Carbon Dating - Reweaving?
Jabba,
Your first link seems broken, and in your second one you ask us to look at entry 39, but there are only 32 entries in the document. Before you fix the links, please make sure they do not refer to the reweaving techniques that use threads from other parts of the shroud. Otherwise, a patch would have no effect on the C14 dating and would in fact confirm that the entire shroud is Medieval.
Thanks,
Ward
Ward,
- I'm not sure what the problem is for that first link, but I can't seem to go there directly myself. Instead, go to
http://www.shrouduniversity.com/textiles.php, scroll down and click on “The Art of French Reweaving.” That should work.
- The other link actually does work, but I forgot that there are two different numbered sections -- the last section is labeled as "Appendix" and only goes to #32. The first section goes to #45.
- As to the issue of using threads from other parts of the Shroud: that was Han's next question which I will be happy to address -- once we put THIS issue to rest.
- Note that I did acknowledge back in post #3308 that on page 38 of the French Reweaving book it is said that "except in rare cases," this method does use threads from other parts of the Shroud. I went on to concede that this admission does seem to be a serious problem for Rogers' hypothesis...
- I know that focusing on one small sub-sub-issue at a time is quite tedious, but believe that not doing so is the main reason why human debate almost never gets anywhere. It's better to go slow and forward than fast and circular. Here, I'm basically claiming that a patch getting past the experts may not be as unlikely as it first appears -- if we reconsider our assumptions. For now, that's the sub-sub-issue at stake.
- And, all we need, in order to put this sub-sub-issue to rest, is the effective presentation, by each side, of its significant evidence. We shouldn't need, or even expect, to come to agreement on the particular sub-sub-issue. By believing that we have given our best shot at presenting it, we can walk away and "gracefully" move on to the next -- allowing the members of the audience to make up their own minds as to which side had the best case.
- Enough for now.
--- Jabba
-