National Institute of Mental Health rejects DSM-5

Orphia Nay

Penguilicious Spodmaster
Tagger
Joined
May 2, 2005
Messages
54,636
Location
Australia
NIMH Director Thomas Insel has announced that the institute will be moving away from the DSM's symptom-based diagnosis towards "precision medicine"; a system based on the "emerging research data".


The NIMH have formed the NIMH Research Domain Criteria (RDoC):

  • First, RDoC is conceived as a dimensional system (reflecting, e.g., circuit-level measurements, behavioral activity, etc.) spanning the range from normal to abnormal. As with dimensions like hypertension or cholesterolemia in other areas of medicine, this approach incurs both the problem and advantage of defining cutpoints for the definition and extent of pathology – e.g., mild, moderate, and severe. (To the extent that DSM-V introduces dimensions in addition to classes, the crosswalks to RDoC dimensions may be enhanced.)
  • Second, RDoC is agnostic about current disorder categories. The intent is to generate classifications stemming from basic behavioral neuroscience. Rather than starting with an illness definition and seeking its neurobiological underpinnings, RDoC begins with current understandings of behavior-brain relationships and links them to clinical phenomena.
  • Third, RDoC will use several different units of analysis in defining constructs for study (e.g., imaging, physiological activity, behavior, and self-reports of symptoms). Indeed, RDoC, as a research framework, has been developed with the explicit goal of permitting investigators to choose an independent variable from one of several different units of analysis.

As Insel puts it, "RDoC is nothing less than a plan to transform clinical practice by bringing a new generation of research to inform how we diagnose and treat mental disorders."
 
http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2013/05/the-real-problems-with-psychiatry/275371/

You say one of the issues with taking these categories too seriously is that it eliminates the moral aspect behind certain behaviors.

Homosexuality was deleted from the DSM by a referendum. A straight up vote: yes or noIt's our characteristic way of chalking up what we think is "evil" to what we think of as mental disease. Our gut reaction is always "that was really sick. Those guys in Boston -- they were really sick." But how do we know? Unless you decide in advance that anybody who does anything heinous is sick. This society is very wary of using the term "evil." But I firmly believe there is such a thing as evil. It's circular -- thinking that anybody who commits suicide is depressed; anybody who goes into a school with a loaded gun and shoots people must have a mental illness. There's a certain kind of comfort in that, but there's no indication for it, particularly because we don't know what mental illness is.

Who was involved in the creation of the DSM-5?

The American Psychiatric Association owns the DSM. They aren't only responsible for it: they own it, sell it, and license it. The DSM is created by a group of committees. It's a bureaucratic process. In place of scientific findings, the DSM uses expert consensus to determine what mental disorders exist and how you can recognize them. Disorders come into the book the same way a law becomes part of the book of statutes. People suggest it, discuss it, and vote on it. Homosexuality was deleted from the DSM by a referendum. A straight up vote: yes or no. It's not always that explicit, and the votes are not public. In the case of the DSM-5, committee members were forbidden to talk about it, so we'll never really know what the deliberations were. They all signed non-disclosure agreements.

It would be useful to find some science to use for diagnoses.
 
The DSM is what it is, a communication tool, the use of the statistical tools to generate the scalar fields is what people have been talking about since 1990 when i started in mental health.

the utility of the DSM is in the background of its creation, passive aggressive PD did not pan out, nor did MMPD. So the statistical scalar models will be interesting but the goal is communication and classification.

The science of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder is not going to change the diagnostic categories that much.

Al the 'moral' dimension of behaviors already exists in the application of mental health, is there a specific aspect you would like to discuss?

One of my favorite phrases was from a crisis manager when confronted with people who blamed the past for their poor choices "And so did thousands of other people and they did not choose to do what you did."

The vast majority of people who are mentally ill and commit crimes are processed through the judicial system that same as any one else. The reasons behind suicide are much more complex than 'they are depressed'.

The reasons behind the change of the DSM away from the diagnosis of homosexuality is very broad, it is not something that represents a functional impairment in the execution of daily life. So yes there were politics in its original inclusion and later removal that is its main reason for being dropped.

there are many ways that people who are homosexuals are impacted and seek mental health treatment that are comparable across the choice of sexual partners, they have anxiety disorders, depression, etc... The main focus of treatment is in those areas.

So please explain the relevance of the article you have presented, I would like to discuss what issue you feel should be addressed. It is not mental health professionals who say "anybody who goes into a school with a loaded gun and shoots people must have a mental illness". When Steven Kazmierczak shot people at the NIU campus, it was only partly related to his living with bipolar disorder, 'And so are thousands of other people and they did not choose to do what he did'.

So if there is a conversation where people blame mass killings solely on mental illness, in is not in the mental health community.
 
Last edited:
The DSM is what it is, a communication tool, the use of the statistical tools to generate the scalar fields is what people have been talking about since 1990 when i started in mental health.

the utility of the DSM is in the background of its creation, passive aggressive PD did not pan out, nor did MMPD. So the statistical scalar models will be interesting but the goal is communication and classification.

The science of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder is not going to change the diagnostic categories that much.

Al the 'moral' dimension of behaviors already exists in the application of mental health, is there a specific aspect you would like to discuss?

One of my favorite phrases was from a crisis manager when confronted with people who blamed the past for their poor choices "And so did thousands of other people and they did not choose to do what you did."

The vast majority of people who are mentally ill and commit crimes are processed through the judicial system that same as any one else. The reasons behind suicide are much more complex than 'they are depressed'.

The reasons behind the change of the DSM away from the diagnosis of homosexuality is very broad, it is not something that represents a functional impairment in the execution of daily life. So yes there were politics in its original inclusion and later removal that is its main reason for being dropped.

there are many ways that people who are homosexuals are impacted and seek mental health treatment that are comparable across the choice of sexual partners, they have anxiety disorders, depression, etc... The main focus of treatment is in those areas.

So please explain the relevance of the article you have presented, I would like to discuss what issue you feel should be addressed. It is not mental health professionals who say "anybody who goes into a school with a loaded gun and shoots people must have a mental illness". When Steven Kazmierczak shot people at the NIU campus, it was only partly related to his living with bipolar disorder, 'And so are thousands of other people and they did not choose to do what he did'.

So if there is a conversation where people blame mass killings solely on mental illness, in is not in the mental health community.
Define mental illness. :)

From my link above:
Will the APA lose credibility?
Of course it will. The DSM-5 will come out on May 22 and people will take their pot shots at it -- like shooting fish in a barrel. I had to be convinced to write this book, though. How hard is it to criticize an organization that seriously thinks that it's okay to call "Internet Use Disorder" a mental illness? They're going to take shot after shot. And the response will be ineffectual and weak. They'll bob and weave, talk about the "living document," and unleash their line of ********.

Is there a solution?
The solution is to take the thing away from them. The APA owns these diagnoses. I didn't ask permission because I don't care -- let them sue me. But if anyone wants to put diagnostic criteria into this book, they have to pay the APA. That's absurd. And if you add the vacuousness of the document and the incompetence with which the revision was carried out -- take the damn thing away from them.

Other than that I guess it's all ok. :boxedin:
 
One of my favorite phrases was from a crisis manager when confronted with people who blamed the past for their poor choices "And so did thousands of other people and they did not choose to do what you did."

Yes, I've heard this one trotted out plenty of times. It's just another variation on the 'Argumentum ad populum' fallacy.
 
Define mental illness. :)
So i see you can not actually comment on the OP or the relevance o the material you cited to the OP, I am shocked, I has thought you were more that an sound byte poster.
So you move the goal posts. which really shocks me as you are a cogent and usually relevant poster.
I take it them you are not going to provide the relevance of the article you posted in context of the shift from the DSM non scalar classification by three from Column A and four from Column B approach to the multifactor scalar approach suggested by the NIMH.

Nor does the DSM seek to define mental illness, and the definition of the focus of treatments in the DSM is not circular despite what it said in the article you cited and can't explain.
From my link above:


Other than that I guess it's all ok. :boxedin:

So show us the criteria they criticize, i would assume it is either provisional or going to be based upon the abuse/dependence criteria.

Which way does it go.

Oh it probably uses the functional criteria of 'clinically significant impairment or distress', followed by the column A of check boxes.

But unless you actually want to discuss why this person who wrote the article chose to say why this shows the incompetence of the APA regards this specific criteria, it is just an argument for ignorance.

So how are you going to classify treatments for someone who has lost successive jobs and relationships due to a non productive engagement in an addictive seeming behavior.

Is there are reason you are posting here at all?
 
Yes, I've heard this one trotted out plenty of times. It's just another variation on the 'Argumentum ad populum' fallacy.

No it is not, unless you care to explain how that is. It is not an argument that the majority of people hold this view therefore it is true. It is an argument of how many people can go through similar events with separate outcomes.

I wonder why you just engaged in a drive by posting without discussing my actual post. people have choices all the time, they are not excused for their behaviors because of past events or because of a mental illness.(Except in specific legal settings unrelated to teh Atlantic articles rambling tirade on the APA and the DSM) So what exactly was your point?

I am sure it can be quite interesting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom