My close encounters of the 9/11 "truther" kind

It'a a matter of being closed to information that contradicts what they believe, and want to believe, it's quite common with woosters of all types; biblical literalist xians don't want to know about the errors and contradictions in the bible, believers in homeopathy don't embrace studies that show it doesn't work, holocaust deniers actively avoid facts about the holocaust, et cetera, et cetera.

I wish I could remember where I read this, but I once saw a story about a man who was arguing with a woman who was a biblical literalist xians. They were outside during the daytime. The woman insisted that you could not see the Moon in the daytime. The man pointed out that, in fact, you could see the Moon in the daytime, and if she looked up at that moment, she'd see the moon above them. The woman refused to look up.

I have never understood someone so afraid of seeing contradictory evidence to that degree. I ,mean, I understand it in an academic, theoretical way, but I find it very, very difficult to put myself in their shoes...
 
I only really have one personal experience with a truther...it wasn't even really directed at me.

My fire dept was doing an EMS standby at a local lawn fete, and we were just hanging around one of the engines we brought with us so the kids could have a look around. As one of the kids was wandering through the back of the cab, the dad asked my buddy why he got into the company. My buddy says that, in part, it was due to seeing the bravery of the FDNY on 9/11.

The dad says, "well, knowing what I know about the events that day, those guys weren't really brave, just mis-led."

My buddy and I kind of give him a weird look...

He continues..."well, the higher ups should have told them the buildings were rigged to come down, right?"

My jaw dropped, speechless. My buddy says, without blinking, "yeah, they knew...but you gotta keep your voice down...we aren't supposed to talk about it. We all get monthly checks from the government to keep quiet about that. You know, if you join the company, they'll set you up, too!"

The dad doesn't say another word...just collects his kid and hussles out of there...

We still joke about that...we always wondered if the guy's head exploded later that night...
 
I only really have one personal experience with a truther...it wasn't even really directed at me.

My fire dept was doing an EMS standby at a local lawn fete, and we were just hanging around one of the engines we brought with us so the kids could have a look around. As one of the kids was wandering through the back of the cab, the dad asked my buddy why he got into the company. My buddy says that, in part, it was due to seeing the bravery of the FDNY on 9/11.

The dad says, "well, knowing what I know about the events that day, those guys weren't really brave, just mis-led."

My buddy and I kind of give him a weird look...

He continues..."well, the higher ups should have told them the buildings were rigged to come down, right?"

My jaw dropped, speechless. My buddy says, without blinking, "yeah, they knew...but you gotta keep your voice down...we aren't supposed to talk about it. We all get monthly checks from the government to keep quiet about that. You know, if you join the company, they'll set you up, too!"

The dad doesn't say another word...just collects his kid and hussles out of there...

We still joke about that...we always wondered if the guy's head exploded later that night...

Don't you mean imploded?
 
Dash, what does he say when he comes by your house? I mean, why has he zeroed in on you to harass? because you where there? Does he think you are just going to blurt out that you are a paid government shill? :boggled:
I think the moron really thinks I'd admit lying/being a shill. It really wound him up to meet someone who actually witnessed the events, there's little truthers can do apart from the standard "shill!" remarks. I also got the "what you saw was a missile" crap thrown at me. It's pathetic really, the guy is actually quite intelligent in general.
 
Last edited:
One of the standard claims that the truthbots use to "prove" it was an inside job is the Silverstein quote - "Pull it" wrt building 7.

I've worn out a keyboard trying to explain that the term has no relation to demo work in any way, shape or form.

My attempts at education have only resulted in being called every bolierplate truthbot response - dupe, sheeple, you name it.

If I reference my training and experience, the only thing I could possibly be is a shill...

I believe catsmate hit it on the head - it's a "Faith = Fact" construct.
 
One of the standard claims that the truthbots use to "prove" it was an inside job is the Silverstein quote - "Pull it" wrt building 7.

I've worn out a keyboard trying to explain that the term has no relation to demo work in any way, shape or form.

My attempts at education have only resulted in being called every bolierplate truthbot response - dupe, sheeple, you name it.

If I reference my training and experience, the only thing I could possibly be is a shill...

I believe catsmate hit it on the head - it's a "Faith = Fact" construct.
I learned some truther rules pretty early.

An expert (which is debatable with many truthers) who supports the truth movement is a genius.

An expert who supports the official account is a liar/shill.

A layman who supports the truth movement is smart and above "the sheeple"

A layman who supports the official account is a shill/sheeple/idiot.
 
Last edited:
In discussions of creationist woo, true believers' inability to even recognize contrary information has been given a Name: "Morton's Demon."

A bit off-topic, but I had a run in with the person who coined this phrase, Glen Morton, on another forum. Ironically, he still suffers (well, he did at that time in 2009 anyway) from his "demon" as he deniers AGW. Me and him had a long and heated discussion, but eventually he was simply denying things just like a creationist or any other kind of CT. I told him that I found it ironic, and then he left the thread.
 
Ok – I talked to one of the participants and received the all clear to write an account of their experience with a truther.

I can only wish I was on the scene to see this, as the way it was described to me was funny beyond words – I’ll try to do it justice here.

To get a leg up, check out this link:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slowly_I_Turned

Old time comedy routine that is the best way of describing this incident.

One of my friends is a dedicated hot-rodder. He builds his own stuff from pretty much scratch, other than engine machine work and final paint – everything else including interior, body work; re-engineering suspension etc. is done by him and his crew of OCB – old cheap bastard - buddies. He has a nice little collection, and one of his rides has won its class at the Oakland Roadster show, and another of his rods (with him explaining the build) made it onto the Speed channel.

He belongs to a few car clubs, and makes it to most local shows – I had to call him today while he was on the road to Reno for the Hot August Nights show.

In one of the clubs he belongs to he has a friend who is the proverbial Rocket Scientist – for real – who is a long time employee of the Lawrence Livermore Lab. The only small area of explosive employment that I’m not specifically trained in, he is. Very interesting guy with good taste in hot rods, music and a great sense of humor.

So, here’s what happened:

These two guys are displaying their cars at an informal outdoor car show, parked side-by-side. My friend has a very nice sound system in the ride he was displaying (not one of those juvenile sub-woofer deals) and as is his habit, he was playing a disc with mixed oldies, Rockabilly, and a local band that happens to be a favorite of just about everybody, Tower of Power.

There they were, minding their own business, when a young guy started talking to both of them about their rides – nothing unusual here.

At some point, this young fella stopped and listened to the music for a second, and asked “who’s that band?” My friend, quite reasonably answered “Tower of Power.”

In an instant, this kid’s face changes, and he said “Tower? Like you mean the TWIN TOWERS!” Shouting it at my friends…

When they told me this story, my friend said that his first reaction was “oh ****” and he tried to remember if he had his carry gun. His friend’s reaction (as he described it to me) was “What the ****?”

My friend described it perfectly – the kid heard the word “tower” and immediately went into a delusional zone – just like the old comedy routine.

This kid just launches into a diatribe about everything under the sun 9/11 truthbot related.

Now my friend doesn’t really know what the hell this kid is getting on about – he couldn’t care less about nut theories about anything from anyone.

His buddy had actually heard this stuff before, and decides (in retrospect a mistake, in his words) to inform the kid about where he went wrong…

My friend describes what happened next fairly well - He told me that as soon as his buddy started speaking to the kid, he lost me right after “the collapse was initiated” after that, I understood every third word.

Evidently the truthbot wasn’t interested is listening in any case, but he did ask a question of our rocket scientist, who informed him that he was a scientist, and had looked at the numbers related to kinetic energy released by the impacts and the heat of the fire, and was satisfied that the impact of the planes combined with the fire and structural damage caused the collapse of the towers – at which point the kid actually screamed at our guy, calling him a “shill” and a “murderer” at the top of his lungs – now, the wives and assorted passer-bys are involved in the action…

The kid’s yelling attracts two hired security guards, who don’t know what to make of the situation but are eye-balling the screaming nutjob.

Now enters a third individual into the discussion, another car club member who for the sake of clarity I’ll call “King Kong” – I’m 6’ 4” 210, and this guy is two of me – he looks like a non-tattooed Danny Trejo in extra large.

King Kong asks the truther “is there a problem?” again – my friend’s description and imitation of the kid was priceless – the kid does a full Hollywood double take when he gets an eyeful of KK - the kid dials down the volume, and mumbles some nonsense.

Mr. Kong motions to the security guards, who, in the words of my friend, looked more afraid of Mr. Kong than the formerly screaming nut, and Mr. Kong requested that the two escort the truthbot away from the club parking area.

The two guards do as requested, and tranquility was restored.

I’m sure I failed in my desire to replicate the humor in all this, written humor being harder than in person examples, but my eyes are wet while writing this. In my minds eye I can see the facial expressions of my friends, especially the double take the kid pulled when he noticed Mr. Kong for the first time.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It kind of worked out well for me with one individual. An acquaintance who would call, say once a week, and with whom I then felt compelled to go for a beer with. I always thought there was something off about the guy, a little bit too intense to be normal, but without ever being able to quite identify anything specific in his character (I don't think I ever discussed 9/11 issues with him, it just never came up).

Then a few months ago he posted an advert on FB for one of the Box Boy's recent speaking engagements on this side of the pond, followed by an argument with some of his friends, him throwing all the usual truther memes in there and, bam, I had the guy figured out. Now I don't feel any guilt about cutting ties so win win win.

It disappoints me, though, to see how some others, friends etc, not truthers or anything even close to it, have absorbed bits and pieces of the nonsense without realizing it.

Example. Over lunch last week, someone asked me how a plane went through "that small hole" in the Pentagon. When I quizzed him a little further, I found out he meant either the round exit hole in the C ring wall or wasn't sure what "small hole" he was talking about.

Good grief.
 
Ok – I talked to one of the participants and received the all clear to write an account of their experience with a truther.

I can only wish I was on the scene to see this, as the way it was described to me was funny beyond words – I’ll try to do it justice here.

To get a leg up, check out this link:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slowly_I_Turned

Old time comedy routine that is the best way of describing this incident.

One of my friends is a dedicated hot-rodder. He builds his own stuff from pretty much scratch, other than engine machine work and final paint – everything else including interior, body work; re-engineering suspension etc. is done by him and his crew of OCB – old cheap bastard - buddies. He has a nice little collection, and one of his rides has won its class at the Oakland Roadster show, and another of his rods (with him explaining the build) made it onto the Speed channel.

He belongs to a few car clubs, and makes it to most local shows – I had to call him today while he was on the road to Reno for the Hot August Nights show.

In one of the clubs he belongs to he has a friend who is the proverbial Rocket Scientist – for real – who is a long time employee of the Lawrence Livermore Lab. The only small area of explosive employment that I’m not specifically trained in, he is. Very interesting guy with good taste in hot rods, music and a great sense of humor.

So, here’s what happened:

These two guys are displaying their cars at an informal outdoor car show, parked side-by-side. My friend has a very nice sound system in the ride he was displaying (not one of those juvenile sub-woofer deals) and as is his habit, he was playing a disc with mixed oldies, Rockabilly, and a local band that happens to be a favorite of just about everybody, Tower of Power.

There they were, minding their own business, when a young guy started talking to both of them about their rides – nothing unusual here.

At some point, this young fella stopped and listened to the music for a second, and asked “who’s that band?” My friend, quite reasonably answered “Tower of Power.”

In an instant, this kid’s face changes, and he said “Tower? Like you mean the TWIN TOWERS!” Shouting it at my friends…

When they told me this story, my friend said that his first reaction was “oh ◊◊◊◊” and he tried to remember if he had his carry gun. His friend’s reaction (as he described it to me) was “What the ****?”

My friend described it perfectly – the kid heard the word “tower” and immediately went into a delusional zone – just like the old comedy routine.

This kid just launches into a diatribe about everything under the sun 9/11 truthbot related.

Now my friend doesn’t really know what the hell this kid is getting on about – he couldn’t care less about nut theories about anything from anyone.

His buddy had actually heard this stuff before, and decides (in retrospect a mistake, in his words) to inform the kid about where he went wrong…

My friend describes what happened next fairly well - He told me that as soon as his buddy started speaking to the kid, he lost me right after “the collapse was initiated” after that, I understood every third word.

Evidently the truthbot wasn’t interested is listening in any case, but he did ask a question of our rocket scientist, who informed him that he was a scientist, and had looked at the numbers related to kinetic energy released by the impacts and the heat of the fire, and was satisfied that the impact of the planes combined with the fire and structural damage caused the collapse of the towers – at which point the kid actually screamed at our guy, calling him a “shill” and a “murderer” at the top of his lungs – now, the wives and assorted passer-bys are involved in the action…

The kid’s yelling attracts two hired security guards, who don’t know what to make of the situation but are eye-balling the screaming nutjob.

Now enters a third individual into the discussion, another car club member who for the sake of clarity I’ll call “King Kong” – I’m 6’ 4” 210, and this guy is two of me – he looks like a non-tattooed Danny Trejo in extra large.

King Kong asks the truther “is there a problem?” again – my friend’s description and imitation of the kid was priceless – the kid does a full Hollywood double take when he gets an eyeful of KK - the kid dials down the volume, and mumbles some nonsense.

Mr. Kong motions to the security guards, who, in the words of my friend, looked more afraid of Mr. Kong than the formerly screaming nut, and Mr. Kong requested that the two escort the truthbot away from the club parking area.

The two guards do as requested, and tranquility was restored.

I’m sure I failed in my desire to replicate the humor in all this, written humor being harder than in person examples, but my eyes are wet while writing this. In my minds eye I can see the facial expressions of my friends, especially the double take the kid pulled when he noticed Mr. Kong for the first time.

Thanks BStrong. You captured the moment well in this story as well as your personal encounters. This I will certainly take away with me:
They assert, they get offended, they leave.

Thanks again!
 
What surprises me is the absolute refusal to listen to anyone with experience and credentials that doesn't agree with them.

There are many things that I don't have the foggiest idea about that are often subjects of discussion.

If I don't know anything about a subject, but am interested in it, I'll research the subect, preferably with someone I know that has expertise in the field - even then I'm more inclined to keep my mouth shut than spout off.

In the case of truthbots, it seems that the less they know, they more they spout off.

Yes, but what's worse is that Truthers will tell the person they are engaging that the listener is being close-minded. Truthers are the absolute anti-thesis of open-minded.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom