Misuses of Energy Concepts in Pseudoscience

Hands of Light covers that but I will look at other sources too - do you know of any popular healing touch practitioners that focus on the energy issues?

These people call themselves the "Leaders in Energy Medicine".

healingtouchprogram.com has a FAQ where they seem to describe their program as Energy Healing. Their description includes the gem of gems:

There is still much mystery to how energy therapies work. Many theoretical frameworks for how energy medicine works exist in the literature of quantum physics and holistic healing.

The emphasis is my addition. Later they go on about chakras, lack of balance, etc. It's super.
 
I've been working on a book lately with a work colleague on the history of science (basically 'what we used to believe but don't anymore' sort of thing), and I've taken quite an interest in a recurring concept which relates to modern abuses of the term 'energy'.

Energy seems to have two uses - one is for the modern physics notion of a universal currency, where energy describes the value of work being done; the second is a vague replacement for the God of the gaps principle. Another way of putting it is having one form of energy being mechanistic, and the other vitalistic or metaphysical.

The lay person has difficulty in seeing energy as a quantifiable value which is used to describe how matter behaves. Therefore it becomes something which exists independently of the physical universe and can be used to describe anything and everything without the need to justify it empirically. For centuries, vitalism was a field which was essentially a battle between these two groups - one believed life was mechanistic and even though the chemistries and physics weren't yet described, they were confident that they would be. The other group believed that life required a unique 'energy' which could not be described or quantified. Of course the latter camp is not scientific, which is why vitalism in all its forms will continue to have its supporters. Energy in that form cannot be nailed down and therefore can also never be falsified.

Good luck in your research. If I find something in my own research notes you can use, I'll forward them your way.

Athon
 
These people call themselves the "Leaders in Energy Medicine".

healingtouchprogram.com has a FAQ where they seem to describe their program as Energy Healing. Their description includes the gem of gems:

There is still much mystery to how energy therapies work. Many theoretical frameworks for how energy medicine works exist in the literature of quantum physics and holistic healing.

The emphasis is my addition. Later they go on about chakras, lack of balance, etc. It's super.


Thanks for those, they look really useful (well for me, not so much for the sick ;))


I've been working on a book lately with a work colleague on the history of science (basically 'what we used to believe but don't anymore' sort of thing), and I've taken quite an interest in a recurring concept which relates to modern abuses of the term 'energy'.


Sounds fascinating :)


Energy seems to have two uses - one is for the modern physics notion of a universal currency, where energy describes the value of work being done; the second is a vague replacement for the God of the gaps principle. Another way of putting it is having one form of energy being mechanistic, and the other vitalistic or metaphysical.


Yep this would match with my observations as well. The problem is when these two different uses are mixed and matched. A lot of believers hear the word "energy" and presume it has all the scientific meaning, backing and certainty of the thermodynamic meaning which they struggled through and mostly ignored during school science classes. They don't realise the two concepts are entirely unrelated.


The lay person has difficulty in seeing energy as a quantifiable value which is used to describe how matter behaves. Therefore it becomes something which exists independently of the physical universe and can be used to describe anything and everything without the need to justify it empirically. For centuries, vitalism was a field which was essentially a battle between these two groups - one believed life was mechanistic and even though the chemistries and physics weren't yet described, they were confident that they would be. The other group believed that life required a unique 'energy' which could not be described or quantified. Of course the latter camp is not scientific, which is why vitalism in all its forms will continue to have its supporters. Energy in that form cannot be nailed down and therefore can also never be falsified.


Good point. The other thing I have noticed is that people tend to think of energy as a thing - they imagine balls of energy, bolts of energy or something similar as a real tangible thing. With this misconception it seems viable for an energy healer to manipulate their "energy".


Good luck in your research. If I find something in my own research notes you can use, I'll forward them your way.

Athon


Many thanks, appreciated :)
 
Yep this would match with my observations as well. The problem is when these two different uses are mixed and matched. A lot of believers hear the word "energy" and presume it has all the scientific meaning, backing and certainty of the thermodynamic meaning which they struggled through and mostly ignored during school science classes. They don't realise the two concepts are entirely unrelated.

To be fair, the concept of energy is an extremely abstract thing. It doesn't exist as a 'thing', therefore has no concrete basis that most people can imagine. And since most people have problems with abstract ideas, the concept of energy being a 'thing which is not a thing' (i.e. metaphysics) becomes a whole lot more appealing than 'not a thing which acts like a thing'.

Good point. The other thing I have noticed is that people tend to think of energy as a thing - they imagine balls of energy, bolts of energy or something similar as a real tangible thing. With this misconception it seems viable for an energy healer to manipulate their "energy".

I taught my students that energy is like money - you can have a coin, or a bank note, but that in itself isn't money. It's a representation of how much currency you have. It's easier to use that analogy these days when they use credit cards and EFTPOS. 'You can lose money to somebody else, and you can have somebody give it to you, but you can't just magically say you have more of it.' While economists can easily find flaws in the analogy, high school kids still get a better idea of how energy works that way.

Many thanks, appreciated :)

No problem.

Athon
 
I taught my students that energy is like money - you can have a coin, or a bank note, but that in itself isn't money. It's a representation of how much currency you have. It's easier to use that analogy these days when they use credit cards and EFTPOS. 'You can lose money to somebody else, and you can have somebody give it to you, but you can't just magically say you have more of it.' While economists can easily find flaws in the analogy, high school kids still get a better idea of how energy works that way.
Athon

Pilots also use this simile: "Altitude is like money in the bank, and airspeed is like money in your pocket."
 
I taught my students that energy is like money - you can have a coin, or a bank note, but that in itself isn't money. It's a representation of how much currency you have. It's easier to use that analogy these days when they use credit cards and EFTPOS. 'You can lose money to somebody else, and you can have somebody give it to you, but you can't just magically say you have more of it.' While economists can easily find flaws in the analogy, high school kids still get a better idea of how energy works that way.

I like this analogy as well, particularly because these days money doesn't really exist as a tangible thing, much like energy. And I have even seen people (sometimes awkwardly) extend the analogy to talk about converting money to "work" (i.e. paying someone to mow your lawns) etc.

I think what really started me towards understanding it years ago was Feynman's description of the first law from Six Easy Pieces:

“There is a fact, or if you wish, a law, governing natural phenomena that are known to date. There is no known exception to this law—it is exact so far we know. The law is called conservation of energy. That is a most abstract idea, because it is a mathematical principle; it says that there is a numerical quantity, which does not change when something happens. It is not a description of a mechanism, or anything concrete; it is just a strange fact that we can calculate some number, and when we finish watching nature go through her tricks and calculate the number again, it is the same.”
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom