[Merged]WTC fires / Photograph

It's terrible how they use these pictures to further their agenda. Absolutely terrible.

Do you happen to have the time that was taken? Floor #95 (which I assume he is on) was predicted by NIST to be quite quite hot until over an hour into the fire. I guess there's no identification of him either?
 
Also keep in mind that the fires were hottest where the fuel was. The aircraft impacts were expected to push all of the consumable furniture, files, etc. away from the point of impact, which is where those unfortunate people were standing.

That particular location was probably relatively cool, and almost certainly the only place where fresh air could be found. Not surprising in the least for someone to be driven in that direction.

Moral of the story to all those Junior Detectives using this to further their own agenda, if you're going to be a jerk and exploit the memory of those who perished, at least think about what it really implies.
 
Unfortunately, in that picture we see another person, on the floor on her right. :(

Has that been determined yet? Afaik it is to unclear to tell if that is a victim or debris.

Allthough it doesn't really matter. The whole picture (and others where the people are standing in the windows) is sad as it is. Be it one, two or hundreds of people.
 
Why is it that if the fires were burning so fiercely there are pictures of a woman standing looking out of the hole where the plane hit?
 
Why is it that if the fires were burning so fiercely there are pictures of a woman standing looking out of the hole where the plane hit?

Possibly because the plane ploughed all the contents away from the entry hole, so there wasn't much stuff there to burn. The observed deformation of the exterior columns happened on the opposite side, showing that the fires were more severe there.

Possibly because, since the air for the combustion entered through the impact hole, it was cooler in that area, cool enough for a human being to survive.

Possibly because the rest of the floor was filled with smoke, and near the hole was the only place where there was clean air to breathe.

Edna Cintron didn't make it out alive, so we'll never know for sure.

An alternative question to ask would be, if there weren't severe fires, why were people jumping to a certain death from above the impact zones even before the South tower fell, and why were people making cellphone calls reported as saying the heat was unbearable? And, incidentally, why do many photographs of the Twin Towers show severe fires?

Dave
 
I hate that photograph.

When I look at it, I see a fragile human being in the final, horrifying moments of her life. A person who has done nothing to deserve their fate standing in stark realization of exactly how few choices she has left and knowing with absolute certainty what that fate is going to be. In careful hands that photograph would bring people together in empathy and loss.

When a troother looks at that photograph they see an opportunity to play amateur fire investigator. A chance to pick at the threads on the hem of the investigation so they can convince others that their particular frankenstein monster of a theory is somehow more credible than all the other conspiracy theories and that the official conclusion is somehow wrong. All based on the final moments of a person's life, captured by chance on film. In their hands it is a nothing but a tool: a prybar with jagged edges used to worry any perceived gap.

I don't know who that woman is, but I hope she passed as quickly and painlessly as possible in that hell. No one deserves that treatment in life, and she definitely doesn't deserve this treatment afterwards.

Bolding mine.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=93771
 
Let us analyse the logic of that situation first, before assumptions are made.

If you are in a building that gets hit by an aircraft or, lets for one moment entertain conspiracy theories, is struck by a series of explosions, are you going to stay where you are, or are you going to try and evacuate?

The photo of her standing there does not tell us directly that the fires in the building were not severe. It just tells us that at that spot where she was, it was not severe. Logical analysis will ask, why is she there and why is she not trying to escape? A logical answer - because she can't.

Based on that it seems plausible that the fires else where severe enough to prevent her from escaping. Judging by the countless videos and photographs showing the large columns of smoke coming from the building, it would be hard to believe that the fires were anything but severe.
 
Last edited:
Cheers for the replys.

I once heard Mark Roberts explain it but I'll be buggered if i can remember what he said. I'm watching part 2 of the Avery Roberts hardfire program i think its on there.
 
Why is it that if the fires were burning so fiercely there are pictures of a woman standing looking out of the hole where the plane hit?
Whenever I see this question, all I can think of is what would it take to get me out there? The answer. No other choice!
 
This cropped picture of woman clinging to shattered window in North Tower is often used
(usually with some disgusting comments about fireproof underwear or such) by truthers.
What dont show is fires raging several floors above. She was at the lower edge of the
impact area - floors above took most of the impact forces and jet fuel to spread the fires. As stated the planes path through the building acted as a plow to push all the
debris toward the opposite wall and soak it with jet fuel to ignite massive fires. Also
at that height would be strong winds which would blow fires away from her. Many
people (ie Stanley Prainmuth in South Tower) survived the direct impact of the aircraft
into their floor.

Does anyone have copy of the picture? Both the cropped "truther" version and the
actual shot showing the fires above.
 
This cropped picture of woman clinging to shattered window in North Tower is often used
(usually with some disgusting comments about fireproof underwear or such) by truthers.
What dont show is fires raging several floors above. She was at the lower edge of the
impact area - floors above took most of the impact forces and jet fuel to spread the fires. As stated the planes path through the building acted as a plow to push all the
debris toward the opposite wall and soak it with jet fuel to ignite massive fires. Also
at that height would be strong winds which would blow fires away from her. Many
people (ie Stanley Prainmuth in South Tower) survived the direct impact of the aircraft
into their floor.

Does anyone have copy of the picture? Both the cropped "truther" version and the
actual shot showing the fires above.

There's a wider picture in the thread linked to in my post above.
 
879046f3a6b3807c7.jpg
 
To elaborate on the explanations above:

1)
In any fire, there will be fresh-air corridors. The more fierce the fire, the more airflow in those corridors (because obviously, the fire consumes a lot of air). I have seen packages wrapped in unharmed brown paper right next to (about two feet) molten glass in a fire site. It does not take much intelligence to realize that such corridors start where air can get in, like in holes in the walls. The unfortunate lady followed a fresh air corridor and ended up where we see her, which leads to:

2)
She is standing in a heap of jagged metal plates on the brink of a 800ft drop. What do you think she is doing there? Enjoying the view?? Would any sane person stand in such a place if she had anywhere else to go?

Hans
 
Last edited:
Just on related topic. Does anyone know if the floors of the offices were carpeted, what ceiling material, office divders etc were used in the building. Any links?

Troofers seem to harp on the point that kerosene burned up to quickly, couldn't burn at this temperature etc.

Sorry, if this has been covered before. I feel a fire analysis (model), taking into account of what materials were in the building would provide some nice material for any debate.

HAS someone done some fire models?
 
Just on related topic. Does anyone know if the floors of the offices were carpeted, what ceiling material, office divders etc were used in the building. Any links?

Troofers seem to harp on the point that kerosene burned up to quickly, couldn't burn at this temperature etc.

Sorry, if this has been covered before. I feel a fire analysis (model), taking into account of what materials were in the building would provide some nice material for any debate.

HAS someone done some fire models?

NIST has, but obviously NIST is part of the gubmint and 'in on it' :rolleyes:

http://wtc.nist.gov/
 
I'd be highly surprised if the office areas weren't carpeted; I could see the hallways and other general use areas being tiled, but generally it creates a richer feel to a place if there is a nice looking carpet in place.

That being said, I can't find anything that states whether or not the floors were carpeted or not; I'm simply going off of logic and my own experience of office areas (of which I've never seen one that was uncarpeted). Sorry buka.
 
As a rule, break rooms, copy areas are tiled. When the buildings were built, it was still common to tile in large areas of open space. when these areas were carpeted later, they generally didn't bother to remove the old tiles.
 
Look at those poor fires:
21mzp1e.jpg


Floors 96,97 and 98 look particularly untouched.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom