ExMinister
RSL Acolyte
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2007
- Messages
- 2,982
Claus, it was a general comment - not picking you out at all.
I'm concerned by some of the comments, illustrated by what was written on the page you linked. I just feel we could all benefit from considering a question that people have asked me to incorporate into t-shirts, partly inspired by these recent events - "what would Robert do?".
I agree. I sincerely hope the nasty e-mails he received weren't from people who post here. They certainly shouldn't be considered representative of skeptics in general or Randi's forum in particular. We have every right to speculate on his motives here in these threads, especially as we have been in a crisis trying to sort out what happened, attempting to figure out how best to move forward. Speculation is not accusation, and if we rant a bit here, that should be our right. But if there is one thing most of know, it is that whenever we are dealing publically with people like this, WE need to be the voice of sincerity, honesty and reason; and any time we send a letter or put something in writing that the other person can quote or respond to, we have to remember that in the eyes of SB followers and other followers of psychics, we mis-represent skepticism when we stoop so low. Worse, we do nothing but continue to undo the work Robert Lancaster has done in showing the world how respectful and sincere we can be. That said, Ocelot and Claus' comments seemed rational and appropriate rebuttals that did stick to the issues raised by BK without resorting to name calling or worse. I feel strongly that we need to maintain a tone like that, especially in this situation where Robert's work is involved.
OK, I will climb off my soapbox.
As a side note, Susan, I was just so glad to hear that Robert is alert enough to be following some of this and to have a definite opinion about it all! That's the best news I've heard in a long time.