Making critical thinking look even sexier

Danniel

Student
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
39
Let's face it. Just knowing the list of fallacies by heart and parroting the Latin names for each fallacy when we see them probably isn't the best one could do when trying to persuade someone to a certain point of view. Sarcasm may be funny, but I think that it has mostly a sort of "preaching to the choir" effect; you don't say a sarcastic remark about someone's point of view, specially when it's about deeply regarded beliefs, and expect the interlocutor to laugh and be convinced. More likely it will reinforce rationalization of the point of view we're trying to prove to be wrong, and bitterness toward what we think to be the right perspective on the subject.

Once I've heard something about being a salesman, that you should never say to the potential customer that he "is wrong", not directly, does not matter how meaningless the disagreement may be, instead of a "no, it's not like that, this way it's much better" type of argument, something like "yes, indeed, very well pointed. Its actually because of this that when we consider X we realize that it could be even better with some Y and a bit of Z". There's even a saying that's something on the lines of "the client is always right".

I believe that's more or less what's called "Socratic discourse" or something like that. It would be something like, proposing a chain of questions formulated in a manner that the other person would tend to agree, starting from something more "broad", and then go tightening the whole subject, conducting to the final conclusion.

This is not at all about "ass kissing" or some sort of dishonesty or deception (as may be in sales, indeed). I see it as finding commonalities and trying to find a common ground of agreement from where we are more likely to be able to present a more appealing, convincing perspective for what we honestly think to be true (which isn't necessarily the case with salespersons). It's taking human psychology more seriously into account in this whole ideal of the promotion of critical thinking, making our ideas more palatable.





Having said all that, the idea is to discuss this whole subject, of course. I think we could do things like, exposing some examples of harsh, crude, ineffective argumentation in general and pondering alternative manners to convey the same thing in a more attractive presentation.

I'll start with a message I posted in another forum while discussing the whole "pro-life" vs "pro-choice" subject:

Pro-life guy: I do respect the noble interest of the doctor X [not me, BTW] in defending a cause that may save lives and relief suffering, but the brain death, as brain inactivity, defines a point from which the life cannot return, it's an absolute ending of life. In the foetus, in the other hand, the lack of cerebral activity is a natural point when the life is just about to begin in its wholeness, and this is a crucial difference that we can't pretend that we don't see.

Me: No one denies that there's such difference, no one thinks that brain activity is something random with respect with ontological development, "so, the foetus is just like a person with brain death. Ops, look there! A fully functional brain just appeared in this foetus, and it's alive, who would imagine that?". Pro-choicers just don't consider this distinction to be relevant. Brain activity, which is more consensually (as the area of common agreement between pro-lifers and pro-choicers) regarded as "human life" than mere cellular or organismic metabolism, just hasn't started yet.

We could equally point that an egg should have the right to fecundation and life, as it is different from any other somatic cell, as no other cell goes through meiosis and waits to fecundation, and that "we cannot pretend to not see that difference". It's not actually defended by anyone (not that I know) because traditionally such notion never existed, perhaps because in humans the estrus is concealed. There are those though, who will argue something similar in relation to spermatozoa ejaculated within the vagina, that they should be left to follow their natural destiny, and that spermicide at this moment is somewhat like mass murder.

And no one thinks that brain activity wouldn't start, or that there isn't difference between an embryo and a "brain-dead" person; only that this argument that it was just about to develop itself wholly could be extended backwards to the egg, whose natural destiny is the fecundation, or, in a even more bizarre version, that everybody will fatally suffer brain death, so no one should have more rights than a corpse has.


Now, analyzing it after the fact, the thing that strikes me as the most obvious improvement would be that I perhaps I should have spared the fictitious person thinking that the brain would "just appear" all of a sudden... I think it may sound somewhat insulting, and straw-mannish.



So, other suggestions for this case (even though the message isn't going to be edited anymore) and case-studies are welcome.
 
Last edited:
I think that debates are like chess matches, and not necessarily a war plan as all war plans quickly fall apart if they don't account for the opponent's every possible move. Chess is looking several moves ahead, employing tactics and a few tricks, responding to the opponents strategy, maneuvering to gain slight advantages, etc. etc. I think you can effectively play devil's advocate, use ridicule, be more informed, point out logical fallacies...and many other tricks of the trade. It all depends on the objectivity of your opponent...their willingness to consider other lines of investigation.

In your example, you have to ask yourself if you've been outmaneuvered. Does his point make more sense than yours? From a physiological aspect, are you saying that a brain-dead person is dead? And, if so, then there is no difference between the dead and a fetus without brain activity?

Perhaps you should have taken the approach that the process of development is gradual transitions. There is no particular point (at least that I'm aware of) when the mind switches on, as your opponent seemed to suggest and you agreed with (by implication). This then leads back to the moment when it is no longer morally acceptable to perform abortions. One maintains that it is never acceptable, the other maintains that it is up to a point which is not well defined.
 
Debates are a lousy way to arrive at the truth. I've seen several creationism debates where the creationists 'won.' It wasn't because there was any way they were more correct than the scientists they were debating against, they were just able to rip them apart rhetorically. I can try to dig one or two up if anyone is interested, its a great way to look at how an absolutely absurd opinion can seem more reasonable than the actual truth when a good speaker is on it.

I prefer debate from overwhelming evidence - back up every point with facts, and use facts to discredit inaccuracies.

Of course this fails miserably in the abortion debate because there is no substantial disagreement on the facts. Everyone agrees on how humans are conceived. Everyone agrees on how babies develop in the womb. Everyone agrees that abortion ends the possibility of a human life developing from the fetus. The entire debate is opinion-based, and I'd rather not go there (except to note its going to happen even if its illegal (provable fact) is more dangerous when its done illegally by untrained people (provable fact) and therefore the debate is over whether it should be safe, reasonably simple, and legally condoned, or risky, complicated and potentially deadly, and illegal).

In that debate, I'd just go choose a fact-based beachhead and hold it. The concept of 'when life begins' is nebulous and silly. Genetically, its a separate life as soon as the cell splits - it has its own unique DNA at that point. From a social point of view, Abortion seems reasonably necessary in order to allow a woman to have more control over her life, to help control overpopulation, to prevent needless deaths, and to help ensure that children are raised by capable parents, which makes them more likely to 'succeed' in society. But I don't see any reason to deny that an independent, unique DNA pattern that will form (in all likelyhood, given the low rates of miscarriage in this country) a human life is being destroyed. Also, its no different from contraception, where a potential human life is being prevented from being formed, or abstinence, where the possibility of a life-creating act is being denied.
 
Last edited:
I've said this before, but nobody listened on this forum even though I think I'm right.

Ramming your beliefs down others throat even if you're right sometimes doesn't always work. Especially some of the atheists on this forum come off downright insensitive, condescending and obnoxious.

My opinion is to simply present the information in an unbiased fasion (if you're right, why do you need to bias information in order to win -- you should be spreading the truth) and let them arrive at the conclusion. If a person arrives at the correct conclusion themselves they tend to be much more likely to accept it even if reluctantly, than if it is forcibly shoved down their throat.

In the past, atheists often argued that if even one person was swayed by their argument it was worth all of it. I thought that was a rather bad approach -- Basically, it's saying that "I'm willing to continuously use an approach that not only doesn't work 99% of the time, but will offend a lot that 99% most of the time, and will only sway 1% if I'm lucky." It definitely did not strike me as an intelligent strategy.


INRM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom