My Lai Cover-Up

bonavada

Unregistered
Joined
Mar 26, 2006
Messages
1,073
a very interesting programme on BBC Radio 4 last night:-

The Mai Lai Tapes

today is the 40th anniversay of this, one of Americas darkest days and the broadcast offers a little insight into the botched cover-up that followed the massacre.
what interested me (with respect to most of the topics discussed in this forum) is that despite:

all the american witnesses to the events that morning being US government employees (US armed forces)
the atrocity happening in a remote environment with powerful US entities in complete control

is that the terrible details quickly became worldwide knowledge.

surely this must put the lie to the "impossibly vast conspiracy of 9/11" as pomeroo so succinctly puts it.

BV
 
[truther] ahhh but they done gone learned from past mistakes and 9-11 woz done better than those old ones so it woz kept seekrit from sheeple but is obvious to people like wot i am, innit? [/truther]
 
a very interesting programme on BBC Radio 4 last night:-

The Mai Lai Tapes

today is the 40th anniversay of this, one of Americas darkest days and the broadcast offers a little insight into the botched cover-up that followed the massacre.
what interested me (with respect to most of the topics discussed in this forum) is that despite:

all the american witnesses to the events that morning being US government employees (US armed forces)
the atrocity happening in a remote environment with powerful US entities in complete control

is that the terrible details quickly became worldwide knowledge.

surely this must put the lie to the "impossibly vast conspiracy of 9/11" as pomeroo so succinctly puts it.

BV

The same can be said for Abu Ghraib.
 
Another thing to point out - Some tried to stop the parts of the tragedy they saw and could do something about:

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5133444

You'll note that Mr. Thompson's crew did not merely pull civillians out of the area, they also deliberately confronted other soldiers in order to try and stop the killings. Most people who are essentially of good character will try to do right when it's obvious that extreme wrongs are being committed.

Yet, despite the abundance of examples of people doing the right thing in important situations, we're somehow supposed to believe that buildings obviously still in use got wired for demolitions in preparations for a grand deception without a single person coming forward and revealing it after it became obvious that the deception entailed killing innocent people.

Yet, somehow, we're supposed to believe that the military was "stood down" with no ATC coming forward to ask why the hell the response never materialized.

Yet, somehow, we're supposed to believe that firefighters were pulled back from rescue and firefighting operations, without any of them coming forward asking why they were ordered back from buildings that weren't dangerously aflame or in danger of collapsing.

Fine. I'll admit that this whole post is a big fat argument from incredulity. But in turn, I'll argue that the credulity necessary to swallow those arguments can only take place if one ignores past examples of human behavior.
 
[truther] ahhh but they done gone learned from past mistakes and 9-11 woz done better than those old ones so it woz kept seekrit from sheeple but is obvious to people like wot i am, innit? [/truther]

That's a pretty poor impersonation of a "truther" uk_dave. Since when did they say "innit"? Or write in lower case?
 
Another thing to point out - Some tried to stop the parts of the tragedy they saw and could do something about:

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5133444

You'll note that Mr. Thompson's crew did not merely pull civillians out of the area, they also deliberately confronted other soldiers in order to try and stop the killings. Most people who are essentially of good character will try to do right when it's obvious that extreme wrongs are being committed.
My personal heroes of that war. And have been since I first heard of it while at Long Binh.
 
You'll note that Mr. Thompson's crew did not merely pull civillians out of the area, they also deliberately confronted other soldiers in order to try and stop the killings. Most people who are essentially of good character will try to do right when it's obvious that extreme wrongs are being committed.
I just wanted to comment on this. It has been demonstrated experimentally that the majority of people will obey orders, despite the fact that they are being ordered to commit extreme wrongs. Very few will actually stand up for the right thing.
 
In a thread here a year or so back, that was reported on re: girl who was forced by two MCDonald managers/personnell to strip + because ordered to by a "detective" on the phone. The person who stopped it was a black custodian. Good people take lots of forms - just not an overabundance of them. Yes, many people just take orders and follow them. Part of why/how I differentiate between soldiers and warriors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom