I’m still skeptical that all hope is lost.
1) Susan says in her OP:
The lady told me that StopKaz.com was coming up for renewal in Dec, as well as a few others, so I went ahead and paid for all of it. She was kind enough to give me a whopping 20% discount.
But if you take a look at the whois info through domaintools.com one can see that StopKaz.com doesn’t expire until August 30, 2009. So if the godaddy.com CSR was inaccurate about that ... what else was she inaccurate about?
2) Also, StopKaz.com has these status codes:
Registrar Status: clientDeleteProhibited
Registrar Status: clientRenewProhibited
Registrar Status: clientTransferProhibited
Registrar Status: clientUpdateProhibited
Frankly, I don’t understand these status codes as well as I would like to, but I do know that the basic intent is to prevent someone else from initiating a transfer of a domain name to their control. My understanding is that under the current rules anyone can request that a domain name be transferred to their control. It’s up to the person or business that owns the domain name to protest this request upon being notified about it otherwise it will take place. One way to prevent that is for the domain name owner to request that their domain registrar put a lock on their domain name. That is basically what the above status codes do. This prevents a transfer from a domain name taking place where the relinquishing domain name owner is passive in the process. With these status codes in place, a transfer can only take place if the relinquishing domain name owner is active in the process or initiates it.
So, if Robert took these precautions for StopKaz.com, I think its safe to assume that he did the same for StopSylviaBrowne.com Therefore I think we can rule out that Boris Kreiman (the current supposed owner of the stopsylviabrowne.com domain name) legitimately obtained the domain name by requesting it, and then automatically getting ownership when Robert declined to say no for obvious reasons.
3) I couldn’t find the information that erlando found on godaddy.com about auctions. I did see this though:
http://help.godaddy.com/article/795
Can I transfer an expired domain?
There is a 45-day grace period for expired .COM, .NET, .ORG, .INFO, .BIZ, .US, .CC, .TV, .NAME, and .WS domains. During this time, you can renew your domain and then follow the procedure for transferring it to your new registrar. Or, your new registrar can initiate a transfer request if you provide the required authorization for the expired domain.
If your expired domain is not transferred or renewed during the 45-day grace period, your old registrar may release the domain near the end of the grace period. Once your expired domain is released, it enters a separate 35-day redemption grace period in which the domain is unavailable for registration. After the redemption period, the domain becomes available for registration.
Based on the above godaddy didn’t follow their own procedures to have a total of an 80 day grace period. (45 +35 = 80) It's still not 80 days since August 21, the anniversary date of the domain name creation.
So perhaps if Susan or if someone else on Robert’s behalf protests this at ICANN (the regulating body for IP addresses and domain names), Robert can still keep ownership of the domain name.
Also I found this:
http://www.bitlaw.com/internet/domain.html
…
This policy has now been replaced with a Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy created by ICANN and used by all accredited registrars. Under this new policy, a trademark owner can initiate a relatively inexpensive administrative procedure to challenge the existing domain name. In order to prevail, the trademark owner must show:
1. that the trademark owner owns a trademark (either registered or unregistered) that is the same or confusingly similar to the registered second level domain name;
2. that the party that registered the domain name has no legitimate right or interest in the domain name; and
3. that the domain name was registered and used in bad faith.
If the trademarkIf the trademark owner successfully proves all three points in the administrative proceeding, then the domain name can either be cancelled or transferred to the prevailing trademark owner. If the trademark owner fails to prove one of these points, the administrative panel will not cancel nor transfer the domain name.
Among the ways that a domain name owner can prove a legitimate right or interest in a domain name is by showing:
• use or preparations to use the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services prior to any notice of the dispute;
• that the domain name owner has been commonly known by the second level domain name; or
• that the domain name owner is making legitimate noncommercial or fair use of the domain name, without intent of (i) commercial gain, (ii) misleadingly diverting consumers, or (iii) tarnishing the trademark at issue
A trademark owner can show that a domain name was registered and used in bad faith in a variety of ways, including by showing that the domain name owner:
• registered the name primarily for the purpose of selling or transferring the domain name to the trademark owner or a competitor of the trademark owner for a price greater than out of pocket costs;
• engaged in a pattern of registering trademarks of others to prevent the use of the domain name by the trademark owner;
• registered the domain name primarily to disrupt the business of a competitor; or
• is attempting to attract users to a web site for commercial gain by creating a likelihood of confusion with the trademark owner's trademark.
At this point it may be easiest to have a lawyer who specializes in domain name conflicts to handle this. Given the nature of what Robert’s web sites are all about – non-profit sites that are free and whose only intent is to help protect people from fraud it’s very possible that a lawyer may be willing to do this on a pro bono basis. I would imagine that the potential of the PR value for such a lawyer could be very high.
I'm just tossing these ideas out there because I really hate it when the scumbags win.