No, Donald Trump did not start his political career with birtherism

MrFliop

Thinker
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
212
The media has been falsely claiming that Trump started the birther issue because he's racist, if this were true why did he only begin talking about it over 2 years after Obama's election during an interview when he was only asking a question then later began expressing doubts when several more reporters asked him the same question provoking him to research the issue further.

No I am not a birther.

The person who deserves the credit for starting this controversy is Hillary Clinton's 2008 campaign.
Here is a summary of the facts, from breitbart.com

1.More than a full year before anyone would hear of Orly Taitz, the Birther strategy was first laid out in the Penn memo.

2.The “othering” foundation was built subliminally by the Clinton campaign itself.

3.Democrats and Clinton campaign surrogates did the dirtiest of the dirty work: openly spread the Birther lies.

4.Staffers in Hillary’s actual campaign used email to spread the lies among other Democrats (this was a Democrat primary after all — so that is the only well you needed to poison a month before a primary).

5.The campaign released the turban photo.

6.Hillary herself used 60 Minutes to further stoke these lies.

 
The media has been falsely claiming that Trump started the birther issue because he's racist, if this were true why did he only begin talking about it over 2 years after Obama's election during an interview when he was only asking a question then later began expressing doubts when several more reporters asked him the same question provoking him to research the issue further.

No I am not a birther.

The person who deserves the credit for starting this controversy is Hillary Clinton's 2008 campaign.
Here is a summary of the facts, from breitbart.com




Sorry, no that was debunked about two minutes after Trump's campaign tried to push it. Of course he didn't start it, that was obvious. A low-level staffer loosely floated the idea in a campaign memo, which was rightly rejected and that staffer was let go. Are you really saying Clinton is responsible for propagating that rumor and Trump was intellectually interested in the idea and was just asking questions?
 
Last edited:
Even if the stupid dishonest distortion about Clinton were true, this would not absolve Trump of being stupid and dishonest too. The birther nonsense was racist idiocy from the start, and saying you stupidly and thoughtlessly copied it from someone else is no excuse. Give it up. It's over.
 
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 0/12 removed.

1. Top members of the campaign only fired the staffer AFTER it leaked that he had spread the rumors.
2. If you watch the video I posted it shows that only in 2011 did Trump ever begin to raise the issue. At first he said he believed that Obama born in HI but only AFTER doing his own research did he begin to speculate that he may have been born somewhere else. And Donald had a good reason to find out, because a non-natural born citizen CANNOT be president.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 0/12 removed.

1. Top members of the campaign only fired the staffer AFTER it leaked that he had spread the rumors.
2. If you watch the video I posted it shows that only in 2011 did Trump ever begin to raise the issue. At first he said he believed that Obama born in HI but only AFTER doing his own research did he begin to speculate that he may have been born somewhere else. And Donald had a good reason to find out, because a non-natural born citizen CANNOT be president.

Not sure if Poe. I suppose we all owe Mr. Trump a great deal of gratitude after getting to the bottom of it. I can see Googling "Obama Kenya born Trump" and three more variations.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The media has been falsely claiming that Trump started the birther issue because he's racist, if this were true why did he only begin talking about it over 2 years after Obama's election during an interview when he was only asking a question then later began expressing doubts when several more reporters asked him the same question provoking him to research the issue further.

No I am not a birther.

The person who deserves the credit for starting this controversy is Hillary Clinton's 2008 campaign.
Here is a summary of the facts, from breitbart.com




But nothing you wrote addresses the claim that Trump's run for presidency began by pushing racist garbage - those who remember 2011 will recall that he temporarily became the GOP frontrunner that year by pushing the birther nonsense.

(And that junk you wrote has long since been debunked, but the actual point is that it's one of many actions that clearly show that he is a white supremacist, so I see no need to debunk it again. Also, quoting white nationalist sites like breitbart isn't going to do you much good.)
 
Here is a summary of the facts, from breitbart.com
Well, that certainly explains why your post is lacking in factual content.

Sorry, no that was debunked about two minutes after Trump's campaign tried to push it. Of course he didn't start it, that was obvious. A low-level staffer loosely floated the idea in a campaign memo, which was rightly rejected and that staffer was let go...
It was an unpaid volunteer, as I recall.
 
This meme -- Hillary Clinton and/or her campaign started the birther issue in the 2008 primary -- is never going to die, sad to say, it is just way too appealing to a certain mindset. I copied a previous series of messages to a file becaue I know this is going to keep coming up.

First:
newyorkguy said:
Politicfact knocks down this baloney that Clinton had anything to do with the birther nonsense (which began AFTER she conceded to Obama in June 2008) much less started it.
There is no record that Clinton herself or anyone within her campaign ever advanced the charge that Obama was not born in the United States. A review by our fellow fact-checkers at Factcheck.org reported that no journalist who investigated this ever found a connection to anyone in the Clinton organization.​
​

The article also gave some pretty clear history on who started it and how:

A Clinton volunteer in Texas, Linda Starr, played a key role in spreading the rumor. Starr connected with Pennsylvania attorney Philip Berg in August [2008] and Berg followed up by suing in federal court to block Obama’s nomination. The suit was thrown out repeatedly on the grounds that Berg lacked standing and the U.S. Supreme Court ultimately refused to hear his appeal.
Linda Starr, is quite a character. She "deduced" Obama must have been born in Kenya when she was unable to obtain a copy of Obama's Hawaiian birth certificate. She was also instrumental in the Rathergate affair, supplying information (ultimately proved false) to CBS News about George Bush's malfeasance during his days flying jets for the National Guard. Why?

Linda claims her distaste for George Bush stems from the fact that Bush physically assaulted her, while he was Texas Governor back in the 1990s, leading to a long term debilitating depression which left her unable to work.

Not coincidentally, the lawyer she hooked up with, Philip Berg, also has a strong dislike for George W. Bush. In 2004 Berg filed a RICO (racketeering) complaint against President George W. Bush and 154 others, claiming they orchestrated the 9/11 attacks. Berg, who was disbarred last year, now works as an Uber driver in Philadelphia.

Linda also claims:
  • She has evidence that teenaged Laura Bush murdered her 17 year old boyfriend back in the sixties.
  • She has evidence that Michelle Obama was disbarred in Illinois in 1993 for insurance fraud.

Link
 
Sorry, but what are you saying? Do you think that Linda Starr has been made up?

It would be a fairly strange thing to do: make up a source for birtherism and then name her after Tripp and Starr. Not a very good way to hide the conspiracy.

Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove breach of rule 0 and rule 12
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Even if the stupid dishonest distortion about Clinton were true, this would not absolve Trump of being stupid and dishonest too. The birther nonsense was racist idiocy from the start, and saying you stupidly and thoughtlessly copied it from someone else is no excuse. Give it up. It's over.

Why was it racist?
 
Believe what you want. I don't believe for one second that such nonsense would have been perpetrated if the person in question were not black. Believe what you want.

It looks like you're believing what you want. Your side calls racism so damn much the word means nothing anymore.
 
No.

If you're genuinely interested in where the birther nonsense began, I can only point to this pair of blog posts. It discards single, off-hand remarks on Obama being born abroad, being a muslim, and combinations there-of, in order to focus on the "Born in Kenya, rushed to US, family secured a fake birth certificate"-narrative that was the main birther talking point:

http://barackryphal.blogspot.dk/2011/06/secret-origin-of-birthers.html
http://barackryphal.blogspot.dk/2011/06/secret-origin-part-2.html
 
Breaches of several rules etc. removed to AAH. Keep to the topic and if you can't post without breaching your Membership Agreement don't post.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
If you're genuinely interested in where the birther nonsense began, I can only point to this pair of blog posts...focus [is] on the "Born in Kenya, rushed to US, family secured a fake birth certificate"-narrative that was the main birther talking point: Blog link

The blog, by Loren Collins, is very interesting and I thank KDLarsen for linking it. The blog does seem to establish that the rumor first appeared on the Internet in the early hours of Saturday, March 1, 2008, on the conservative web forum, FreeRepublic.com, by a poster with the screenname FARS:
I was told today...that Obama’s mother gave birth to him overseas and then immediately flew into Hawaii and registered his birth as having taken place in Hawaii.

It is noted the source given is anonymous, just "I was told." But one previous source was found but, incredibly, one day before and it was a joking reference.
On February 28, 2008, UCLA Law Professor Eugene Volokh posted to The Volokh Conspiracy a short item where he stated that he was certain that John McCain was a natural-born citizen. In the comments thread to this post, one commenter posited this legal scenario:

Let's change the hypothetical (just for grins and giggles).

Barack Obama's father was a citizen of Kenya. What would Senator Obama's citizenship status (and Presidential eligibility) be if:

1) He had been born in Kenya, but taken by his mother to the United States immediately after birth and then spent the rest of his life as he has subsequently lived it?​


But the "rumor" was now out there in cyber space, findable by right wingers who already loathed the idea of Obama as American president. The story seems to have percolated until June 2008 when Obama pulled into the delegate lead and seemed all but certain to win the Democratic nomination. The bloger Collins notes that was when the story really took off:
FreeRepublic started its first thread devoted to the rumor on June 10. WorldNetDaily published its first article about Obama’s eligibility on the same day. Websites like Atlas Shrugs, TexasDarlin, and Larry Johnson’s NoQuarter, which all served as leaders of the early Birther movement (long before they were even dubbed “Birthers”), all ran their first Birther-related stories after June 9. Literally overnight, rumors about Obama’s birth and eligibility went from being impossibly obscure to practically commonplace, and a document that only a handful of people had ever suggested be released was suddenly the subject of urgent demands of transparency all over the web.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom