New age fraud and critical thinking

Thank you, torsprings and Ellen T.!! Yes I certainly have learned a lot. And no it was not a difficult or unpleasant time, it's just that I've shocked myself in realizing how gullible I can be, lol!

All's good because now instead of constantly buying new agey books, I will have some money for new clothes...instead of spending time reading that NA crap, I can finally get to some real novels by wonderful authors who have amazing imaginations who genuinely want to tell an amazing story, not someone peddling their workshops and classes in their fluff-and-filler books that repeat the same message over and over. I now have more time to get back to playing the piano instead of trying to meditate, still myself and do the chakra cleansing, white light protection all while trying to maintain a "high vibration" and not have any negative thoughts or emotions so that spirit can flow freely within me.. lololol! Lord, how nutty!


Heehee, I started out to hilite a little of your statement about being free... and wound up having to choose all of your post!

I'm glad to see you have slipped straight into a group of fellow escapees from the lands of woo! It can be lonely feeling like a party pooper among the sheep... the flock of the "saved" ( whether they be "saved" from "mainstream" "beliefs", which is the Glasto vibe of "open-minded" "alternative physics" (what a daft notion! :boggled:) or from non-xtian life, or satan, or whathaveyou... all the same retreat into fantasy maskerading as self-righteous superiority and wisdom).

I wasn't so involved as you apparently were, but I still had to work for a couple of decades and more to rid myself of the occasional bad turn into fear and paranoia.... as someone said (I think in a different thread) it's good to learn what your triggers are, and then to keep away from them.

As you say, without all that pointless waste of energy required to maintain a "magical" lifestyle (that's drained into "magical thinking"), there's so much more delight and sense of freedom to be had in a worldview based in science. Liberating, isn't it!

Also, the money you can waste, as you point out, in buying those pointless books etc!.Until I was made redundant from my job in Waterstone's nearly 4 years ago, I was always feeling ashamed to be selling those "mind body and spirit" books... they are so half-baked, over-priced, dull plotless wannabe "sense of wonder" trash, far inferior in imaginative qualities to the wonderful works of imagination in the science fiction section... not to mention the entertainment value in the sf, with great characters and plots, to go with the far more informed and stimulating speculations in science and philosophy the authors of the sf community have been developing.

It does my heart good to see you guys all freeing yourselves! Hopefully there's a growing groundswell of people like you (and me!) getting fed up with the sterile magical thinking world, and finding sense and reality... this site, and people such as have been posting in this thread, can be an important station on their progress.

Torsprings, Ellen Travis, s_pepys, Exminister, and Kataleena... and anyone else I might have missed... I salute you!

Respect, a Syd ;):p:cool::)
 
An incident on a visit to Glastonbury a few years ago springs to mind. It's an illustration of the kind of self-selecting group of censorious guardians of the ingroup mentality which discourages critical thinking, or questioning of any aspect of the bs being passed off by these charlatans:

We were standing in front of a bookshop, and in the window were some books by that Japanese guy who claims to photograph water "crystals" (what?! does he mean ice? He never explains how these "crystals" are formed, nor mentions freezing or ice...) after talking to the water. He claims that being nice to the water creates better crystals, and being mean to the water makes for less symmetrically formed crystals. :rolleyes:

Anyway, I was standing there expressing my incredulity over this guy's claims, and as I was saying "water doesn't form crystals. What's he on about?" and happened to see a bloke standing a few feet away with a disapproving look on his face, slightly annoyed, perhaps offended that anyone should question the statements of any person professing any old idea at all... it's just not done to question the truth of such people's claims!

Despite being contemptuous of this particular idiocy, I still got the vibe from this censorious stranger, and if I were living in the town I know that pressure would have felt more oppressive.

It's really hard to not just keep your mouth shut and not rock the boat.

Again, respect!
 
i just have to say you are both the opposite of gullible.

Thank you for your post of support, especially that sentence above. While less emotional people may roll their eyes at me, I got very upset and shed a tear when the reality of my woo thinking hit me. It disturbed me greatly that I could actually believe all of the woo scam artists. I am a recovering Catholic also and while I am not knocking any religion, my point is that I blindly accepted what I was taught being brought up as a Catholic. I got out of that and chided myself on how gullible I was.

Next round - Woo Woo. Gullible again. But I got out. I started to worry about myself, telling myself I need to stay away from all people and books for a while because I'm soooo impressionable and gullible. At least until I recover my sanity.


We all succumb to thoughts that are a bit irrational and I tend to forget that. Even my earthy, practical and rational parents had their day of extreme Catholicism and speaking in "tongues" when I was a kid!!!

I need that support that I am not gullible :o so thank you!
 
Heehee, I started out to hilite a little of your statement about being free... and wound up having to choose all of your post!

I'm glad to see you have slipped straight into a group of fellow escapees from the lands of woo!

...

Also, the money you can waste, as you point out, in buying those pointless books etc!.Until I was made redundant from my job in Waterstone's nearly 4 years ago, I was always feeling ashamed to be selling those "mind body and spirit" books... they are so half-baked, over-priced, dull plotless wannabe "sense of wonder" trash, far inferior in imaginative qualities to the wonderful works of imagination in the science fiction section... not to mention the entertainment value in the sf, with great characters and plots, to go with the far more informed and stimulating speculations in science and philosophy the authors of the sf community have been developing.

...

Torsprings, Ellen Travis, s_pepys, Exminister, and Kataleena... and anyone else I might have missed... I salute you!

Respect, a Syd ;):p:cool::)


Lol at the highliting!

And it's funny you should mention science fiction. I LOVE reading and though I love imaginative stories, I never got into sci-fi. Until now. The first book I picked up after my New Age Recovery was a sci-fi book called "Clockwork Angels" by Kevin Anderson (based on story and lyrics of the Rush album, Clockwork Angels by best drummer in the world, Neil Peart)

I LOVE Rush (Canadian rock band) and have for about 34 years. Neil Peart, the drummer, loves to read and loves sci-fi. He's also the lyricist for the band and a lot of it is sci-fi-like.

So I'm in my glory right now, back to music, books and the joy of looking for more sci-fi books to read!! And what you wrote about SF is inspiring!!

Thank you!!;)
 
Lol at the highliting!

And it's funny you should mention science fiction. I LOVE reading and though I love imaginative stories, I never got into sci-fi. Until now. The first book I picked up after my New Age Recovery was a sci-fi book called "Clockwork Angels" by Kevin Anderson (based on story and lyrics of the Rush album, Clockwork Angels by best drummer in the world, Neil Peart)

I LOVE Rush (Canadian rock band) and have for about 34 years. Neil Peart, the drummer, loves to read and loves sci-fi. He's also the lyricist for the band and a lot of it is sci-fi-like.

So I'm in my glory right now, back to music, books and the joy of looking for more sci-fi books to read!! And what you wrote about SF is inspiring!!

Thank you!!;)

funny. just the other day a friend showed me a drum solo by said drummer. very cool.

books, music, poetry etc are all gloriously made up by people who dont have too incorporate controling or false ideaologies to appreciate and celebrate their imaginations.

youll probably enjoy these things more now you are free to like and dislike whatever YOU decide.

i would say also, dont lock yourself away from the world. people are good generally, even beleivers (as im sure you where still a nice person whilst still in the grip of the woo). hold your head up high and kindly tell them how you feel if the subject comes up. you arent the first to come to their senses and you (hopefully) wont be the last. education is key. pointing out the con artists at the top of these pyramids is key.
you have a knowledge and insight into a world that not many have.
use it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnFMrNdj1yY

lxxx
 
Lol at the highliting!

And it's funny you should mention science fiction. I LOVE reading and though I love imaginative stories, I never got into sci-fi. Until now. The first book I picked up after my New Age Recovery was a sci-fi book called "Clockwork Angels" by Kevin Anderson (based on story and lyrics of the Rush album, Clockwork Angels by best drummer in the world, Neil Peart)

I LOVE Rush (Canadian rock band) and have for about 34 years. Neil Peart, the drummer, loves to read and loves sci-fi. He's also the lyricist for the band and a lot of it is sci-fi-like.

So I'm in my glory right now, back to music, books and the joy of looking for more sci-fi books to read!! And what you wrote about SF is inspiring!! Thank you!!;)


Well I can recommend loads of brilliant contemporary sf! In fact, I might start a thread specifically on contemporary sf, to make room for the good new stuff, which all these old hand sf people seem to miss out on while they hark back to the previous "golden age" of the 50s, and maybe the 70s if we're lucky!
:rolleyes:

Honestly we are living through a new golden age, and have been for 20 years! There's a load of great authors and their pile of books that are truly a flowering of the genre!

Let me suggest Bruce Sterling. Start with Distraction, the most positive and witty and entertaining novel which imagines alternative ways to organise cities and commerce in a future of balkanised geographical areas in an information economy, and the sort of activist "politics" probably required... a crisis and stuff, characters you want for friends, desperate adventures and unexpected outcomes... very satisfying!

Or Kim Stanley Robinson. The Science in the Capitol trilogy that starts with Forty Signs of Rain and continues with Fifty Degrees Below and Sixty Days and Counting. Wonderful humanist socially progressive positive novelisations of modern life and scientists dealing with the ecological crisis we are entering... set a few years from now.

Or Justina Robson. Her series of books in the Quantum Bomb series are a sheer delighting in reimagining ideas about elves and demons etc, in a wild and fun cosmology... revel in the freedom to think of different mythologies... they are just stories... but what gret stories she tells with such sensual and wry relishing of the fantastic possibilities of story! Start with Keeping It Real.

Or Trisha Sullivan! Enjoy Maul.

But I meant to suggest that you might enjoy attending the World Science Fiction Convention to be held in London in 2014, August! SF fans are gregarious and fun-loving, in a nerdy kind of way... quite often they were the kid with glasses who wasn't good at sports etc, the fat kids that were lonely etc (a bit of a stereotype, but a lot of truth in it) and they are liberated by discovering the sf community, where authors and fans mix freely in an egalitarian friendly enjoyment of intellectual stimulation, centred on having fun with it! ;)

I bet you would really feel at home and have the time of your life. My wife and I are going! :D Check out the website http://www.loncon3.org
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom