[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

kageki, as I said, this subject is vast. You've already chosen not to respond to the links I've given you, which contain a vast amount of information to help people like you answer specific questions. Remember, that was your choice.

So let's focus on what you need to know to be convinced that Nazis systematically killed millions of Jews, okay?

As I said, if you can't think of any evidence that would convince you, then you should take as much time as you need to think about that. It's very important. If you decide that nothing would convince you, then you have an unfalsifiable belief and we cannot help you.

If you're ready to take the next step, let's proceed right now.

kageki, specifically what evidence would convince you that the Nazis systematically killed millions of Jews? Please do the respectful thing and give that a serious reply, so we can get right to directing you to that information.

Thank you.

Well what is the specific evidence to prove it?

Are we talking about the Final Solution?
 
So we are lead to believe they all turned to ash so we can just come up with any number we please?

No, we do know approximately how much ash corresponds to a human body (Think about how big a cremation urn is.) A pile of ashes ten times that size represents about ten bodies. A pile of ashes a thousand times that size would be about a thousand bodies. This is routine mathematics.
 
Mengele most certainly was concerned with the wellbeing of the Jews. He was after all a doctor.
ANGEL OF DEATH!!
Monarch to the kingdom of the dead!

rock.gif
 
No, we do know approximately how much ash corresponds to a human body (Think about how big a cremation urn is.) A pile of ashes ten times that size represents about ten bodies. A pile of ashes a thousand times that size would be about a thousand bodies. This is routine mathematics.

So that proves bodies were cremated. So what? Was it to stop the spread of disease?
 
Well what is the specific evidence to prove it?

Well, let's see. The claim on the table, just to make sure we're on the same page, is that "the Nazi's systematically killed [multiple] millions of Jews."

So, let's start with the basics. Werre there multiple millions of Jewish deaths under the Nazi regime? Yes. Simple demographic statistics prove it. For example, the Jewish population of Poland dropped from about 3.3million to less than 100,000 during the period from 1939--1945, while the number of Jewish emigrants/refugees/displaced persons was less than 250,000. So there were at least 2.5 million Jewish deaths in Poland alone. Similar demographic statistics indicate at least a half million Jewish deaths in Hungary, and so forth.

if your claim is that these two-and-a-half million Poles did not die, then where were they in 1946?

Were these people killed by the Nazis? Well, the Nazis were very public about how they were rounding up the Polish Jews; we have lots of surviving documentary evidence about the sweeps, as well as reports of the numbers of Jews killed (particularly by the Einsatzgruppen). We have train records indicating that millions of people were systematically delivered by train to the concentration camps, including the Operation Reinhard extermination camps, from which they never returned.

We further have forensic evidence in the forms of dead bodies and cremation remains.

We have eyewitness testimony by people who actually performed the killings, as well as official directives outlining the methods of killing and ordering the constrution of the killing equipment.

What more direct evidence would you like?
 
Last edited:
So that proves bodies were cremated. So what?

It also proves how many bodies were cremated.

Was it to stop the spread of disease?

On that scale? Remember, there was enough capacity in the crematoria to empty the entire camp each month or so. There were enough people moving into that camp each month or so to re-fill it (we have train records, remember).

No disease known to science causes death on that scale and that quickly. An unknown disease of such magnitude would have wiped out the concentration camp guards as well -- which we know (from the surviving medical records) didn't happen.

And beyond that, if the disease were that virulent and dangerous, then continuing to ship prisoners into such an environment would constitute murder in and of itself.

So, no, it wasn't to stop the spread of disease.
 
Germans were tortured for their confessions. Not all the Jews say it happened. Some of them even admitted to lying.

Show me where germany's biggest newspaper tortured Oskar in this piece.

oskar said:
Apart from brief testimony at trials of gas chamber operators and the SS high command, he has never spoken of the camp - until now.

A 1948 tribunal cleared him of war crimes and he began work as the manager of a glass factory. But he never really left Auschwitz and it never left him.

"Every night and every day I remember it for the nightmare it was," he said in Bild, Germany's most widely read newspaper. "It was in 1942 that my SS chiefs in Berlin ordered me there.

rest of story as you really did not read it did you?

http://www.theage.com.au/news/World/Auschwitz-guards-life-of-lingering-nightmares/2005/01/26/1106415663534.html

kag said:
The ovens and chambers do exist. Again they do not prove what is claimed that happened.

oskar is quite definite about what happened in the gas chambers, he seen it happen

who tortured gerhard schroeder in 2005 to make him admit this

http://www.theage.com.au/news/World/Schroeder-admits-ordinary-Germans-role/2005/01/26/1106415663543.html

the germans admit it but you deny it?

you wanted links so here they are, read them this time
 
It's possible to have extermination camps without "burning people alive in ovens. There are more ways to kill people than by burning them.

Yes we know that which if it was the official narrative no one would argue. The Nazis didn't burn Jews alive in ovens.

Which they did. They then burned the bodies in crematoria, enough bodies to make a twenty-foot thick layer of human ash at Treblinka (IIRC).

The nature of that layer of ash is easily identifiable upon chemical analysis. How many bodies does it take to get that much ash? How do you get that many bodies short of deliberate extermination?

Many people died due to disease and starvation. Have you heard of the Black Plague? Ashes don't prove extermination do they?

Oh? What's your explanation for the 500,000 people who arrived at Belzec and never left?

You keep simply asserting that the extermination camps never existed. But merely stating someting over and over again doesn't make it true, rational, or even believable. If you really think that Belzec was something other than an extermination camp, then you should be able to explain what happened to all the people who (you believe) weren't exterminated there.

Killing nearly 100,000 civilians by gassing in trucks is hardly "how anyone would kill people in wars."

Where exactly is the source for this number? If that many people vanished then surely there must be traces left? You haven't provided anything to prove that it was an extermination camp either.

Experts are wondering if you can really kill that many people using engine exhaust. You people bank too much on the results of a kangaroo court, but since that is the case for now then I'll just have to believe these trucks really existed which still doesn't add up to 6 million or that it was just Jews.
 
It also proves how many bodies were cremated.



On that scale? Remember, there was enough capacity in the crematoria to empty the entire camp each month or so. There were enough people moving into that camp each month or so to re-fill it (we have train records, remember).

No disease known to science causes death on that scale and that quickly. An unknown disease of such magnitude would have wiped out the concentration camp guards as well -- which we know (from the surviving medical records) didn't happen.

And beyond that, if the disease were that virulent and dangerous, then continuing to ship prisoners into such an environment would constitute murder in and of itself.

So, no, it wasn't to stop the spread of disease.

This entire post is assumptions. Where's is the evidence to prove the exact capacity for these crematoriums? Many might have been deported further east?

It wasn't just disease obviously, but it played a big role as there was an epidimic.

Your claim that burning corpses wasn't at least partially to stop the spread of disease is factually incorrect.
 
Many people died due to disease and starvation. Have you heard of the Black Plague?

I have indeed. I also know that it doesn't kill at that rate. Medicine has advanced just a bit since the 14th century, you know....

Ashes don't prove extermination do they?

Well, they prove death. If you have another explanation for deaths on that scale that will stand up to realistic analysis -- and "disease" will not -- I invite you to present it.




Where exactly is the source for this number?

Already presented. Train manifests, as cited in "The Operation Reinhard Death Camps."

f that many people vanished then surely there must be traces left?

There are indeed. A twenty-foot thick layer of cremated human bodies.


Experts are wondering if you can really kill that many people using engine exhaust.

No, they're not. The "experts" already know that you can. See the Irving trial. For that matter, work it out on a pocket calculator for yourself. The capacities of the trucks (including how long it takes to kill people and how many people they would hold) are clearly presented in the Irving trial.
 
Last edited:
Have you heard of the Black Plague?

have you?

when was the last time this was in europe?

you really are all over the place aren't you

where is your proof that you were taught that the nazis killed the jews by burning them in ovens? i think you are lying, either that or you went to a "special" school
 
I don't recall hearing about epidemics during WWII. Please source the claim that there was one; thank you.
 
This entire post is assumptions.

None of it is assumptions.

Where's is the evidence to prove the exact capacity for these crematoriums?

The architect's blueprints and design documents.

Many might have been deported further east?

How? Not by train -- the manifests are very clear on that. There wasn't enough transport capacity otherwise. And there's still this pesky matter of human remains that didn't get there by itself.


It wasn't just disease obviously, but it played a big role as there was an epidimic.

What epidemic? Show that such an epidemic occurred (in all three camps -- remember, we need to explain the deaths at all of the extermination camps), that it lasted for the entire year-and-a-half that the camps were in operation, and give me some independent estimates about the number of casualties caused by the epidemic.

Beyond that -- just how big a role? Even if an epidemic killed half the people in the camp (which I doubt, and which I suspect you will be unable to support), what happened to the other half?




Your claim that burning corpses wasn't at least partially to stop the spread of disease is factually incorrect.

I stand by my writing. Your "epidemic" is an assumption, and a particularly egregious one.
 
Last edited:
I don't recall hearing about epidemics during WWII. Please source the claim that there was one; thank you.

http://www.scrapbookpages.com/BergenBelsen/BergenBelsen01.html

Some of the prisoners died of dysentery, but most of them perished in an epidemic of spotted fever (typhus) which broke out in mid November 1941.

By far the biggest killer in the camp was typhus, a deadly disease that is transmitted by body lice.

It shows that there were 350 deaths in the camp in December 1944 before the typhus epidemic started. In January 1945, after a typhoid epidemic started, there were between 800 and 1000 deaths; in February 1945, after the typhus epidemic broke out, there were 6,000 to 7,000 deaths. In March 1945, the number of deaths had escalated to an incredible 18,168 in only one month. In April 1945, the deaths were 18,355 in only one month, with half of these deaths occurring after the British took over. Unlike the death camps in Poland, the Bergen-Belsen camp was not equipped to handle this kind of death rate; there was only one crematory oven in the camp.

To fight typhus epidemics during World War II, the Germans used an insecticide, called Zyklon B, to kill the lice which were common in the overcrowded Nazi concentration camps. Zyklon B was also used as a poison gas to kill the Jews in the gas chambers, although there was no gas chamber at Bergen-Belsen. Initially, the Jews at Bergen-Belsen were well-treated because the Nazis were hoping to use them for exchange for German prisoners.
 
have you?

when was the last time this was in europe?

you really are all over the place aren't you

where is your proof that you were taught that the nazis killed the jews by burning them in ovens? i think you are lying, either that or you went to a "special" school

Funk you should really stop this pathetic attempt at playing dumb. Even my mother who grew up in Japan associate the Holocaust with the ovens.

Why don't you go to your usual Holocaust sources? Why is the idea of Jews burning alive in ovens so prominent in my belief in the Holocaust? Why were people so hesitant in answering no to my question about ovens?
 
Well what is the specific evidence to prove it?
kageki, I'm asking you to try to be as rational as you can, and not to waste our time. Let's focus on what's most important, okay?

Allow me to direct you to this past exchange of ours. I gave you the following links several times. At these sites are authoritative answers to all the common – and many uncommon – Holocaust denial claims:
http://www.nizkor.org/

[SIZE=-1]66 Questions & Answers About the Holocaust [/SIZE]

This is the third time that I've linked to Nizkor for your benefit. Specifically what do they get wrong? Back your claims with equal or superior evidence to that used by Nizkor.

Fair enough, kageki?

You replied:
What exactly is the point of just linking the entirety of the site? I've read the articles on there and I don't find some of them persuasive especially on the contentious issues....

However, kageki, you did not say what you found unconvincing, and why, nor did you present evidence to refute a single one of Nizkor's answers, as I asked you to do. I doubt that you can have read very much of the information on that site or the sources it cites.

If you are here simply to state your opinion and leave it at that, please say so. If you have made up your mind and cannot be swayed, please do the right thing and say so. I'm sure you don't want us wasting our valuable time, right? Right?

But if you are here to find answers to questions that are unresolved in your mind, we can help. What we cannot do, kageki, is present all the evidence for every Holocaust issue. As I've repeatedly said, the subject is far too vast for that. Let's please be adult about this.

Are we talking about the Final Solution?
You tell us. This is about specifically what you need to know. As a reminder, the subject of this thread is "The Holocaust never happened!"

So, kageki, for the eighth time: We want to direct you to the information you need. Specifically what would convince you that the Nazis systematically killed millions of Jews?
 
Last edited:
Cool. Let's look at that a little more closely.

Unlike the death camps in Poland, the Bergen-Belsen camp was not equipped to handle this kind of death rate; there was only one crematory oven in the camp.

So, to start out with, this is explicitly not a death camp we're talking about. This is Bergen-Belsen, not Treblinka, Sobibor, or Belzec. All of those camps had much greater crematory capacity (check the blueprints if necessary).

But let's do the math.

here were 350 deaths in the camp in December 1944 before the typhus epidemic started. In January 1945, after a typhoid epidemic started, there were between 800 and 1000 deaths; in February 1945, after the typhus epidemic broke out, there were 6,000 to 7,000 deaths. In March 1945, the number of deaths had escalated to an incredible 18,168 in only one month. In April 1945, the deaths were 18,355 in only one month, with half of these deaths occurring after the British took over.

Let's assume that the 350 deaths/month "before the typhus epidemic started" was typical of the 50 or so months between 1945 when the camp was in operation. That's 17,500 deaths prior to 1945. January had 1000 deaths, February had 7000, March and April both had 20,000. That's 65,500 deaths from typhus.

Compare that to the known population of Bergen-Belsen (about 60,000 prisoners), that is indeed frightening. Why, a third of the population died every month from disease.

However, remember that at Belzec, the entire population died every month. So even if there were an equally bad epidemic at Belzec, that still means that 2/3 of the population would be dying of other causes each month. What killed them?

And, of course, the epidemic wouldn't have been nearly as bad at the Reinhard camps, precisely because the major contributing factor -- the lack of sufficient crematory capacity -- wasn't there.

This particular citation does more to prove the existence of the Holocaust than to deny it.
 
LOL. What does shootings have to do with whether burnings pits are possible?

First, no, ovens not "debunked." That's a strawman argument. The primary methods were gassing, shooting, starvation, disease and working to death. Oh yeah, other methods of excecution such as hangings and beatings.

You are "LOL"-ing over mass murder. What a despicable statement.

Shooting was second-largest means of killing applied in the Holocaust.
 
Well let's see it. You people never seem to cough up anything to back up your claims.

Mass gassings don't even seem possible. Testimonies are not solid evidence.

Well we are told that Nazis were burning people alive in ovens. I want to know if that was made up.

Mass gassings are entirely possible and indeed took place. Where did you decide they weren't/ didn't?

Individual testimony is usable evidence both in a court of law and in historical research. (I speak as someone with a PhD in European history from the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.) What is your credential? High school diploma from the Joseph Goebbels Famous Murderers' College?

Mass shooting was also carried out, etc etc. Your statements are not merely vile, they are lies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom