Caustic Logic
Illuminator
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2007
- Messages
- 4,494
*Note - beware, mixed sarcasm in spots below*
I was just trying to work something up on the motives alleged to Libya, and it occurred to me I don't know as much as I should about the subject. Since my favorite way to learn about something is to start a discussion about it and hope some old timers with learnin' in their whiskers will pop in.
So, I'll start. Uh... well, Wikipedia says this:
Deceptive patterns: heavy use of "alleged." Is it true or not? Why doesn't this author know the exact answer? Then, on the naval encounters - I presume it was Naval forces shooting down those jets. There's no mention of the heavy U.S. losses in those engagements. Seriously, Libyans getting killed without attacking first? They always attack, evil little buggers. We probably lost 3 ships for each of theirs.
So, defensive actions by noble US forces minding their own business in "Libyan" waters leads to a nightclub bombing in revenge. Well, the nerve! So we bomb some targets including by accident a girl he "adopted," whatever exactly that means, who must have lived somewhere very near a legitimate military/terrorist site? So he gets all miffed and orders a hijacking. AND this other list of atrocities, taking dozens of lives all over the world, from another Wiki page. AND then, two and a half years later, the bombing of PA 103 which killed 270. No "said to" about it, it's just true, and all the plots go right to the top. Colonel Daffy Gaddafi/Qaddafy/Khadaffee, always, the evil genius hovering with omnipotent insatiable bloodlust and that weird, hate-able face. God I hate that guy!
Sorry... back to the subject at hand. I'm having a hard time seeing it. Of course, I don't believe any of the evidence against Libya either, so maybe I need some help. But in revenge for the deaths of about 40 people I hear, he'll launch the terrorstorm in that link, and also wait nearly three years and then order a bombing that makes 259 completely innocent people and their plane fall on 11 others?
It's possible, I suppose. It's fact, many will flatly say. But the symmetry and timing are off and I'm left wondering again "why are we suspecting Libyans at all?" That question's been addressed well elsewhere - the evidence is all bad or fake. But that has little impact on people who can so clearly see the motive, the means, and the will for the Black Colonel to launch such a cold attack.
But for comparion, I'm also wondering why this isn't a pretty good motive/revenge pairing:
1) The US takes a high-tech, expensive, non-losable/jumpy/aggressive robotic warship specializing in identifying and shooting down a hundred planes or missiles at the same time. Sends it in to help enforce sanction on Iran fight coast guard units trying pathetically to impose their embargo on Iraq. This is mid-1988, at the end of the Iraq-Iran War. The ship misidentifies one civilian airliner ascending to cruising altitude as a fighter on attack profile and destroys it with two missiles. 290 innocent people are sent falling miles to their deaths. US apologizes as sternly as possible, awards he sailors responsible, and Iran agrees to a cease-fire within a few weeks.
2) Iran takes America's investigative whitewashes as whitewashes, decided the attack was intended, probably to help badger them into surrender, and vows it will not pass without revenge. Meetings are held to plan the revenge, $10 million is reportedly paid out. Iranian Qanon e-Qesas mandates equal retaliation. Bombs triggered by altimeters and hidden in consumer electronics are commissioned, with a PFLPGC cell in Germany, and built, by a Jordanian intelligence asset. These are made to destroy a plane, in the air - at cruising altitude, usually 35-45 minutes after takeoff. The group making them is busted in late October but a few live bombs are unaccounted for.
3) Pan Am 103 blows up Dec 21 1988, 38 minutes after leaving London, and reaching cruising altitude. As described, 270 people are killed, most of them only after falling miles.
4) We're to believe that the PFLPGC cell and its bomb and plots stopped with the October bust and was then replaced with, by coincidence (?), Libya's bizarrely belated and overblown revenge for the '86 bombings? Again? In just the right time and way and death toll to fit the bill of Iran's required revenge? Even down to accidentally mimicking, with their surprisingly durable timers, the effect of the PFLPGC altimeter bombs?
5) And the Iranians never did get their revenge?
Discuss.
I was just trying to work something up on the motives alleged to Libya, and it occurred to me I don't know as much as I should about the subject. Since my favorite way to learn about something is to start a discussion about it and hope some old timers with learnin' in their whiskers will pop in.
So, I'll start. Uh... well, Wikipedia says this:
Alleged motive
The motive that is generally attributed to Libya can be traced back to a series of military confrontations with the US Navy that took place in the 1980s in the Gulf of Sidra—Libya's "territorial waters." First, there was the Gulf of Sidra incident (1981) when two Libyan fighter aircraft were shot down. Then, two Libyan radio ships were sunk in the Gulf of Sidra. Later, on 23 March 1986 a Libyan Navy patrol boat was sunk in the Gulf of Sidra,[71] followed by the sinking of another Libyan vessel on 25 March 1986.[72]
The Libyan leader, Muammar al-Gaddafi, was accused of retaliating to these sinkings by ordering the 5 April 1986 bombing of West Berlin nightclub, La Belle, that was frequented by U.S. soldiers and which killed three and injured 230.
The CIA's alleged interception of an incriminatory message from Libya to its embassy in East Berlin provided U.S. president Ronald Reagan with the justification for USAF warplanes to launch Operation El Dorado Canyon on 15 April 1986 from British bases[74][75] —the first U.S. military strikes from Britain since World War II—against Tripoli and Benghazi in Libya.
Among dozens of Libyan military and civilian casualties, the air strikes killed Hanna Gaddafi, a baby girl Gaddafi said he adopted, To avenge his daughter's death, Gaddafi is said to have sponsored the September 1986 hijacking of Pan Am Flight 73 in Karachi, Pakistan.[76]
Deceptive patterns: heavy use of "alleged." Is it true or not? Why doesn't this author know the exact answer? Then, on the naval encounters - I presume it was Naval forces shooting down those jets. There's no mention of the heavy U.S. losses in those engagements. Seriously, Libyans getting killed without attacking first? They always attack, evil little buggers. We probably lost 3 ships for each of theirs.
So, defensive actions by noble US forces minding their own business in "Libyan" waters leads to a nightclub bombing in revenge. Well, the nerve! So we bomb some targets including by accident a girl he "adopted," whatever exactly that means, who must have lived somewhere very near a legitimate military/terrorist site? So he gets all miffed and orders a hijacking. AND this other list of atrocities, taking dozens of lives all over the world, from another Wiki page. AND then, two and a half years later, the bombing of PA 103 which killed 270. No "said to" about it, it's just true, and all the plots go right to the top. Colonel Daffy Gaddafi/Qaddafy/Khadaffee, always, the evil genius hovering with omnipotent insatiable bloodlust and that weird, hate-able face. God I hate that guy!
Sorry... back to the subject at hand. I'm having a hard time seeing it. Of course, I don't believe any of the evidence against Libya either, so maybe I need some help. But in revenge for the deaths of about 40 people I hear, he'll launch the terrorstorm in that link, and also wait nearly three years and then order a bombing that makes 259 completely innocent people and their plane fall on 11 others?
It's possible, I suppose. It's fact, many will flatly say. But the symmetry and timing are off and I'm left wondering again "why are we suspecting Libyans at all?" That question's been addressed well elsewhere - the evidence is all bad or fake. But that has little impact on people who can so clearly see the motive, the means, and the will for the Black Colonel to launch such a cold attack.
But for comparion, I'm also wondering why this isn't a pretty good motive/revenge pairing:
1) The US takes a high-tech, expensive, non-losable/jumpy/aggressive robotic warship specializing in identifying and shooting down a hundred planes or missiles at the same time. Sends it in to help enforce sanction on Iran fight coast guard units trying pathetically to impose their embargo on Iraq. This is mid-1988, at the end of the Iraq-Iran War. The ship misidentifies one civilian airliner ascending to cruising altitude as a fighter on attack profile and destroys it with two missiles. 290 innocent people are sent falling miles to their deaths. US apologizes as sternly as possible, awards he sailors responsible, and Iran agrees to a cease-fire within a few weeks.
2) Iran takes America's investigative whitewashes as whitewashes, decided the attack was intended, probably to help badger them into surrender, and vows it will not pass without revenge. Meetings are held to plan the revenge, $10 million is reportedly paid out. Iranian Qanon e-Qesas mandates equal retaliation. Bombs triggered by altimeters and hidden in consumer electronics are commissioned, with a PFLPGC cell in Germany, and built, by a Jordanian intelligence asset. These are made to destroy a plane, in the air - at cruising altitude, usually 35-45 minutes after takeoff. The group making them is busted in late October but a few live bombs are unaccounted for.
3) Pan Am 103 blows up Dec 21 1988, 38 minutes after leaving London, and reaching cruising altitude. As described, 270 people are killed, most of them only after falling miles.
4) We're to believe that the PFLPGC cell and its bomb and plots stopped with the October bust and was then replaced with, by coincidence (?), Libya's bizarrely belated and overblown revenge for the '86 bombings? Again? In just the right time and way and death toll to fit the bill of Iran's required revenge? Even down to accidentally mimicking, with their surprisingly durable timers, the effect of the PFLPGC altimeter bombs?
5) And the Iranians never did get their revenge?
Discuss.