this is at the minimum a massive conspiracy.

No, it's incompetent people covering their rears. Even if it is a conspiracy, it's one of incompetence, not malice. Such as a guy making an incorrect statement and refusing to acknowledge, ever, that he was wrong.

I am referring to Ergo's "moon-sized rubble field", of course.

Of course, you'd have to ignore a whole set of obvious questions that begin with, why? Why would the Bush admin so actively protect the Saudis? Why didn't Bush take any of the intel seriously?

I think you mean the CIA and FBI. I mean, I had a Time magazine from January of that year that said that Osama was probably planning an attack.

It's bad for the jreffers because what was once the realm of goofy twoofies is becoming accepted journalistic reporting. Perhaps, enough time has passed that the emotional sensitivity is wearing off and actual journalism can take place.
Yes, because none of the debunkers here have pointed out the lack of accountability and butt-covering on multiple occasions, and even specifically recommended books that address those issues.
 
Yes, because none of the debunkers here have pointed out the lack of accountability and butt-covering on multiple occasions, and even specifically recommended books that address those issues.

I read a lot of posturing and cowardly defense of those who were criminally negligent. I don't see too many debunkers holding anyone accountable, and I'd like to see your list of recommended books that addresses this.
 
I read a lot of posturing and cowardly defense of those who were criminally negligent. I don't see too many debunkers holding anyone accountable, and I'd like to see your list of recommended books that addresses this.

I first watched loose change thinking it was about CYAing or at most LIHOP (even though I didn't know the term). I HATED Bush. I would have loved anything that might have got him in trouble. Instead, I watched that bunk and recognized it as such immediately, without knowing anything about MIHOP theories at the time.
 
I read a lot of posturing and cowardly defense of those who were criminally negligent.

So far, I've haven't seen anyone make a case for criminal negligence (for anyone).

I suspect your level of evidence is on par for this case as it was for Larry Silverstein, "making out like a bandit"? ;)
 
Last edited:
opinion/the-bush-white-house-was-deaf-to-9-11-warnings.html, Opinion. Wonder if this is an election year.

Did anyone else get the same information? Congress? Anyone else? Opinion - not very much info in those political stories, with some history mixed in for effect. Good for the political forum, not much to do with 911 CT crazy claims.

Then Yahoo news? Yahoo! Why did they hold these stories for 9/11? Was that yahoo? News, all the news, even if we have to go back to 2004; yahoo

Bush Knew More About Bin Laden's Plans Than We Realized
I knew in the 90s UBL was planning to kill Americans. These op-ed guys are slow, or stupid; both?

Is there going to be another book?

Yes, there is a book, $$$
. Follow the money, and you find the "truth".

This is funny stuff - capitalism mixed with politics and what if stuff. Marketing 101, or what?
 
Last edited:
I read a lot of posturing and cowardly defense of those who were criminally negligent. I don't see too many debunkers holding anyone accountable, and I'd like to see your list of recommended books that addresses this.

IMO, your "made out like a bandit" discussion, and all it implies, makes it appear as if you couldn't tell "criminally negligent" if it bit you in the nether regions
 
I read a lot of posturing and cowardly defense of those who were criminally negligent. I don't see too many debunkers holding anyone accountable, and I'd like to see your list of recommended books that addresses this.
I never said I had any books, though I hear "The Looming Tower" being bandied about by the people I refer to. I haven't read it myself.

Literally the first reply in this very thread addresses the gov't's incompetence. And the second reply as well. Then your post. There is a difference between MIHOP, LIHOP, and just being bad at their jobs.

You have not demonstrated the administration's criminal negligence, not in any post I recall reading. But you implied that all JREFers were reluctant to address the CYA aspects. Except several have done precisely that. Just about any time PaloAlto posts one of his ridiculous screeds, in fact. Come to think, you never actually claimed you saw debunkers defending criminally negligent people, or that debunkers do not hold the USG accountable for dropping the ball. I mean, you could always start a poll and ask.
 
This thread has 12 replies.
1 by RedIbis
7 replying to RedIbis, not the OP.

Why don't posters respond to the OP first?
 
opinion/the-bush-white-house-was-deaf-to-9-11-warnings.html, Opinion. Wonder if this is an election year.

Did anyone else get the same information? Congress? Anyone else? Opinion - not very much info in those political stories, with some history mixed in for effect. Good for the political forum, not much to do with 911 CT crazy claims.

Then Yahoo news? Yahoo! Why did they hold these stories for 9/11? Was that yahoo? News, all the news, even if we have to go back to 2004; yahoo


I knew in the 90s UBL was planning to kill Americans. These op-ed guys are slow, or stupid; both?

Is there going to be another book?

Yes, there is a book, $$$ . Follow the money, and you find the "truth".

This is funny stuff - capitalism mixed with politics and what if stuff. Marketing 101, or what?

Perhaps I'm misreading you but you come across as a diehard Bush Jr. partisan unwilling to admit he or his advisors could have been the least bit negligent regarding 9/11.

Why would this be an election year issue? Other than being from the same party there is little to tie Romney to Baby Doc & Co.

Yahoo didn't 'hold' anything they reported on the Op-Ed on 9/10/12 because that's the day it came out, the linked 2004 WP story was relevant.
 
September 10, 2012
The Deafness Before the Storm
By KURT EICHENWALD

IT was perhaps the most famous presidential briefing in history.

On Aug. 6, 2001, President George W. Bush received a classified review of the threats posed by Osama bin Laden and his terrorist network, Al Qaeda. That morning’s “presidential daily brief” — the top-secret document prepared by America’s intelligence agencies — featured the now-infamous heading: “Bin Laden Determined to Strike in U.S.” A few weeks later, on 9/11, Al Qaeda accomplished that goal.

On April 10, 2004, the Bush White House declassified that daily brief — and only that daily brief — in response to pressure from the 9/11 Commission, which was investigating the events leading to the attack. Administration officials dismissed the document’s significance, saying that, despite the jaw-dropping headline, it was only an assessment of Al Qaeda’s history, not a warning of the impending attack. While some critics considered that claim absurd, a close reading of the brief showed that the argument had some validity.

That is, unless it was read in conjunction with the daily briefs preceding Aug. 6, the ones the Bush administration would not release. While those documents are still not public, I have read excerpts from many of them, along with other recently declassified records, and come to an inescapable conclusion: the administration’s reaction to what Mr. Bush was told in the weeks before that infamous briefing reflected significantly more negligence than has been disclosed. In other words, the Aug. 6 document, for all of the controversy it provoked, is not nearly as shocking as the briefs that came before it.

[...]

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/11/opinion/the-bush-white-house-was-deaf-to-9-11-warnings.html

See also:

http://news.yahoo.com/bush-knew-more-bin-ladens-plans-realized-040141177.html

NOTE TO MODS: There should be a quotation mark between 'PDB' and 'reflected'

I read the NYT article and am still left with the same questions I have had since information began to come out about the events leading up to that terrible day.

Supposing the Bush admin had taken seriously (I think it's pretty obvious that they did not) the vague and non-specific warnings they were receiving, what is it that people think they could have done to prevent the attacks? Should they have rounded up all young males of Middle-Eastern origin who were attending flight schools in the US and deported them immediately? Locked down air travel entirely? Water-boarded Moussaoui until he spilled the beans on what he knew?

Make no mistake, I do not believe that those events were destined to happen. IIRC, at the time air travelers were allowed to bring knives on board with blades up to 4" and mace. It seems to me that restricting such items, while it wouldn't have guaranteed they would have been stopped, definitely would have made it tougher for them to achieve their goals. But that is easy to say in hindsight. Before that day, few if any at all could have imagined what such simple devices could enable 19 hate-filled men to accomplish.

I am familiar with more than a few LIHOP and MIHOP claims and given the evidence we have to this point, find all of them to be lacking in credibility. As for CYA? Of course there was, if people can be counted on for one thing, it is is to bunker down and try avoid being the one left holding the bag when the crap hits the fan. It doesn't make it right, but it isn't surprising to me at all. Now, if smoking gun evidence comes out of them having ignored specific threats then I obviously will have to rethink my conclusions on such things, though I don't believe such evidence exists.

In the end, as I see it we failed to prevent the events of 9/11 because of what is both our greatest strength and our most easily exploited weakness here in the U.S.: Our freedom. The monsters who carried out those attacks knew this and exploited it to our eternal sorrow. I just hope in our desire to protect ourselves we don't wake up one day and realize we gave away that freedom because then they will have truly defeated us.
 
While it is accepted that there is practically no way to prevent all terrorist attacks(if there were then Israel and Northern Ireland would be rather peaceful places all the time)
there is also a reason for these briefings. Obviously the purpose is to attempt to head off such attacks as much as possible. The Bush administration seemed fixated on other issues and unwilling to devote time, energy and resources to anything outside their pet projects. All other considerations were pushed to the side. One such fixation it seems was GWB's desire to finish his Daddy's work in Iraq and have that be his legacy and to that end he surrounded himself with others who shared his desire in that regard.

This is an all too common theme in high office whether it be political or in private enterprise, and most of the time the organization manages through it until such time as that fixation is complete or subsides. However, occassionally it brings great calamity upon the organization and the people within it.
In the case of 9/11/01 the people of Manhattan and those in the planes and the Pentagon paid the price for such single sightedness.
In the case of Wall Street and the mortgage trading that saw only paper profit as the driving fixation, the whole world's middle classes paid the price.

Is this incompetance, I say yes. When the shinola hits the fan and the piper comes to collact payment do these people begin a campaign of CYA and pointing fingers away from themselves,,, ohhh you betcha.

Is that a conspiracy? Yes, a conspiracy to deflect blame and in this case, 9/11/01, that conspiracy has absolutely nothing in common with the alledged conspiracies that RedIbis and like minded people would have us believe in. It fits into neither the so called MIHOP, or the LIHOP scenarios. It is a It-Happened,-Must-Deflect-Blame, a rather unwieldy acronym of IHMDB

or perhaps OMG-MDB (Oh My God-Must Deflect Blame)
or perhaps COAN (Cover Our Ass Now)
 
One of the problems with LIHOP is that all CYA seems to have only begun after 9/11/01, when one would think that some sort of campaign to do so, as the plot unfolded over months prior to autumn 2001, would have been implemented.
 
We can always guess at what could have been done (yes, there were things that could have been done), and what impact preventative actions may have had. However, we will never know, because no actions were taken - the response was completely passive.

If the leader doesn't think its important enough to take any action, how will his followers take it?
 
Governments exist to protect their citizens from disasters. When they fail, disasters happen. End of argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom