My 'new' type of government/economic system: Anarcho-Socialism

Dartfishy is not suggesting he has the solution to the world's problems in the one true just system. He is just floating an interesting idea to see if people can poke holes in it.

Unfortunately it's utopian -- literally, as it will work nowhere. The problem, as G. K. Chesterton said about similar schemes in the past, is that you start with the assumption that nobody will want more than their share -- and then argue whether this share should be delivered to them by motor-car or airship.
 
Give it 20 years. But yes. If we were able to halt population growth we are probably at this point able to produce a post scarcity society in terms of food and water.

"A post scarcity society in terms of <limited list of goods>" is almost oxymoronic.

I don't want "food and water"; I want food that tastes good, decent wine, and perhaps fresh-ground coffee. I don't want to subsist on the prepack Soylent Green and MREs that we can supply in unlimited quantities to everyone in the world.

When we get to the point where we can supply actual meat and fresh veg to everyone, people will still want out-of-season fruit and single malt liquor.

If we can supply "shelter" in the form of a cot in a gymnasium somewhere to everyone, people will still want private rooms. If we can supply private rooms, people will still want ensuite showers. If we can supply showers, they'll want bathrooms -- or hot tubs.

So we're back in a scarcity society again.
 
"A post scarcity society in terms of <limited list of goods>" is almost oxymoronic.

I don't want "food and water"; I want food that tastes good, decent wine, and perhaps fresh-ground coffee. I don't want to subsist on the prepack Soylent Green and MREs that we can supply in unlimited quantities to everyone in the world.

It is however a useful way of measureing progress in that dirrection. In pratice of your list the only problematical one would be coffee (currently we tend towards something of a wine surplus).

When we get to the point where we can supply actual meat and fresh veg to everyone, people will still want out-of-season fruit and single malt liquor.

Meats is a problem the others less so.

If we can supply "shelter" in the form of a cot in a gymnasium somewhere to everyone, people will still want private rooms. If we can supply private rooms, people will still want ensuite showers. If we can supply showers, they'll want bathrooms -- or hot tubs.

So we're back in a scarcity society again.

I didn't claim otherwise. However if we are able to bring population growth under control then we have the technological capacity to move in the dirrection of a post scarcity society.
 
Dartfishy is not suggesting he has the solution to the world's problems in the one true just system. He is just floating an interesting idea to see if people can poke holes in it.

Unfortunately it's utopian -- literally, as it will work nowhere. The problem, as G. K. Chesterton said about similar schemes in the past, is that you start with the assumption that nobody will want more than their share -- and then argue whether this share should be delivered to them by motor-car or airship.

"Their share" only makes sense in terms of personal ownership something that anarcho communism would of course not accept.

Now for many many reasons anarcho communism is not useful as a currently posible form of goverment. It is to an extent useful as a long term aim.
 
"Their share" only makes sense in terms of personal ownership something that anarcho communism would of course not accept.

No, "their share" also makes sense in terms of personal allocation, not just ownership. "My share" of an airplane is the amount of seating and luggage space divided by the number of passengers, which is why I get annoyed when someone else comes on with six carry-on suitcases. I don't own the airplane or own the space. But I did have a reasonable expectation of being allocated enough space for my suitcase, and now I don't have it, because someone else took "my share."

If in our post-scarcity society I am allocated 2000 calories of Soylent Green, what happens if I want more? Perhaps I've got a legitimate reason for it (I've been working hard, or I'm temporarily ill that causes me to need more food); perhaps I'm just greedy. But either way, in a true post-scarcity society, I could simply get as much more as I needed.

If we need to worry about whether or not there's enough Soylent Green (or coffee) to go around, then we need to worry about "fair shares."
 
Unless we dump international trade and capitalism in favor of centrally planned welfare states we won't have to worry about humanity being threatened by a scarcity of resources. Oil won’t run out either…

I’d apply for the Randi $1.1 million but I think they’re smart enough to see that I’m not predicting the future just applying basic economic logic.
 
Unless we dump international trade and capitalism in favor of centrally planned welfare states we won't have to worry about humanity being threatened by a scarcity of resources.

There is a difference between "humanity" and "civilisation".
 
No, "their share" also makes sense in terms of personal allocation, not just ownership. "My share" of an airplane is the amount of seating and luggage space divided by the number of passengers, which is why I get annoyed when someone else comes on with six carry-on suitcases. I don't own the airplane or own the space. But I did have a reasonable expectation of being allocated enough space for my suitcase, and now I don't have it, because someone else took "my share."

Except when you purchased the ticket you expected it to come with enough space for your suitcase. In fact tickets general come with the offer of allowing you a certian amount of carryon luggage.

If in our post-scarcity society I am allocated 2000 calories of Soylent Green,

The odds of any food stable appearing that isn't grain or yeast based are minaimal although we are makeing progress on vat grown meat.

what happens if I want more? Perhaps I've got a legitimate reason for it (I've been working hard, or I'm temporarily ill that causes me to need more food); perhaps I'm just greedy. But either way, in a true post-scarcity society, I could simply get as much more as I needed.

Under anarcho communism you would just take more. If you get fat that is your problem.


If we need to worry about whether or not there's enough Soylent Green (or coffee) to go around, then we need to worry about "fair shares."

At the present time there is enough food produced on this planet to feed everyone. If fair shares are to be a concern then we must reject the current system.

The ususal argument is social pressures keep people inline to an extent. You don't build your house out of grain because well that would be impolite.
 
This is definitely reminiscent of Libertarian Socialism, but with less of an emphasis on Syndicalism.



From anecdotal experience, I find that many libertarians are quite... impassioned in their beliefs. Out of curiosity, how did your libertarianism affect your current anarcho-socialism? What drove you away from libertarianism?

Pretty much seeing first hand that a more socialised nation (i.e Finland) can not only work but provide things that more Free Market Nations have difficulty in doing, e.g. free higher education for me, as a citizen of another country. Of course there are certain circumstances in Finland and the other Scandanavian countries that makes a more socialised society easer.

The second thing was working with the rural and poor people in South Africa as part of a University project. Something just clicked inside me that made me realise that the invisible hand is never gonna get to these people. There is really a need to some government intervention at these levels.

I still think that private enterprise is a great way to drive innovation and wealth creation, I just don't think it should be the only way, nor that it should be unfettered.
 
Dartfishy is not suggesting he has the solution to the world's problems in the one true just system. He is just floating an interesting idea to see if people can poke holes in it.

Unfortunately it's utopian -- literally, as it will work nowhere. The problem, as G. K. Chesterton said about similar schemes in the past, is that you start with the assumption that nobody will want more than their share -- and then argue whether this share should be delivered to them by motor-car or airship.

Thanx for that quote, it's one of my favourites when it comes to Utopian ideas and something I tried to keep in mind when floating my idea. Of course I do assume that everybody will be happy with their share though I'm not convinced that will ever happen.

I do see some elements of it happening in small localised domains though, e.g. open source.

The thing that makes Open Source relevant to this discussion is not that people are giving away software for free. I've given away software for free, designed a website for someone for free etc. but it was generally somebody I knew first hand, someone in my close community. Through the technology of the internet that kind of sharing can spread across the world, which has really enabled the Open Source moment to gain a lot more traction.

I wonder thus if more technological advances will not possible create more opportunities for these kind of communities to be created?
 
I'm writing this OP for two major reasons:

(1) To see if this idea of mine is new at all (hence the scare quotes in the title), since a lot of ideas one has tends to be a re-hash of some old idea that you just haven't heard about.

(2) To hear some good criticism against the idea. Most of the posters here in the politics forum are able to take a political position apart in very few words in a succinct and decisive manner so I would like to see how my idea holds up.

Essentially this idea sprung up from my own political/economic journey. A couple of years ago I was essentially a libertarian, very much pro-Free Market and as much deregulation as possible (I blame a combination of Slashdot and Civilization).

Through my interactions on this forum as well as my experiences in the more socialised countries e.g. Finland, I've moved towards the idea that a Socialist system has more advantages than a purely Free market system. This is especially pertinent in my own country (South Africa) where there is a large gulf between rich and poor with a large part of the country living in abject poverty, with their only possible recourse being welfare and government support.

Having gone through this change in perspective I come to my idea for a possible new type of economic system government, i.e. a combination of both systems.

Essentially, this would be a true free market. I.e. everything would be free :p

Ok I can see you shaking your heads and waiting for me to link to the crazy website with all the bright colours... hang on a bit before consigning me to the loony bin.

Let's look at an example of how this would work to try and clarify what I mean a little more:

Joe is a baker, baking bread, buns, rolls, cakes etc. Everyday he bakes approximately enough food for a 100 people (as an example). So in our society he keeps enough for him and his family and gives the rest away for free. Jack is a doctor who lives in the same community. Each day he takes enough free bread from Joe to feed himself and his family. He provides his services as a doctor for free. One of his patients in John who works on a farm close by, that gives away its flour for free, to amongst others Joe the baker.

The idea is that because everybody gives away their labor for free nobody will every want for anything. Kind of like a real world application of the Open Source movement.

Obviously there are a couple of major problems with this system which I will try and highlight and answer:

(1a) Infrastructure. There will still need to be some basic infrastructure, e.g. electricity, transportation, health etc. to allow this kind of society to function.
(1b) Possible solution: There would still be large government projects which would be done with a 'labour tax' i.e. providing one day a month of your labour in your specialty to assist in some large project. John the farmer could provide manual labour, while Joe the baker could provide food for the other workers on the project etc.

(2) People unable/unwilling to contribute. There will be those who are unable (through disability or some other reason) to contribute and those who might not want to contribute.
(2b) Possible solution: The idea would be that by giving away most of your labour for free, you allow those who cannot contribute a kind of welfare, whereby they can get their basic needs fulfilled. If the proportion of people who are 'spunging' off the system is small enough this problem should not be catastrophic for the system.

(3) Large projects, high technology: How to produce large projects (anything from a car to a airplane) and things that require high levels of technology.
(3b) Possible solution: Collaborative projects between individuals, that provide their entire production for free.

(4) How to move towards this kind of society?
(4b) Possible solution: No idea, but maybe a gradual evolution of society.

Now the final bit (and I'm trying to keep this short still), what are the advantages of this system (if it runs moderately well):

- People will be able to do what they love. If you are an artist, you don't need to worry about getting paid, because as you give things away for free, so you can get things for free.
- The poor, disabled, less fortunate will be taken care of. Because everything is free, the concept of somebody who is poor will not really exist.
- Relative financial safety. So long as there are enough people producing the things you need, you will never go hungry, cold, homeless etc.

Ok... I'm pretty sure this system is full of holes, but let's have at it anyway. Please feel free to ask for more clarification on some of the issues.

This sounds like you might be interested in this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_threefolding
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom