Neil deGrasse Tyson - People at the equator would float

In this example the centripetal force *is* gravity. So there's no canceling. Free fall is achieved when the object's forward momentum (tangential to the surface of the earth) is high enough that the earth's surface constantly "curves away" from the fall.

Imagine shooting a cannonball over a hill. The cannonball can follow the curvature of the hill such that it stay a constant distance from the surface. Now, if you extend the curve of the hill all the way around, you get the earth. An object in free fall is constantly "falling" toward the center, but balanced by the tangential momentum.

ETA: Sorry Greg, just noticed you already said this, in many fewer words.
 
Last edited:
His 20 or so full length novels are famous for the unusual physics, and his stories for their use of hard science as a plot device rather than window dressing.

His "Iceworld" was the first science fiction book I ever read. Someone gave me a copy when I was about 10 and I read that thing at least four times. It's time to reread some of his stuff, I think.
 
Balancing gravity against centripetal force. It's what being in a free-fall orbit is all about.

As Philosaur and Greg noted, for an orbiting object gravity is a centripetal force (centripetal=towards the center). Any other centripetal force, if there were one, would add to it, not balance it. What one usually says is that motion in a circle (or ellipse) involves acceleration since the velocity is changing; therefore there must be an unbalanced force, and that's gravity.

However there is a way to think of the orbit as the result of two canceling forces. If you go to a rotating reference frame, e.g. one that rotates with the orbiting object, then there are so-called "fictitious forces" (a name I object to, incidentally). One such force is centrifugal (=away from the center). An object at rest in the rotating frame is orbiting, and the centrifugal force cancels the gravitational attraction, which allows it to remain at rest.
 
If the planet was spinning that fast, gravity at the poles would squash the planet so it would expand at the equator. The land then pushed beyond the orbit point would be beyond escape velocity, and would simply continue to go outward, pulling the planet into a disc, and eventually coming apart and flying off into space. Or so thinks this amateur.

If it maintained its shape, though, I wonder how different our lives would be if we evolved on a planet that alternated 40 minutes of day, 40 minutes of night. Certainly rules as to proper drinking time would have to be ammended.
 
In Mission of Gravity, the gravity was comparable to g (though higher, about 2g IIRC) at the equator, and many times higher at higher latitudes. The native species were adapted to higher gravity, but within limits. The higher gravity near the poles was inhospitable to the intelligent natives to a degree comparable to polar climate conditions on earth for humans.

(Of course, the human spacefarers visiting the planet, who can interact face to face with the natives at the equator, need the natives to go on an expedition into the dangerous high gravity regions.)

An innate fear of being underneath anything substantial was, IIRC, one of the more interesting native adaptations to a high gravity environment.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
In Mission of Gravity, the gravity was comparable to g (though higher, about 2g IIRC) at the equator, and many times higher at higher latitudes. The native species were adapted to higher gravity, but within limits. The higher gravity near the poles was inhospitable to the intelligent natives to a degree comparable to polar climate conditions on earth for humans.

(Of course, the human spacefarers visiting the planet, who can interact face to face with the natives at the equator, need the natives to go on an expedition into the dangerous high gravity regions.)

An innate fear of being underneath anything substantial was, IIRC, one of the more interesting native adaptations to a high gravity environment.

Respectfully,
Myriad

...they also fear heights. The Meskelin leader has a conniption early when a human casually picks him up and places him on a surface 24 inches high. He learns to like it. He's shaped like a centipede, 2 inches high.
 
As Philosaur and Greg noted, for an orbiting object gravity is a centripetal force (centripetal=towards the center). Any other centripetal force, if there were one, would add to it, not balance it. What one usually says is that motion in a circle (or ellipse) involves acceleration since the velocity is changing; therefore there must be an unbalanced force, and that's gravity.

However there is a way to think of the orbit as the result of two canceling forces. If you go to a rotating reference frame, e.g. one that rotates with the orbiting object, then there are so-called "fictitious forces" (a name I object to, incidentally). One such force is centrifugal (=away from the center). An object at rest in the rotating frame is orbiting, and the centrifugal force cancels the gravitational attraction, which allows it to remain at rest.

Yeah, I got the word wrong; I tripitalled on my fugal.

Is it too late to claim that I was obviously thinking in such a rotational frame? Can I get away with that? :)
 
....

However there is a way to think of the orbit as the result of two canceling forces. If you go to a rotating reference frame, e.g. one that rotates with the orbiting object, then there are so-called "fictitious forces" (a name I object to, incidentally). One such force is centrifugal (=away from the center). An object at rest in the rotating frame is orbiting, and the centrifugal force cancels the gravitational attraction, which allows it to remain at rest.
Am I to understand that the transfer of centrifugal force does not require a physical connection ?
 
...they also fear heights. The Meskelin leader has a conniption early when a human casually picks him up and places him on a surface 24 inches high. He learns to like it. He's shaped like a centipede, 2 inches high.

conniption ... thanks for that, a brand new word for me! I suspect it may be uncommonly useful on internet discussion forums :D
 
What if you had a very long (billions of miles) very strong pole that you started to raise into space from the equator. Assuming you don't hit anything in space, eventually the tip of the pole will start to approach the speed of light. At some point, would the energy needed to raise the pole any further become infinite?
 
What if you had a very long (billions of miles) very strong pole that you started to raise into space from the equator. Assuming you don't hit anything in space, eventually the tip of the pole will start to approach the speed of light. At some point, would the energy needed to raise the pole any further become infinite?

As you raised the pole into space the earth rotation would actually slow; conservation of angular momentum being what it is. The slowing is generally negligible when lifting a small weight, but if you had a pole attached to a small weight far enough out it would contribute enough to the moment of inertia to be significant.
 
What if you had a very long (billions of miles) very strong pole that you started to raise into space from the equator. Assuming you don't hit anything in space, eventually the tip of the pole will start to approach the speed of light. At some point, would the energy needed to raise the pole any further become infinite?

The opposite. Beyond a certain point (somewhere above above GEO) you will actually be acquiring energy, not spending it, in raising the pole. There will come a point where the pole is being raised "for free" and beyond there will come a point where the pole is ripped off the Earth by the forces acting on it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom