ElMondoHummus
0.25 short of being half-witted
I'm not claiming that they support any of the theories put forward by the 9/11 truth movement, but they do support individual pieces of the puzzle. Dr. Quintere supports the truth movement's assertion that the NIST report lacks scientific integrity. Dr. Astaneh-Asl corroborates the dozens of other reports of molten steel at GZ...
... Both men were very clear in what they said, and those were not isolated quotes.
Dr. Quintiere also said that the fire resistant material installation was potentially faulty (thus increasing the steel's susceptibility to fire), that he doesn't consider NIST's thesis that the fireproofing was stripped off to be sufficient (indicating that some fireproofing remained, yet wasn't sufficient to protect the steel), and that NIST underestimated both the weight and amount of flammable material in the fire zones of the towers (indicating that there was much more fuel for the fires, which would result in longer burning times). If those criticisms are accurate, they then strengthen the narrative of fires weakening an already damaged structure to the failure point, and very much moot any argument that Quintiere's criticisms lead to an overall refutation of the NIST report, as well as any argument that he negates the impacts + fires scenario.
In short, while Quintiere's criticisms certainly reveal flaws in the NIST investigation, they do not render inaccurate the overall conclusion about fires and impact damage. They merely suggest a different path in reaching that conclusion. But what his criticisms do end up achieving is a further refutation of the conspiracy fantasy that external agents in the form of explosives or incendiaries were responsible; his critiques indicate that the collapse would happen even if certain elements of the NIST assumptions were not true. That's hardly a negation of their conclusion.
As far as Astaneh-Asl's statements go, I've already said all that needs to be said about his stance in the previous thread Mackey linked above:
Astaneh-Asl's comments reflect the engineering consensus: Impacts plus fires led to the collapses. He's had ample time to voice opinions over the state of the steel not reflecting this paradigm, but instead, he's chosen to concentrate his efforts on other issues (namely, the issue of construction codes). His observations regarding the steel components are consistent with exposure to the heat and chemical reactions in the debris pile and whatever was done to the steel during the debris recovery/recycling. The only way to think his observations mean anything different are to blatantly ignore the fact that he was observing post-recovered steel, and to presume that anything he's observed was due to pre-collapse events. That's a two-step method of selective memory and is not conducive to understanding the truth. As R.Mackey pointed out, there's not only no way for Dr. Astaneh-Asl to know if what he's seeing took place prior to collapse or not, there happens to be a mountain of a reason to accept that what he observed stemmed from exposure to the post collapse environment. And that mountain of a reason is his postion in the recovery chain: He was viewing post-collapse, post-recovery-process steel. If you ignore that, you are ignoring the reality of what the steel went through before Dr. Astaneh-Asl saw it.
There is nothing left here to discuss. There certainly is nothing about Astaneh-Asl's work that needs to be debunked. The doctor's observations support the narrative of impacts plus fires equals collapse. The only thing left to debunk are conspiracy fantasists misinterpretations of his statements, and that's been done over and over already.
Bolding added for emphasis.Why in God's name is this subject still being beaten to death?
What matters is when he viewed the beams. Now merely what he saw. As Mackey pointed out, he did not get his eyes on them until after they had been recovered and removed from their place on the debris pile. They had been exposed not only to the heat and any reactions existant in the piles, but had also been subject to the processes taken during the recovery efforts. And that's the point where Astaneh-Asl saw them: After the members had been recovered and moved from the debris pile.
The steel was exposed to the debris pile and recovery efforts for far longer (order of days to weeks) than it had been exposed to whatever conditions existed from the time of the impacts to the end of the collapse (under an hour and a half for WTC 1, around 50-some minutes for WTC 2). Why is it not obvious that whatever condition the steel was in was mostly due to the debris pile exposure and recovery efforts than it was due to the pre-collapse conditions?
There is no "there" there. Any statement by Astaneh-Asl must be evaluated in the context in which he viewed the steel. And he viewed them post recovery. How can that not be taken into account?
You see, here's the problem for you: Both Quintiere's and Astaneh-Asl's statements may criticize the NIST report or supposedly and superficially provide support for a point detail of the conspiracy fantasy, but their conclusions are absolutely fatal to any notion that the model NIST sets forth is wrong. Their arguments are refinements of the general direction NIST is heading in; they're far from being refutations of their conclusions. You cannot separate Quintiere's statement about peer review and being a "proper" conspiracy theorist from his statement about the role of fireproofing and the increased likelyhood of failure even with the SFRM intact (which, incidentally is also the Arup and Edinburgh stance, yet I don't see any conspiracy peddlers adding them to their sacred lists of people refuting the NIST line, when in fact they're doing exactly that). And you can't separate Astaneh-Asl's statements from the fact that he was observing steel that not only had sat in the rubble piles for days to weeks, but also had undergone whatever handling necessary to extract the steel from said piles.
The point is, sure, you can bring them up to point out that NIST's work had flaws. And believe it or not, we agree. But, beware of doing so because acceptance of their criticisms is also a de facto acceptance of the overall narrative of fires plus impacts equals collapse, and an overall refutation of bombs or thermite. So sure, I encourage you to embrace their work. It'll end up supporting the truth as we in this forum have been arguing all along. It just won't do so in the direction that "Inside Job" advocates want it to.
