Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

If you were sincerely interested in the topic and your attitude wouldn't be to deconstruct the BS* of a little object of studies like me, you would know that i don't have an answer to your questons.

I still want to know how you explain Reynold's morphing from an anti-workers-right economist to a person who not only supports some 911 CTs - which i appreciate in the case of Ray McGovern and others - but spread silliest delusions so obvious false that even the hardcore conspiracists have problems with him.

Questions about me are not relevant to this discussion but if you honestly wanna understand my position, i urge you to read this book: Edward Bernays - Propaganda

*Believe System

So the fact that a conservative economist and Bush appointee becomes a cter is not the problem, correct? Let's be clear about this one. There could be other conservatives who have lost faith in the Bush admin. for one reason or another. This fact alone is hardly suspicious.

It's the 'silliness' of the no-plane theory that bothers you, correct? Reynolds seems to be a smart guy, an accomplished academic, and such people don't promote silly theories, unless of course they have an ulterior motive, correct?

I would suggest to you that the no-plane theory is not SO much sillier than the other CTs out there. Fake cell calls, no plane at Pentagon, nukes, drones, remote-controlled Boeings, it's all pretty wacky. Only LIHOP seems remotely reasonable to me. Yet there are a smattering of academics and 'serious' intellectuals that hold all the above mentioned positions. Reynolds is not a hard scientist/ technical/mechanical type, he's an economist. His theories may simply reflect this lack of technical expertise. Furthermore you seem to know nothing about him or his mental state but are assuming much about it based on knowing only the bare outline of his credentials. I assure you there are nuts all over the place - high places too.
 
Judy Woods Billiard-Ball Paper convinced me of an ongoing COINTELPRO-scheme. I hope you like that answer but i think it's clear that my impression is subjective, hence irrelevant, isn't it?

Well, it's definitely not the answer I expected. Please, tell me more. How did Judy Woods's ridiculous paper convince you of a COINTELPRO scheme? I read it, and that was not what came to my mind.
 
What do you think?
I'm asking you because you've stated an opinion that Reynolds is a disinfo agent. You must have some angle on who is and who isn't working undercover for the USG. Otherwise you're just making that up, right?

Morgan Reynolds, maintaining his "deep cover":

Then there's Morgan O. Reynolds, appointed by George W. Bush as chief economist at the Labor Department. He left in 2002 and doesn't think much of his former boss; he describes President Bush as a "dysfunctional creep," not to mention a "possible war criminal." –Washington Post

:rolleyes:
 
Childlike Empress,

How do you explain those handful of scientists who dispute anthropogenic global warming and recieve funding from oil companies via certain right wing organisations?

Are we to assume that they are actually a cunning plot by the scientific consensus to discredit the (already) discredited bush enviroment policy and at the same time con the oil companies into coughing up some money?

Or can we rightly claim that they are more idealogically driven than scientifically driven, or that they see a way of obtaining funding and tenure by going against the mainstream, or that maybe they just aren't very good scientists?

Could the same be true of the 911 'scholars'?

IF at the end of the day they are a cunning ploy by the USG to divide the CT movement and make it look bad in the public eye, then their success is more down to the weakness of the CT movement than any skill on the part of the USG.

If the CT is damaged by these scholars then the CT should distance themselves from them. The fact that many within the CT are willing to believe these whacky theories speaks volumes about the mindset of the CT'ers.
 
So the fact that a conservative economist and Bush appointee becomes a cter is not the problem, correct? Let's be clear about this one. There could be other conservatives who have lost faith in the Bush admin. for one reason or another. This fact alone is hardly suspicious.
I may be wrong, but my reading of the Empress is that she finds his conversion from free-market voodoo economist to Bush-hating CTist suspicious. (apologies to the Empress if I'm wrong)

I think what the Empress is saying is that she finds it difficult to believe that such a hard-core conservative would suddenly 'switch to the other side,' thus, she believes him to be a double (COINTELPRO) agent. (once again, apologies to the E. if I am wrong)

My problem with finding double agents lurking in the shadows everywhere is how fine-grained this conspiracy would be. Bush/Wolfie/Cheney didn't need COINTELPRO; they just went out and brazenly lied about the intelligence, and got everything they wanted, because the googly-eyed, star-struck mainstream media just swallowed it all and regurgitated it out to the public, with fancy graphics.

COINTELPRO? They don't need no stinkin' COINTELPRO!

Just one person's $.02, highly devalued in this economy.
 
I assure you there are nuts all over the place - high places too.

For sure. In case of Reynolds not only his theories but his aggressive attitude make me sceptic.

@R.: This paper is so stupid that anyone who has the slightest clue on what is going on in engineering sees that is is BS*. This woman is either braindead or has different motives. She still is active so i think braindead is not an option.

Cu, folks - perhaps someone finds a better explanation for Reynolds behaviour until i wake up again.

* Bullsh!t
 
During the cold war, within the intelligence community, there was a condition commonly known as 'sick think'

This has now transfered into the CT community

Though in some cases the 'think' part has been dropped.
 
I may be wrong, but my reading of the Empress is that she finds his conversion from free-market voodoo economist to Bush-hating CTist suspicious. (apologies to the Empress if I'm wrong)

I think what the Empress is saying is that she finds it difficult to believe that such a hard-core conservative would suddenly 'switch to the other side,' thus, she believes him to be a double (COINTELPRO) agent. (once again, apologies to the E. if I am wrong)

My problem with finding double agents lurking in the shadows everywhere is how fine-grained this conspiracy would be. Bush/Wolfie/Cheney didn't need COINTELPRO; they just went out and brazenly lied about the intelligence, and got everything they wanted, because the googly-eyed, star-struck mainstream media just swallowed it all and regurgitated it out to the public, with fancy graphics.

COINTELPRO? They don't need no stinkin' COINTELPRO!

Just one person's $.02, highly devalued in this economy.

I think it is difficult to believe that a person with Reynolds vita turns into a raving lunatic all of a sudden. And i don't agree with you that no COINTELPRO was needed.
 
For sure. In case of Reynolds not only his theories but his aggressive attitude make me sceptic.

@R.: This paper is so stupid that anyone who has the slightest clue on what is going on in engineering sees that is is BS*. This woman is either braindead or has different motives. She still is active so i think braindead is not an option.
Well, sure, I agree with that. In fact, I'd say virtually every Conspiracy Theorist paper is transparently false to anyone with a modicum of scientific training. I can only think of a couple that required any real scrutiny, out of the admittedly small cross-section I've examined.

There are many "different motives," though. Some I'd like you to think about:

  • Profit (off of paranoiacs who believe any conspiracy theory)
  • Partisan political agenda ("bring our troops home at any cost")
  • Feeling of membership and belonging in a select group (who ARE mad)

And there's my favorite:

  • She just wasn't that good a scientist to begin with (dentists and economists talking about complex structural problems)

I'm sure there are plenty of other possibilities.

So, what do you think of them? How does COINTELPRO stack up against these possibilities in your opinion? How do you propose we find out which is the truth?
 
As a professor once told me, the difference between a scientific theory and a conspiracy theory is scientific theories have a predictable outcome. You can actually take an input and predict an outcome to it. Conspiracy theories are set up so that they get the outcome they want, no matter what the inputs are.

If the evidence supports a conspiracy theory, then it proves the CT.

If there is no evidence to support the conspiracy theory, then that is because there is a coverup.

If the evidence disproves a conspiracy theory, then it is fake.

If a member of the conspiracy theory community does something rational, then conspiracy theorists are rational.

If a member of the conspiracy theory community does something irrational or stupid, then they are a disinformation agent.

No matter what the situation, based on their "logic", they win. Heads I win, tails you lose.
 
Morgan Reynolds, maintaining his "deep cover":

Then there's Morgan O. Reynolds, appointed by George W. Bush as chief economist at the Labor Department. He left in 2002 and doesn't think much of his former boss; he describes President Bush as a "dysfunctional creep," not to mention a "possible war criminal."
Actually, such a posture would ingratiate him with leftists in the CT movement.

And it would seem that the majority of the CT movement is made up of leftists (excepting Alex Jones and some of his flock, and probably some other anomalous groups I'm forgetting about).

However, as I said in my previous post, it's just too complicated for me to believe. The don't need to divide the left, let alone the CT movement, both of which fracture on their own constantly.

COINTELPRO "worked" (somewhat; I'm not totally familiar with the history) in the '60s and early '70s because they were infiltrating a true, grassroots movement that stood for something and had real, if minimal, power, and was getting increasing attention in the MSM.

The CTers are not and have not. Why bother? The MSM has been in line with the neo-cons just fine. Why bother?

Of course, now things are getting really interesting, with people turning against the war and the Republican culture of corruption. Isn't that a Chinese curse or something, 'may you live in interesting times?' LOL...
 
And it would seem that the majority of the CT movement is made up of leftists

That's a bold claim.

The heart of the conspiracy paranoia seems (to me) to be an abiding feeling that some evil (in the religious sense) force is plotting behind the scenes to enslave us all.

The right of centre mindset is very prone to this paranoia, which is why those such as alex jones are adopted by the new generation of CT'ers.

CT is a matter of faith just the same as religion, and it has the same bigotry and racism as the worst examples of religion.

By no means is CT a majority left of centre pursuit.
 
I think it is difficult to believe that a person with Reynolds vita turns into a raving lunatic all of a sudden. And i don't agree with you that no COINTELPRO was needed.
I've explained why I don't think it was needed (no fine-tuning needed to invade Iraq, sheeple all lined up anyway, etc.).

Can you explain why you believe COINTELPRO was (or rather, is still) needed?

More specifically, what does the Bush administration (or whatever faction within it we're discussing) need to pull the wool over our eyes about in order to get something they've not already gotten?
 
That's a bold claim.

The heart of the conspiracy paranoia seems (to me) to be an abiding feeling that some evil (in the religious sense) force is plotting behind the scenes to enslave us all.

The right of centre mindset is very prone to this paranoia, which is why those such as alex jones are adopted by the new generation of CT'ers.

CT is a matter of faith just the same as religion, and it has the same bigotry and racism as the worst examples of religion.

By no means is CT a majority left of centre pursuit.
Maybe you're right. Maybe it's just the circles I run in, LOL...

And thanks, Dave, this is my 15th post!

(Now, do I enter the realms of paradise? LOL...)
 
Holy crap, I am trying so hard to not be insulting in this post. I am literally holding it in and grinding my teeth together..

Childlike, there is also the minute chance that you are that hot chick in your avatar so I don't want to offend you too much just in case there's a chance we may play "Hide the Salami" in the future.

However, you need to step back from your monitor and take a good look at what you are suggesting. Its truly insane.

Take a walk and sip a fine wine. Enjoy your life and escape from this awful paranoia that is gripping you.
 
Umm, the Reynolds publications mentioned upstream suggest that he was already practiced at the fine art of starting with an ideologically-driven conclusion and then trying to hammer and file the data to fit it.

That's a skill that every aspiring CTist needs to develop- and a habit of thinking nicely calculated to help one become a CTist.

IMHO, speculating about his mental heath is pointless. "Insane" is a legal, not a scientific concept, and you don't have to be suffering from a rcognized mental illness to be a crackpot.
 
A base line of your argument is that the conspiracy theorists are completely wrong because they take Operation Northwoods and other incidents as an indication that the US Government might sacrifice their own citizens for "higher" purposes. And now you want to make me believe that Morgan Reynolds went nuts right in time to "support" the 911 Skeptics? I think "ignorant" is a term in favor of you - we should name it "hypocricy" as it is.

He seems a Texan who went nutso over the Kennedy Assassination but had enough on the ball to publish some fairly conservative economic books, so he got an administration job and then went bonkers on 9-11. He's more a libertarian than a conservative, although of course the fact that he's a nut on 9-11 overshadows everything.
 
Holy crap, I am trying so hard to not be insulting in this post. I am literally holding it in and grinding my teeth together..

Childlike, there is also the minute chance that you are that hot chick in your avatar so I don't want to offend you too much just in case there's a chance we may play "Hide the Salami" in the future.

However, you need to step back from your monitor and take a good look at what you are suggesting. Its truly insane.

Take a walk and sip a fine wine. Enjoy your life and escape from this awful paranoia that is gripping you.

No, you are wrong. Did you know that tourette patients can take a great advantage of smoking marihuana?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom