Split Thread Magnetic Thermite and Thermal Bonding

The VOLUNTEERS didn't start until Oct 2001. They were not at the impact site but at collection points. Still why all the hurry to destroy the steel?

Again, false. One more time: Astaneh-Asl left the day after, and began work within one week of the tragedy. There were also local professionals from the Structural Engineers Association of New York (SEAoNY) there on the 12th as well. Furthermore, as noted in the FEMA BPS, FEMA and SEI/ASCE had by the 12th already assembled and dispatched team members to assist with the cleanup and begin the initial surveys. The arrival of the bulk of the team shouldn't be taken as the first time any non-emergency personnel were allowed at Ground Zero. And the fact that the Building Performance Study Team did not start formal investigation of the rubble until after search and resue operations were conducted - and not incidentally, until after they had also taken the time to meet and plan, as noted in the first chapter of the BPS - does not give weight to your insinuation that the site was not attended by trained investigators in the time between the event and October 7, the date of the FEMA BPS team's official "start".

Furthermore, you ignore the fact that FBI, NYPD, US Customs agents, FDNY investigators (not just firefighters), and the like were present in the immediate aftermath, even before the bulk of the FEMA team was there.

And as far as "destroying" the steel: If you're referring to the disassembly of all the towers components at Ground Zero, this was necessary for rescue, then afterwards for cleanup purposes. If you're referring to the recycling process, you ignore the fact that this "hurry" ended up taking well into 2002. Furthermore, not all of it was sent away. Up till 2006 and possibly later, some of it was still available in the temporary storage area in the JFK airport hangar. And there are individual pieces all over the US (and one in Canada) serving as monuments; one just came through Indianapolis, In. a couple of months ago.

We've seen this argument before, that these "Powers That Be" hurriedly shipped off the debris in order to cover something up. Do a search for previous threads on the topic.

And also: Get up to speed. I provided links earlier that you need to internalize in order to be at the same level of knowledge as anyone else here, truther or not, and you're not studying them. You need to get that base level of knowledge first. I recommend you suspend your posting for a bit and read that material.
 
Examination of the steel would have shown if it had been acted upon by a corrosive or a thermitic substance. Also the steel from around the impacts would have conclusively answered or debunked a lot of the 9-11 conspiracy, except no one in charge wanted clear facts and analysis.

Ok, one more time: NCSTAR 1-3C. 1-3 is a study of the steel recovered from around the impact zones, and 1-3C is the cataloguing of it. I already refered you to it.

Again, read the material that has been given to you. You are not doing this. You are merely making charges based on ignorance.
 
NCSTAR 1-3 Tells me that more than 99% of the relevant material was destroyed. Your researchers did a great job under harsh conditions, but somebody else was making the rules.
 
NCSTAR 1-3 Tells me that more than 99% of the relevant material was destroyed. Your researchers did a great job under harsh conditions, but somebody else was making the rules.

Incorrect. 100% of the relevant material - i.e. the steel around the collapse initiation zones - was studied by the NIST researchers. And prior to that, other organizations had also studied the steel. WPI, for example. The FDNY as well. The steel that was not studied by NIST was examined by the FEMA BPA teams and discarded as irrelevant to the collapse initiation.

Don't conflate NIST not studying various components with nobody studying 90+% of the steel. Both the FBI and FDNY would be aghast to hear that claim. So would the FEMA BPST and the SEAoNY.

You're trotting out the old truther claims. You need to do searches of this forum before posting a claim. This is ground that's already been covered years ago.
 
Oh Mr DeathDart.

What laws were broken exactly? You made this claim that was obviously feed to you by someone else (like all your "thinking"). Try a little brain work, WHAT LAW WAS BROKEN?
 
More:
And although this is a fire scene, it is also a crime scene, which means a large unit of crime scene investigators is present, working from a tent at the corner of West St. and Liberty. (p. 194)

NYPD Detective first grade Hal Sherman: "At Ground Zero the CSU is responsible for photographing the site, recovering physical evidence, documenting body parts and any other physical evidence like weapons or a wallet, manning the temporary morgue at the site (as well as the city morgue up on 28th Street), inspecting debris that leaves the site, and inspecting debris as it gets sifted out at Staten Island. ...All evidence is documented...
http://www.nysm.nysed.gov/wtc/recovery/sortingprocess.html

"Law enforcement authorities survey the material for evidence. Only then is it released to a scrap processor under an existing long-term contract with the NYC Department of Sanitation to purchase and then recycle scrap metal."
http://www.americanrecycler.com/11wtc.html
​
Again: http://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/groundzerocleanup,freshkillssortingopera. You need to read not just the info gathered up and put on this page, but the other sources cited and linked on it.
 
I'm at a loss to understand what the relevance of examining the columns from the impact zones would be for the purpose of understanding the collapses. If you want to work out the effect of the impact damage on the stability of the structure the relevant information would most likely be which columns were broken and where they were broken. That can be derived from the photographic record.

That record was extensive enough to permit NIST to do a column-by-column comparison of the actual pattern of damage with that predicted by their impact simulations, to determine what set of initial conditions gave the best fit to the actual damage. See NCSTAR 1-2, pdf pages 382-391.

Perhaps examining the columns broken by the plane impacts might have added to humanity's store of knowledge of the behavior of structural steel under very high strain rate conditions, and that would have been a good thing from the point of view of science, but its relevance to CT claims utterly escapes me.
 
Enough magnetic thermite could have been in the cargo hold of the planes to do the job. It could have been actually been listed in the cargo and ignored, or it was placed there by the ground crew in full knowledge of the results.
Please explain this statement.

*Fearless prediction - I'm going to shut off my PC now and drive home. You STILL won't answer that proving you're no better than any of the truthers I've encountered on here, and wouldn't be at all surprised if you are indeed one of them. Ergo perhaps.

Wow. I was right. How about that.

Coward.
 
Actually I consider the Thermite to be only a possibility, not a probability.

Before it could be a possibility I had to figure out a way to make it technically feasible.

Without a confession and most of the evidence intentionally destroyed it is only a possibility.

As far as grading the idea of the evidence being intentionally destroyed it is a strong probability. Too many unusual events were necessary and the connections between potential conspirators are strong.

If Mr Giuliani passed a properly given counterintelligence polygraph I would be very surprised. But why would anybody make him take one?
The powerful are above the law, at least they thought so.
 
What sweet madness is this?

Enough magnetic thermite could have been in the cargo hold of the planes to do the job. It could have been actually been listed in the cargo and ignored, or it was placed there by the ground crew in full knowledge of the results.
And you're going to provide evidence instead of speculation...when? For example, how much thermite would be required, roughly? Given that there was an explosion when the planes hit, wouldn't undetonated dust be thrown all over Manahattan? Has this "magnetic thermite" ever been used in demolitions before, let alone anything as...unconventional as 9/11?

A single security firm, owned by one country, but controlled by another, was in charge of security at all the departure points for 9-11 flights. The FBI's lack of thoroughness in all of this appears to be intentional.
Would you care to name this firm?

Also, you are indirectly accusing the thousands of FBI agents who participated in the investigation of being in on it.

All the directly impacted beams had been removed by the time (a month later) when investigators were allowed on site.
I'm pretty sure the "directly impacted" beams would still be near the bottom of tons of rubble.

Why were they in such a hurry to recycle the metal and then argue for years about how to use the empty site?
Politics.

Thousands of tons of steel were carted away and recycled before any expert could examine what could have been telltale clues.
The debris was pored over by detectives and forensic experts at Fresh Kills looking for bodies, for a combined total of over 1.5 million man hours. Tons of it is still there today. All you need to get at it is a shovel. Truthers like to act like the evidence was destroyed, but a lot was just moved. TO the far, far remove of Staten Island.

The buildings survived the impacts. The fire is presumed to cause the collapse.
Only in the case of 7. Since 7 is one building, not several, I would like to point out that the 1 and 2 collapses were blamed on both the plane impact and fire.

By law the scene should have been left alone so that lessons could be learned about how the fire caused the building structure fail.
What law would that be?

Building 7 had minor damage and a few fires when it collapsed in about 7 to 8 seconds into it's own footprint......?
Any building that has been on widespread fire, largely unfought for 7 hours is not going to have "minor damage", and it did not collapse into into its own footprint. It struck Fiterman Hall and the Verizon building, both across streets to the North and West respectively. It only collapsed in 7/8 secs. if you pretend the penthouse somehow isn't actually part of the building.

How it happened is covered by some reports filed under fiction
By, I assume, the Department of Mysteries.
 
The affected steel could have picked out if you were acting like an investigator or an archaeologist and not a thief in the night. It would have been difficult to reconstruct, but became impossible when you aren't given time or resources.
I assure you, it would be quite impossible with either of those.

Where is the catalog, with a photograph of each piece of steel, and its probable location in each of the buildings? Its been nearly 10 years where is it? You can have a warehouse of totally irrelevant steel that doesn't tell any story.
You are, literally, asking the impossible. This wasn't an airplane crash, this was a skyscraper collapse. We are talking tons of metal here. They don't need to figure out where each piece was.

What happened at the World Trade Center would cause the United States to spend a lot of lives and money. But there wasn't any time or money to document what happened at the World Trade Center?
I seem to recall something about a federal investigation into exactly that, something about a report or two. I dunno, it's all fuzzy.
 
The buildings survived the impacts. The fire is presumed to cause the collapse. By law the scene should have been left alone so that lessons could be learned about how the fire caused the building structure fail.

Name the law. Cite it please.

(I wouldn't reccommend using NFPA 921 either. I'll take you to school on that one.)

Building 7 had minor damage and a few fires when it collapsed in about 7 to 8 seconds into it's own footprint......?

Except for the parts that hit neighboring buildings like Fitterman Hall, the Verizon Building, and the Post Office. But yeah, except for those parts....:rolleyes:

How it happened is covered by some reports filed under fiction.

And anyone who actually knows the first thing about building construction, failure prevention, fire protection engineering, or fire science, files them under the non-fiction category.....but hey, who cares about them, right? An unknown on an obscure website forum says differently.....


Why it had to collapse is easier to figure out.

You're absolutely correct on that. Fire tends to cause things to fail. Especially steel.


After a disaster like this, FEMA would normally run the show.

Citation needed that it wasn't.

FEMA was in building 7.

You mean like they had offices there?


Instead of FEMA Rudolph Giuliani would use NYC's Department of Design and Construction. They would contract out the removal of steel to be scrapped and smelted.

Makes perfect sense to me.

These people hit the ground so fast that they had been removing material for a month before the engineering investigators were allowed on site. Actually the engineering investigators weren't allowed on site, they had to take what was given to them.

Citation needed.
 
...
As far as grading the idea of the evidence being intentionally destroyed it is a strong probability. Too many unusual events were necessary and the connections between potential conspirators are strong.
...

Another weird way of truther logic: They suggest that there is some "usual" course of action about events like 9/11, Because the word "unusual" implies just that.

However, 9/11 was a day like no other before or after. Nothing about what happened there was "usual" in any way, shape or form, and, appropriately, the response to it involved all sorts of novel, one-of-a-kind decisions and eactions. For example: The huge effort expended on huge investigations, some of which were the largest of their respective kinds ever (criminal, forensic engineering, medical forensics, ...), is certainly "unusual". The financial impact, the inner-city infrastructure challenges are unrivalled and demanded "unusual" decisions and efforts.

There is nothing unusual about an unusual event spawning unusual responses.
 
Ok, I was thinking about the whole idea of Thermite Pellets On A Plane last night, and I have some questions for DeathDart.

1) Just what size would these pellets be? 1 mm diameter? Less than 1 mm? More like 5 mm? Bigger?

2) Is the plan for the pellets to adhere to the bar joists, the core columns, the exterior columns or all of the above?

3) So the plane flies into the building at 500 mph. The pellets are in a relatively small area of the flying debris, right? Then there is a fairly big explosion, which could scatter the pellets about at pretty high velocities in EVERY direction, including OUTSIDE the structure altogether?

4) In areas where the fireproofing is not knocked off the beams and columns, are the magnetic pellets going to magnet to the fireproofing or drywall or are you expecting them to just lodge there? If they are lodged in fireproofing, how will they catch fire?

5) Are pellets being propelled at speeds of 500 mph or more going to adhere to columns, or bounce off?

6) Isn't there a probability that the bag(s) of pellets will continue on through the building and out the other side, given that some of the engines and numerous of the other plane components did? Is that a risk the PTB is willing to take?

7) The plan depends on there being a fire in the area where the pellets have adhered large enough to activate them. What if the fire isn't really in that area?

8) What if the pellets end up mostly going down the elevator shafts?

9) How much damage can an individual pellet do to a heavy structural steel column? Would it just burn a hole through it and then stop or what? How would PTB assure that there were enough pellets actually making it onto columns to initiate the collapses?

Anyone else feel free to speculate :)
 
And don't forget, thermite requires a very high temp igniter, usually magnesium.

So how was the supposed "magnetic" thermite deposited randomly through the structure ignited?
 
Coating unmagnetized thermite pellets with a thermal bonding material, before magnetizing them, will allow them to mechanically bond to the steel. When the temperature exceeds the magnetic thermal limits (Curie Temperature), they will be bonded to the beam. After a time the jet fuel fire will reach ignition temperature for the material bonded to the steel.

Upon ignition the steel beam will weaken or melt.

Big pile of FAIL. You still have to actualy place the magnets against the steel. The magnets would not just buzz around like a bunch of blowflies looking for a corpse until they found the steel. A lot of it should have passed right through the buildings and totally escaped the fires. It would have been noticeable stuck to vehicles all over the place down-range. No magnet residues were seen anywhere.

And you still have the problem of the light that it would produce.

:dl:

Sorry, no other way to rate a post with this much fail in it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom