Ed New domain name for stopsylviabrowne = stopsylvia.com

It's one thing searching for "stop sylvia browne" that implies that the searcher knows that the site exists. However the benefit of a good google rank is the new viewers that it brings. As such I'm more concerned about the search phrase "Sylvia Browne"

It used to be that a person search for that would first find sylvia's own site and then right next to it would see Roberts site.

Now the old domain is sitting at 31 whilst the new www.stopsylvia.com address is at 126.

Not great but it's an imporvement. We're still getting the same list of backlinks for either site though. I guess patience is the important factor in this.

For those of you clicking on google links I must admit that I was duboius that this would have any effect. Whilst the weblogs on the destination server would register that you came from google via the referer infomration provided by your web browser, the google server logs would be unaware that you'd clicked on the link unless the link was to google's own site. Some website to use a referal page for external sites and one reason for this is to log where they're sending hits. The links google uses go directly to the external site so I thought that google would know what you clicked on. However examining the source I do see that some java script is executed when either mouse button is clicked over the link. I don't do Java Script myself and found it rather impenetrable though it may well be that google is logging such clicks.

Can anyone confirm this?
 
For those of you clicking on google links I must admit that I was duboius that this would have any effect. Whilst the weblogs on the destination server would register that you came from google via the referer infomration provided by your web browser, the google server logs would be unaware that you'd clicked on the link unless the link was to google's own site. Some website to use a referal page for external sites and one reason for this is to log where they're sending hits. The links google uses go directly to the external site so I thought that google would know what you clicked on. However examining the source I do see that some java script is executed when either mouse button is clicked over the link. I don't do Java Script myself and found it rather impenetrable though it may well be that google is logging such clicks.

Sometimes Google uses redirects rather than straight links in the search results, so they can track clicks even if Javascript is disabled. Using Javascript or redirects, Google can also look at things like the time between clicks at Google.com. So they may be tracking how long you look at a page. If you click on a link at Google.com then quickly come back to Google and do a search or click on another link, Google could assume you didn't find the first link you clicked to be interesting.

Also, many people have the Google toolbar installed which can give Google more information about their search and browsing habits.

In any case, I doubt it's worth the trouble trying to manipulate Google by deliberatly searching for Sylvia Browne and clicking on the StopSylvia.com result. There's just not enough of us to affect the results in a positive way - a few clicks from us are going to be lost in the noise of the millions of searches done on Google every day.

And Google has been fighting attempts to manupulate the search rankings since they started. So, unnatural attempts to inflate the ranking of StopSylvia.com could result in penalties.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
The Quackwatch page is mighty high up. They've updated their link to the Stop Sylvia Browne site. When I wrote to the e-mail address more than a week ago, Bryan Farha told me that I was the 3rd person to ask them to update the link!

Does it help to hit the Quackwatch page and follow the link to the new site?
 
The links google uses go directly to the external site so I thought that google would know what you clicked on. However examining the source I do see that some java script is executed when either mouse button is clicked over the link. I don't do Java Script myself and found it rather impenetrable though it may well be that google is logging such clicks.

Can anyone confirm this?

Yes, that piece of Javascript on links in Google results page is used by Google to determine which results are clicked on. They figure results that are clicked are probably what the person wanted.

I can't imagine it counts for a ton in the ranking of a site but you never know. And believe me Google has automated procedures in place to detect attempts to "game" systems like that. "Click fraud" is a huge problem for them, particularly with ads, but also for stuff like this.

This is why I have been downplaying this throughout this discussion. I was afraid some overzealous skeptic out there would write a script to repeatedly click on stopsylvia.com from Google result pages. (We've already seen other rash actions taken as a result of this event).

If you were to do that and Google were to detect you, you would do untold damage to Robert's site.

DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT IT.

Seriously! Do not attempt to manufacture stopsylvia.com clicks. You will do more harm than good.
 
Last edited:
This is why I have been downplaying this throughout this discussion. I was afraid some overzealous skeptic out there would write a script to repeatedly click on stopsylvia.com from Google result pages. (We've already seen other rash actions taken as a result of this event).

If you were to do that and Google were to detect you, you would do untold damage to Robert's site.

DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT IT.

Seriously! Do not attempt to manufacture stopsylvia.com clicks. You will do more harm than good.

(Thinking like Bruce Schneier) Perhaps we should do that for the old site instead? :D
 
Well, hopefully Boris and his buddies aren't reading this board and trying the same stuff with the new site...but I think they are (reading this board, that is).

I wouldn't recommend trying to click-kill the old site at any rate. I don't think that's something Robert would do, or would want us to do.
 
Well, hopefully Boris and his buddies aren't reading this board and trying the same stuff with the new site...but I think they are (reading this board, that is).

I wouldn't recommend trying to click-kill the old site at any rate. I don't think that's something Robert would do, or would want us to do.

I don't clicking a site a million times will have much of an effect besides wearing out your mouse. Google would be well aware that both sides can play that game.
 
(Thinking like Bruce Schneier) Perhaps we should do that for the old site instead? :D

No. Apart from it being wrong, if Google didn't pick up on it as a fraud you're just helping the rankings of the old site.

I'm sure you're not being serious though.
 
Both Robert and Susan have made it clear that they want us to leave the old site alone. No google-bombing, no ranting posts on their blog, nothing that would draw attention to it. Just work steadily at getting the new site's rankings improved in Google.

Indeed.
 
What we need to do is to pretend that stopsylvia.com is a new site, and work accordingly to help raise it in the Google rankings, and to pretend that SSB dot com has never ever existed in the first place, and treat that site accordingly as well.

Look into my eyes...you are getting sleepy...when you wake up, you will forget that SSB dot com ever existed....<snaps fingers>....you are now awake, and only stopsylvia.com exists.
 
Both Robert and Susan have made it clear that they want us to leave the old site alone. No google-bombing, no ranting posts on their blog, nothing that would draw attention to it. Just work steadily at getting the new site's rankings improved in Google.

Precisely.

What we need to do is to pretend that stopsylvia.com is a new site, and work accordingly to help raise it in the Google rankings, and to pretend that SSB dot com has never ever existed in the first place, and treat that site accordingly as well.

Look into my eyes...you are getting sleepy...when you wake up, you will forget that SSB dot com ever existed....<snaps fingers>....you are now awake, and only stopsylvia.com exists.

What's SSB dot com?
 
Good news everyone! Earlier in the thread someone mentioned the great Jon Ronson Guardian article, which has a very high Google ranking for "Sylvia Browne", has a link to the old URL.

I said I'd see what I could do, and I am happy to report that the link article halfway down has been changed:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/oct/27/usa.jonronson

We owe a huge thankyou to Jon for giving this his personal attention.
 
Last edited:
Holy Cow! The correct version of SSB just popped up for me in StumbleUpon! I'm going to give it a review and a thumbs up! :)

ETA: I gave a simple review on the articles page.
 
Last edited:
Interesting development at Google. Try this link:

Pages that link to StopSylvia.com

Just now it gave me 328 pages that should be linking to the new address. I haven't clicked on all 328 (no, I'm not that keen), but I chose several at random to check if they are really linking to the new address. They are.

Now replace "stopsylvia" with "stopsylviabrowne" in the Google search. Google told me that there are no pages linking to this address! I know for a fact that this isn't true: there are still many pages that link to the old address (including one on the StopSylvia site itself!), so I wonder what this means. Is Google in the process of writing off the old address?

I'd be interested to see if others get the same results later on in the day.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom