"Not Ever" - A Campaign Against Blaming Rape Victims

With regard to this "I never undestood this. Take crossing the road in a green light. You learn to look both ways regardless. Is that "blaming the victim" of road accidents?".

Advising someone to look both ways is good road safety. It is not victim blaming.

The police asking a road accident victim who has been knocked down by a car if the looked both ways, is part of the enquiry into the cause and responsibility for the accident. It could be victim blaming depending on how fault is being attributed.

The motorist asking and suggesting it passes fault onto the victim, is victim blaming.

I think context determines if something is good advice or victim blaming.
 
With regard to this "I never undestood this. Take crossing the road in a green light. You learn to look both ways regardless. Is that "blaming the victim" of road accidents?".

Advising someone to look both ways is good road safety. It is not victim blaming.

I agree, it should be common sense. These days, though, it seems that most of the pedertrians I encounter look neither left nor right before crossing, but down -- at their phone.

/oldmanmode.

ETA: Sorry for the offtopic post.
 
I can sympathize maybe a bit with the "the victim had some responsibility here" way of thinking. If you are walking through a bad neighborhood flashing a wad of cash and you get jumped, well... you had a hand in provoking that outcome. It doesn't make you primarily responsible, but as theprestige is fond of saying, you sometimes have to mean for things NOT to happen. Cops aren't allowed to set up irresistible bait for criminals in some interpretations either (entrapment and all that). In a perfect world, no means no, no matter when you decide no, but you sometimes have to say no proactively if you want to keep the bad guys at bay.
 
Last edited:
Cops aren't allowed to set up irresistible bait for criminals in some interpretations
That's right. Woman should realize that having two X chromosomes makes them irresistible to men, who then can't stop themselves from raping.

You might think that all a woman must do to lessen the chances of being raped is make herself look unattractive and avoid men, and you would be right.

Numerous studies have shown that attractive women are more likely to be raped (no cite, just take my word for it). There are many ways women can make themselves look unattractive, but the easiest is to wear a Burqa. This has been proven very affective in preventing rape in countries like Afghanistan (where there were only 21 reported rapes in 2025). Unfortunately some countries have unwisely banned the burqa, including Cameroon, Chad, Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and France. In these countries the next best thing - a Santa Claus outfit with fake beard and lots of padding - may suffice.

Staying way from men is also a very good idea. In the US ~51% of female victims reported being raped by an intimate partner and 41% by an acquaintance. The numbers don't lie - 92% of female rapes are committed by a lover or 'friend'. The best way to avoid this is obvious - don't have any kind of relationship with a man. Women who must have a relationship should wait until they are older. 80% of reported female victims were first raped before they reached 25, while those aged 65 and over are 92% less likely to report being raped.

This isn't victim blaming, it's just common sense. All men are potential rapists and may not be able to control themselves around women. We shouldn't blame them for that either - it's not their fault that millions of years of evolution selected for rapists.
 
I can sympathize maybe a bit with the "the victim had some responsibility here" way of thinking. If you are walking through a bad neighborhood flashing a wad of cash and you get jumped, well... you had a hand in provoking that outcome. It doesn't make you primarily responsible, but as theprestige is fond of saying, you sometimes have to mean for things NOT to happen. Cops aren't allowed to set up irresistible bait for criminals in some interpretations either (entrapment and all that). In a perfect world, no means no, no matter when you decide no, but you sometimes have to say no proactively if you want to keep the bad guys at bay.
Can you think of some ways in which being a woman is not like flashig a wad of cash, perhaps?

 
I can sympathize maybe a bit with the "the victim had some responsibility here" way of thinking. If you are walking through a bad neighborhood flashing a wad of cash and you get jumped, well... you had a hand in provoking that outcome. It doesn't make you primarily responsible, but as theprestige is fond of saying, you sometimes have to mean for things NOT to happen. Cops aren't allowed to set up irresistible bait for criminals in some interpretations either (entrapment and all that). In a perfect world, no means no, no matter when you decide no, but you sometimes have to say no proactively if you want to keep the bad guys at bay.

I agree that at times victims have to carry some responsibility for what they did. Leave your house unlocked in a high crime area with lost of thieves, is not a good idea and may affect your insurance pay out. Get injured in a car crash that was in part due to your excessive speeding and you may not get compensation.

There are times when claims about responsibility are nonsense, such as what a woman wears on a night out.
 
Can you think of some ways in which being a woman is not like flashig a wad of cash, perhaps?
I can think of many. Why do you ask?
That's both a super weird 'art exhibition', and starts off with a severely flawed premise that it uses to justify the 'art'.

It says “What were you wearing?” — as if their clothing determines consent." No no no, a thousand times no. The issue is not a mistake, where clothing implies consent. It might be attracting predators, though, which is not a good idea if you dont want to get victimized. Your attire can also signal "I'm looking to get boned". Crude way of putting it, but that's a legit concern if you are not trying to attract a predator. Again, "No Means No" is an absolute, full stop. That works fine with civilized people, but some mother ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ ain't civilized, and sometimes you have to take preventative action to ward off the uncivilized.

This was on my mind when the thread resurfaced because I had the unusual experience of being on the streets and using public transportation in Philadelphia in the middle of the night on Halloween. I'm glad it was a warm night, because the dozens of young ladies I saw would otherwise have succumbed to hypothermia. I'm not talking about cheeky costumes- I'm talking full bare ass and much much more on public display. And they were with 1-3 similarly un-attired young women (no guys with them), and not one was in any position to run (stilletos), fend off an attacker, and certainly didn't have enough clothing to conceal a pair of nail clippers, much less a defensive weapon. As I kept my eyes politely occupied elsewhere, I was seriously worried about what kind of night these young ladies were in for.

I mean, I think and act defensively all the time, because I don't rely on random strangers having acceptable behavioral standards, and I don't get victimized. This whole thing about "I'm going to stand in front of you essentially naked and you have to act like nothing is out of the ordinary" is just so... I dunno, naive maybe? You have to be proactive sometimes.
 
Or just being a woman, which is what most rape victims are guilty of. The husses!
Right, in the vast majority of assaults (I believe), the woman has no blame at all. They had the misfortune of crossing paths with a low life at the wrong time. It could happen to anybody.
 
Or just being a woman, which is what most rape victims are guilty of. The husses!
Indeed.
I can think of many. Why do you ask?

That's both a super weird 'art exhibition', and starts off with a severely flawed premise that it uses to justify the 'art'.

It says “What were you wearing?” — ...snip....
That works fine with civilized people, but some mother ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ ain't civilized, and sometimes you have to take preventative action to ward off the uncivilized.
...snip...
That is the type of reasoning given by some people who believe women should be completely covered if they have need to go outside the home. It really starts to be "what do you expect given what you were wearing?"

(I am sure that you don't mean that but that is how your reasoning above comes across.)
 
Indeed.

That is the type of reasoning given by some people who believe women should be completely covered if they have need to go outside the home. It really starts to be "what do you expect given what you were wearing?"

(I am sure that you don't mean that but that is how your reasoning above comes across.)
You're right, I don't mean that, and you're right, I know it sounds like that.
 
Most, if not all, women who are raped, attract predators by being women. What the women are wearing doesn't seem to matter much (there are many exhibits of what rape victims wore that make this clear). Women are raped, because they are women, and have the misfortune of meeting a predator. At home, or abroad, as it were. The same is true of all rape victims, ie men and children as well.

Just being a woman is the equivalent of flashig wads of cash. I know that you are not blaming the victims, btw. I just reacted to your choice of words, since we can never not "flash our cash".
 
Again - indeed.

It may be interesting to understand why there is a common thought that somehow how someone is dressed makes them more likely to be targeted for rape but I don't think there is evidence that it reflects how rapists target their victims.
 
The funny thing is, is that I'm not saying it's what they wear at all. The young women in Philly got me thinking about being vulnerable, specifically having no way to reasonably protect themselves or escape from/deflect unwanted attention, which they were absolutely drawing from half the guys in sight.
 
The "Cornell 7" case is an interesting dilemma.

From the victim's sworn statements when the case was originally investigated, it's clear that everything started out consensual. She was there willingly, she was very much interested in consummating a threesome, and she was very much a voluntary participant in the drugs-and-alcohol aspect of the party. I think this is why both the state prosecutor and the university originally decided to drop the case. It's hard to press for rape charges when the whole situation was debauched, and the victim herself clearly says that she was there for debauchery and willingly joined in that debauchery.

It also doesn't help that at several points in the first half of her sworn narrative, she says "no" to specific acts, and her refusals are respected by the men she's with.

It also doesn't help that her communications in the days immediately after she sobered up and had a chance to think things over, all indicate that she did not consider what happened that night to be rape. It seems like the rape narrative started to develop in tandem with the development of her reputation on campus as a legendary 304.

That said, it's also clear from her sworn statements that as the debauchery progressed, her "no" lost power, and her lack of enthusiasm for continuing went unnoticed. At some point, things went from consensual participant in debauchery to nonconsensual victim of depravity.



If you take advantage of someone who's too intoxicated to consent, that's rape.

If you take advantage of someone because both of you are too intoxicated to seek or get consent, is that also rape? Who's the rapist?

If you get together with friends, with the mutual agreement that you're all going to voluntarily get wasted and have sex, and at some point you all end up too wasted to keep having consensual sex, but keep having sex anyway, is it rape? At some point, does opting into a ketamine-fueled, blackout-drunk orgy cross the line from victim to accomplice? I kind of think it does.

It's one thing to get date-raped by a predator who catches you by surprise. I'm not sure you can get date-raped by a friend or acquaintance, where both of you agree to get high and have sex, and you both end up too high to keep checking for enthusiastic consent during the ongoing sexual encounter.
 
Last edited:
The "Cornell 7" case is an interesting dilemma.
While I get your point, I don't think it pans out in this example. The Wiki account says she consented to a threesome in a frat house (after being already both drunk and underage), then more guys started coming in, and sent out a mass text to the frat boys of "free p***y". That's how it ended up being the Cornell 7, not the Cornell 2 guys. She consented to two, but never agreed to be free-use to all comers, and it was too late by then for her to consent to anything. She agreed to getting lit up and getting her freak on with two specific guys, not the whole frat house in a train.
 
If you get together with friends, with the mutual agreement that you're all going to voluntarily get wasted and have sex, and at some point you all end up too wasted to keep having consensual sex, but keep having sex anyway, is it rape?
Yes, of course it's rape. I'm surprised you even have to ask that question.

But hey, let's go with it. If two guys get so wasted that one can't defend himself and the other gets angry and kills him, is it still murder?

Or what if two guys get wasted, and one decides he wants the other's leather jacket and 'asks' for it by kicking him to the ground and taking it, is it still robbery? 10 out of the 12 people on the jury said no, and blamed the victim for being drunk. Luckily two of us were able to convince the others that the thug was guilty.
 
That works fine with civilized people, but some mother ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ ain't civilized, and sometimes you have to take preventative action to ward off the uncivilized.
I know what you mean. I was assaulted once in the middle of town in broad daylight by a guy in a suit and tie. It caught me off-guard because I wasn't expecting it from someone who looked 'respectable'. I have since seen it happen to another person too. I now treat all 'suits' as potential thugs.

And they were with 1-3 similarly un-attired young women (no guys with them), and not one was in any position to run (stilletos), fend off an attacker, and certainly didn't have enough clothing to conceal a pair of nail clippers, much less a defensive weapon. As I kept my eyes politely occupied elsewhere, I was seriously worried about what kind of night these young ladies were in for.
I'm pretty sure that virtually nobody around here carries any 'defensive weapons' when they are in public. But there is strength in numbers, and I hear that stilletos can be quite effective when used skillfully.

What kind of society do you live in where people can expect to be attacked just for wearing a costume? Oh wait... this is America we are talking about. Now it makes perfect sense!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom