Nanothermite-Is it more powerful or not?

Crazy J

Student
Joined
Jan 13, 2011
Messages
28
Just reading Griffin's book on WTC 7 and came across something. He says that nanothermite is much more powerful than conventional explosives used in demolitions. But a few pages earlier in Griffin's book he says that nanothermite doesn't have the same effects that conventional explosives do.

So let me get this straight. Nanothermite is classified as an explosive which is much more powerful than conventional explosives, but isn't as loud? Thats what Griffin is arguing. Talk about a contradiction. I'm sorry an explosive is called an explosive for a reason. It stores alot of energy and when released its going to be loud no matter what. And yet they want us to believe that nanothermite is much more powerful and not as loud at the same time, yeah right. Where do these people come up with such things? And to think, I used to be one of them.
 
Well, the entire problem is that nanothermite is not an explosive: It does not evolve a gaseous product at a rate that would cause a supersonic wave front. On the cellular level, researchers have demonstrated that it can indeed react fast enough to drive compounds at a supersonic rate for distances on the order of pico- to micrometers, but that's on the microscopic level. There's been zero substantiation of nanothermite having that capacity on the macro level.
 
Just reading Griffin's book on WTC 7 and came across something. He says that nanothermite is much more powerful than conventional explosives used in demolitions. But a few pages earlier in Griffin's book he says that nanothermite doesn't have the same effects that conventional explosives do.

So let me get this straight. Nanothermite is classified as an explosive which is much more powerful than conventional explosives, but isn't as loud? Thats what Griffin is arguing. Talk about a contradiction. I'm sorry an explosive is called an explosive for a reason. It stores alot of energy and when released its going to be loud no matter what. And yet they want us to believe that nanothermite is much more powerful and not as loud at the same time, yeah right. Where do these people come up with such things? And to think, I used to be one of them.

Hi Crazy J, welcome to the forums! The answer, as I'm certain you'll get from many of the other posters is that what classifies an object as an "explosive" has to do with the rate at which the energy is released (omitting industry standards like composition and energy kinetics).

The theory of collapse accepted by the vast majority of scientists and engineers states that the office furniture, paper, carpet and other consumables in the WTC fires were sufficient to heat the steel structure and weaken it. Here, we are concerned with the total amount of heat released.

Nanothermite, thermite, and many other "explosives" do not have as much available chemical energy as things like wood and paper. That seems counter-intuitive, but it is true. The reason we use explosives is that we need energy evolved quickly, and while it might be useful to have a higher energy density material, if the rate changes, the explosive becomes useless. The collapse of the twin towers was a total energy issue, not a rate of energy release issue. Proponents of nano-thermite have contended that the material, an explosive, was used to heat the structure beyond the temperature created in the fire. I think you can figure out why using an explosive to do something like heating a steel column is beyond silly.
 
Last edited:
As I mentioned in your other post, I used to be one of "them" too, it's really great you are here, I hope this is the start of an exodus!

I really like something I have found out recently: "Truthers claim that if nanothermite was in the buildings it wouldn't be set off by fires 'cause it ignites at over 900 degrees.

But the Jones/Harrit chips burned at about 450 degrees in the DSC. That's the same temp as paint burns, btw....coincidence of course... So either the chips ain't what they claim, or it would have been destroyed by fire."

- Credits to Alienentity.

Incidentally, my path from a "truther" into the truth, has ignited an interest in science for me, next year I begin my studies, with the goal of obtaining a degree in chemistry. You can definitely pick up knowledge on the forums, as you were once a truther, you may find some posts by truthers a headache, I know I do!
 
Welcome abord! Congratulations for turning away from the dark side. Your NWO debunking salary begins the first of the moth. Play your cards right, and it's a key to the executive washroom here in NWO towers. ;)
 
Oh nanothermite is the philosopher's stone of the 9/11 truth movement. It is magic, it has whatever characteristics they need it to have. It is rich in nutrients, it is a birth control, it removes tough stains...
 
But the Jones/Harrit chips burned at about 450 degrees in the DSC. That's the same temp as paint burns, btw....coincidence of course... So either the chips ain't what they claim, or it would have been destroyed by fire."

Well, I don't know if it's possible to actually make the statement that "paint burns" at 450oC (Minor correction: The paper notes a 430oC ignition temp, not 450). There are so many different formulations of paint that I don't think it's possible to be so blanket with that assertion. That said, there's nothing about a 430o or 450o ignition point that points at thermite. It's ridiculous for them to try and claim that as support for their claim.
 
Just reading Griffin's book on WTC 7 and came across something. He says that nanothermite is much more powerful than conventional explosives used in demolitions. But a few pages earlier in Griffin's book he says that nanothermite doesn't have the same effects that conventional explosives do.

You've just stumbled upon one of the "truth" cult's most embarrassing and explosive contradictions.

"If you wanted the building to come down, and blame it on fire, which is not explosive in nature, you would use a different type of charge, an incendiary to cut the beams. You would NOT use explosives which would give away your project."

-Richard Gage

The explosives had to be so intense such as to hurl these beams at 65 mph laterally, landing five hundred feet away."

-Richard Gage


Truthers make life so much more fun.
 
Incidentally, my path from a "truther" into the truth, has ignited an interest in science for me, next year I begin my studies, with the goal of obtaining a degree in chemistry. You can definitely pick up knowledge on the forums, as you were once a truther, you may find some posts by truthers a headache, I know I do!
Ain't it freakin' KEWL?!? :D I dearly LOVE watching how I learned something!

Um, edited some BS.
 
Last edited:
An explosive is a substance that, when initiated, undergoes an exothermic reaction creating a pressure wave. The reaction is also understood to be self-sustaining, where the pressure of the explosive sets off the rest of the explosive.

There are two types of explosions: Detonation, where the pressure wave created is in fact a shock wave, viz. a sharp discontinuity in pressure that travels greater than the speed of sound (in the explosive, not in the open air); or a deflagration, where the pressure rise has a finite "thickness," travelling approximately at the speed of sound. Whether your explosive detonates or deflagrates depends on whether there is a unique solution of the Rankine-Hugoniot curve (which relates conditions ahead of and behind the shock as it passes through the explosive) and the Rayleigh Line, which describes a state condition where momentum is conserved (required for the reaction to be self-sustaining or better). This solution, the so-called Chapman-Jouget Point, defines the speed of the explosion as it develops in the explosive, and determines whether it is supersonic or merely sonic.

Like explosions, explosives are generally categorized into two types. The first are the so-called "low" explosives, such as black powder, which deflagrate rather than detonate. The second, the "high" explosives, actually detonate. This difference has a profound effect upon the target.

Note that subtle changes in composition or geometry can change how an explosive behaves. Perhaps the best known example is a Fuel-Air Explosive (FAE). If you get the air mixture just right, you can have a true detonation, causing extensive destruction. In general, however, you only get a deflagration, as being slightly fuel-rich slows down the reaction and "smears" the pressure pulse.

If the mixture is way off, it won't explode at all, but merely burn in a big smoky fireball. This burning can still seem like an explosive, but since the reaction is now being driven by thermal effects rather than compression, it is really not an explosive any longer. This also happens in firearms and in your car -- in both of these applications, we want the chemicals to burn, but if conditions are wrong they can detonate (that's what knocking is in your car) and damage the device.

There are two ways to measure the "power" of an explosive. One is by energy content, i.e. the total amount of energy released by the chemical reaction, typically expressed in terms of energy per unit mass -- Joules per kilogram. The other is in terms of the speed of reaction, a quantity sometimes referred to as "brisance." Both of these quantities are determined through experiment. There is no strict correlation between them -- Ammonium nitrate-fuel oil (ANFO) has a higher energy content than TNT, for instance (about 6.3 kJ/g versus 4.6 kJ/g), but TNT has higher brisance with a propagation speed of 6900 m/s vs. 5200 m/s for ANFO. Both are classified as high explosives, but they perform differently. TNT would be more useful for shattering reinforced structures or solid rock, while ANFO is more appropriate for a "cratering charge," or moving large volumes of material.

With that out of the way, let us finally turn to "nanothermite." There is such a thing, as it has been described in about two dozen scientific papers, but it has only been produced in minute quantites. Strictly speaking, nanothermite is not an explosive at all. The reactants undergo a redox reaction but only generate heat, and their reactants are molten metal oxides rather than gases. They generate no increase in pressure whatsoever. Thus, there is no Rankine-Hugoniot curve in the first place.

It has been suggested that nanothermite may be manufactured with a buffer material, and this material -- while not taking any part in the chemical reaction -- might absorb some of the heat of reaction and flash to a gas phase, kind of like a steam explosion. Indeed, laboratory nanothermite does contain trace amounts of nonparticipatory organics in order to form a "xerogel," i.e. a highly porous plastic that contains the reactants in numerous microscopic cavities, however the mass of this substrate is negligible and additional inert matter would be needed for any significant pressure effect.

IF this were done, the resulting hybrid material would still not be classified as an explosive, since the reaction would be self-sustaining only through thermal effects. Thus it would only burn. But it would be unique in that the burning speed could be supersonic.

If we ignore this technicality and measure it like an explosive, we find that nanothermite would be classified as a low explosive. This is because boiling the inert material will be a slow reaction and cannot happen fast enough to support a shock wave. In fact, the presence of the shock wave will itself try to compress the inert material back into a solid... Thus, we must see a gradual pressure rise, just like a low explosive. Paradoxically, the most effective nanothermite "explosive" would be where the reaction speed is tuned, by varying particle size and surface condition, to slow down the reaction front to exactly sonic speed, otherwise the reaction front will actually outrun the "steam" expansion and spread out the pressure front. Very weird stuff.

In terms of energy content, nanothermite has been measured to have only about 30% as much energy as normal thermite. This is because the tiny particles of aluminum invariably acquire an inert oxide coating, and the nanoparticles are so small that the coating is, in fact, a large fraction of their total mass. This leaves nanothermite with an experimentally measured energy content of about 1.5 kJ/g, or much lower than any known true explosive. But that's just for the thermite reactants. We would have to subtract from this number to account for our "steam," which will absorb energy equal to its heat of fusion vaporization. We are not likely to have much left over.

So, in conclusion:

  • Nanothermite is not an explosive at all.
  • Any attempt to make it behave like an explosive will not be powerful by any definition.
  • At best, a nanothermite derivative would be a "low" explosive.
  • The energy content of this derivative is lower than any known explosive.
  • The brisance of this derivative would be < 1 km/s, among the lowest of any known explosive.
  • Figures in the Truth Movement, attempting to claim otherwise, are liars.
 
Last edited:
Neatly summarised RM.
clap.gif
 
An explosive is a substance that, when initiated, undergoes an exothermic reaction creating a pressure wave. The reaction is also understood to be self-sustaining, where the pressure of the explosive sets off the rest of the explosive.

There are two types of explosions: Detonation, where the pressure wave created is in fact a shock wave, viz. a sharp discontinuity in pressure that travels greater than the speed of sound (in the explosive, not in the open air); or a deflagration, where the pressure rise has a finite "thickness," travelling approximately at the speed of sound. Whether your explosive detonates or deflagrates depends on whether there is a unique solution of the Rankine-Hugoniot curve (which relates conditions ahead of and behind the shock as it passes through the explosive) and the Rayleigh Line, which describes a state condition where momentum is conserved (required for the reaction to be self-sustaining or better). This solution, the so-called Chapman-Jouget Point, defines the speed of the explosion as it develops in the explosive, and determines whether it is supersonic or merely sonic.

Like explosions, explosives are generally categorized into two types. The first are the so-called "low" explosives, such as black powder, which deflagrate rather than detonate. The second, the "high" explosives, actually detonate. This difference has a profound effect upon the target.

Note that subtle changes in composition or geometry can change how an explosive behaves. Perhaps the best known example is a Fuel-Air Explosive (FAE). If you get the air mixture just right, you can have a true detonation, causing extensive destruction. In general, however, you only get a deflagration, as being slightly fuel-rich slows down the reaction and "smears" the pressure pulse.

If the mixture is way off, it won't explode at all, but merely burn in a big smoky fireball. This burning can still seem like an explosive, but since the reaction is now being driven by thermal effects rather than compression, it is really not an explosive any longer. This also happens in firearms and in your car -- in both of these applications, we want the chemicals to burn, but if conditions are wrong they can detonate (that's what knocking is in your car) and damage the device.

There are two ways to measure the "power" of an explosive. One is by energy content, i.e. the total amount of energy released by the chemical reaction, typically expressed in terms of energy per unit mass -- Joules per kilogram. The other is in terms of the speed of reaction, a quantity sometimes referred to as "brisance." Both of these quantities are determined through experiment. There is no strict correlation between them -- Ammonium nitrate-fuel oil (ANFO) has a higher energy content than TNT, for instance (about 6.3 kJ/g versus 4.6 kJ/g), but TNT has higher brisance with a propagation speed of 6900 m/s vs. 5200 m/s for ANFO. Both are classified as high explosives, but they perform differently. TNT would be more useful for shattering reinforced structures or solid rock, while ANFO is more appropriate for a "cratering charge," or moving large volumes of material.

With that out of the way, let us finally turn to "nanothermite." There is such a thing, as it has been described in about two dozen scientific papers, but it has only been produced in minute quantites. Strictly speaking, nanothermite is not an explosive at all. The reactants undergo a redox reaction but only generate heat, and their reactants are molten metal oxides rather than gases. They generate no increase in pressure whatsoever. Thus, there is no Rankine-Hugoniot curve in the first place.

It has been suggested that nanothermite may be manufactured with a buffer material, and this material -- while not taking any part in the chemical reaction -- might absorb some of the heat of reaction and flash to a gas phase, kind of like a steam explosion. Indeed, laboratory nanothermite does contain trace amounts of nonparticipatory organics in order to form a "xerogel," i.e. a highly porous plastic that contains the reactants in numerous microscopic cavities, however the mass of this substrate is negligible and additional inert matter would be needed for any significant pressure effect.

IF this were done, the resulting hybrid material would still not be classified as an explosive, since the reaction would be self-sustaining only through thermal effects. Thus it would only burn. But it would be unique in that the burning speed could be supersonic.

If we ignore this technicality and measure it like an explosive, we find that nanothermite would be classified as a low explosive. This is because boiling the inert material will be a slow reaction and cannot happen fast enough to support a shock wave. In fact, the presence of the shock wave will itself try to compress the inert material back into a solid... Thus, we must see a gradual pressure rise, just like a low explosive. Paradoxically, the most effective nanothermite "explosive" would be where the reaction speed is tuned, by varying particle size and surface condition, to slow down the reaction front to exactly sonic speed, otherwise the reaction front will actually outrun the "steam" expansion and spread out the pressure front. Very weird stuff.

In terms of energy content, nanothermite has been measured to have only about 30% as much energy as normal thermite. This is because the tiny particles of aluminum invariably acquire an inert oxide coating, and the nanoparticles are so small that the coating is, in fact, a large fraction of their total mass. This leaves nanothermite with an experimentally measured energy content of about 1.5 kJ/g, or much lower than any known true explosive. But that's just for the thermite reactants. We would have to subtract from this number to account for our "steam," which will absorb energy equal to its heat of fusion vaporization. We are not likely to have much left over.

So, in conclusion:

  • Nanothermite is not an explosive at all.
  • Any attempt to make it behave like an explosive will not be powerful by any definition.
  • At best, a nanothermite derivative would be a "low" explosive.
  • The energy content of this derivative is lower than any known explosive.
  • The brisance of this derivative would be < 1 km/s, among the lowest of any known explosive.
  • Figures in the Truth Movement, attempting to claim otherwise, are liars.

# oysteinbookmark
 
At the very best, then, a small bit of nanothermite might deflagrate and produce a bit of local over-pressurization, but that over-pressurization would be rather insignificant. It might, at best, break open a glass vessel, but so could beer bottled too soon.

Asa thermnal cutting charge, it would be pretty well useless as well because it would not stay hot enough long enough to transfer significant heat to a thick steel column.

I have made a calcium/aluminum thermite charge capable of cutting upright beams, but it is slow-burning by comparisoon to nanothermite. A block about the size of an 8-ounce coffee cup can theoreticly cut through 6 inches of steel, but it would burn for about 30 seconds and would leave identifiable residues, including a greasy plaster shell and chalky white crusts that would raise a red flag with any fire fighter or iron worker who saw it.

You would not be able to pick up pieces of it with a magnet. You can pick up most red primer paint with a magnet.
 
Just reading Griffin's book on WTC 7 and came across something. He says that nanothermite is much more powerful than conventional explosives used in demolitions. But a few pages earlier in Griffin's book he says that nanothermite doesn't have the same effects that conventional explosives do.

So let me get this straight. Nanothermite is classified as an explosive which is much more powerful than conventional explosives, but isn't as loud? Thats what Griffin is arguing. Talk about a contradiction. I'm sorry an explosive is called an explosive for a reason. It stores alot of energy and when released its going to be loud no matter what. And yet they want us to believe that nanothermite is much more powerful and not as loud at the same time, yeah right. Where do these people come up with such things? And to think, I used to be one of them.

For the current batch of twoofers it can be ANYTHING you want it to be.

it can be powerful enough to "eject beams" hundreds of feet
but it can be silent enough that it doesn't show up on any video recording of the collapses (besides in hoboken where you can clearly hear it on that one video).

It is so super powerful that it won't burn in normal office fires, but can cut horizontally or obliquely through steel columns.

It is soooo adaptable that no one will ever see it or understand it.

It can be made into ceiling tiles or a type of paint which is undetectable.

It will even make your bed, clean your room and can be used to make julien fries.
 
Just reading Griffin's book on WTC 7 and came across something. He says that nanothermite is much more powerful than conventional explosives used in demolitions. But a few pages earlier in Griffin's book he says that nanothermite doesn't have the same effects that conventional explosives do.

So let me get this straight. Nanothermite is classified as an explosive which is much more powerful than conventional explosives, but isn't as loud? Thats what Griffin is arguing. Talk about a contradiction. I'm sorry an explosive is called an explosive for a reason. It stores alot of energy and when released its going to be loud no matter what. And yet they want us to believe that nanothermite is much more powerful and not as loud at the same time, yeah right. Where do these people come up with such things? And to think, I used to be one of them.

Griffin is a philosopher by trade so he can make all the arguments he wants and in his experience they will work because they do not require physical proof only fulfill the requirements of a philosophical argument. Griffin is ignorant to anything else. He is in over his head but he will fight strenuously to maintain his scrap of turf so that the money he is making and the attention he is getting does not fade.
 
Oh nanothermite is the philosopher's stone of the 9/11 truth movement. It is magic, it has whatever characteristics they need it to have. It is rich in nutrients, it is a birth control, it removes tough stains...

And it will end the war!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom