"Not Ever" - A Campaign Against Blaming Rape Victims

I just want to point out that most rapes aren't perpetrated by strangers, but by people the victims knows, and probably trusts.

And i definitely think that if you agree to sex, even sex which gets called "debauchery", with a friend, or friends, you haven't given some kind of carte blanche for anyone to do anything to you.

If I agree to give a friend a sum of money, I haven't agreed for them to call their friends to come and get half of what I own.
 
Just to set the record straight, cops are indeed permitted to 'set up irresistible bait'. It's only entrapment when they coerce or induce people into committing crimes.
Just to set the record straight, I said some. Your record setting was entirely unnecessary.
I know what you mean. I was assaulted once in the middle of town in broad daylight by a guy in a suit and tie.
I don't believe you.
It caught me off-guard because I wasn't expecting it from someone who looked 'respectable'.
You should take your personal safety more seriously.
I have since seen it happen to another person too. I now treat all 'suits' as potential thugs.
You should. Or at least, be aware of who can do any kind of damage to you at any time.
I'm pretty sure that virtually nobody around here carries any 'defensive weapons' when they are in public.
Most dont here, either. But if you are walking around naked in a city with a high violent crime rate in the middle of the night, it might be a good time to consider in advance what you plan to do if things don't go your way.
But there is strength in numbers
There is. Two to four naked young women against the City of Brotherly Love is some powerful strength, too. Maybe not in the way you assume, but there you go.
, and I hear that stilletos can be quite effective when used skillfully.

What kind of society do you live in where people can expect to be attacked just for wearing a costume? Oh wait... this is America we are talking about. Now it makes perfect sense!
I believe you live in New Zealand, and just above, you claimed you were attacked, and presumably didn't have a costume on? You might want to choose one bull ◊◊◊◊ version and stick with it.

The young women would not be attacked for wearing a costume on Halloween. No idea why you would make such a connection. They might be attacked because they were exceptionally vulnerable and already undressed in a particularly criminal infested area.

And that's kind of what we are talking about. If you make yourself ridiculously vulnerable to attack, do you bear any responsibility for that? Legally, no. But as a matter of simply being outrageously and electively stupid? Yeah, I think you need to consider why the ◊◊◊◊ you would do that.

Like, I work and play in some dicey areas. So I'm eyes open at all times, ready and expecting things to go south at any minute. I lock my vehicle, don't leave valuables laying around, that kind of thing. If I leave my vehicle unlocked with the windows down with my wallet and phone and keys on the dash, it doesn't mean I consented to being robbed. But it ain't anyone's fault but mine that I was. I don't think taking reasonable, foreseeable precautions is so high a bar.
 
Yes, of course it's rape. I'm surprised you even have to ask that question.
This one comes up a lot, and I think it's tricky. By your standard, a married couple couldn't have sex if they were concurrently getting lit up.

Take this scenario, for instance: my wife actually likes to be... serviced... when she drinks. I happily volunteer to be the designated driver on such evenings. Have I repeatedly raped her?
But hey, let's go with it. If two guys get so wasted that one can't defend himself and the other gets angry and kills him, is it still murder?
Begging the question. We are trying to determine if it would be rape when consent was already freely given to get wasted and ◊◊◊◊, and your murder counterexample requires that it was definitionally and indisputably already a high crime with no consent ever given.
Or what if two guys get wasted, and one decides he wants the other's leather jacket and 'asks' for it by kicking him to the ground and taking it, is it still robbery? 10 out of the 12 people on the jury said no, and blamed the victim for being drunk. Luckily two of us were able to convince the others that the thug was guilty.
Ten of those people were thinking that the guy bore some responsibility, and I can see that. It wouldn't justify being rolled legally, but he did go out of his way to present himself as a helpless target, and he did not need to do so. It doesn't make sense to me to say "ok, I am willingly putting myself at the mercy of any predator, so you guys all be nice, ok?" That's not very good self preservation. That's bordering on suicide.
 
Yes, of course it's rape. I'm surprised you even have to ask that question.

But hey, let's go with it. If two guys get so wasted that one can't defend himself and the other gets angry and kills him, is it still murder?

Or what if two guys get wasted, and one decides he wants the other's leather jacket and 'asks' for it by kicking him to the ground and taking it, is it still robbery? 10 out of the 12 people on the jury said no, and blamed the victim for being drunk. Luckily two of us were able to convince the others that the thug was guilty.
Your scenario has one person violently assaulting another who cannot consent.

My scenario has two people engaged mutually agreeable sex, but also they're both too drunk to give informed consent if asked. I don't think they're analogous.

Your analogy would be closer to my scenario if it were a case of drunken mutual combat, where afterwards, having sobered up, one or both of the mutual combatants regrets the drunken choice they made to engage in mutual combat.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom