Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
Going way off the reservation...

IIRC, the invisible weaving technique is only used on areas up to 3/8 inch round, approximately one cm. What are the odds that all three samples were composed of 100% patched areas (assuming the invisibly weaved threads were not from some where else on the shroud)? A more likely scenario would be a mix of old and new threads in different proportions. This would make each sample, when dated, have wildly variable dates. This did not happen. Therefore the samples were homogenous and the dating stands. Correct?
 
<polite snip>

My point is, it's not entirely possible for such a process to occur. That said, the shroud isn't made of the right materials and you really can't use the techniques I know on a cloth. It's not reweaving, it's something you do while making the cloth.


Informative as always. Thank you.

:)
 
For some things it's not actually impossible. I've dabbled in nalbinding, which is sort of like crochet. One of the tricks an expert told me to do was to buy single-strand wool yarn. With that, you can actually fuse the ends of two strands together (it's the lanellin in the yarn, I believe, combined with the oils in your fingers and saliva and twisting--a simple process, but chemically fairly complicated). It's literally invisible to the naked eye, because you're connecting the threads in exactly the same way that the threads themselves were put together in the first place. This also makes nalbinding a pain in the rear--you have to FIND single-strand wool yarn, or a sheep and someone to spin it (I'm horrible at spinning--too much time working on maille armor, my fingers don't work the right way).

My point is, it's not entirely possible for such a process to occur. That said, the shroud isn't made of the right materials and you really can't use the techniques I know on a cloth. It's not reweaving, it's something you do while making the cloth.

Interesting. I ask you this not assuming you are an expert, but assuming you are more of an expert than anyone else in this thread. Even if the threads in the shroud were single strand wool and even if you could join the threads using your method and have them fit seamlessly in the warp and woof herringbone pattern in the shroud, do you think that it would still be invisible if you were joining threads that were 1,400 years newer than the original old piece of fabric?

I know you are not defending the invisible patch theory. I'm just reminding everyone that the "invisible reweavers" apparently perfectly matched 1,400 year old threads in one corner of a shroud that has many other obvious patches on it for no apparent reason.

As many times as this has been pointed out, I think it bears repeating. It seems repeating something scores of times sometimes sometimes gets Jabba's attention.

Ward
 
wardenclyffe said:
Even if the threads in the shroud were single strand wool and even if you could join the threads using your method and have them fit seamlessly in the warp and woof herringbone pattern in the shroud, do you think that it would still be invisible if you were joining threads that were 1,400 years newer than the original old piece of fabric?
Doubt it. It'd be good enough to fool someone like me, who isn't very good at it--but the instant you touched it youd' be able to tell, and an expert would easily be able to see the difference. That much time has an effect on cloth. I'm not even sure you could do it with wool that's that old--the method I know works best with newer wool, since it relies on oils in the wool itself.

I know you are not defending the invisible patch theory. I'm just reminding everyone that the "invisible reweavers" apparently perfectly matched 1,400 year old threads in one corner of a shroud that has many other obvious patches on it for no apparent reason.
It's a fair question. :)
 
Since the shroud is made of linen, and not wool, the connecting of thread ends is far more difficult. Linen is made of long fibers, not the short twisty ones that wool has, and linen doesn't have the lanolin to aid in process. Linen is connected by overlapping the fibers in such a way that the ends are staggered throughout the thread. I believe the only way a relatively invisible patch could be made would be to unweave a fairly large section (much larger than the space you are trying to patch), carefully remove individual fibers from the threads, add in new fibers with the ends of each fiber staggered, and then reweave the entire section. The fibers would also have to be the same general length as the old fibers in the area around the patch, and somehow look as old as the rest. It would be a far more complicated and time consuming process than the invisible reweaving techniques shown so far.
 
I believe that Flury-Lemberg implied that some kind of invisible reweaving was possible in some kinds of cloth.

If I understand what she meant she was referring to a process where both warp and weft threads that are passing through a damaged area would be completely removed and replaced with undamaged threads or a process like Dinwar described whereby threads could be reattached by some mechanism.

However, her opinion about the shroud is that nothing like that would be possible because of the material it was made of. Just based on common sense it seems very likely to me that she was correct. Of course, my opinion means little about this and the opinion of a relatively unknown alleged cloth expert isn't proof. However, if somebody disagrees with her and wants to prove her wrong all that is necessary is to demonstrate the technique in a cloth similar to the shroud. The fact that nobody has done anything like this suggests strongly that the people disagreeing with Flury-Lemberg don't have any evidence.

Of course, if they did actually succeed in providing a demonstration of the process that they claim is possible that would only leave six or so very strong arguments that there is no invisible patch in the shroud which by themselves provide proof that the C14 sample area didn't contain an invisible path.
 
Googling "wool microscope" gives a lot of pictures showing the little scales on each strand which serve to hook onto another strand in the spinning process. Also shown, by hovering cursor on "nylon" or "silk" are pictures showing the perfectly smooth surfaces, which explains why you cannot easily spin yarn; same to a certain extent with dog and cat hair, or so I have been told.
 
Cat hair? Really? That stuff clings to everything. I'd have thought it would be easy to spin.
 
- According to SOME of the experts, patches CAN be made to be ESSENTIALLY invisible (http://www.shrouduniversity.com/fren...uctionbook.pdf -- page 2; and, http://shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf, Entry: #39), and as far as I can tell, we don't really know what "measurements" were taken by the experts on this small corner piece prior to the dating process, and Madame Flury-Lemberg implies that all she needed to do in order to determine if any reweaving has been done is to look -- with the naked eye -- at the back of the cloth.
- I guess that the question is whether or not the procedures carried out by the three C14 labs would have exposed such a patch... Seems like someone has argued that in the past, but I can't remember who, where or when. Any thoughts?
--- Jabba

Jabba, why don't you post up the links to the actual papers, rather than through the other site?
Have you actually read the papers yourself?
I have.
I posted up reasons why the Benford/Marino paper is extremely weak.
You read my posts, didn't you?


I'm absolutely shocked that Jabba didn't address the C14 in his latest post. Shocked.

This just appeared on Fox News, of all places.

That's good news, carlitos.
Thanks for posting it up.

If I understand what she meant she was referring to a process where both warp and weft threads that are passing through a damaged area would be completely removed and replaced with undamaged threads or a process like Dinwar described whereby threads could be reattached by some mechanism.
davefoc, this has already been extensively discussed and documented by me earlier in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Just a quick question on this for Jabba to ignore:

How is it proposed that reweaving which was invisible to the naked eye could be accomplished by reweavers who themselves had nothing more than their unaided eyesight?

The reweavers were blind that way their tactile sense increased to the point they could micro weave the actual ends of the threads together.
 
There you are, tsig!
The subject for a paper you can present at shroudie conventions/symposiums til 2025!
 
Carbon Dating - Reweaving?

Jabba,

Your first link seems broken, and in your second one you ask us to look at entry 39, but there are only 32 entries in the document. Before you fix the links, please make sure they do not refer to the reweaving techniques that use threads from other parts of the shroud. Otherwise, a patch would have no effect on the C14 dating and would in fact confirm that the entire shroud is Medieval.

Thanks,
Ward
Ward,

- I'm not sure what the problem is for that first link, but I can't seem to go there directly myself. Instead, go to http://www.shrouduniversity.com/textiles.php, scroll down and click on “The Art of French Reweaving.” That should work.
- The other link actually does work, but I forgot that there are two different numbered sections -- the last section is labeled as "Appendix" and only goes to #32. The first section goes to #45.

- As to the issue of using threads from other parts of the Shroud: that was Han's next question which I will be happy to address -- once we put THIS issue to rest.
- Note that I did acknowledge back in post #3308 that on page 38 of the French Reweaving book it is said that "except in rare cases," this method does use threads from other parts of the Shroud. I went on to concede that this admission does seem to be a serious problem for Rogers' hypothesis...

- I know that focusing on one small sub-sub-issue at a time is quite tedious, but believe that not doing so is the main reason why human debate almost never gets anywhere. It's better to go slow and forward than fast and circular. Here, I'm basically claiming that a patch getting past the experts may not be as unlikely as it first appears -- if we reconsider our assumptions. For now, that's the sub-sub-issue at stake.
- And, all we need, in order to put this sub-sub-issue to rest, is the effective presentation, by each side, of its significant evidence. We shouldn't need, or even expect, to come to agreement on the particular sub-sub-issue. By believing that we have given our best shot at presenting it, we can walk away and "gracefully" move on to the next -- allowing the members of the audience to make up their own minds as to which side had the best case.

- Enough for now.
--- Jabba

-
 
<waffle>

- And, all we need, in order to put this sub-sub-issue to rest, is the effective presentation, by each side, of its significant evidence.


See, there's your whole problem right there, Jabba.

You don't have any evidence of invisible patches, on the shroud or on any other piece of comparable fabric, significant or otherwise.

Which is as close as we're ever likely to get to evidence for our side of the argument that there's no such thing.

Oops.


<more waffle>

-allowing the members of the audience to make up their own minds as to which side had the best case.


You really don't get that this isn't an episode of Perry Mason, do you?
 
Ward,

- I'm not sure what the problem is for that first link, but I can't seem to go there directly myself. Instead, go to http://www.shrouduniversity.com/textiles.php, scroll down and click on “The Art of French Reweaving.” That should work.
- The other link actually does work, but I forgot that there are two different numbered sections -- the last section is labeled as "Appendix" and only goes to #32. The first section goes to #45.

Would you please link directly to the things you want us to read?


Here, I'm basically claiming that a patch getting past the experts may not be as unlikely as it first appears -- if we reconsider our assumptions.

Would you please post up the basis for your claim?


- And, all we need, in order to put this sub-sub-issue to rest, is the effective presentation, by each side, of its significant evidence. We shouldn't need, or even expect, to come to agreement on the particular sub-sub-issue. By believing that we have given our best shot at presenting it, we can walk away and "gracefully" move on to the next -- allowing the members of the audience to make up their own minds as to which side had the best case. ...

What is this?
Can it be you are still trying for the courtroom debate project?
 
Jabba said:
- I know that focusing on one small sub-sub-issue at a time is quite tedious, but believe that not doing so is the main reason why human debate almost never gets anywhere.
This is a lie. Human debates DO get somewhere, when each side agrees that evidence takes priority over rhetoric. You simply don't like where the evidence leads, and are attempting to obfuscate the facts using cheap rhetorical tricks.

It's better to go slow and forward than fast and circular.
Slow and circular, the way this thread is going, is worst of all.

Here, I'm basically claiming that a patch getting past the experts may not be as unlikely as it first appears -- if we reconsider our assumptionsignore the relevant data.
You appear to have misspelled a few words. I've taken the liberty of fixing them for you.

And, all we need, in order to put this sub-sub-issue to rest, is the effective presentation, by each side, of its significant evidence.
Jabba, WE HAVE PRESENTED OUR EVIDENCE. The one who's refused to do so is you. You've presented nothing but rhetoric and "I'll get to it in a bit". I'VE presented a better case for your conclusion than you have.

We shouldn't need, or even expect, to come to agreement on the particular sub-sub-issue.
Considering the fact that I don't find you to be an honest participant in this debate (no insult here--we've caught you lying numerous times) I doubt we'd come to an agreement if the guy who made the shroud confessed in front of you and produced a video of him doing it. I know the first bit won't convince you, because the guy who made the shroud DID confess back when it was made.

By believing that we have given our best shot at presenting it, we can walk away and "gracefully" move on to the next -- allowing the members of the audience to make up their own minds as to which side had the best case.
Right. You demand that we abandon even the pretense of scientific inquiry, and have openly admitted multiple times now that your intent is to use us as a vehicle for spreading your ignorance. Why should we bother?

This isn't a courtroom or an election. This is science. There IS a right answer, and the way to find it is to examine the evidence. We've done that. You haven't--and you've demonstrated that you're incapable of doing so in a few cases. That means that we're almost certainly the ones that are right. If you believe otherwise SHOW US THE DATA. Further discussions of how to argue do nothing but show that you've no interest in an actual examination of the topic.
 
You don't have any evidence of invisible patches,

Do you see a patch? Has ANYONE detected a patch in that section?

NO

Hence, that PROVES it is invisible. What more evidence could you need? It's as obvious as can be that you can't see it.
 
- And, all we need, in order to put this sub-sub-issue to rest, is the effective presentation, by each side, of its significant evidence.
-

You have yet to post such evidence. What evidence do you have that such an unprecidented, rare, and undetected patch actually exists?
 
Jabba portrays this forum as rude or nasty when he communicates with pro-Shroud sites, but I am often amazed at how much slack we have been willing to provide to Jabba in this thread.

To summarize, there is absolutely no evidence of a patch at the position in question (i.e. one that would make the samples chosen for 14C analyses non-representative of the rest of the Shroud). According to Jabba, that's because it is an invisible patch! Not just an invisible patch, but a very special invisible patch that is better than the best "invisible repair" methods known to date, cannot be seen even under a microscope, and does not use thread from elsewhere in the Shroud. In other words, it is not just an invisible patch, but one without precedent in textile science.

Do you know that I live in a castle, but everyone thinks I live in a small wooden ranch-style house? It's because of my unicorn, who casts a spell on my castle and hides it. You may not know that even unicorns can do this, but I have a very special unicorn that works this very special spell...

We have indulged Jabba in all of his claims to the point of researching invisible weaving techniques for him, and allowing bizarre hypothetical scenarios where the obscure corner of the Shroud used for 14C dating was somehow worth a complicated invisible patch while major other sections of the cloth, near the holy image itself, were crudely and quite visibly stitched together.

I have found these discussions interesting and I have learned a lot. But just to remind Jabba: there is no evidence for a patch, a patch would not be invisible if it existed, and it would have the same 14C date as the rest of the Shroud.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom