Mystery illness in US consulate due to non-ionizing radiation?

Consumption of organic produce is increasing.

Number of people playing Dungeons and Dragons is increasing.

Therefore eating organic produce causes people to play Dungeons and Dragons.

And decreased fertility causes Alzheimer's.

And autism causes decreased fertility.

To be clear: I'm not ruling out a causative correlation between cell phone usage and some kind of health problem. It seems unlikely but many things that seemed unlikely turned out to be true, and the data that's been gathered and analysed is not yet sufficient to rule it out. But "PartSkeptic has a gut feeling" is not part of that data. It's an utterly worthless observation.
 
There is a definite correlation between the length of a thread and the degree of tenuousness of claims made. I call this the Bonkers Gradient(TM)

There is also a definite correlation between my eating porridge and the number of random assertions in this thread. Ergo, porridge increases assertiveness.

Shut up.
 
Sorry, I missed this one, and I think you're actually on to something here:

Can I argue that my "fear" of cell radiation is "real" and therefore the tower is a health hazard?


It depends on your definition of health, but you could definitely argue that your fear of cell radiation threatens your well-being. You can argue that about almost anything, so it's a good idea to distinguish between rational and irrational fears and rational and irrational solutions to these fears.
If you have a fear of measles, for instance, it may actually be rational, depending on the level of fear: The virus makes you sick, and in (nowadays and in our part of the world) extreme cases, it may even kill you. The rational solution to the problem is to be vaccinated against the disease - unless you belong to one of these minorities.
However, if you fear the color yellow, then you are suffering from xanthophobia. Your fear is 100% irrational so the color doesn't really threaten your well-being, but your phobia does. Trying to eliminate or avoid the color is the wrong way to deal with the problem.

The first step of a rational solution to your fear of cell-phone radiation is to carry out the (double-blinded!) experiment to determine if you can actually sense the difference between a cell-phone that's turned on and one that isn't. (You may even consider to have somebody remove the battery entirely to make sure that there is no electromagnetic radiation whatsoever.)
 
How much effort did you expend assessing the reliability of this source?


Here is an article (actually a book) for all you scoffers.:boggled:

https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/1977/29d1d72e619835c0b4d4199bac0cf8b26a8f.pdf

After you have properly read this, try telling me why cell phones are safe, and that they are CERTAINLY NOT to blame for consulate problems.

My instincts were (once more) correct as far as I am concerned.

The heating effects are being used as the "gold standard" for safety. Low-level triggering effects are grudgingly being acknowledged by the industry but being sidelined for obvious reasons.

They are finding that pulsed and resonant microwaves cause problems. This is a new field of study that is difficult to get repeatable experiments.

Another problem is scaling. A rat is rather small compared to a human.
 
I like this quote from the book (IEEE Wiley 2007)

"The sun may well warm a plant. Nobody says, however, that the action of the sunlight on a plant is exclusively thermal."
 
“The truth isn't easily pinned to a page. In the bathtub of history the truth is harder to hold than the soap and much more difficult to find.”

― Terry Pratchett, Sourcery
 
Here is an article (actually a book) for all you scoffers.:boggled:

https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/1977/29d1d72e619835c0b4d4199bac0cf8b26a8f.pdf

After you have properly read this, try telling me why cell phones are safe, and that they are CERTAINLY NOT to blame for consulate problems.

My instincts were (once more) correct as far as I am concerned.

The heating effects are being used as the "gold standard" for safety. Low-level triggering effects are grudgingly being acknowledged by the industry but being sidelined for obvious reasons.

They are finding that pulsed and resonant microwaves cause problems. This is a new field of study that is difficult to get repeatable experiments.

Another problem is scaling. A rat is rather small compared to a human.

Tell you what - it's your claim you tell us why - once you've properly read the book of course.
 
Tell you what - it's your claim you tell us why - once you've properly read the book of course.


I have read the book. It supports my claims, although it is 2007. It is however trying to steer a neutral course. The authors clearly know (and say it) the contentious issues.

No-one here has done any research, and if they have, it is to check what the agencies say. There is now a flood of studies with possible risks. The similarity to the tobacco and leaded gasoline toxicity scandals are becoming very evident.

BTW. Up to 1940 (not 1840) it was thought that defective babies were due to hereditary causes. Fetal alcohol syndrome changed that thinking.

I feel like I am debating flat-earthers.
 
I have read the book. It supports my claims, although it is 2007.

Then it's a bit odd that you haven't actually been able to score a single point in this thread. Thus far you have not demonstrated a keen understanding of non-ionising radiation.

No-one here has done any research, and if they have, it is to check what the agencies say. There is now a flood of studies with possible risks.

I did enough research to determine that your previous source, the Bio-Initiative Report, is published by a bunch of political activists and a consultant who delivers EMF fearmongering for dollars, and the fact that the papers published in both reports have serious quality issues and reflect excessive levels of confirmation bias.
 
A glance at the contents page shows that it contains no data whatsoever on correlations, let alone possibly causative correlations, between cell phone usage and health problems. The only relevant sections seem to be about mechanisms by which non ionising radiation might have an affect on biological tissue. That's akin to speculating about the mechanisms by which homeopathy might work without first establishing that it does work.

ETA: I've now scanned the book and it appears to be a fairly comprehensive summary of the research into the effects of various kinds of radiation on biological tissue. The main focus seems to be on medical uses, but there are a few mentions of general public exposure where the conclusion is usually that most studies have shown no ill effect but further studies are needed, with which I would not disagree.
 
Last edited:
Did you find time to do the double-blinded test yet, PartSkeptic?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom