Man sues website where jilted women diss men

Number Six

JREF Kid
Joined
Sep 5, 2001
Messages
5,016
The webstie is dontdatehimgirl.com. The idea is that when a guy cheats on a woman the woman can go to this website and put up info about the guy saying what a lout he is and warning other women to stay away from him. It's an interesting concept and it makes for some funny reading but one guy says the stuff on there about him isn't true and he's suing. What will become of this? I don't know. Let the lawyers battle it out I guess.

http://www.courttv.com/people/2006/0707/dont_date_him_ctv.html?cnn=yes
 
The webstie is dontdatehimgirl.com. The idea is that when a guy cheats on a woman the woman can go to this website and put up info about the guy saying what a lout he is and warning other women to stay away from him. It's an interesting concept and it makes for some funny reading but one guy says the stuff on there about him isn't true and he's suing. What will become of this? I don't know. Let the lawyers battle it out I guess.

http://www.courttv.com/people/2006/0707/dont_date_him_ctv.html?cnn=yes

It Déjà vu all over again. --Yogi Berra
 
It certainly makes sense for a guy to seek to have private information about him taken off a public website, especially if it's not true. (or even if it is true for that matter)
Would anyone like to be accussed by name of having herpes on a site that anyone could see. I mean, this guys mother ended up finding out about it!

However, it's interesting that in the article the person who runs the website claims the victim never contacted her about removing the information, but went straight to the press. Whereas the victim claims he did ask to have the info emoved and was refused in no uncertain terms.
Somebody's lying.
 
The problem is that many things, when shared with someone, are no longer private at all. For instance, giving someone an STD -- they are as much a part of the experience as you are. This means that if they elect to make the information public (" I got this STD from so and so") I don't see how it could be considered privacy infringement. On the other hand, saying instead "so and so has this STD," certainly could be. Seems like a pretty fine line, but it makes a difference.

Contrast this with something like disclosing a SSN. Such personal information is always private, because there is no way to 'share' it with anyone else.
 
However, it's interesting that in the article the person who runs the website claims the victim never contacted her about removing the information, but went straight to the press. Whereas the victim claims he did ask to have the info emoved and was refused in no uncertain terms.
Somebody's lying.

There should be no effort required by law in order to "opt out" of things. Spam, telemarketing, some website, or the squeegee-cleaning homeless who work in traffic...

It's their job not to bug people in the first place, they have no right to make people say "No, thank you" a thousand times a day (or even once). Not that they would listen, of course.
 
Okay, come on. Don't tell me I'm the only one who checked to see if I had a dossier on there.
 
As I vaguely recall from law school, falsely reporting that an individual has an STD is defamation per se-- you don't need to show any particular harm in order to recover damages, because the harm is assumed. Of course, truth is an absolute defense, so it will all depend on whether the allegations reported on the site are actually true.

However, this website is pursuing a pretty risky line of business, because any time a jilted girlfriend decides to stretch the truth, they're looking at a potential lawsuit. I'm surprised it hasn't happened before now.
 
However, this website is pursuing a pretty risky line of business, because any time a jilted girlfriend decides to stretch the truth, they're looking at a potential lawsuit. I'm surprised it hasn't happened before now.

True. But then, jilted BOYFRIENDS are the main reason quality porn remains free on the internet. Funny how such materials take a life of their own once they hit the Web...

Note to the ladies: No matter how great the idea sounds at the time, do NOT let him take those photos. You'll thank me later.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom