McCain says "we could kill Iranians with cigarettes".

I found these remarks in Haaretz dubious. The Iranians are a smart people and know Obama is just another tool of the Zionists. That was made clear when he spoke at AIPAC.

Without officially admitting it, observers say Iran clearly favors Democratic candidate Barack Obama as next U.S. president, especially as he has several times spoken in favor of resuming diplomatic talks with Iran.

Another reason for favoring Obama is his middle name Hussein, which is also the name of the third Shiite Imam who is highly respected in Iran.
 
You don't have a clue as to what neocon means, do you?

I think I do. The term means different things to different people. The original usage seems to have been applied to Democrats who favored more confrontational foreign policy (Jeanne Kirkpatrick is the classic example I believe). Pat Buchanan has defined it something like that.

As it is often used today it applies to a group of mostly Republican people particularly ones that were associated with PNAC that have very hawkish views toward the middle east and in particular Israel where they strongly agree with US military aid and with all Israeli military actions and tend to be critical of Israel only when it isn't being militaristic enough for their tastes.

Your implication is that you don't think McCain is a neo-con. Given that he distanced himself a bit from Hagee perhaps not. But Hagee appears to be his own kind of nut job whose views only overlap somewhat with the average neo-con.

So what do you think distinguishes McCain from the people like Perle, Wolfowitz and Hadley that makes him clearly not a neo-con? One thing that might distinguish him is that some of the original Bushco neocons that led the US into Iraq have expressed reservations about the decision to go to war. Maybe McCain is out neo conning the neo cons by not admitting to reservations and by loose cannon rhetoric that adds instability to an already unstable situation.
 
I think I do. The term means different things to different people. The original usage seems to have been applied to Democrats who favored more confrontational foreign policy (Jeanne Kirkpatrick is the classic example I believe). Pat Buchanan has defined it something like that.

As it is often used today it applies to a group of mostly Republican people particularly ones that were associated with PNAC that have very hawkish views toward the middle east and in particular Israel where they strongly agree with US military aid and with all Israeli military actions and tend to be critical of Israel only when it isn't being militaristic enough for their tastes.

Your implication is that you don't think McCain is a neo-con. Given that he distanced himself a bit from Hagee perhaps not. But Hagee appears to be his own kind of nut job whose views only overlap somewhat with the average neo-con.

So what do you think distinguishes McCain from the people like Perle, Wolfowitz and Hadley that makes him clearly not a neo-con? One thing that might distinguish him is that some of the original Bushco neocons that led the US into Iraq have expressed reservations about the decision to go to war. Maybe McCain is out neo conning the neo cons by not admitting to reservations and by loose cannon rhetoric that adds instability to an already unstable situation.

As I suspected. Here's a clue: "Neo" means "New". John McCain is not a "new" conservative, nor were many of the members of PNAC. Jeanne Kirkpatrick I'll give you, although I don't recommend listening to Pat Buchanan about much of anything. Buchanan wants to label all conservatives who aren't as right-wing as he is as neocons.

I was a neocon at one point in my life, but I would not classify myself that way any more. Neoconservatism was for me (and I suspect for many other Republicans) a bridge from liberalism to conservatism, but once I crossed the bridge it ceased to be necessary to identify myself as a neocon. Buchanan is trying to claim the mantle of legitimate conservatism, but in fact the paleoconservatism he represents is nowhere near the mainstream. People like to say Cheney, Bush (and McCain) are neocons, which is risible; they were always conservatives. That they and the neocons agree on almost everything is simply because the neocons have crossed over the bridge.
 
I think I do. The term means different things to different people. The original usage seems to have been applied to Democrats who favored more confrontational foreign policy (Jeanne Kirkpatrick is the classic example I believe). Pat Buchanan has defined it something like that.

As it is often used today it applies to a group of mostly Republican people particularly ones that were associated with PNAC that have very hawkish views toward the middle east and in particular Israel where they strongly agree with US military aid and with all Israeli military actions and tend to be critical of Israel only when it isn't being militaristic enough for their tastes.

Your implication is that you don't think McCain is a neo-con. Given that he distanced himself a bit from Hagee perhaps not. But Hagee appears to be his own kind of nut job whose views only overlap somewhat with the average neo-con.

So what do you think distinguishes McCain from the people like Perle, Wolfowitz and Hadley that makes him clearly not a neo-con? One thing that might distinguish him is that some of the original Bushco neocons that led the US into Iraq have expressed reservations about the decision to go to war. Maybe McCain is out neo conning the neo cons by not admitting to reservations and by loose cannon rhetoric that adds instability to an already unstable situation.

I don’t think McCain is a neocon. A better label would be war monger.
 
As I suspected. Here's a clue: "Neo" means "New". John McCain is not a "new" conservative, nor were many of the members of PNAC. Jeanne Kirkpatrick I'll give you, although I don't recommend listening to Pat Buchanan about much of anything. Buchanan wants to label all conservatives who aren't as right-wing as he is as neocons.

I was a neocon at one point in my life, but I would not classify myself that way any more. Neoconservatism was for me (and I suspect for many other Republicans) a bridge from liberalism to conservatism, but once I crossed the bridge it ceased to be necessary to identify myself as a neocon. Buchanan is trying to claim the mantle of legitimate conservatism, but in fact the paleoconservatism he represents is nowhere near the mainstream. People like to say Cheney, Bush (and McCain) are neocons, which is risible; they were always conservatives. That they and the neocons agree on almost everything is simply because the neocons have crossed over the bridge.

Paleo-conservatism may not be mainstream today, but they are the closest thing to original conservatism.

Mainstream conservatives today are really liberals. They certainly are liberals when it comes to race. Look at how they tackle the immigration issue. They have no problem with little Brown people coming into this country as long as they do it legally. If White people become a minority in America that is fine with modern conservatives as long as there are new workers to pay into Social Security.

Original conservatives of the past, be they segregationists, or nativist, or isolationists wanted to keep America White and nationalistic. Teddy Roosevelt, and for the most part, those before him would be a good example of an original conservative.
 
Paleo-conservatism may not be mainstream today, but they are the closest thing to original conservatism.

Conservatism is resistance to change, and thus is inherently based around the status quo. (Although there's a certain amount of flexibility in deciding when exactly something becomes status quo.) Liberalism, at least in the broad sense of the word of liberal democracy and individualism, is the status quo, and as such conservatives ought to conserve it.

Original conservatives of the past, be they segregationists, or nativist, or isolationists wanted to keep America White and nationalistic. Teddy Roosevelt, and for the most part, those before him would be a good example of an original conservative.

I really wouldn't call Teddy Roosevelt a conservative. Yes, he was sort of a racist (although not extremely so by the standards of his day) but Teddy Roosevelt made some significant expansions of government regulation of the economy by strengthening anti-trust enforcement, creating the FDA and regulated the railroad industry. Hell, he ran in 1912 under the Progressive Party.
 
Last edited:
Mainstream conservatives today are really liberals. They certainly are liberals when it comes to race. Look at how they tackle the immigration issue. They have no problem with little Brown people coming into this country as long as they do it legally. If White people become a minority in America that is fine with modern conservatives as long as there are new workers to pay into Social Security.

Once again, the conservatives try to move the center.

Richard Nixon was considered a moderate-conservative at his time, and many of his policies would be attacked as liberal now. John Paul Stevens was appointed by Gerald Ford as a moderate replacement for the liberal supreme court justice William O. Douglas, and he's now the most liberal justice on the court.

Taxes on the wealthy have been cut dramatically, welfare has been cut back dramatically, prison populations have skyrocketed, drinking ages have been raised, gun laws have been liberalized, and yet they will try to convince you that the government is run by a bunch of liberals. Bull.
 
Do people like you who think this sort of thing is funny have the slightest ability to empathize with the people who will be killed when McCain's "jokes" are used to raise tensions to the point of war.

Selling cigarettes will bring us to the point of war? It was an off color remark that he specifically stated he was only joking about.

The thought that the US finds itself in a situation where a man so phenomenally insensitive to the international repercussions of his words could be elected to the presidency is sad.

It was a joke incorporating the danger of cigarettes with current events. If you are so politically correct that you can't handle that, I'd suggest building yourself a nice little box that blocks out all radio, television, and outside visitors.

By the standards of what a regular guy might say there is admittedly very little to be worried about. Regular guys make stupid, inappropriate jokes all the time. But they are not trying to be the primary international representative of the US. McCain is and it is amazing that he continues to fan the flames of war with his stupid rhetoric. If he is so friggin gung ho to see Iranians die I wish he'd make it clearer that those are his own sentiments and that he doesn't represent me or the vast majority of other Americans that don't want to kill Iranians.

Just so we're clear, you believe McCain wants to kill Iranians? Specifically, Iranian civilians?
 
Just so we're clear, you believe McCain wants to kill Iranians? Specifically, Iranian civilians?

I don't think that on a conscious level McCain wants to kill Iranians but I think this joke provides insight into his simplistic world view. In McCain's mind things are simple. Countries are good or evil and Iran is evil and by extension its citizens are evil and zapping them is akin to zapping Cylons.

McCain quickly realized that his joke was inappropriate and I guess that is why many of the people in this thread don't see it as a big deal.

But I think it is a big deal because it is the second time that he has made a joke that suggests he is little concerned with killing Iranians and it suggests that his world view is more tied to Saturday morning cartoons than reality. This is an idea that is supported by McCain's gaffes on Iraq which suggest that he has failed to grasp the difficulties of that complex situation.

But even ignoring the above and putting the best possible face on this stupid joke, it would at the very least be a significant embarrassment to the US to be involved in sensitive negotiations with a country and have the president making jokes about killing its citizens. I for one, was hoping for a president that wouldn't be an international embarrassment this time around.

For what it is worth here are a couple of youtube videos of Stephen Kinzer talking about the history of US meddling in Iranian affairs.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=VV7YBnf6IHs
http://youtube.com/watch?v=_RuVi6DAO6s

Here's a completely off topic video about a ski vacation in Iran. I just thought that some people in this thread might like to see that the Iranians that McCain was joking about killing look a lot more like us than Cylons.

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x1oyxs_ski-vacation-in-iran-axis-of-evil_sport
 
But even ignoring the above and putting the best possible face on this stupid joke, it would at the very least be a significant embarrassment to the US to be involved in sensitive negotiations with a country and have the president making jokes about killing its citizens.
And yet the country we'd be engaged in sensitive negotiations with makes outrageous statements all the time and never seemsto suffer the least embarrassment.

Maybe the premise of your statement -- that jokes should be the cause of embarrassment so significant that will have a real impact on international relations -- is flawed.

I know it's a real popular cliche to believe that diplomacy is run like a Star Trek episode where an interstellar war can be started if Jean Luc mispronounces a single word in the 300-page ritual greeting, but it doesn't actualy work that way. Nobody who is a diplomat with whom you could feasible negotiate is going to get his panties in a knot over one, two or even ten off-the-cuff remarks intended for humorous value.

Iran made its statement condemning the joke to try to spin this to their favor, just like America will spin the next time Ahmedinejad says something stupid like "There are no gays in Iran" or "Allah will wipe Israel from the map" or some apocalyptic nonsense. But embarrassment? Interruption in diplomatic relations and negotiations? Over a joke about cigarettes?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom