NY Governor Patterson wants to nominate a woman to the Senate

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
According to NY1...he likes the idea because "women are underrepresented in the Senate".

I hear Pagans, Wiccans, Bahais, and Shintos are also not well represented in the Senate. Why not nominate one of them?

The politics of race and gender is very stupid.
 
One would hope that nominating a qualified, competent individual who will faithfully and intelligently represent the state of New York would be a higher priority.
 
One would hope that nominating a qualified, competent individual who will faithfully and intelligently represent the state of New York would be a higher priority.

I guess there's a first time for everything.
 
No, he isn't.

... Yes, yes he is.

The debate about female/black/what-have-you representation in the government has to do with whether it is proportionate to the number in the general populace. Even if you totaled the numbers of all the groups he mentioned, it would still be less than one half of one percent of the general populace. As such, it really has nothing to do with anything.
 
One would hope that nominating a qualified, competent individual who will faithfully and intelligently represent the state of New York would be a higher priority.

Which is what he said in an interview last night. Any discussion on his choice is pure speculation........but anyway.

One thing he did say was troubling him was the fact less than 38% congress members selected by governors have failed to win a popular vote at the next election. He went on to say that who ever he chooses will go to the people in less than 18 months, so in his eyes even if he makes a poor choice, the people will fix it pretty soon
 
So why is he taking so long? Blago named his senator quite some time ago.

He said he didn't want to get in the way of the incomming new president, and will be naming the person in the next few days
 
Let me just say that I agree with this sentiment. The voters of New York voted, and the person they voted for was a liberal woman with interesting ideas and a high profile.

He should try to fit their intentions as best as possible in selecting Hillary's replacement. Women are underrepresnted in the Senate, and the Governor cannot overlook the possibility that one of the things that got her elected was her gender.

As for "being female" the same as "being Shinto..." No. Just no. This statement is stupid.
 
Let me just say that I agree with this sentiment. The voters of New York voted, and the person they voted for was a liberal woman with interesting ideas and a high profile.

So I can put you down for the Fran Dreschir camp?

He should try to fit their intentions as best as possible in selecting Hillary's replacement. Women are underrepresnted in the Senate, and the Governor cannot overlook the possibility that one of the things that got her elected was her gender.

Or the even greater possibility that what got her elected was her last name. The standard seems to be a liberal woman with a famous name. So...still Fran Dreschir?
 
So I can put you down for the Fran Dreschir camp?

Or the even greater possibility that what got her elected was her last name. The standard seems to be a liberal woman with a famous name. So...still Fran Dreschir?

Your man, he is built of straw. Alas your torch is wet, you cannot even successfully set him ablaze. Languish, and hope a fortuitous strike of inspiration, like lightning ,might at last ignite your pitiful effigy. You will not be right. But at least then you will be warm.
 
Last edited:
Your man, he is built of straw. Alas your torch is wet, you cannot even successfully set him ablaze. Languish, and hope a fortuitous strike of inspiration, like lightning ,might at last ignite your pitiful effigy. You will not be right. But at least then you will be warm.

At least you had the good sense not to even try and defend your earlier statements.
 
At least you had the good sense not to even try and defend your earlier statements.

I'll defend them when you post some criticism of them. As far as I can tell, your post was a simple tribute to a woman you have a deep infatuation with, and at best tangentally related to the thread topic.

Do you actually have a relevant objection to the concept that a Governor should attempt to follow, as best as possible, the will of the people when nominating a replacement?

Do you actually have an objection to the idea that Hillary being a woman may have been a factor in the votes of New York citizens?

Do you actually have an objection to the idea that women are treated differently by society than men, and that therefore a firsthand perspective on that difference is valuable?

Or do you just have a crush on Frau Dreschir?
 
As far as I can tell, your post was a simple tribute to a woman you have a deep infatuation with,

I'm going to have to stop you there and ask whether or not you've ever actually heard Fran Dreschir's voice? I assure you, I have no such infatuation.

and at best tangentally related to the thread topic.

No, she serves as a satire. But I'll let you continue.

Do you actually have a relevant objection to the concept that a Governor should attempt to follow, as best as possible, the will of the people when nominating a replacement?

Yes, considering that most of the polls put Cuomo ahead of Kennedy in public opinion. This would seem to upset your rather poorly articulated statement that by virtue of the fact that her predecessor was a woman, Caroline Kennedy is the choice of the New York people.

Do you actually have an objection to the idea that Hillary being a woman may have been a factor in the votes of New York citizens?

I have no idea. I'm sure it mattered to some people, but, as I've all ready stated, the polls seems to disagree that the people want a woman for the sake of having a woman.

Do you actually have an objection to the idea that women are treated differently by society than men, and that therefore a firsthand perspective on that difference is valuable?

Mostly irrelevant, as implicit here is the idea that a man cannot represent the interests of women. As was stated earlier, a Muslim would have a firsthand perspective on differences in treatment for Muslim Americans. A homosexual would have a firsthand perspective on the treatment of homosexuals. The questions is not on what perspective a person will have, but if that person will faithfully and intelligently represent the interests of that state.

Or do you just have a crush on Frau Dreschir?

So you resort to ad hominems then?
 
What is wrong with Pagans? Yes, they ARE underrepresented. (Except I know of one closeted pagan who was in the House in the 90s.)

But Pagans are about 3% of the population.

FAR less than the proportion of women in the population, which last I looked, was more than 50%.

And so the disparity is less glaringly obvious in the case of Pagans.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom