Medical and Healthcare phishing

It might help if you first checked what the generic name of Mevacor was before assuming it was the least effective statin. And if you look at the Bandolier site you'll see where Mevacor's effectiveness is in relation to Lipitor. Or did you just omit the information on Mevacor while trying to sound like you knew something?

For the record, Mevacor is ~$50/month and Lipitor ~$300. So why would anyone prescribe Lipitor unless a Mevacor trial failed?

Love that last sentence, s'doc. I believe they have at least a clue already.

Where did I say lovastatin was the least effective?

You are not a crazy cat lady, but you are as mean, untruthful and vindictive as anybody I can imagine.

Good luck with your life, I will avoid crossing paths with you.
 
Are you still working? Are you now disabled?

Are you on narcotics to relieve your pain?

Narcotics are well known to change the personality of the subject, I have direct knowledge of at least one case of divorce, both spouses were my patients.

To set the record straight: there is no state or federal regulation against self medication with non-narcotic medications.

I hope you find relief for your pain and a cure for your disease.

I will not answer any of your posts, so direct your energies to other subjects.
You really don't have a clue as to how assinine you appear to most of the members on this board, do you?

fowlsound is a respected and beloved presence on these fora, and such sly ad hominem attacks as you have attempted (above and previously) only serve to sharply point out how petty and cruel you must actually be.

You should be ashamed of yourself.

Go ahead and put me on your (certainly growing) ignore list, along with all the others. Soon you may not see _any_ posts that challenge your sanctimonious self-image. How comforting that prospect must be for you.

I pity you.

Cheers,
Dave

Edit: Added emphasis, parentheses, & penultimate sentence.
 
Last edited:
Are you still working? Are you now disabled?

Are you on narcotics to relieve your pain?

Narcotics are well known to change the personality of the subject, I have direct knowledge of at least one case of divorce, both spouses were my patients.

To set the record straight: there is no state or federal regulation against self medication with non-narcotic medications.

I hope you find relief for your pain and a cure for your disease.

I will not answer any of your posts, so direct your energies to other subjects.



Wow. That was some great vitriol.

Yes I am working, no I am not disabled. No I am not on narcotics. What the hell does a changing personality have to do with anything? Are you making assumptions about my personality or just acting like a twat?

None of that has anything to do with the fact that you are apparently so arrogant as to assume you can self-diagnose yourself.

I didn't say there was a state or federal law against it. I quoted the AMA on the subject.

Or are you above them as well?
 
After skepticdoc posted a nasal saline recipe that was criticised:

Many people, at least my patient, benefit from homemade salt solutions.

To criticize the salt solution takes somebody who just wants to pick a fight. I could not imagine anything simpler that was non-controversial, and yet an argument ensued.

BTW, after the discussion I did make some changes to the recipe incorporating the about.com formula.
 
Many people, at least my patient, benefit from homemade salt solutions.

To criticize the salt solution takes somebody who just wants to pick a fight. I could not imagine anything simpler that was non-controversial, and yet an argument ensued.

BTW, after the discussion I did make some changes to the recipe incorporating the about.com formula.


Interesting you accuse others of picking a fight when you previously admit to baiting a conversation.

Why does a doctor need an article from about.com when you already administer this treatment to your patient?
 
CaveDave, what do you do when somebody questions your ethics and work in a forum?

Is ignoring the author the best choice?
 
just read #344, I have nothing else to add, final answer, if you don't like it, just include me on your ignore list, now improved!

As you know, I already read your so-called "final answer." As you also doubtless know, it contained no answer. You have refused to answer even the easiest "softball" questions, even after it was explained to you that you had not answered and you were given a free re-try. Quoting Wikipedia is not the same as telling me what you thought the word "phishing" meant when you used it. Surely you're able to understand this, but your evasions have convinced me that it embarrasses you to admit you were wrong -- that you are unwilling to learn and grow.

I will accept that the thread title is misleading, but I have been as honest as I can be, and as consistent as my uncertainty allows. see post#340

Your thread title has absolutely nothing to do with the actual content of this thread, including the original post, made when there were no replies that could've made the topic drift; in other words, you have been dishonest from the very beginning of the thread. If it's true that you have been as honest as you can be, the inescapable logical conclusion is that you are unable to be honest. Was that what you meant to say? Like it or not, that is what you told us.

Your advice to those who don't like your distortions, your personal attacks on those trying to engage you in civil conversation, is that they should put you on ignore and let you continue to spew vitriol, distortions, and out-and-out falsehoods without correcting you or pointing out your continuing intellectual dishonesty. I'm not surprised.

But it's not going to happen. Obnoxiousness and intransigence do not earn a free pass to harangue without being called when you try to pull a sleaze. So far you've been caught trying to engage in half the logical fallacies in the book. If you're smart you'll cut your losses now, not try to hit all the remaining invalid arguing tactics (your behavior has convinced just about everyone reading the thread that you aren't the brightest bulb in the pack; I believe that even you could learn if you were to try, but doubt that you will do it).

[edited for a typo]
 
Last edited:
Are you still working? Are you now disabled?

Are you on narcotics to relieve your pain?

Narcotics are well known to change the personality of the subject, I have direct knowledge of at least one case of divorce, both spouses were my patients.
This is one of the most offensive posts I have seen. Your uncalled-for, ridiculous insinuations about an individual with malignancy (and who is quite obviously of sounder mind than yourself) mark you out as an arrogant, uncaring and insensitive person. Even if these stupid assertions were true, are you totally lacking in empathy and have zero insight as to whether it is appropriate for a doctor to make such remarks?
I am ashamed that you are a doctor (so you say). Your posts here have done nothing to enhance the status and respect of your (and my) profession - you have shown disdain for anyone who disagrees with your twisted concepts of medicine. You merely reveal yourself as an overbearing, supercilious tosser with a massive inferiority complex who is unable to answer simple direct questions without resorting to snide/nasty personal comments, and who cannot grasp and apply the most basic principles about the scientific method and evidence-based medicine.

I hope you find relief for your pain and a cure for your disease.
Your insincerity is palpable.


Oh, and BTW I find it interesting to see you glibly admit to prescribing drugs to your patients which you acknowlege have personality-altering side effects, and which culminated in destroying the marriage of 2 of your patients. What were you doing all this time - sitting on your backside taking notes while their whole world fell apart? I hope your insurance premiums are up to date if this is your usual standard of medical care.
 
And to think I only started to read this thread because I accidentally misread the title as "Medical and Healthcare publishing". :rolleyes:

Rolfe.
 
The Real Intention of the Thread

This may be a case of an explanation given too little, too late:

Whoever answered the original question received this response:

Please consider joining the Skeptic Forum, if you do, send me a PM there.

The Skeptic forum has no "buddy list", and the administrator was extremely kind to set up a "private" discussion group. Even S'girl was invited. There is very little interest in pursuing any private discussions, there is a very active thread in the Skeptic Forum involving chiropractic manipulation, but it is part of the general topics.

In a tangential way, the thread was started to "phish" for skeptics/JREFers involved with healthcare, there was nothing illegal, deceptive, or fraudulent; so it really did not meet the accepted Wikipedia definition. The project was not successful as intended, just initiated one of the most active threads in the JREF Forum.
 
This may be a case of an explanation given too little, too late:

Whoever answered the original question received this response:

Please consider joining the Skeptic Forum, if you do, send me a PM there.

The Skeptic forum has no "buddy list", and the administrator was extremely kind to set up a "private" discussion group. Even S'girl was invited. There is very little interest in pursuing any private discussions, there is a very active thread in the Skeptic Forum involving chiropractic manipulation, but it is part of the general topics.

In a tangential way, the thread was started to "phish" for skeptics/JREFers involved with healthcare, there was nothing illegal, deceptive, or fraudulent; so it really did not meet the accepted Wikipedia definition. The project was not successful as intended, just initiated one of the most active threads in the JREF Forum.



Thought you weren't going to explain yourself anymore? Oh yeah, you always have to have the last word.

By the way, you're very wrong about having started one of the most active threads in the JREF forum. You can check these links for stats:

Top 30 most viewed threads.

Top 30 most replied to threads.

It would appear your self image is greatly exaggerated.

ETA:

These are the top 10 threads that have seen the most activity in the past week (gathered by a specially designed query to the database):

posts/thread ID/title

191 56407 What judge in his right mind could lock away a beautiful 'babe'
203 56077 In the Box
233 48975 The last person to post in this thread wins
235 56262 New "bigfoot" photo Mount Hood
302 56458 An open letter to Linda and Randi.
306 55077 Word Association (please read OP before posting)
333 56391 Rumsfeld proven a liar. Twice.
432 37822 The Three Word Story
490 51801 Say what's on your mind right now
764 53102 Loose Change


So it would seem in no way would you be correct in saying you started one of the most active threads on the forum.
 
Last edited:
CaveDave, what do you do when somebody questions your ethics and work in a forum?
So far, I don't believe it has ever happened.
As a hypothetical question? I would want to reexamine and review my actions, behavior, and writings critically, searching for any reason for such questions to arise, and in the absence of any, I would request from the questioner their evidence.
If I found reasons, I would attempt to correct any misunderstanding that may have led to the questioning or apologise and correct myself if there were indeed factual evidence of transgression on my part.
If the challenger proved to be unwilling to discuss the matter, and the accusations were spurious, I believe that I could trust that the other participants would reach their own conclusions about the affair. I never delude myself into the belief that I can control the thoughts of other men. If persuation via reasoned debate fails, I can choose to withdraw my participation.

How would you answer the same question?

Is ignoring the author the best choice?
No, but in the event that no other option remains, then go ahead.

=======================

Earlier, you wrote:
To criticize the salt solution takes somebody who just wants to pick a fight
I disagree. This is a forum mainly dedicated to challenging Authority when they proclaim "X" without properly supporting their assertions for "X" to be acceptably proven. In this case, you were asked to give the reasons for *each* of the particular recommendations in the recipe, and if it was indeed a useful product. I still doubt the need for boiling, assuming reasonable quality water, but learned a great deal from both sides in the debate between s'girl and the respiatory therapy expert (forgot the screen name, sorry.).

At another point you wrote:
You are not a crazy cat lady, but you are as mean, untruthful and vindictive as anybody I can imagine.
I disagree. I saw a self-confident, educated, dedicated professional who could be opinionated (most competent professionals are), occasionally abrupt (only a small fault, probably due to a busy schedule), and disinclined to suffer fools gladly (good for her).
I saw no evidence of any of your charges, but would welcome you to present your evidence for those assertions.
Please be precise and specific. Post your quotes supporting each charge with references to the original post number.
Let's have a lively debate, how about it?:)

Cheers,
Dave
 
CaveDave, what do you do when somebody questions your ethics and work in a forum?
I don't suppose it has yet occurred to you that you wrongly questioned my integrity, knowledge and skills as a nurse practitioner, based purely on your ignorance and prejudice about other professions than your own. (That is if you are a doctor which I am not convinced of based on your posts.)
 
This may be a case of an explanation given too little, too late:

Whoever answered the original question received this response:

Please consider joining the Skeptic Forum, if you do, send me a PM there.

The Skeptic forum has no "buddy list", and the administrator was extremely kind to set up a "private" discussion group. Even S'girl was invited. There is very little interest in pursuing any private discussions, there is a very active thread in the Skeptic Forum involving chiropractic manipulation, but it is part of the general topics.

In a tangential way, the thread was started to "phish" for skeptics/JREFers involved with healthcare, there was nothing illegal, deceptive, or fraudulent; so it really did not meet the accepted Wikipedia definition. The project was not successful as intended, just initiated one of the most active threads in the JREF Forum.
Now let's not be exaggerating here. You haven't posted anything on the Skeptic Forum different from here and you abruptly stopped posting when I added a link to this thread.

No one was posting much in your "secret forum" which I find bizarre anyway. I presumed I was automatically added by posting in your other threads. And I no longer see the forum title on my index so I assume you took my name off the "secret list".

Is it in your imagination all this takes place? If I were aware you really were a physician, I'd be tempted to inform the board I was concerned about your mental health and cognitive ability. I'd share your posts and let them decide. I could be negligent if I knew you were truly as you appear here and I didn't notify the board.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone really think this guy is a medical doctor?

I'm not remotely convinced.
 
Does anyone really think this guy is a medical doctor?

I'm not remotely convinced.


One who has severely lost his marbles, possibly. I've seen cases like this in my line of work (medical secretary in a university hospital - boss involved in medical professions disciplinary authorities) ... Not too competent but unaware of their limitations, good at hiding it from patients and some colleagues, good at hiding their psychological and personnal problems, and at shifting the blame for their mistakes on subordinates, arrogant, huge chips on their shoulders when it comes to women (especially competent and independent ones) and different cultures, lacking any basic respect for their patients despite discourse about their humanitarian motivations, and the constant shifting of issues when challenged. Usually ends badly.
 
One who has severely lost his marbles, possibly. I've seen cases like this in my line of work (medical secretary in a university hospital - boss involved in medical professions disciplinary authorities) ... Not too competent but unaware of their limitations, good at hiding it from patients and some colleagues, good at hiding their psychological and personnal problems, and at shifting the blame for their mistakes on subordinates, arrogant, huge chips on their shoulders when it comes to women (especially competent and independent ones) and different cultures, lacking any basic respect for their patients despite discourse about their humanitarian motivations, and the constant shifting of issues when challenged. Usually ends badly.


Well he's delusional enough to think he started "one of the most active threads in the JREF forum."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom