Merged Militias ‘mobilizing’ to support embattled Clark County rancher in clash with federal

crescent

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
6,086
Location
Colorado
Militias ‘mobilizing’ to support embattled Clark County rancher in clash with federal rangers

From near and wide, armed men are trickling toward Cliven Bundy’s ranch, where the rancher’s fight with the federal government has become a rallying cry for militia groups across the United States.

On Wednesday, that dispute teetered at the edge of deadly conflict, when Cliven Bundy’s family members and supporters scuffled with rangers from the Bureau of Land Management sent to protect the federal roundup of Bundy’s cattle on public land.

One of Bundy’s seven sons was shot with a stun gun, and Bundy’s sister was knocked to the ground; but no one was seriously hurt, and no arrests were made.

By late Wednesday, three militia members — two from Montana and one from Utah — had arrived at the ranch 80 miles northeast of Las Vegas. Other militia groups have inundated the Bundy household with calls and pledges to muster at the site. Their stated goal: to protect the Bundys from tyranny.

Interesting times in Southern Nevada....
 
I remember this happened with that couple that decided not to pay taxes a few years back and barricaded themselves in their home. Feds surrounded it, and intercepted nutjobs trying to bring them food and supplies.

I think movies about the plucky band of misfits bringing down the evil empire has given some people the wrong idea.
 
That said the article suggests the BLM is being the sterotypically heavy-handed government agency, with the typical "**** you" 1st amendment areas
 
I'm guessing white supremacists smell a new Ruby Ridge.

ETA: It's funny how in the comments section when people cite how the Bundy's don't have a constitutional right to the land, citing actual legal sources, the so called constitution loving righties dismiss it as leftist propaganda.

The constitution apparently starts and ends with the 2nd amendment for these people.
 
Last edited:
That said the article suggests the BLM is being the sterotypically heavy-handed government agency, with the typical "**** you" 1st amendment areas
I'm guessing white supremacists smell a new Ruby Ridge.

ETA: It's funny how in the comments section when people cite how the Bundy's don't have a constitutional right to the land, citing actual legal sources, the so called constitution loving righties dismiss it as leftist propaganda.

The constitution apparently starts and ends with the 2nd amendment for these people.
Indeed. Buckley lost the case back in '98 and was told a year ago that his cattle could be seized; a fairly typical freeloading FMOTL it appears.
More links.
The case.
The militia.
This should be amusing.
 
That said the article suggests the BLM is being the sterotypically heavy-handed government agency, with the typical "**** you" 1st amendment areas

Which doesn't seem to be the case. My understanding is that the guy's family was using federal lands for grazing for many years. At some point the federal gov't said "you gotta pay in order to let your cattle graze here". Whether that was from day 1 or instituted later on, I dunno, but they paid the fee.

Then in the late 90s, they stopped paying the fee. Went to court, lost, and last year they were told by a court to stop or else their cattle would be seized. Surprise, surprise, one year later they are still letting the cattle graze and so the BLM is seizing the cattle.
 
Thanks for the details of the dispute castmate1 and bonzombiekitty. Having lived in Las Vegas for some time, this is what I suspected when I read the OP.

What a lot of people don't realize, is that that BLM land is not 'public' land in they way we typically think of it. While it is owned by the federal government it is not open for public use. A lot of time the feds will keep ownership of the lends but lease rights to use the land (typically mining but sometimes ranching as well).
 
Well, yep, now heavily armed revolutionary rightwingers are grouping for the start of a revolution.

In other news, a judge's relative was kidnapped in an attempt to influence the judiciary.

Welcome to Germany, 1933.
 
Thanks for the details of the dispute castmate1 and bonzombiekitty. Having lived in Las Vegas for some time, this is what I suspected when I read the OP.

What a lot of people don't realize, is that that BLM land is not 'public' land in they way we typically think of it. While it is owned by the federal government it is not open for public use. A lot of time the feds will keep ownership of the lends but lease rights to use the land (typically mining but sometimes ranching as well).

I liked the BLM statement of, basically, "to be fair to the other cattle owners, who are abiding by the law, we have to do this"

He's not just ripping off the government, he's cheating his fellow farmers.
 
What a lot of people don't realize, is that that BLM land is not 'public' land in they way we typically think of it. While it is owned by the federal government it is not open for public use. A lot of time the feds will keep ownership of the lends but lease rights to use the land (typically mining but sometimes ranching as well).

Ranching is much more widespread than mining, and nearly all grazing allotments are open to the public. Very little BLM land is not open to the public, although some bits and pieces charge fees and some areas are not accessible by vehicle. The public use is structured (designated roads and trails, permits required for commercial uses and such), but it is clearly there.

Wonkette has a good article on this, providing some more background. Bundy has made a lot of comments in the past about getting "physical", or using "force" to "take things back". He has not, to my knowledge ever made any clear cut overt threats of violence, but has made a great many statements that seem to strongly imply violence. I don't know if he is purposefully ambiguous or not, but a good bit of what he says is open to interpretation, and many people interpret his statements as threats.

I do agree that the first amendment areas were a bad idea - I didn't like the concept when the Bush administration started using them, and I still don't like it. BLM has since taken them down. A nice press kit with suggestions for where it might be safe to congregate would have been a better idea.

I work for the BLM, the office I work in is not involved with this, other than having a few of our LEOs assigned to the operation - I am following this out of personal interest but have no professional involvement, and I am pretty much just a low level peon with no authority anyway. The "Ranch Riot" video embedded in the OP article gives an idea of how amped up people are. I am just hoping this does not lead to violence.
 
Last edited:
Well, yep, now heavily armed revolutionary rightwingers are grouping for the start of a revolution.

In other news, a judge's relative was kidnapped in an attempt to influence the judiciary.

Welcome to Germany, 1933.

Quick question.
In your metaphor, is it the militia or the BLM that are the Nazi's.
 
Quick question.
In your metaphor, is it the militia or the BLM that are the Nazi's.


First, there's no metaphor. I'm simply referring to known historical facts.

As to your dishonest attempt to suggest that I might somehow endorse the criminal actions of right-wing fascist revolutionaries, well, that kind of dishonestly speaks only to your own conduct.

As an aside, the BLM, here, is only trying to do what Reagan, Bush 1, and Bush 2, among others, told them to do, which is pay their own way.
 
Well, yep, now heavily armed revolutionary rightwingers are grouping for the start of a revolution.

In other news, a judge's relative was kidnapped in an attempt to influence the judiciary.

Welcome to Germany, 1933.

It was a prosecutor's father and it was done by the Bloods Street Gang.

You attempt to conflate that with "rightwingers" in you Godwin post is clearly fraudulent
 
I'm guessing white supremacists smell a new Ruby Ridge.

ETA: It's funny how in the comments section when people cite how the Bundy's don't have a constitutional right to the land, citing actual legal sources, the so called constitution loving righties dismiss it as leftist propaganda.

The constitution apparently starts and ends with the 2nd amendment for these people.

I'd be willing to bet a lot on the other side hope it ends up similar to Waco for the militia nuts.
 
It was a prosecutor's father and it was done by the Bloods Street Gang.

You attempt to conflate that with "rightwingers" in you Godwin post is clearly fraudulent

And your incredibly meaningless "refutation" misses the entire point, which is that the GOP, in concert with the media, has polarized the entire country to the point where people feel entirely free to act out.

Which is, of course, a classical historical point from 1930's Germany that you are simply avoiding.

ETA: Indeed, it was a prosecutor's relative. Sorry about that. The point still entirely remains, and is perhaps even made stronger.
 
Last edited:
So this all seems to stem from Bundy's contention that the federal government can not legally own land within the borders of a state?
 
Does he have a leg to stand on with regards to adverse possession?

Some of the comments I have seen on articles claim his family bought "perpetual grazing rights" back in the 1800's. Is that a thing?
 
Some of the comments I have seen on articles claim his family bought "perpetual grazing rights" back in the 1800's. Is that a thing?

Taylor Grazing Act (1934)

U.S. Grazing Service

No, it is not a thing. His family might have informally purchased rights from the local Indian tribe, way back when. It was not uncommon for ranchers to do that, but it would have had no legal standing.

From the Taylor Grazing act onward, grazing rights are leased. Leases last 10 years, and contain clauses allowing the BLM to make changes if the need arises. BLM made changes in 1993, so Bundy stopped paying. In 1998 the lease expired, which made it possible for someone else to pick it up. That someone else was Clark County.

Buying the lease and then intentionally not grazing cattle on it protected Desert tortoise habitat. This desert tortoise protection was done to compensate for the destruction of desert tortoise habitat caused by the growth of Las Vegas and other cities and towns in Clark County. The process was part of Clark County's Habitat Conservation Plan.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom